Hello
- User
Hello
- Assistant
Hello! How can I assist you today?
- User
import numpy as np import pandas as pd import matplotlib.pyplot as plt import seaborn as sns
mushrooms_df = pd.read_csv('https://archive.ics.uci.edu/ml/machine-learning-databases/mushroom/agaricus-lepiota.data', header=None)
mushrooms_df[::20]
column_names = [ 'class', 'cap_shape', 'cap_surface', 'cap_color', 'bruises', 'odor', 'gill_attachment', 'gill_spacing', 'gill_size', 'gill_color', 'stalk_shape', 'stalk_root', 'stalk_surface_above_ring', 'stalk_surface_below_ring', 'stalk_color_above_ring', 'stalk_color_below_ring', 'veil_type', 'veil_color', 'ring_number', 'ring_type', 'spore_print_color', 'population', 'habitat' ]
mushrooms_df.columns = column_names
mushrooms_df[::20]
list_of_features_to_visualize = column_names[1:] # (excluding 'class')
list_of_features_to_visualize
custom_palette = {'e': 'royalblue', 'p': 'tomato'} # custom colors
for feature in list_of_features_to_visualize: count_data = mushrooms_df.groupby([feature, 'class']).size().reset_index(name='count') # number of mushrooms for a feature and a class
plt.figure(figsize=(8, 4)) sns.barplot(data=count_data, x=feature, y='count', hue='class', palette=custom_palette, errorbar=None) plt.title(f"Distribution of feature '{feature}' around the classes") plt.legend(title='Class', labels=['Edible', 'Poisonous']) #plt.xticks(rotation=45) # Rotate x labels plt.grid(axis='y') # Add horizontal grid lines plt.show() # Show each plotmushrooms_df['bruises'].value_counts()
mushrooms_df.groupby(['bruises', 'class']).size().reset_index(name='count')
from sklearn.metrics import accuracy_score # calculate the accuracy of the predicted classifications against the true classifications
def frequency_based_classifier(features: pd.Series, target: pd.Series): mapping = {} # store the predicted class for each unique value in the feature_series groups_by_feature = target.groupby(features) # group target by features
for val, group in groups_by_feature: #if not group.empty: # Check if group is not empty pred_most_common_class = group.value_counts().idxmax() # get the most common class mapping[val] = pred_most_common_class # update the mapping
return mapping
results = {}
for feature in list_of_features_to_visualize: mapping = frequency_based_classifier(mushrooms_df[feature], mushrooms_df['class']) preds = mushrooms_df[feature].map(mapping) # change values to predicted by the function above accuracy = accuracy_score(mushrooms_df['class'], preds) # compare true classes with predicted classes results[feature] = accuracy print(f"Accuracy for feature '{feature}': {accuracy:.4f}\n")
best_feature = max(results, key=results.get) print(f"The most informative feature is '{best_feature}' with accuracy: {results[best_feature]:.4f}")
from sklearn.naive_bayes import CategoricalNB
mushrooms_df
Each column of categorical data is converted to a numerical format using pd.factorize()
mushrooms_numerical_df = mushrooms_df.copy() for col in mushrooms_numerical_df.columns: mushrooms_numerical_df[col] = pd.factorize(mushrooms_numerical_df[col])[0] # assigns integers to each unique category
mushrooms_numerical_df[::2000]
features and target
X = mushrooms_numerical_df.drop('class', axis=1) y = mushrooms_numerical_df['class']
naive_bayes_model = CategoricalNB() naive_bayes_model.fit(X, y)
y_pred = naive_bayes_model.predict(X) # предсказание nb_accuracy_from_sclearn = accuracy_score(y, y_pred) # оценить точность print(f"Accuracy of Naive Bayes classificator from SKLEARN is: {nb_accuracy_from_sclearn:.4f}")
X = features
y = classes = target
mushroom_data = pd.read_csv('https://archive.ics.uci.edu/ml/machine-learning-databases/mushroom/agaricus-lepiota.data', header=None)
Y = (mushroom_data[0] == 'p').astype(int) # Convert class labels to binary values: 'p' -> 1 (poisonous), 'e' -> 0 (edible)
prior_probability = Y.sum() / Y.shape[0] # prior probability for class 1 prior_logit = np.log(prior_probability) - np.log(1.0 - prior_probability) # Logit transformation #print(f"p0, z0: {p0}, {z0}")
X_logit = pd.DataFrame(index=mushroom_data.index) # DataFrame for features
target encoding
for feature in mushroom_data.columns[1:]: frequency_table = mushroom_data.groupby(feature)[0].value_counts().unstack().fillna(0) # frequency for each feature
