I want to make my own self consolidating concrete. I live in the Philippines and have…
- User
I want to make my own self consolidating concrete. I live in the Philippines and have access to river sand, cement, vulcanic ash, and different additives like plastizers and so on. I also have all kinds of tools. I have no experience how to do this, but I saw videos online where people have created self consolidating concrete with very little cement (much less than for normal concrete) that has a spread from a slump cone of 800 millimeter and that reaches a compression strength of 50 to 70 megapascal after just one day. Can you guide me step-by-step how to do it?
- Assistant
Creating your own self-consolidating concrete (SCC) requires precise formulation and testing to ensure quality, as SCC is designed to flow easily under its own weight and fill formworks without mechanical vibration. Here's a general guide to help you get started, considering your available materials:
Materials:
- Cement - Portland cement is commonly used.
- Fine aggregate - River sand.
- Coarse aggregate - Choose well-graded, clean stones.
- Volcanic ash (pozzolan) - Can replace a portion of cement to reduce cost and enhance properties.
- Superplasticizer (high-range water reducer) - To increase workability.
- Viscosity-modifying admixture (VMA) - Optional, helps maintain stability.
- Water - Clean mixing water.
Tools:
- Mixing container
- Slump cone for testing spread
- Measuring tools (weight scale, volumetric containers)
- Concrete mixer
Steps:
-
Proportioning the Mix:
- Start with a target mix ratio, commonly 1:1.5:2 (cement: sand: coarse aggregate) by volume for normal concrete.
- For SCC, reduce the cement content and increase the fines (volcanic ash and sand).
- Example starting ratio: 1:2:1.5 (cement: fines: aggregate). Use volcanic ash to replace 20-30% of the cement content.
-
Determine Water-to-Cement Ratio (w/c):
- Aim for a low water-to-cement ratio (0.35 - 0.40) for high strength.
- Adjust based on workability requirements.
-
Additives:
- Superplasticizer: Add according to the manufacturer’s instructions. This is key for flowability.
- VMA: Use if segregation or bleeding occurs.
-
Mixing:
- Start by mixing dry ingredients (cement, volcanic ash, and sand).
- Add about 2/3 of the water and mix for a few minutes.
- Slowly add superplasticizer and remaining water while mixing.
- Finally, add coarse aggregates and mix thoroughly.
-
Test Workability:
- Use a slump cone to measure the spread. You should aim for a spread of 650-800 mm.
- Adjust the superplasticizer dosage or water content to achieve the desired flow.
-
Make Test Specimens:
- Pour the SCC into molds for cylindrical or cube specimens.
- Allow the concrete to cure for 24 hours in a moist environment or cover it with plastic sheets to prevent water loss.
-
Testing:
- Test the compressive strength after 1 day using appropriate equipment. Adjust your mix design based on results.
- Continue to test for 7, 28 days for further validation.
-
Adjustments & Iteration:
- Revise your mix proportions, admixture dosages, or raw material quality as needed to reach desired properties.
- Document each batch to refine your method and reproduce successful results.
Tips:
- Safety: Always wear protective gear (gloves, mask, goggles) when handling materials.
- Quality Control: Consistent mixing time and technique are critical for repeatability.
- Curing Conditions: Ensure consistent curing conditions for accurate strength results.
Since achieving a 50-70 MPa in one day is ambitious and depends heavily on precise control over materials and methods, it might take several iterations to optimize your mix. Consider consulting local experts or laboratories if you encounter difficulties.
- User
Do I need sieves with different meshes (5mm, 2mm, all the way down to 0.045mm) also? Will it help? I read that online.
- Assistant
Yes, sieves with different mesh sizes can be very beneficial when preparing self-consolidating concrete (SCC) as they allow for precise control over the particle size distribution of your aggregates. This is crucial because SCC relies heavily on having the right balance of coarse and fine materials to ensure good flowability and to prevent segregation. Here's how sieving can help:
-
Achieving Optimal Particle Size Distribution:
- Sieving allows you to classify and separate aggregates into different size fractions. By combining these in the right proportions, you can achieve a dense packing of particles, which is crucial for the flowability and stability of SCC.
-
Reducing Voids:
- Proper grading minimizes void content in the mix, requiring less paste (water and cementitious materials) to fill gaps, which enhances strength and reduces material costs.
-
Controlling Fines Content:
- Finer particles (like silt and clay from unwashed sand) can adversely affect the workability and stability of SCC. Using a sieve stack down to 0.045 mm helps control and limit the amount of fines, impacting the viscosity of the mix.
-
Enhancing Mix Consistency:
- Consistent particle sizes mean more repeatable and uniform concrete properties batch after batch.
Steps to Use Sieves:
-
Prepare the Aggregate:
- Collect a representative sample of your river sand and coarse aggregates.
-
Sieve Analysis:
- Arrange your sieves from largest mesh size (5 mm) to smallest (0.045 mm) in a stack.
- Weigh a dry sample, place it in the top sieve, and agitate the stack for a consistent period (e.g., 10 minutes).
-
Measure Results:
- Weigh and record the mass of material retained on each sieve.
- Calculate the percentage passing each sieve to construct a particle size distribution curve.
-
Adjustments:
- Based on the results, adjust your proportions of coarse and fine aggregates in the mix to better meet desired grading curves for SCC.
-
Incorporating Findings:
- The fine-to-coarse aggregate ratio might need adjustment to achieve optimal packing density and workability.
Using sieves may add complexity to your process but will greatly enhance the quality and performance of your SCC by ensuring you have control over the aggregate gradation. It can also aid in troubleshooting issues like segregation or excessive bleeding, which can be particularly important when working with local materials that may vary in quality and composition.
-
- User
Ok. What should the largest diameter of the coarse aggregate be and does it matter is the stones are crushed or smooth (as they come from the river)?
- Assistant
The largest diameter of the coarse aggregate in self-consolidating concrete (SCC) is an important factor that impacts workability, filling ability, and the potential for blocking during placement. Generally, the maximum size of the coarse aggregate should be limited to ensure smooth flow and prevent segregation. Here are some guidelines:
Maximum Aggregate Size:
-
Diameter Guidelines:
- Typically, the largest diameter should not exceed 20 mm (3/4 inch) for most SCC applications.
- If you have dense reinforcement or need to fill complicated form shapes, consider using a maximum of 12 mm (1/2 inch) aggregates.
-
Considerations:
- The maximum aggregate size should generally be less than 1/5 of the narrowest dimension of the formwork or spacing between rebar.
Aggregate Shape:
-
Crushed Stone vs. River Gravel:
- Crushed Stone:
- Provides a rougher surface texture which can improve the bond with the cement paste.
- Angular particles can offer better interlock, increasing stability.
- River Gravel:
- Typically rounded and smoother, which might help enhance flowability.
- May reduce the risk of blockage, particularly when passing through tight spaces.
- Crushed Stone:
-
Mix Adjustments:
- If you use rounded river stones, you may need to adjust the mix design to ensure adequate cohesion and stability, potentially increasing fines or using a viscosity-modifying agent if bleeding becomes an issue.
-
Combination:
- Some SCC mixes use a combination of both crushed and smooth aggregates to balance workability and stability.
Conclusion:
The choice between crushed or smooth aggregates can depend on your specific application requirements, available materials, and desired concrete properties. You might need to conduct trials to understand how your local materials behave within your SCC mix and adjust accordingly to achieve optimal performance for your specific use case.
-