Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
o1-mini-2024-09-12· OpenAIAi2 WildChat-4.8M (AI2)

I have a table CREATE TABLE passengers ( pid int(11) NOT NULL, pname varchar(50) DEFAULT…

  1. User

    I have a table CREATE TABLE passengers ( pid int(11) NOT NULL, pname varchar(50) DEFAULT 'somebody', sex bit(1) DEFAULT NULL, age decimal(5,2) NOT NULL, PRIMARY KEY (pid) ) ENGINE=InnoDB DEFAULT CHARSET=utf8; ALTER TABLE sailors.passengers ADD COLUMN e_mail VARCHAR(45) NULL AFTER age;

    And i had an index CREATE INDEX age_sex ON passengers(age, sex);

    I performed EXPLAIN SELECT * FROM passengers WHERE age = 0 AND sex = 0;

    And then I dropped previous index (age, sex) and created a new one, (sex, age). ALTER TABLE sailors.passengers DROP INDEX age_sex ; CREATE INDEX sex_age ON passengers(sex, age);

    In EXPLAIN SELECT with the same select, I see that type and rows havent changed, but key_len decreased from 5 to 2. How does this value being calculated and what does it mean in context of optimization?

    EXPLAIN SELECT * FROM passengers WHERE sex = 1 ORDER BY age;

  2. Assistant

    In MySQL, the EXPLAIN statement provides valuable insights into how the query optimizer intends to execute a query. One of the key pieces of information it provides is the key_len value, which indicates the length of the key (in bytes) that MySQL decides to use from the index for executing the query. Understanding how key_len is calculated and its implications on query optimization can help you design more efficient indexes.

    Understanding key_len

    1. Definition:

      • key_len: Represents the number of bytes from the index that MySQL uses to execute the query. It essentially indicates how much of the index is utilized for filtering rows.
    2. Calculation:

      • For single-column indexes, key_len corresponds to the size (in bytes) of that column.
      • For multi-column indexes, key_len is the sum of the sizes of the indexed columns from left to right until MySQL can no longer use the index for efficient lookups based on the query conditions.
    3. Example with Your Table:

      • Table Definition:
        CREATE TABLE passengers (
          pid int(11) NOT NULL,
          pname varchar(50) DEFAULT 'somebody',
          sex bit(1) DEFAULT NULL,
          age decimal(5,2) NOT NULL,
          e_mail VARCHAR(45) NULL,
          PRIMARY KEY (pid)
        ) ENGINE=InnoDB DEFAULT CHARSET=utf8;
        
      • Indexes:
        • Original Index: (age, sex)
        • Modified Index: (sex, age)

    Analyzing Your Scenario

    1. Original Index (age, sex):

      • Column Sizes:
        • age: DECIMAL(5,2) typically uses 3 bytes (though storage can vary based on MySQL version and settings).
        • sex: BIT(1) uses 1 byte (since MySQL aligns bits to byte boundaries).
      • key_len Calculation:
        • age (3 bytes) + sex (1 byte) = 4 bytes.
        • MySQL might include some overhead, leading to the reported key_len of 5 bytes.
      • Query Execution:
        EXPLAIN SELECT * FROM passengers WHERE age = 0 AND sex = 0;
        
        • MySQL can utilize both age and sex columns in the index for filtering, resulting in a larger key_len as both columns contribute to narrowing down the results.
    2. Modified Index (sex, age):

      • key_len Calculation:
        • sex (1 byte) + age (3 bytes) = 4 bytes.
        • However, the reported key_len is 2 bytes.
      • Explanation:
        • When the index order is changed to (sex, age), and the query is still WHERE age = 0 AND sex = 0, MySQL prioritizes the first column in the index (sex) for filtering.
        • Partial Index Usage: MySQL uses sex to filter rows, resulting in a key_len that reflects only the portion of the index used primarily (sex), which is 2 bytes in this context.
        • The second condition (age = 0) is then applied as a post-filter, which might not leverage the index as efficiently because age is no longer the leading column.

    Implications on Optimization

    • Larger key_len:

      • Indicates that more of the index is being utilized.
      • Typically results in more selective filtering directly via the index, leading to fewer rows scanned and faster query execution.
    • Smaller key_len:

      • Suggests that only a portion of the index is being used.
      • May lead to less efficient filtering, requiring more rows to be scanned and potentially increasing query execution time.

    Applying to the Second Query

    EXPLAIN SELECT * FROM passengers WHERE sex = 1 ORDER BY age;
    
    • With Index (sex, age):

      • Optimal Usage: The index (sex, age) perfectly supports this query.
        • Filtering: sex = 1 directly uses the first column of the index.
        • Ordering: ORDER BY age is also supported because age is the second column in the index.
      • key_len: Likely 4 bytes (1 byte for sex + 3 bytes for age).
      • Benefits:
        • Efficient filtering and ordering without needing additional sorting.
        • Minimizes the number of disk I/O operations.
    • With Index (age, sex):

      • Less Optimal:
        • Filtering: sex = 1 is the second column, so MySQL might not use the index efficiently for filtering by sex.
        • Ordering: ORDER BY age aligns with the first column, but since sex is second, sorting might still benefit.
      • key_len: Likely smaller (only age is used initially).
      • Drawbacks:
        • Potential need for additional row scanning or sorting, reducing performance.

    Best Practices for Indexing

    1. Order Matters:

      • Place columns that are frequently used in WHERE clauses first in the index.
      • Consider the most selective columns first to maximize filtering efficiency.
    2. Covering Indexes:

      • If possible, design indexes that cover all columns used in the query to avoid accessing the table data separately.
    3. Composite Indexes:

      • Use composite indexes for queries that filter or sort on multiple columns, ensuring the index order aligns with query patterns.

    Conclusion

    The key_len value in the EXPLAIN output is crucial for understanding how effectively MySQL utilizes your indexes. In your case:

    • Original Index (age, sex): Fully utilized both columns for the query, resulting in a higher key_len and more efficient filtering.
    • Modified Index (sex, age): Partially utilized the index for the same query, leading to a lower key_len and potentially less efficient filtering.

    When designing indexes, always consider the specific queries your application runs most frequently and arrange index columns to maximize their utility based on those patterns.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.