how check size "std::unorderedmap<LampState, uint32t, LampStateHash, LampStateEqual>…
- User
how check size "std::unordered_map<LampState, uint32_t, LampStateHash, LampStateEqual> states2id_ { {{nami_perception_msgs::msg::LampState::RED, 0, 0, 16657}, 1091698688},
{{nami_perception_msgs::msg::LampState::YELLOW, 0, 0, 16657}, 1091829760}, {{nami_perception_msgs::msg::LampState::GREEN, 0, 0, 16657}, 1091960832}, {{nami_perception_msgs::msg::LampState::UNKNOWN, 0, 0, 16657}, 1073741824}, {{nami_perception_msgs::msg::LampState::UNKNOWN, 0, 0, 16673}, 1073741824}, {{nami_perception_msgs::msg::LampState::UNKNOWN, 0, 0, 16689}, 1073741824}, {{nami_perception_msgs::msg::LampState::UNKNOWN, 0, 0, 16705}, 1073741824}, {{nami_perception_msgs::msg::LampState::RED, nami_perception_msgs::msg::LampState::RIGHT, 0, 16673}, 1092747266}, {{nami_perception_msgs::msg::LampState::RED, 0, 0, 16673}, 1092747265}, {{nami_perception_msgs::msg::LampState::GREEN, nami_perception_msgs::msg::LampState::RIGHT, 0, 16673}, 1093009410}, {{nami_perception_msgs::msg::LampState::GREEN, 0, 0, 16673}, 1093009409}, {{nami_perception_msgs::msg::LampState::RED, nami_perception_msgs::msg::LampState::LEFT, 0, 16689}, 1093804032}, {{nami_perception_msgs::msg::LampState::RED, 0, 0, 16689}, 1093799936}, {{nami_perception_msgs::msg::LampState::GREEN, nami_perception_msgs::msg::LampState::LEFT, 0, 16689}, 1094066176}, {{nami_perception_msgs::msg::LampState::GREEN, 0, 0, 16689}, 1094062080} };" ? - Assistant
To check the size of a
std::unordered_mapin C++, you can use thesize()member function. Thesize()function will return the number of key-value pairs in the unordered map.Here's a simple example showing how you could check the size of your
states2id_unordered map:#include <iostream> #include <unordered_map> // Make sure to include the appropriate definition for LampState, LampStateHash, and LampStateEqual // Also include necessary headers int main() { // Assuming necessary definitions for LampState, LampStateHash, and LampStateEqual are available std::unordered_map<LampState, uint32_t, LampStateHash, LampStateEqual> states2id_ = { {{nami_perception_msgs::msg::LampState::RED, 0, 0, 16657}, 1091698688}, {{nami_perception_msgs::msg::LampState::YELLOW, 0, 0, 16657}, 1091829760}, {{nami_perception_msgs::msg::LampState::GREEN, 0, 0, 16657}, 1091960832}, {{nami_perception_msgs::msg::LampState::UNKNOWN, 0, 0, 16657}, 1073741824}, {{nami_perception_msgs::msg::LampState::UNKNOWN, 0, 0, 16673}, 1073741824}, {{nami_perception_msgs::msg::LampState::UNKNOWN, 0, 0, 16689}, 1073741824}, {{nami_perception_msgs::msg::LampState::UNKNOWN, 0, 0, 16705}, 1073741824}, {{nami_perception_msgs::msg::LampState::RED, nami_perception_msgs::msg::LampState::RIGHT, 0, 16673}, 1092747266}, {{nami_perception_msgs::msg::LampState::RED, 0, 0, 16673}, 1092747265}, {{nami_perception_msgs::msg::LampState::GREEN, nami_perception_msgs::msg::LampState::RIGHT, 0, 16673}, 1093009410}, {{nami_perception_msgs::msg::LampState::GREEN, 0, 0, 16673}, 1093009409}, {{nami_perception_msgs::msg::LampState::RED, nami_perception_msgs::msg::LampState::LEFT, 0, 16689}, 1093804032}, {{nami_perception_msgs::msg::LampState::RED, 0, 0, 16689}, 1093799936}, {{nami_perception_msgs::msg::LampState::GREEN, nami_perception_msgs::msg::LampState::LEFT, 0, 16689}, 1094066176}, {{nami_perception_msgs::msg::LampState::GREEN, 0, 0, 16689}, 1094062080} }; // Check the size of the unordered map std::cout << "Size of states2id_: " << states2id_.size() << std::endl; return 0; }In the example above:
- Replace the
LampState,LampStateHash, andLampStateEqualwith your actual struct/class definitions and implementations. - The
size()method is called onstates2id_, and the result is printed to the console.
