que dice sobre su implicacion como espia, analiza bien el texto para encontrar detalles…
- User
que dice sobre su implicacion como espia, analiza bien el texto para encontrar detalles ocultos: "Everywhere man How a Spanish journalist befriended the Russian opposition, was unmasked as a Kremlin spy, and returned home a hero 04:53 PM, 21 August 2024Yulia Akhmedova, Novaya Gazeta Europe correspondent Everywhere man Pablo González. Photo: Juan Teixeira /eulixe.com
Earlier this month, Russia welcomed home eight of its citizens — a killer, a few hackers and some undercover intelligence operatives — as part of the largest ever prisoner exchange between the country and the West. One of those undercover spies was 42-year-old Pavel Rubtsov, who for years was a regular fixture at Russian democratic opposition forums and conferences in the EU, where delegates knew him as Spanish journalist Pablo González.
Rubtsov was arrested for espionage in Poland just days after Russia launched its full-scale invasion of Ukraine in February 2022. Independent media outlet Agentstvo reported in May 2023 that González had probably been an agent embedded by the GRU, Russia’s foreign military intelligence agency, in the entourage of Zhanna Nemtsova, the daughter of murdered opposition politician Boris Nemtsov.
However, as there was no official explanation forthcoming from Polish intelligence, many Russian opposition figures struggled to believe that González had really been an agent. Indeed, numerous press freedom and human rights organisations spoke out on his behalf after he was charged, only to watch in horror when Putin came to meet González personally at Moscow’s Vnukovo Airport on 1 August.
Just how did González manage to ingratiate himself with the Russian opposition, betray them and yet still end up escaping Polish justice?
Charm offensive The Boris Nemtsov Forum, an annual event where Russian opposition figures meet European politicians and intellectuals to discuss the future of Russia-EU relations, was hosted in the German capital Berlin in October 2017. It was attended by politicians Ilya Yashin and Dmitry Gudkov, lawyer Ilya Novikov and other representatives of Russia’s democratic opposition.
Many at the forum remembered a certain Spanish journalist by the name of Pablo González who actively wanted to be introduced to everyone. This large, imposing man of about 35 was presented to everyone as a freelancer specialising in Eastern Europe and military conflicts. He spoke perfect Russian, was sympathetic to the Russian opposition and weighed into discussions about the importance of free speech with gusto. González made many useful contacts, had his picture taken with Yashin and attended multiple other Nemtsov Foundation events with some of Russia’s leading opposition figures.
From left to right: Pablo González, Alisa Ganieva, Ilya Yashin, Pavel Yelizarov. Photo: Alisa Ganieva From left to right: Pablo González, Alisa Ganieva, Ilya Yashin, Pavel Yelizarov. Photo: Alisa Ganieva
It took seven years and the spectacle of Putin personally welcoming him home at Vnukovo Airport earlier this month for the Russian opposition to finally accept that all this time the friendly Spaniard had been writing reports for the GRU.
González first met Zhanna Nemtsova, Nemtsov’s daughter and the co-founder of the Boris Nemtsov Foundation for Freedom, in Brussels in 2016. Pavel Yelizarov, a Portugal-based political activist and Nemtsova’s ex-husband, recalls González requesting she do an interview with him, after which he became “part of her circle”.
Yelizarov admits that at some point his relationship with González was rather friendly and in 2017 and 2018, they communicated quite frequently, with González describing himself as a leftist.
“Pablo is an everywhere man. He likes to sit in a bar and drink beer. He’s an adrenaline junkie, so would go to places where there were military conflicts, protests, that sort of thing. He found all that interesting,” Yelizarov remembers.
González became friendly with Novaya Gazeta special correspondent Ilya Azar while they were both covering conflicts in Donbas and Nagorno-Karabakh.
Zhanna Nemtsova receives the 2015 Atlantic Council Freedom Award on behalf of her late father at the Wrocław Global Forum in Poland, 12 June 2015. Photo: Maciej Kulczynski / EPA Zhanna Nemtsova receives the 2015 Atlantic Council Freedom Award on behalf of her late father at the Wrocław Global Forum in Poland, 12 June 2015. Photo: Maciej Kulczynski / EPA
“We crossed paths in places that made me think he couldn’t possibly be a GRU employee,” Azar says. “When you come under shelling in Stepanakert at night and drink whiskey with dazed colleagues in bulletproof vests in a half-dark hotel, you somehow don’t find yourself thinking: ‘You’re not a GRU guy by any chance, are you, Pablo?’”
Azar remembers him as easy to talk to and reliable, a fellow journalist “it was nice to exchange stories and have a drink with”. “I generally trust colleagues, and there’s a sort of journalistic solidarity in wars and conflict zones,” says Azar.
“When you come under shelling in Stepanakert at night and drink whiskey with dazed colleagues in bulletproof vests in a half-dark hotel, you somehow don’t find yourself thinking: ‘You’re not a GRU guy by any chance, are you, Pablo?’”