frequency_table['prob'] = (frequency_table['p'] + 1) / (frequency_table['p'] + frequency_table['e'] + 2) # Laplace smoothing frequency_table['logit'] = np.log(frequency_table['prob']) - np.log(1.0 - frequency_table['prob']) - prior_logit # logit transformation # Map the logit values for each feature X_logit[feature] = mushroom_data[feature].map(lambda x: frequency_table.at[x, 'logit'] if x in frequency_table.index else 0)total_logit = X_logit.sum(axis=1) + prior_logit predicted_probabilities = 1 / (1 + np.exp(-total_logit)) # Convert logit to probability
naive_bayes_accuracy_implemented = ((predicted_probabilities > 0.5) == (Y == 1)).sum() / Y.shape[0] print(f"Naive Bayes accuracy SKLEARN: {nb_accuracy_from_sclearn:.4f}") print(f"Naive Bayes accuracy IMPLEMENTED: {naive_bayes_accuracy_implemented:.4f}")
from sklearn.linear_model import LogisticRegression
logistic_regression_model = LogisticRegression().fit(X_logit,Y) logistic_predicted_probabilities = logistic_regression_model.predict(X_logit)
logistic_accuracy = ((logistic_predicted_probabilities > 0.5) == (Y == 1)).sum() / Y.shape[0] print(f"Logistic Regression accuracy: {logistic_accuracy:.4f}")
This is my codes and my teacher told me I need to make this answer question (Задание по работе 2 для Хайн Ко. Построить логистическую регрессию на трёх лучших переменных, вывести точность.) Solve this question.
- Assistant
Здравствуйте!
В вашем задании нужно построить логистическую регрессию, используя три лучших переменных (признака) по информативности, которые вы уже находили в пункте 2.2 (то есть по точности классификации на основании частот). Также необходимо вывести точность полученной модели на обучающей выборке.
Как правильно это сделать:
-
Определить топ-3 переменных с максимальной точностью из вашего словаря
results. -
Использовать для логистической регрессии признаки из датафрейма
X_logit, ограничившись этими тремя переменными. -
Обучить модель логистической регрессии на этих переменных.
-
Сделать предсказание на обучающих данных.
-
Вывести точность.
Пример решения с вашим кодом:
from sklearn.linear_model import LogisticRegression from sklearn.metrics import accuracy_score # 1. Найдем 3 лучших признака (уже есть словарь results с точностями) sorted_features = sorted(results.items(), key=lambda x: x[1], reverse=True) top3_features = [f for f, acc in sorted_features[:3]] print(f"Top 3 features: {top3_features}") # 2. Выбираем из X_logit только эти 3 признака X_top3 = X_logit[top3_features] # 3. Обучаем логистическую регрессию на 3 признаках log_reg = LogisticRegression() log_reg.fit(X_top3, Y) # 4. Предсказываем классы (используем threshold 0.5) y_pred = log_reg.predict(X_top3) # 5. Вычисляем точность accuracy_top3 = accuracy_score(Y, y_pred) print(f"Logistic Regression accuracy on top 3 features: {accuracy_top3:.4f}")
Пояснения:
-
results— словарь с точностями по каждому признаку из вашего кода 2.2:results[feature] = accuracy. -
X_logit— датафрейм с закодированными признаками (в логит-преобразовании с регуляризатором), как в вашем коде 2.4. -
Использование трёх лучших признаков уменьшает размерность модели, но сохраняет информативность.
Если хотите, могу помочь объединить этот код в ваш скрипт — скажите!
-
- User
This is error NameError Traceback (most recent call last) in <cell line: 0>() 3 4 # 1. Найдем 3 лучших признака (уже есть словарь results с точностями) ----> 5 sorted_features = sorted(results.items(), key=lambda x: x[1], reverse=True) 6 top3_features = [f for f, acc in sorted_features[:3]] 7
NameError: name 'results' is not defined
- Assistant
Ошибка
NameError: name 'results' is not definedговорит о том, что переменнаяresultsотсутствует в вашей текущей области видимости.
Причина ошибки
Вы пытались воспользоваться словарём
results, который создавался в разделе 2.2 вашего кода вот так:results = {} for feature in list_of_features_to_visualize: mapping = frequency_based_classifier(mushrooms_df[feature], mushrooms_df['class']) preds = mushrooms_df[feature].map(mapping) accuracy = accuracy_score(mushrooms_df['class'], preds) results[feature] = accuracy print(f"Accuracy for feature '{feature}': {accuracy:.4f}\n")Но, судя по ошибке, эта часть кода либо не была выполнена, либо находится в другом блоке, где переменная не сохранилась.
