Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
o1-preview-2024-09-12· OpenAIAi2 WildChat-4.8M (AI2)

Twelve packets are sent over TCP, with a 1ms difference in the submission time. The…

  1. User

    Twelve packets are sent over TCP, with a 1ms difference in the submission time. The first packet is sent at time 0. The receivers send ACK immediately when receiving a packet. The RTT is 8ms (half RTT is 4ms), and the timeout time is 10ms. The transmission time (that is, putting the data on the line) for the packets and ACK is negligible. Assume that the TCP window size is always big enough, so there is no need to wait to send new packets. Also, assume that all packets sent before time 0 were already acknowledged. There is no use of “delayed Ack” (an ACK is sent as soon as a packet arrives). A packet that is sent again can be sent immediately.

    1. (3 points) Assume that the ACK for the seventh packet (sent at time 6) was lost. Also, assume that the fast retransmit is used and no more packets are lost. When will the sender know that the seventh packet has arrived?
    2. (3 points) Assume the seventh packet (sent at time 6) was lost. Also assume that the fast retransmit is not used, and no more packets are lost. When will the seventh packet arrive (to the receiver)?
    3. (3 points) Assume the third packet (sent at time 2) was lost. Also assume that the fast retransmit is used, and no more messages are lost. When will the third packet arrive (to the receiver)?
    4. (3 points) Assume the third packet (sent at time 2) was lost. In addition, also the fourth, sixth and seventh packets were lost. Assume that the fast retransmit is used, and no more packets are lost. When will the third packet arrive (to the receiver)?
    5. (3 points) Assume the third packet (sent at time 2) was lost. In addition, also the fourth, sixth and seventh packets were lost. Assume that the fast retransmit is not used, and no more packets are lost. When will the third packet arrive (to the receiver)?
    6. (5 points) Assume the second packet (sent at time 1) was lost. In addition, also the third, fourth, fifth, sixth, seventh, eighth and ninth packets were lost. Assume that the fast retransmit is used, and no more packets are lost. When will the third packet arrive (to the receiver)? As a course assistant in computer networks BS.c, show detailed calculations with deep explanations so we may understand each answer.
  2. Assistant

    To determine when the sender will know that the seventh packet has arrived when its ACK is lost, we need to analyze the sequence of events, considering TCP's cumulative acknowledgment mechanism.

    Sequence of Events:

    1. Packet 7 Sent:

      • Time Sent: 6 ms
      • Time Received by Receiver: (6 \text{ ms (send time)} + 4 \text{ ms (one-way delay)} = 10 \text{ ms})
      • Receiver Action: Sends ACK for packet 7 immediately at 10 ms.
      • Issue: The ACK sent at 10 ms is lost in transit.
    2. Packet 8 Sent:

      • Time Sent: 7 ms
      • Time Received by Receiver: (7 \text{ ms} + 4 \text{ ms} = 11 \text{ ms})
      • Receiver Action: Since packet 7 was received earlier, packets are in order. The receiver sends a cumulative ACK acknowledging up to packet 8 immediately at 11 ms.
    3. ACK for Packet 8 Received by Sender:

      • Time ACK Sent by Receiver: 11 ms
      • Time Received by Sender: (11 \text{ ms} + 4 \text{ ms} = 15 \text{ ms})

    Explanation:

    • TCP's Cumulative Acknowledgment:

      • TCP acknowledges the highest sequence number of in-order received data. Even though the ACK for packet 7 was lost, the ACK for packet 8 will cumulatively acknowledge all packets up to packet 8.
    • Sender's Knowledge:

      • Upon receiving the cumulative ACK for packet 8 at 15 ms, the sender realizes that packets up to packet 8 (including packet 7) have been successfully received.

    Answer:

    The sender will know that the seventh packet has arrived when it receives the cumulative ACK for packet 8 at 15 milliseconds.