González was also very interested in Donbas, says Novaya Gazeta Europe’s editor-in-chief Kirill Martynov, who, like many, met him at the Nemtsov Forum.
“He expressed sympathy for people who found themselves on the territory of the ‘Donetsk People’s Republic’. Back then, many people wrote about their problems, travelled there, and reported on it. It felt like he was a freelance journalist, reporting on the horrors of war, who wanted to be friends with everyone because he had a difficult job. He was very sociable during the conference, making contacts, talking about the importance of freedom of speech. As far as I remember, he met almost everyone at that conference,” Martynov recalls.
Revolutionary heritage Those interviewed by Novaya Europe remember González not only for his ability to put people at ease but also for his unusual background. Born in Moscow in 1982 and originally named Pavel Rubtsov, his mother was a descendant of the “Niños de Rusia” — the children of revolutionaries who opposed the dictatorship of Francisco Franco and were evacuated to the Soviet Union in the 1930s to escape the Spanish Civil War. González’s father, Alexey Rubtsov, has held managerial positions at Russian state-affiliated news outlet RBC since 1999.
A poster reading “Free Pablo González” in the Basque town of Nabarniz, Spain, 1 August 2024. Photo: Vincent West / LETA A poster reading “Free Pablo González” in the Basque town of Nabarniz, Spain, 1 August 2024. Photo: Vincent West / LETA
By the late 1980s, González’s mother had relocated to her ancestral homeland, and brought her son with her. There, she changed his name to Pablo González Yagüe. They lived in Bilbao for a year before moving to Catalonia. In 2005, González settled in the Basque Country, after obtaining a Russian passport in Moscow under his birth name two years beforehand.
González started working as a journalist in 2014, specialising in Eastern Europe and military conflicts. His work led him to cover the illegal Russian annexation of Crimea and the invasion of Donbas, the war in Nagorno-Karabakh, and issues related to the international recognition of Kosovo and Transnistria for Spanish news outlets Público, EFE, and laSexta, as well as Voice of America, Deutsche Welle, and others. González holds a degree in Slavic philology and wrote a doctoral dissertation on the persecution of the LGBT movement in Georgia at the University of the Basque Country.
Detention in Poland Immediately before the Russian invasion began, González was in eastern Ukraine ostensibly reporting, when he received a call from a Ukrainian intelligence officer requesting he come to Kyiv. There, he was interrogated and accused of “pro-Russian bias”, but was subsequently released.
Simultaneously, Spanish intelligence agents questioned his relatives in Spain, though this didn’t lead to any further action either. González returned to Spain and was left in peace for almost a month. He then decided it was safe to leave the country and travelled to the Polish-Ukrainian border on 25 February, purportedly to cover the refugee crisis.
More stories
The art of the deal
Putin is no stranger to trading human lives, as the series of prisoner swaps he’s brokered over the past decade shows
Three days later, he was detained in the Polish city of Przemyśl, near the Ukrainian border. The Polish authorities said that, according to their information, he was working for Russian intelligence and intended to enter Ukraine.
Following his arrest, Spanish protesters took to the streets in the Basque Country demanding González’s release, and a slew of international NGOs, including Reporters Without Borders, Amnesty International and the International Federation of Journalists, quickly condemned the arrest.
Press freedom organisations pointed to the Polish media’s poor state of health at the time, noting that the EU had often raised concerns about shrinking civil liberties in the country, though Reporters Without Borders representative Jeanne Cavelier later told Novaya Gazeta Europe that the organisation had never considered González “arbitrarily detained,” but had simply lobbied the Polish authorities to organise a swift and fair trial to determine whether González was guilty.
Russian citizens released as part of the prisoner swap arrive at Moscow’s Vnukovo Airport, Russia, 1 August 2024. Photo: Sergey Ilyin / Sputnik / Kremlin Pool / EPA-EFE Russian citizens released as part of the prisoner swap arrive at Moscow’s Vnukovo Airport, Russia, 1 August 2024. Photo: Sergey Ilyin / Sputnik / Kremlin Pool / EPA-EFE
According to those close to the investigation into González’s infiltration of the Nemtsov Foundation, González described the activities of Nemtsova and her friends, foundation employees and partners, as well as students at the foundation’s annual journalism summer school in great detail. Sensitive materials were also found in González’s possession which investigators suspected had been copied from Nemtsova’s computer.
The Nemtsov Foundation did not respond to Novaya Europe’s request for a comment. The foundation’s co-founder Olga Shorina also declined to comment, noting that she could not comment on the matter due to a non-disclosure agreement.
After González was part of the largest prisoner swap since the Cold War that saw 24 prisoners exchange hands, there can now be little doubt that he was a Russian spy.
It is unclear whether González will be tried in absentia by a Polish court following the exchange. However, as if it were needed, the Rubtsov case provides yet more evidence that Russian intelligence officers continue to target the political opposition both domestically and abroad.