When you run this code, it will output the number of elements in the
unordered_map. - Replace the
- User
how faster this code "void TrafficLightImageVisualization::loadIcons(const std::string& iconsPath) { std::vectorstd::string iconsPathVec;
cv::glob(iconsPath + "*.png", iconsPathVec, false);
// Declare the map that uses a trafficlight id class as a key, and looks // up a map that stores the trafficlight resized icons for (const auto& iconPath : iconsPathVec) { uint32_t iconId; cv::Mat resizedTl; processIcon(iconPath, iconId, resizedTl); dbTls_[iconId] = resizedTl; } }
"
- Assistant
To improve the performance of your
loadIconsmethod in theTrafficLightImageVisualizationclass, there are several aspects to consider. Here are potential optimizations you might implement:Code Review and Optimization Suggestions:
-
Reserve Capacity for the Vector: If you have an idea of the number of icons you expect to load, you can reserve space in the vector to avoid multiple allocations.
std::vector<std::string> iconsPathVec; // Reserve space (example) iconsPathVec.reserve(100); // Adjust as necessary based on your expected input -
Avoid Repeated String Concatenation: If you're constructing the glob pattern in a more complex way, reduce the overhead:
std::string globPattern = iconsPath + "*.png"; cv::glob(globPattern, iconsPathVec, false); -
Parallel Processing: If
processIconis independent for each icon path, consider parallelizing the processing using a thread pool or a parallel execution method (ifprocessIconexecutes independently and the resultingcv::Matcan be safely written to thedbTls_without conflicts).#include <thread> #include <vector> #include <future> // Assuming dbTls_ is a thread-safe data structure, like std::mutex wrapped access std::vector<std::future<void>> futures; for (const auto& iconPath : iconsPathVec) { futures.push_back(std::async(std::launch::async, [this, iconPath]() { uint32_t iconId; cv::Mat resizedTl; processIcon(iconPath, iconId, resizedTl); std::lock_guard<std::mutex> lock(dbTlsMutex_); dbTls_[iconId] = resizedTl; })); } // Wait for all futures to complete for (auto& future : futures) { future.get(); } -
Optimizing
processIcon: Analyze theprocessIconfunction's implementation. If it can be optimized to reduce computational expense (e.g., caching results, optimizing image processing), it could reduce the load time significantly. -
Check File I/O Overhead: If
cv::globis slow due to many files, ensure you're managing file I/O efficiently. Avoid scanning directories incorrectly or overloading with unnecessary files. -
Use of Map Efficiently: Depending on frequency and performance needs, you might analyze how frequently
dbTls_is accessed. If you have lots of read-heavy operations, consider using a read-write lock or other concurrency strategies to minimize overhead when accessing the map. -
Minimize Copies: Ensure you're not making unnecessary copies of large
cv::Matobjects. For example, consider using move semantics or direct assignments instead of copying when possible.
Example of Refactored Code
Here's your
loadIconsmethod with some of the discussed optimizations:void TrafficLightImageVisualization::loadIcons(const std::string& iconsPath) { std::vector<std::string> iconsPathVec; std::string globPattern = iconsPath + "*.png"; cv::glob(globPattern, iconsPathVec, false); std::vector<std::future<void>> futures; for (const auto& iconPath : iconsPathVec) { futures.push_back(std::async(std::launch::async, [this, iconPath]() { uint32_t iconId; cv::Mat resizedTl; processIcon(iconPath, iconId, resizedTl); std::lock_guard<std::mutex> lock(dbTlsMutex_); dbTls_[iconId] = std::move(resizedTl); // Use move to avoid copy })); } // Wait for all futures to complete for (auto& future : futures) { future.get(); } }Concluding Notes
Depending on your specific application and environment that can influence the performance, the importance of these optimizations can vary. Always profile before and after making changes to ensure that your optimizations yield the expected performance improvements.
-
- User
how faster "std::string globPattern = iconsPath.append(".png"); cv::glob(globPattern, iconsPathVec, false);" or "std::string globPattern = iconsPath + ".png"; cv::glob(globPattern, iconsPathVec, false);"?
- Assistant
To determine which of the following two approaches is faster in C++, we should look closely at how each one constructs the
globPatternstring:-
Using
append:std::string globPattern = iconsPath.append("*.png"); -
Using string concatenation (
+):std::string globPattern = iconsPath + "*.png";
Performance Considerations
-
Memory Allocations:
append: ForiconsPath.append("*.png"), the method modifiesiconsPathdirectly. IficonsPathhas enough capacity, it will not trigger reallocations. However, if it needs to grow, it may incur additional cost due to memory allocations.+operator: TheiconsPath + "*.png"creates a new string that contains the contents oficonsPathplus"*.png". This means a new object is created, requiring its own memory allocation (which may or may not involve copying, depending on optimization).
