Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
gpt-4.1-mini-2025-04-14· OpenAIAi2 WildChat-4.8M (AI2)

What if SSBB Super Smash Bros. for Wii (2008), Unused data as Forgotten seven fighters…

  1. User

    What if SSBB|Super Smash Bros. for Wii (2008), Unused data as Forgotten seven fighters with cloned moveset Dr. Mario (Mario) Full-Clone but Mario Tornado as Down Special replaces F.L.U.D.D., Roy (Marth) become a Semi-Clone like Falco and Ganondorf, Dixie Kong (Diddy Kong) Up Special as Propeler Ponyhair and Final Smash as Rocket Barrel, Toon Zelda and Tetra (Zelda and Sheik) as Semi-Clones both and Plusle & Minun (Pikachu) but instead of Pichu, had 8 slots first Half as Plusle and second half as Minun, both Pokemon had a Team battle costumes, Brawl's Fighter clones (Jigglypuff|Kirby Pseudo, Dr. Mario|Mario Full, Roy|Marth Semi, Toon Link|Link Semi, Wolf|Fox Pseudo, Plusle & Minun|Pikachu Full, Toon Zelda/Tetra|Zelda/Sheik Semi and Dixie Kong|Diddy Kong Full)?

  2. Assistant

    You're asking about a hypothetical or fan-theory scenario for Super Smash Bros. Brawl (2008) where there are seven "forgotten" or unused fighters with cloned or semi-cloned movesets, and changes to some moves to differentiate them from their base characters. You also describe a roster concept where the known clone fighters are supplemented by characters like Plusle & Minun (split into 8 slots), and others like Dixie Kong, Toon Zelda/Tetra as semi-clones, etc.

    This is an interesting idea and touches on concepts of character cloning, roster expansion, and move differentiation in Smash Bros.


    Breakdown of your scenario:

    1. Forgotten Seven Fighters (Unused, Cloned/Semi-Cloned):

    • Dr. Mario (Mario Full-Clone)

      • Fully cloned from Mario.
      • Use Mario Tornado as Down Special instead of F.L.U.D.D.
    • Roy (from Fire Emblem, Marth Semi-Clone)

      • Semi-clone much like Falco & Ganondorf compared to their base clones.
    • Dixie Kong (Diddy Kong Full-Clone)

      • Dixie replaces Diddy.
      • Up Special: Propeller Ponytail.
      • Final Smash: Rocket Barrel.
    • Toon Zelda and Tetra (Zelda and Sheik) Semi-Clones

      • Both semi-clones of Zelda & Sheik (like Toon Link & Link).
    • Plusle & Minun (Pikachu Full-Clones)

      • Instead of Pichu, Plusle and Minun have eight slots total.
      • Half slots are Plusle, half are Minun.
      • Both have team battle costumes.

    2. Clone Character List Summary for Brawl (with your proposed clones):

    Base CharacterClone TypeClone Character
    KirbyPseudo CloneJigglypuff
    MarioFull CloneDr. Mario
    MarthSemi CloneRoy
    LinkSemi CloneToon Link
    FoxPseudo CloneWolf
    PikachuFull ClonePlusle & Minun
    Zelda/SheikSemi CloneToon Zelda/Tetra
    Diddy KongFull CloneDixie Kong

    Implications and Analysis:

    A) Dr Mario as a Full Clone but with Mario Tornado Down Special:

    • Dr. Mario shares many moves with Mario except he has F.L.U.D.D. as Down Special in Melee.
    • Replacing F.L.U.D.D. with Mario Tornado gives Dr. Mario much greater zoning/defensive ability suited for a Mario clone.
    • Would tighten the difference while keeping the clone identity intact.

    B) Roy as a Semi-Clone of Marth:

    • In Brawl, Roy’s moveset is very similar to Marth’s with slight differences in hitboxes, timings, range.
    • This is consistent with the semi-clone concept; could be expanded slightly for more distinct gameplay feel for Roy.

    C) Dixie Kong as Diddy Kong Full Clone:

    • Dixie Kong, replacing Diddy, would inherit his mobility and combo potential.
    • Up Special as Propeller Ponytail and Final Smash as Rocket Barrel makes her unique in style, considering she hasn't been officially a fighter in Smash.
    • This adds representation to the Donkey Kong series and adds fresh mechanics while still feeling like a full clone.

    D) Toon Zelda and Tetra as Semi-Clones of Zelda/Sheik:

    • The Zelda & Sheik pairing is iconic as transform-based characters in Brawl.
    • Having Toon Zelda and Tetra as semi-clones could add visual variety and perhaps slight gameplay tweaks.
    • Semi-clones would have mostly similar moves with differences in frame data or range.

    E) Plusle & Minun as Full Clones of Pikachu but Separate Slots:

    • Interesting idea to split Plusle & Minun into separate slots while sharing movesets with Pikachu.
    • Both with team battle costumes for visual distinction.
    • Adds more Pokemon representation and potentially interesting mechanics like switching between team members in tag matches or doubles.
    • Makes roster feel more diverse but consistent with Pokemon's electric themes.

    Overall Concept and Design Impact:

    • This proposal effectively expands the roster using clones and semi-clones, increasing character variety without requiring completely new movesets.
    • Provides unique cosmetic and gameplay twists to clones, making each feel somewhat different.
    • Could make the competitive scene more vibrant with slightly varied clones.
    • Fans would appreciate seeing forgotten or unused fighters brought back with mechanical differences.

    What if this was in actual Brawl?

    • Roster Size: Larger, with more clone-based fighters.
    • Gameplay: More variety but not overwhelming for learning.
    • Competitive meta: Might be richer with semi-clones giving more options.
    • Fan response: Positive among fans of Dr. Mario, Roy, Dixie Kong, Toon Zelda, and Pokemon.
    • Balance: Developers would need to tune clones carefully to avoid near-duplicates or underpowered fighters.

    Summary:

    Your concept is a great example of how Brawl’s clone system could be expanded thoughtfully:

    • Full clones with small but impactful moveset changes (Dr. Mario, Dixie Kong).
    • Semi-clones to add new fighters that feel familiar but unique (Roy, Toon Zelda/Tetra).
    • Unique Pokemon variants as full clones with split roster slots (Plusle & Minun).

    If this concept was implemented, it would enhance the Brawl roster diversity, provide new strategic possibilities, and please fans wanting more variety without reinventing the gameplay wheel.


    If you want, I can help you develop detailed move list ideas or competitive analysis for any of these hypothetical clones!