Skip to content
The Chat Archive
o1-preview-2024-09-12· OpenAI WildChat-4.8M (AI2)

Assume I have integer equations of this form: (n*k1) + a1 (n*k2) - a2 ... n is an…

  1. User

    Assume I have integer equations of this form: (nk_1) + a_1 (nk_2) - a_2 ... n is an integer, ks are integers and a_n can be wither 1, -1 or 0

    Also assume I have a domain, which can get exponentially larger I want a method to find at least one integer which is not part of any equation

    I don't want to enumerate because I have to do it in polynomial time

  2. Assistant

    To solve your problem efficiently, you can leverage properties of modular arithmetic and the fact that each of your equations defines an arithmetic progression over the integers.

    Each equation ((n \cdot k_i) + a_i) generates numbers congruent to (a_i \mod k_i). This means that for each (k_i), the set of integers that are equal to ((n \cdot k_i) + a_i) for some integer (n) is precisely the set of all integers congruent to (a_i) modulo (k_i).

    Your goal is to find an integer (y) that is not congruent to (a_i) modulo (k_i) for any (i), i.e., (y \mod k_i \ne a_i) for all (i).

    Here's how you can proceed:

    1. Initialize (y = 1).

    2. Loop:

      • For each (i):
        • Compute (r_i = y \mod k_i).
        • If (r_i = a_i), this (y) is "bad" (it matches one of the forbidden congruencies). Break out of the inner loop and increment (y).
      • If (y) passes through all (k_i) without matching any (a_i), then (y) is a valid integer not equal to any of the expressions ((n \cdot k_i) + a_i).
    3. Increment (y) and repeat the loop until a valid (y) is found.

    Because the (k_i) can be large, but you're testing small values of (y), the probability that (y) will satisfy (y \mod k_i \ne a_i) for each (i) is high. This is due to the fact that for each modulus (k_i), there are (k_i - 1) acceptable residues out of (k_i) possible residues. Therefore, the expected number of (y) values you'll need to check is small, and the algorithm runs in polynomial time.

    In this way, you can efficiently find an integer that is not part of any of the given equations without enumerating the exponentially large domain.

    Answer:

    Yes—you can find such an integer by trying small values of y and checking whether y mod k₁ ≠ a₁, y mod k₂ ≠ a₂, etc.; since the forbidden remainders aᵢ are rare, a small y avoiding them all can be found in polynomial time without exhaustive search.