-
Return of the String:
- Both operations will produce a
std::stringthat contains the same final result. The execution time may differ depending on internal handling of memory and string length.
- Both operations will produce a
-
Optimization:
- Modern compilers (with optimizations turned on) might inline and optimize both expressions to produce similar results at runtime in terms of performance. The difference would typically be marginal, with the concatenation possibly being a bit slower due to creation of a temporary string.
-
Readability:
- While performance is important, readability and maintainability of code are also critical factors. The
+operator is often clearer to someone reading the code compared to theappend()method.
- While performance is important, readability and maintainability of code are also critical factors. The
Conclusion
Timing and Measurement:
If you want to know the exact performance difference, you should measure them in your specific use case (considering both usual and edge cases). You can do this using a simple timing mechanism in C++:
#include <iostream> #include <string> #include <vector> #include <chrono> #include <opencv2/opencv.hpp> void measurePerformance(const std::string& iconsPath) { std::vector<std::string> iconsPathVec; auto start1 = std::chrono::high_resolution_clock::now(); std::string globPattern1 = iconsPath.append("*.png"); cv::glob(globPattern1, iconsPathVec, false); auto end1 = std::chrono::high_resolution_clock::now(); auto start2 = std::chrono::high_resolution_clock::now(); std::string globPattern2 = iconsPath + "*.png"; cv::glob(globPattern2, iconsPathVec, false); auto end2 = std::chrono::high_resolution_clock::now(); std::chrono::duration<double, std::milli> elapsed1 = end1 - start1; std::chrono::duration<double, std::milli> elapsed2 = end2 - start2; std::cout << "append time: " << elapsed1.count() << " ms\n"; std::cout << "concatenation time: " << elapsed2.count() << " ms\n"; } int main() { std::string iconsPath = "/path/to/icons/"; measurePerformance(iconsPath); return 0; }Final Recommendation:
While it's valuable to consider performance, in many cases, the difference might not be significant in practical use. Hence, choose the method that you find more readable and maintainable, unless you are in a performance-critical section of code where every microsecond counts. If performance becomes a crucial aspect, you can measure as suggested above.
-
- User
main.cpp:10:48: error: no matching function for call to ‘std::__cxx11::basic_string::append(const char [6]) const’ 10 | std::string globPattern1 = iconsPath.append("*.png");
- Assistant
The error you're encountering occurs because the
std::string::appendmethod modifies the string in place and returns a reference to the modified string, which cannot be used directly in the way shown in the error message. When you callappend, it modifiesiconsPath, which might not be what you want if you need to keep the original string intact.To fix this issue, you can either use the
std::string::appendin a different form or use the+operator for concatenation, which is preferable for clarity and safety, avoiding direct modification of the original string.Options to Fix the Code
Below are two correct alternatives:
-
Use
std::string::appendwith a temporary object: You can perform theappendoperation to a temporary string instead of modifyingiconsPath.std::string globPattern1 = iconsPath; // Create a copy globPattern1.append("*.png"); -
Use the
+operator: This is often clearer and avoids direct modification oficonsPath.std::string globPattern1 = iconsPath + "*.png";
Example of Fixed Code
Here’s the adjusted version of the code with both approaches included:
#include <iostream> #include <string> #include <vector> #include <chrono> #include <opencv2/opencv.hpp> void measurePerformance(const std::string& iconsPath) { std::vector<std::string> iconsPathVec; // First approach using append auto start1 = std::chrono::high_resolution_clock::now(); std::string globPattern1 = iconsPath; // Make a copy to avoid modifying the original globPattern1.append("*.png"); cv::glob(globPattern1, iconsPathVec, false); auto end1 = std::chrono::high_resolution_clock::now(); // Second approach using concatenation auto start2 = std::chrono::high_resolution_clock::now(); std::string globPattern2 = iconsPath + "*.png"; cv::glob(globPattern2, iconsPathVec, false); auto end2 = std::chrono::high_resolution_clock::now(); std::chrono::duration<double, std::milli> elapsed1 = end1 - start1; std::chrono::duration<double, std::milli> elapsed2 = end2 - start2; std::cout << "append time: " << elapsed1.count() << " ms\n"; std::cout << "concatenation time: " << elapsed2.count() << " ms\n"; } int main() { std::string iconsPath = "/path/to/icons/"; measurePerformance(iconsPath); return 0; }Summary
- Directly modifying
iconsPath: This is not recommended if you need to keep the original string unchanged. - Using a copy or the concatenation operator: Both methods are valid. The
+operator is typically preferred for its clarity and safety. - Always measure performance: If performance is critical, use timing as shown above to compare the methods in context.
-