More stories"
- Assistant
An Analysis of Pablo González's Involvement as a Spy
The text provided offers a detailed account of Pablo González, born Pavel Rubtsov, and his activities that led to his unmasking as a Russian spy. By carefully analyzing the article, we can uncover both overt and subtle details regarding his espionage activities. Below is a comprehensive examination of the information presented.
Background and Dual Identity
- Birth and Early Life: Born in Moscow in 1982 as Pavel Rubtsov.
- Family Ties:
- Mother: A descendant of the "Niños de Rusia," Spanish children evacuated to the Soviet Union during the Spanish Civil War.
- Father: Alexey Rubtsov, who held managerial positions at Russian state-affiliated news outlet RBC since 1999.
- Migration to Spain:
- Moved to Bilbao, Spain, with his mother in the late 1980s.
- His name was changed to Pablo González Yagüe.
- Return to Russia:
- Obtained a Russian passport under his birth name in 2003.
- Education:
- Degree in Slavic philology.
- Wrote a doctoral dissertation on the persecution of the LGBT movement in Georgia at the University of the Basque Country.
Infiltration into Russian Opposition Circles
- Initial Contacts:
- Met Zhanna Nemtsova, daughter of murdered opposition politician Boris Nemtsov, in Brussels in 2016.
- Requested an interview with her and became part of her social circle.
- Participation in Opposition Events:
- Attended the Boris Nemtsov Forum in Berlin in October 2017.
- Actively sought introductions to key opposition figures like Ilya Yashin, Dmitry Gudkov, and Ilya Novikov.
- Engaged in discussions about free speech and the future of Russia-EU relations.
- Made contacts with numerous opposition figures and journalists.
- Attended the Boris Nemtsov Forum in Berlin in October 2017.
Behaviors and Traits Suggestive of Espionage
- Sociability and Networking:
- Described as an "everywhere man," he was highly sociable, making extensive contacts.
- His friendly demeanor allowed him to gain the trust of opposition figures.
- Language Skills:
- Spoke perfect Russian, aiding his integration into Russian-speaking circles.
- Professional Cover:
- Presented himself as a freelance journalist specializing in Eastern Europe and military conflicts.
- Worked for reputable outlets like Público, EFE, laSexta, Voice of America, and Deutsche Welle.
- Presence in Conflict Zones:
- Covered events in Donbas, Nagorno-Karabakh, Crimea, Kosovo, and Transnistria.
- His presence in these areas could facilitate intelligence gathering under the guise of journalism.
Specific Incidents Highlighting Espionage Activities
- Interest in Donbas:
- Expressed sympathy for individuals in the "Donetsk People’s Republic."
- Frequent travels to conflict zones where Russian interests were prominent.
- Interactions with Zhanna Nemtsova and Associates:
- Gathered detailed information about the activities of Nemtsova, her foundation's employees, partners, and students.
- Allegedly had sensitive materials copied from Nemtsova's computer.
- Arrest and Charges in Poland:
- Detained in Przemyśl, Poland, near the Ukrainian border on 28 February 2022.
- Accused of working for Russian intelligence and intending to enter Ukraine for espionage.
- Release in Prisoner Swap:
- Became part of the largest prisoner exchange between Russia and the West in August 2024.
- Personally welcomed by Vladimir Putin upon arrival in Moscow.
Hidden Details and Subtle Clues
- Lack of Suspicion Among Peers:
- Fellow journalists and opposition figures did not suspect him due to his professional conduct and shared experiences in dangerous environments.
- His ability to handle stressful situations in conflict zones without raising doubts suggests professional training.
- Background Connections:
- His father's managerial role at a Russian state-affiliated news outlet could imply access to insider networks.
- Timing of Movements:
- Returned to Spain after being questioned by Ukrainian intelligence, suggesting possible extraction or redeployment.
- Decided to go to the Polish-Ukrainian border immediately after Russia's invasion of Ukraine, aligning with intelligence interests.
Reactions from Organizations and Governments
-
Support from NGOs and Media Organizations:
- Initial defense from groups like Reporters Without Borders, Amnesty International, and the International Federation of Journalists.
- This support indicates he was well-regarded in journalistic circles, enhancing his cover.
-
Silence from the Nemtsov Foundation:
- The foundation's refusal to comment, citing non-disclosure agreements, hints at the sensitivity and potential impact of his infiltration.
Conclusion
The text provides substantial evidence of Pablo González's involvement as a spy:
- His dual identity and background facilitated access to both Russian and European circles.
- Strategic networking and sociability allowed him to infiltrate opposition groups without arousing suspicion.
- Activities aligned with intelligence gathering, especially his focus on sensitive areas and individuals.
- The discovery of sensitive materials allegedly copied from Zhanna Nemtsova's computer points to direct espionage actions.
- His inclusion in a high-profile prisoner swap and personal reception by President Putin underline his value to Russian intelligence.
Overall, González's case exemplifies the sophisticated methods employed by intelligence agencies to infiltrate opposition movements and gather critical information. The hidden details within the text, such as his seamless integration, timing of actions, and background connections, all contribute to a clearer understanding of his espionage activities.