Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
gpt-4o-2024-11-20· OpenAIAi2 WildChat-4.8M (AI2)

I am reviewing some classes that use polymorphism and inheritance of a colleague of…

  1. User

    I am reviewing some classes that use polymorphism and inheritance of a colleague of mine. However, I am a little bit stuck while understanding if her proposal is fine or not from a design perspective. Indeed, let me share the base class: class Account { private: std::string name; double balance;

    public: Account(const std::string &name = "Unnamed Account", double balance = 0.0) : name{name}, balance{balance} {}

    virtual bool deposit(double amount);
    virtual bool withdraw(double amount);
    
    virtual double get_balance() const;
    virtual std::string get_name() const;
    virtual void display() const
    {
        std::cout << "Account Name: " << name << ", Balance: " << balance << std::endl;
    }
    
    virtual ~Account() = default;
    

    }; ~ This class is a mix between an interface and a base class. Indeed, the user needs name and balance as per a base class. deposit and withdraw should be implemented for each derived, so I expect them as pure virtual. get_balance and get_name I expect them not virtual because they should be just getters. display could be changed while adding a private member that contains a class name such that it can be implemented just once because it can retrieve the class name from a private member. I have two questions:

    1. Does my improvements sound for you? (I know you have few context)
    2. Generally speaking, I can I choose from a design perspective what is the best approach in such a case? There are thumb rule or questions that I can ask myself to improve the code from a design perspective? Thank you for the feedback.
  2. Assistant

    It's great that you're carefully analyzing the design of the class and thinking critically about how it can be improved. I'll try to address both of your questions in detail.


    1. Do your proposed improvements make sense?

    Let's examine your points regarding improvements to the Account class:

    a) Deposit and withdraw as pure virtual methods

    • Your suggestion to make deposit and withdraw pure virtual methods (virtual bool deposit(double amount) = 0;) makes sense if the base class Account is indeed intended to be an abstract base class (acting as an interface) that leaves specific behavior for derived classes.
    • In other words, if each type of account (such as SavingsAccount, CheckingAccount, etc.) has completely different implementations for deposit and withdraw, then making them pure virtual is appropriate.
    • However, if there’s a default implementation (e.g., generic logic for deposit/withdraw), you may want to keep them as virtual with a default behavior that can be optionally overridden.

    b) Getters (get_balance and get_name) should not be virtual

    • You are correct: get_balance and get_name seem like simple getters that rely on data members of the base class, and unless there's a strong reason for these to vary in behavior in derived classes, they shouldn’t be virtual at all. Leave them as regular (non-virtual) member functions.
    • If no overriding is required for these functions, making them virtual violates the "You Aren't Gonna Need It" (YAGNI) principle.

    c) display() function enhancement

    • Good insight! If you want to define the behavior of display() only once in the base class but allow it to include class-specific information, you can introduce a private std::string in the base class to hold a class name or identifier (e.g., "SavingsAccount", "CheckingAccount", etc.). You can set this member in the constructor of the derived class using Account’s constructor.
    • Alternatively, the typeid(*this).name() function from <typeinfo> can provide the runtime class name, but it’s not as clean and isn't user-friendly (the output can be cryptic or compiler-specific).

    Your overall suggestions are valid and aligned with good design practices.


    2. How to evaluate the design objectively?

    When evaluating or designing a class that uses inheritance and polymorphism, you should consider the following principles and ask yourself specific guiding questions:


    a) Single Responsibility Principle (SRP)

    Does the class have a clear and focused responsibility?

    • The Account class seems reasonably focused—it represents a general concept of an account, providing basic fields (name, balance) and behaviors (deposit, withdraw). However, it's an interesting mix of being both an interface and a base class that carries implementation. Ensure you're not trying to do too much in one class.

    b) Interface Segregation Principle (ISP)

    Is the interface exposing only the required operations?

    • If derived classes must implement deposit and withdraw, these should either:
      • Be pure virtual methods (= 0).
      • Or, provide default behavior in the base class where possible.
    • For simple getters like get_balance and get_name, making them virtual unnecessarily burdens users who derive from this class—they shouldn't have to worry about overriding trivial functionality.

    c) Liskov Substitution Principle (LSP)

    Can I seamlessly substitute derived classes where the base is expected?

    • Any derived class (e.g., SavingsAccount) should behave like an Account without clients needing to know whether it's a base class or derived class. For example:
      • If withdraw or deposit isn't implemented properly in the derived class, you might break this principle.
      • To avoid this, the behavior of the base class should be as generic and intuitive as possible.

    d) Dependency Inversion Principle (DIP)

    Am I coding to an abstraction, rather than a concrete implementation?

    • If the Account class will be used by higher-level modules as a polymorphic base, it’s better to define it abstractly—meaning minimal implementation in the base class and leaving specifics to derived classes.

    e) Open/Closed Principle (OCP)

    Can I extend the class without modifying its base structure?

    • The base Account class is reasonably extensible. By relying on deposit, withdraw, and potentially virtual properties of display, you can add new account types and customize their behavior.
    • However, to adhere to OCP, ensure the base class provides enough customization points for derived classes without needing to edit the base itself.

    Guiding Questions for Refactoring

    Ask yourself these questions to assess and improve the design:

    1. What is the role of this class?

      • If Account is meant to be a reusable abstraction (interface), simplify it and make the non-essential parts like name or balance optional. Introduce a pure separator between what should be implemented and inherited.
    2. Which methods vary across derived classes?

      • If all derived classes must override a method like deposit, make it pure virtual.
    3. Which methods are fixed (base functionality)?

      • If functionality like get_balance or get_name is fixed, don’t expose them as virtual—make them non-virtual.
    4. Do I require polymorphic behavior?

      • display is a candidate for polymorphic behavior, but if the output is derived from other fields in the base class, it could be made non-virtual to simplify the implementation.
    5. Am I violating encapsulation?

      • Ensure that the details (name, balance) cannot be directly tampered with outside the class and provide controlled access via non-virtual getters if needed.

    Final Suggestions

    Here’s how you might refactor the Account class based on your feedback:

    class Account {
    private:
        std::string name;
        double balance;
        
    protected:
        std::string account_type;  // Add a member to store the type of account for display()
    
    public:
        Account(const std::string& name = "Unnamed Account", double balance = 0.0, const std::string& type = "Account")
            : name{name}, balance{balance}, account_type{type} {}
    
        virtual bool deposit(double amount) = 0;   // Pure virtual for custom implementation in derived classes.
        virtual bool withdraw(double amount) = 0; // Same logic as deposit.
    
        double get_balance() const { return balance; } // Standard getters - keep non-virtual.
        std::string get_name() const { return name; } 
        
        virtual void display() const {
            // Default behavior for display, extendable in derived classes if needed.
            std::cout << "Account Type: " << account_type 
                      << ", Account Name: " << name 
                      << ", Balance: " << balance << std::endl;
        }
    
        virtual ~Account() = default; // Virtual destructor for polymorphic base class.
    };
    

    Derived classes can set account_type to represent their type, provide their own implementations for deposit and withdraw, and override display if required.


    Takeaway

    Your proposed improvements are solid, especially in making deposit and withdraw pure virtual, simplifying getters, and ensuring display is cleaner. When evaluating designs in general:

    • Focus on separating interface and implementation appropriately,
    • Adhere to SOLID principles,
    • Avoid premature generalization (don’t overuse virtual unnecessarily), and
    • Make the design extensible without sacrificing clarity.

    This approach will lead to a clean, maintainable design!