Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
gpt-4o-mini-2024-07-18· OpenAIAi2 WildChat-4.8M (AI2)

Java%20garbage%20collector%20collection%20question.%20If%20I'm%20holding%20a%20reference%…

  1. User

    Java%20garbage%20collector%20collection%20question.%20If%20I'm%20holding%20a%20reference%20to%20an%20object%20(A)%20that%20itself%20holds%20a%20reference%20to%20another%20object%20(B)%2C%20and%20I%20pass%20A%20into%20another%20thread%2C%20but%20then%20afterwards%20B%20is%20changed%20to%20C%2C%20does%20the%20new%20thread%20see%20B%20or%20C%3F

  2. Assistant

    In Java, when you pass object A into another thread, that thread receives a reference to the same A object that the original thread was holding. If A holds a reference to object B, the new thread can access B through that reference.

    However, if afterward you change the reference held by A to a new object C (e.g., A.setB(C)), whether the new thread sees B or C depends on how the reference to B was changed.

    1. If you modify A directly to point to C: If the thread that received A sees B, it won’t see C unless it re-evaluates or accesses A after the change. This means if the new thread accesses A after you updated it, it will see C; otherwise, it will continue to see B.

    2. If you change the state of B to create C: If B has mutable state and you’re changing some properties of B instead of changing what A references, both threads will still reference the same B object. If you change B to have the characteristics of C (e.g., updating its properties), the new thread will see those updates as long as the new thread accesses B directly.

    In summary:

    • If you change the reference of B in A to C, the new thread will still see the old reference B unless it accesses A after the update to see C.
    • If you change the contents/state of B to represent C but do not modify the reference in A, both threads will see the modified state of B.

    Note on Thread Safety

    Be cautious when updating shared data or references across threads, as doing so without proper synchronization can lead to visibility issues. Using volatile variables, synchronized blocks, or other concurrency controls is often necessary to ensure that changes made by one thread are visible to others.