Give me original and cohesive commentary on this using a critical straitforward informal…
- User
Give me original and cohesive commentary on this using a critical straitforward informal tone: I like the direction jin’s gone for his solo music — this style of pop rock not only suits his voice and personality so well but makes him stand out completely amongst the BTS members.
When the credits for Jin’s new album were unveiled, my eyes immediately fell upon one name: Gary Barlow. I would have never expected to see the British boy group "Take That" member’s credit on a K-pop release. Gary Barlow has written a fair amount of fantastic music, but his taste also tends to be a bit milquetoast. Of course, HYBE’s music has also trended toward easy-listening of late, so his adult contemporary touch makes some sense. After the upbeat pre-release "I’ll Be There", I was hoping title track Running Wild would give Jin a bit more grit.
Running Wild is the weirdest thing because it does sound exactly like a Take That song. I hear Barlow’s voice in every bit of this, which is both a boon and liability. I appreciate that the song has a perspective, but it feels strange that this is so clearly someone else’s perspective transposed onto a K-pop setting. This style of anthemic Britpop isn’t something we hear often from Korean idols. It’s a sound I tend to enjoy, though I’ve come to expect that Korean producers will twist and nudge it in ways that feel unique to this industry. Instead, Running Wild is a solid copy-and-paste job.
The song fits well with Jin’s vocal tone and he excels whenever the melody lets him dive into his rich lower register. However, the falsetto-driven chorus could have used a more robust arrangement to match the surging guitar. Judging from his solo discography so far, Jin clearly enjoys this style. And as predictable as the structure and execution is, it’s nice to hear an open-hearted melodic approach in K-pop. I just wish Running Wild didn’t feel like Jin singing karaoke. He has untapped potential to deliver something much more nuanced and specific than this style of serviceable, fairly anonymous pop/rock.
- Assistant
Jin's solo music journey takes an intriguing route with the pop-rock vibe he's chosen, and there's no denying that it suits him like a glove. It’s a style that not only aligns well with his vocal strengths but also sets him apart from his BTS bandmates in a refreshing way. So, it's clear he’s found a niche that fits, but let’s dig into the details of his latest track, "Running Wild".
The name Gary Barlow jumped out in the credits, which is a head-scratcher for a K-pop release. I mean, seeing this icon of '90s British pop lending his style to a K-pop track is like having Yorkshire pudding at a Korean BBQ—it’s interesting, but does it really work? Barlow’s musical touch is often stamped with a kind of palatable safeness, which reflects in the song's direction. HYBE’s trend towards easy-listening tracks might be a reason he was brought onboard. Still, after the bouncy teaser that "I’ll Be There" was, I was really hoping for something with a bit more bite for the title track.
Listening to "Running Wild" feels like I’ve stumbled upon a lost Take That track. It doesn’t just touch on Barlow’s style; it teleports the listener right into it, which is both fascinating and a bit problematic. The problem isn't the Britpop itself—I'm a fan of that genre's soaring anthems—but the fact that it’s Jin singing over what feels more like someone else’s artistic expression in a pseudo-K-pop shell. Normally, you'd expect K-pop producers to infuse their creations with a characteristic twist, but this comes across more as a direct clone without that innovative flair we anticipate from Korean talent.
Now, Jin does what he can, and his voice melds nicely with the song. His vocal performance shines particularly when he gets to explore his lower range, highlighting his deep, emotive quality. But the chorus feels a bit lacking. The falsetto line could have brought the house down if matched with a stronger punch of instrumentation—especially when you’ve got such a driving guitar undercurrent begging for a big, rounded sound.
From the solo work we’ve seen so far, it’s clear Jin’s invested in this musical direction. However, Running Wild—while pleasant and heartfelt—doesn’t fully leverage his potential. It’s a decent track but not quite the standout solo moment that he’s capable of. Instead of just proficiently covering all the bases of a pop-rock genre, Jin could delve deeper into his artistic vein to create something more personal, distinct, and perhaps a bit daring to truly captivate and surprise.