Skip to content
The Chat Archive
o1-preview-2024-09-12· OpenAI WildChat-4.8M (AI2)

explain this with example: You may have seen code that doesn’t use super(), but instead…

  1. User

    explain this with example: You may have seen code that doesn’t use super(), but instead calls the method directly on the superclass, like this: class NotRecommended(OrderedDict): """This is a counter example!""" def setitem(self, key, value): OrderedDict.setitem(self, key, value) self.move_to_end(key) This alternative works in this particular case, but is not recommended for two rea‐ sons. First, it hardcodes the base class. The name OrderedDict appears in the class statement and also inside setitem. If in the future someone changes the class statement to change the base class or add another one, they may forget to update the body of setitem, introducing a bug. The super() Function | 4893 It is also possible to provide only the first argument, but this not useful and may soon be deprecated, with the blessing of Guido van Rossum who created super() in the first place. See the discussion at “Is it time to dep‐ recate unbound super methods?”. The second reason is that super implements logic to handle class hierarchies with multiple inheritance. We’ll come back to that in “Multiple Inheritance and Method Resolution Order” on page 494. To conclude this refresher about super, it is useful to review how we had to call it in Python 2, because the old signature with two argu‐ ments is revealing: class LastUpdatedOrderedDict(OrderedDict): """This code works in Python 2 and Python 3""" def setitem(self, key, value): super(LastUpdatedOrderedDict, self).setitem(key, value) self.move_to_end(key) Both arguments of super are now optional. The Python 3 bytecode compiler auto‐ matically provides them by inspecting the surrounding context when super() is invoked in a method. The arguments are: type The start of the search path for the superclass implementing the desired method. By default, it is the class that owns the method where the super() call appears. object_or_type The object (for instance method calls) or class (for class method calls) to be the receiver of the method call. By default, it is self if the super() call happens in an instance method. Whether you or the compiler provides those arguments, the super() call returns a dynamic proxy object that finds a method (such as setitem in the example) in a superclass of the type parameter, and binds it to the object_or_type, so that we don’t need to pass the receiver (self) explicitly when invoking the method. In Python 3, you can still explicitly provide the first and second arguments to super().3 But they are needed only in special cases, such as skipping over part of the MRO for testing or debugging, or for working around undesired behavior in a superclass.

  2. Assistant

    Certainly! Let's break down the concept with examples to understand why using super() is recommended over directly calling methods on the superclass in Python, especially when dealing with inheritance and method overriding.

    The Scenario

    Suppose we have a subclass that inherits from a superclass and we want to override a method from the superclass while still calling the original implementation. There are two ways to do this:

    1. Directly calling the superclass method by referencing the superclass name.
    2. Using the super() function to call the superclass method.

    Let's explore both methods with examples.


    Example 1: Directly Calling the Superclass Method

    Here's an example where we directly call the superclass method by referencing its name:

    from collections import OrderedDict
    
    class NotRecommended(OrderedDict):
        """This is a counter example!"""
        def __setitem__(self, key, value):
            OrderedDict.__setitem__(self, key, value)
            self.move_to_end(key)
    

    In this code:

    • We have a class NotRecommended that inherits from OrderedDict.
    • We override the __setitem__ method.
    • Inside __setitem__, we directly call OrderedDict.__setitem__(self, key, value) to use the superclass implementation.

    Why This Is Not Recommended

    1. Hardcoding the Superclass Name:

      • Issue: The name OrderedDict is hardcoded inside the __setitem__ method.
      • Implication: If we later change the superclass or add multiple superclasses, the reference inside __setitem__ will not automatically update. This can introduce bugs if someone forgets to update the method.
    2. Multiple Inheritance Issues:

      • Issue: Directly referencing OrderedDict bypasses the method resolution order (MRO) provided by Python's inheritance mechanism.
      • Implication: In cases of multiple inheritance, directly calling the superclass method may skip other superclass implementations that should be called.

    Example 2: Using super() to Call the Superclass Method

    Here's how you can use super():

    from collections import OrderedDict
    
    class Recommended(OrderedDict):
        """This is the recommended approach."""
        def __setitem__(self, key, value):
            super().__setitem__(key, value)
            self.move_to_end(key)
    

    In this code:

    • We have a class Recommended that also inherits from OrderedDict.
    • We override the __setitem__ method.
    • We use super().__setitem__(key, value) to call the superclass method.

    Benefits of Using super()

    1. No Hardcoding of Superclass Name:

      • Advantage: We don't need to mention OrderedDict inside the method.
      • Implication: If we change the superclass in the class definition, super() will automatically refer to the new superclass. This reduces the risk of bugs due to forgotten updates.
    2. Proper Handling of Multiple Inheritance:

      • Advantage: super() respects the method resolution order (MRO) in Python.
      • Implication: In multiple inheritance scenarios, super() ensures that all appropriate superclass methods are called in the correct order.