Что делать
1. Запустите код из пункта 2.2, чтобы получить словарь
resultsresults = {} for feature in list_of_features_to_visualize: mapping = frequency_based_classifier(mushrooms_df[feature], mushrooms_df['class']) preds = mushrooms_df[feature].map(mapping) accuracy = accuracy_score(mushrooms_df['class'], preds) results[feature] = accuracy print(f"Accuracy for feature '{feature}': {accuracy:.4f}\n")Убедитесь, что после этого код отработал без ошибок и переменная
resultsсуществует.
2. После этого можно запустить код с выбором трёх лучших признаков и логистической регрессией
from sklearn.linear_model import LogisticRegression from sklearn.metrics import accuracy_score # Найдем 3 лучших признака по accuracy sorted_features = sorted(results.items(), key=lambda x: x[1], reverse=True) top3_features = [f for f, acc in sorted_features[:3]] print(f"Top 3 features: {top3_features}") # Подготовим признаки для обучения логистической регрессии X_top3 = X_logit[top3_features] # Обучим модель log_reg = LogisticRegression() log_reg.fit(X_top3, Y) # Предскажем классы y_pred = log_reg.predict(X_top3) # Вычислим точность accuracy_top3 = accuracy_score(Y, y_pred) print(f"Logistic Regression accuracy on top 3 features: {accuracy_top3:.4f}")
Дополнительно
-
Если вы используете Jupyter Notebook, убедитесь, что выполнены все клетки с созданием
resultsиX_logitперед запуском кода с логистической регрессией. -
Если хотите, я могу помочь подключить все куски в один блок.
Если возникнут сложности — напишите, я помогу!
-
- User
Explain me in English
- Assistant
Certainly!
The error:
NameError: name 'results' is not definedmeans that the variable
resultsdoes not exist in your current code environment at the time you try to access it.
Why is this happening?
You created the dictionary
resultsin an earlier part of your code (section 2.2) like this:results = {} for feature in list_of_features_to_visualize: mapping = frequency_based_classifier(mushrooms_df[feature], mushrooms_df['class']) preds = mushrooms_df[feature].map(mapping) accuracy = accuracy_score(mushrooms_df['class'], preds) results[feature] = accuracy print(f"Accuracy for feature '{feature}': {accuracy:.4f}\n")If this code was not executed, or if you’re running the logistic regression code in a new session or cell that doesn’t have access to this variable,
resultswill not be defined, causing this error.
What should you do?
-
Make sure you run the code block that creates the
resultsdictionary first, so it exists in memory. -
Then you can run this code to select the top 3 features and train logistic regression with them:
from sklearn.linear_model import LogisticRegression from sklearn.metrics import accuracy_score # Sort features by accuracy and pick top 3 sorted_features = sorted(results.items(), key=lambda x: x[1], reverse=True) top3_features = [f for f, acc in sorted_features[:3]] print(f"Top 3 features: {top3_features}") # Extract only these 3 features from the logit-encoded DataFrame X_top3 = X_logit[top3_features] # Train logistic regression log_reg = LogisticRegression() log_reg.fit(X_top3, Y) # Predict on the training data y_pred = log_reg.predict(X_top3) # Calculate and print accuracy accuracy_top3 = accuracy_score(Y, y_pred) print(f"Logistic Regression accuracy on top 3 features: {accuracy_top3:.4f}")
Additional tips
-
If you are using Jupyter Notebook, run all the necessary cells in order, especially the ones where
resultsandX_logitare defined. -
Variables defined in one notebook cell will only be available in other cells if you have run those earlier. If you restart the kernel or open a new notebook, variables are lost until you run the code that defines them again.
-
If you want, I can help you combine all relevant parts into one script or one notebook cell for easier execution.
Let me know if you want me to do that or if you have any other questions!
-
- User
Solve this problem again
- Assistant
Sure! Let me provide you with a complete and standalone solution to build logistic regression on the top-3 most informative features from the Mushroom dataset, based on their frequency-based accuracy.
