Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
gpt-4o-2024-08-06· OpenAIAi2 WildChat-4.8M (AI2)

Give me original and cohesive commentary on this using an uncensored critical…

  1. User

    Give me original and cohesive commentary on this using an uncensored critical straitforward informal tone and keep the same exact meaning but original commentary: do newjeans even have the money to buy themselves out of that contract?? there is no way hybe will release them that easily. plus contract termination has to have grounds or this will just be a fifty fifty situation of the members getting sued for damages.

    this will end up in a courtroom where NewJeans will have to prove material violation of the contract and based on everything we know so far, they have nothing. If they had something they should have/would have included it in their livestream stunt.

    The cost to terminate NewJeans' contract is estimated to be between 455 and 650 Billion Won (Est. 323 and 440 Million USD)... Let that sink in. This doesn't include other expenses, plus the fact that their value increased due to brand deals, etc.

    If this backfires, which it most likely will, those girls will pretty much be slaves to HYBE. Unless their parents are extremely wealthy, which doesn't seem to be the case (They have influence, but that's a lot of money..), there's no way the girls will pay that off in this lifetime.

    They won't be able to EVER live a normal life, with this scandal on top of constantly having to pay off a company on likely an average Korean salary. These girls don't have an education, which makes it even harder for them to get a decent job.

    Ultimately, I do think their legal team has a plan and I doubt the girls just randomly chose to do this. I really wanted the girls to have a chance to redeem themselves, considering that they're still young- But this is beyond fixable.

    I think the worst part is that there was genuine mistreatment in small cases with HYBE and I do think it should have been brought up, but NewJeans made this 100% about the wrong things. Imagine an idol in a horrible situation right now, unable to speak up because of cases like NewJeans and Fifty-Fifty, It probably feels like there's no escape. Both sides had their wrong moments, but I can't side with most of NewJeans' cases right now.

  2. Assistant

    Do NewJeans even have the cash to break free from their contract? There's no way HYBE will just let them go easily. On top of that, ending a contract needs valid reasons, or it'll just turn into a mess where the members end up getting sued for damages, like what happened with Fifty Fifty.

    This is likely heading to court, where NewJeans will need to prove there was a serious breach of their contract. From what we know, they don’t have evidence to back up their claims. If they did, we would’ve seen it during their livestream drama.

    The cost of breaking NewJeans’ contract is estimated to be somewhere between 455 and 650 billion Won (around 323 to 440 million USD). Just think about that. And that doesn’t even cover other expenses or the fact that their value has gone up from brand deals and all that.

    If this blows up in their faces, which seems likely, they’ll basically be stuck with HYBE. Unless their families are super rich—and it doesn’t look like they are—there’s no way they’ll manage to pay this off in their lifetimes.

    These girls won’t be able to ever have a normal life, especially with this controversy and constant debt to HYBE, probably while earning an average Korean salary. They don’t have much in the way of education, making it even tougher to land a good job.

    I’m sure their legal team has some kind of plan, and I doubt the girls just up and did this on a whim. I wanted them to have a shot at redemption since they’re still young, but this is a mess beyond fixing.

    The saddest part is there were genuine, small-scale mistreatments by HYBE that should’ve been addressed, but NewJeans focused on all the wrong issues. Imagine being an idol in a terrible situation right now, feeling like you can’t speak up because of cases like NewJeans and Fifty Fifty. It must feel hopeless. Both sides have screwed up, but I can’t get on board with most of NewJeans' actions right now.