    Demonstrating the Problem with an Example

    Let's illustrate the issue by modifying the base class.

    Changing the Superclass

    Suppose we change the superclass from OrderedDict to dict:

    from collections import OrderedDict
    
    class NotRecommended(dict):
        """Changed to inherit from dict instead of OrderedDict."""
        def __setitem__(self, key, value):
            # Still calling OrderedDict.__setitem__, which is incorrect now
            OrderedDict.__setitem__(self, key, value)
            self.move_to_end(key)  # AttributeError: 'NotRecommended' object has no attribute 'move_to_end'
    
    • Issue: The class now inherits from dict, but inside __setitem__, it's still calling OrderedDict.__setitem__.
    • Error: This will cause incorrect behavior or errors because dict doesn't have the move_to_end method, and we're calling the wrong superclass method.

    Using super() After Changing the Superclass

    Now, if we use super():

    class Recommended(dict):
        """Changed to inherit from dict instead of OrderedDict."""
        def __setitem__(self, key, value):
            super().__setitem__(key, value)
            # self.move_to_end(key)  # This will still raise an AttributeError
    
    • Behavior: super().__setitem__(key, value) now correctly refers to dict.__setitem__.
    • Error Handling: Although dict doesn't have move_to_end, the call to super() didn't introduce a bug by referencing the wrong class.

    Multiple Inheritance and Method Resolution Order (MRO)

    Let's consider a scenario with multiple inheritance:

    class LoggingMixin:
        def __setitem__(self, key, value):
            print(f"Setting {key} = {value}")
            super().__setitem__(key, value)
    
    class CustomDict(LoggingMixin, dict):
        pass
    
    • Explanation:
      • CustomDict inherits from both LoggingMixin and dict.
      • LoggingMixin also overrides __setitem__ and calls super().__setitem__.

    Using super() in Multiple Inheritance

    When we use super(), Python's MRO ensures that all __setitem__ methods in the inheritance chain are called appropriately.

    d = CustomDict()
    d['key'] = 'value'
    

    Output:

    Setting key = value
    
    • Behavior: The __setitem__ method of LoggingMixin is called, which prints the message and then calls super().__setitem__.
    • MRO Chain: super() moves to dict.__setitem__.

    Directly Calling the Superclass Method in Multiple Inheritance

    If we had called dict.__setitem__ directly:

    class LoggingMixin:
        def __setitem__(self, key, value):
            print(f"Setting {key} = {value}")
            dict.__setitem__(self, key, value)
    
    • Issue: Bypasses any other superclass methods in the MRO.
    • Implication: If there are other classes in the inheritance chain that also override __setitem__, their implementations will be skipped.

    Understanding super() with Explicit Arguments

    In Python 2, super() required explicit arguments:

    class LastUpdatedOrderedDict(OrderedDict):
        def __setitem__(self, key, value):
            super(LastUpdatedOrderedDict, self).__setitem__(key, value)
            self.move_to_end(key)
    
    • Arguments:
      • LastUpdatedOrderedDict: The class where super() is called.
      • self: The instance of the class.

    How super() Works

    • Dynamic Proxy: super() returns a proxy object that delegates method calls to a parent or sibling class.
    • Automatic Arguments in Python 3: In Python 3, both arguments are optional because the compiler can infer them from the context.
    • Method Binding: The method found via super() is bound to self, so you don't need to pass self when calling it.

    Key Takeaways

    1. Avoid Hardcoding Superclass Names:

      • Using super() makes your code more maintainable and less error-prone when changes are made to the class hierarchy.
    2. Leverage Method Resolution Order (MRO):

      • super() works seamlessly with Python's MRO, ensuring that methods in multiple inheritance are called in the correct order.
    3. Write Forward-Compatible Code:

      • By using super(), your subclasses remain compatible with future changes to the superclass or the addition of mixins.
    4. Simplify Code Maintenance:

      • If the base class or the class hierarchy changes, you don't need to update the method calls inside your methods.

    Conclusion

    Always prefer using super() when calling methods from a superclass. It leads to cleaner, more maintainable, and more robust code, especially in complex inheritance scenarios.


    Additional Example: Using super() with Multiple Inheritance

    Let's demonstrate a complete example with multiple inheritance.

    class A:
        def action(self):
            print("Action in A")
    
    class B(A):
        def action(self):
            print("Action in B")
            super().action()
    
    class C(A):
        def action(self):
            print("Action in C")
            super().action()
    
    class D(B, C):
        def action(self):
            print("Action in D")
            super().action()
    
    d = D()
    d.action()
    

    Output:

    Action in D
    Action in B
    Action in C
    Action in A
    
    • Explanation:
      • The super().action() calls in each class ensure that all superclass methods are called following the MRO.
      • If we had directly called a superclass method like A.action(self), we would have skipped other classes in the MRO.

    By using super(), you ensure that your code is maintainable, respects the inheritance hierarchy, and avoids potential bugs that can occur by directly referencing superclass methods.