Step-by-step solution with code:
import numpy as np import pandas as pd from sklearn.metrics import accuracy_score from sklearn.linear_model import LogisticRegression # 1. Load dataset and set columns column_names = [ 'class', 'cap_shape', 'cap_surface', 'cap_color', 'bruises', 'odor', 'gill_attachment', 'gill_spacing', 'gill_size', 'gill_color', 'stalk_shape', 'stalk_root', 'stalk_surface_above_ring', 'stalk_surface_below_ring', 'stalk_color_above_ring', 'stalk_color_below_ring', 'veil_type', 'veil_color', 'ring_number', 'ring_type', 'spore_print_color', 'population', 'habitat' ] mushrooms_df = pd.read_csv( 'https://archive.ics.uci.edu/ml/machine-learning-databases/mushroom/agaricus-lepiota.data', header=None, names=column_names ) # 2. List of features excluding target 'class' features = column_names[1:] # 3. Frequency-based classifier from 2.2 def frequency_based_classifier(features_series: pd.Series, target_series: pd.Series): mapping = {} groups = target_series.groupby(features_series) for val, group in groups: pred_class = group.value_counts().idxmax() mapping[val] = pred_class return mapping # 4. Calculate accuracy for each feature results = {} for feature in features: mapping = frequency_based_classifier(mushrooms_df[feature], mushrooms_df['class']) preds = mushrooms_df[feature].map(mapping) accuracy = accuracy_score(mushrooms_df['class'], preds) results[feature] = accuracy print(f"Accuracy for feature '{feature}': {accuracy:.4f}") # 5. Find top 3 features by accuracy sorted_features = sorted(results.items(), key=lambda x: x[1], reverse=True) top3_features = [f for f, acc in sorted_features[:3]] print(f"\nTop 3 features by accuracy: {top3_features}") # 6. Prepare data for Naive Bayes style encoding with Laplace smoothing (from 2.4) Y = (mushrooms_df['class'] == 'p').astype(int) # target binary encoding: p=1, e=0 prior_probability = Y.mean() prior_logit = np.log(prior_probability) - np.log(1 - prior_probability) X_logit = pd.DataFrame(index=mushrooms_df.index) for feature in features: freq_table = mushrooms_df.groupby(feature)['class'].value_counts().unstack().fillna(0) # Apply Laplace smoothing for 'p' class probability freq_table['prob'] = (freq_table.get('p', 0) + 1) / (freq_table.sum(axis=1) + 2) # Calculate logit offset (subtract prior logit) freq_table['logit'] = np.log(freq_table['prob']) - np.log(1 - freq_table['prob']) - prior_logit # Map logit for each feature value, default 0 if unseen X_logit[feature] = mushrooms_df[feature].map(lambda x: freq_table.at[x, 'logit'] if x in freq_table.index else 0) # 7. Select only top 3 features for logistic regression X_top3 = X_logit[top3_features] # 8. Train logistic regression on top 3 features log_reg = LogisticRegression() log_reg.fit(X_top3, Y) # 9. Predict and calculate accuracy y_pred = log_reg.predict(X_top3) accuracy_top3 = accuracy_score(Y, y_pred) print(f"\nLogistic Regression accuracy on top 3 features: {accuracy_top3:.4f}")
What this code does:
- Downloads and prepares the Mushroom dataset.
- Computes frequency-based accuracy for each categorical feature.
- Selects the three most informative features (highest accuracy).
- Builds a feature representation with target-encoded logits (with Laplace smoothing).
- Fits logistic regression on just these three features.
- Outputs the classification accuracy on the training dataset.
Run this full code snippet in one go in your Python environment (Jupyter Notebook or script) and you will get the answer your professor asked for.
If you want me to help convert it into functions or modularize it — just ask.
- User
Explain in simplest way
- Assistant
Sure! Here’s a simple explanation and what you need to do:
Goal:
You want to build a logistic regression model using the three best features from the Mushroom dataset.
Step-by-step in the simplest terms:
-
Find the best features:
- For each feature, check how well it alone can classify mushrooms (edible or poisonous).
- Save the accuracy for every feature.
- Pick the top 3 features with the highest accuracy.
-
Prepare these top 3 features for logistic regression:
- We convert the features into numbers that reflect how strongly they relate to edible/poisonous classes.
- This uses a special "target encoding" with smoothing (to avoid zero counts).
-
Train logistic regression on just these 3 features.
-
Check accuracy of your model on the same data.
Everything combined looks like this (roughly):
- Get data
- Calculate accuracy of each feature
- Choose 3 best features
- Encode those features with probabilities
- Train logistic regression with those 3 features
- Print accuracy
In short:
Use the 3 most informative features to train a logistic regression and check how well it predicts edible or poisonous mushrooms.
If you want, I can give you a very small example code snippet doing just those steps. Would you like that?
-
Other models, same or similar prompt
Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.
Identical first prompt
- gpt-4-0314Compare side by side →
- gpt-4-0314Compare side by side →
- gpt-3.5-turbo-0301Compare side by side →
- gpt-3.5-turbo-0301Compare side by side →
- gpt-4-0314Compare side by side →
- gpt-4-0314Compare side by side →
- gpt-3.5-turbo-0301Compare side by side →
- gpt-4-0314Compare side by side →
- gpt-4-0314Compare side by side →
- gpt-4-0314Compare side by side →
- gpt-3.5-turbo-0301Compare side by side →
claude-instant-1Compare side by side →