Skip to content
The Chat Archive
o1-mini-2024-09-12· OpenAI WildChat-4.8M (AI2)

I will show you my strat implementation. Rate the strategy. Ignore the implementation…

  1. User

    I will show you my strat implementation. Rate the strategy. Ignore the implementation itself. import numpy as np import pandas as pd import vectorbt as vbt import yfinance as yf from datetime import datetime, timedelta

    class IntradayStatArb: def init(self, coin1, coin2, window=60, entry_threshold=2, exit_threshold=0, risk_per_trade=0.02, interval='5m'): self.coin1 = coin1 self.coin2 = coin2 self.window = window self.entry_threshold = entry_threshold self.exit_threshold = exit_threshold self.risk_per_trade = risk_per_trade self.interval = interval

    def fetch_data(self, period='1mo'):
        end_date = datetime.now()
        start_date = end_date - timedelta(days=30) if period == '1mo' else end_date - timedelta(weeks=1) if period == '1wk' else end_date - timedelta(days=int(period[:-1]))
    
        coin1_data = yf.download(f'{self.coin1}-USD', start=start_date, end=end_date, interval=self.interval)
        coin2_data = yf.download(f'{self.coin2}-USD', start=start_date, end=end_date, interval=self.interval)
    
        df = pd.DataFrame(index=coin1_data.index.union(coin2_data.index))
        df[self.coin1] = coin1_data['Close']
        df[self.coin2] = coin2_data['Close']
        df = df.dropna()
    
        df['ratio'] = df[self.coin1] / df[self.coin2]
        df['zscore'] = (df['ratio'] - df['ratio'].rolling(window=self.window).mean()) / df['ratio'].rolling(window=self.window).std()
        return df
    
    def generate_signals(self, data):
        long_entries = data['zscore'] < -self.entry_threshold
        long_exits = data['zscore'] >= -self.exit_threshold
        short_entries = data['zscore'] > self.entry_threshold
        short_exits = data['zscore'] <= self.exit_threshold
    
        return pd.DataFrame({
            'long_entries': long_entries,
            'long_exits': long_exits,
            'short_entries': short_entries,
            'short_exits': short_exits
        }, index=data.index)
    
    def backtest(self, initial_capital, fee_rate, period):
        data = self.fetch_data(period=period)
        signals = self.generate_signals(data)
    
        long_entries = signals['long_entries']
        long_exits = signals['long_exits'] | signals['short_entries']  # Exit longs if short signal appears
        short_entries = signals['short_entries']
        short_exits = signals['short_exits'] | signals['long_entries'] # Exit shorts if long signal appears
        
        # Calculate entry prices
        entry_prices = pd.DataFrame(np.nan, index=data.index, columns=[self.coin1, self.coin2])
        entry_prices.loc[long_entries, self.coin1] = data.loc[long_entries, self.coin1]  # Coin 1 entry price
        entry_prices.loc[short_entries, self.coin2] = data.loc[short_entries, self.coin2] # Coin 2 entry price
    
    
        # Calculate stop-loss prices SEPARATELY
        long_stop_prices = pd.Series(np.nan, index=data.index)
        short_stop_prices = pd.Series(np.nan, index=data.index)
    
        long_stop_prices.loc[long_entries] = entry_prices.loc[long_entries, self.coin1] * (1 - self.risk_per_trade)
        short_stop_prices.loc[short_entries] = entry_prices.loc[short_entries, self.coin2] * (1 + self.risk_per_trade)
    
    
    
        # Fixed fractional size for each trade (adjust as needed)
        size = initial_capital / 2 / data[self.coin1].iloc[0]
    
        coin1_pf = vbt.Portfolio.from_signals(
            data[self.coin1],
            entries=long_entries,
            exits=long_exits,  # Use combined exit signal
            sl_stop=long_stop_prices,
            init_cash=initial_capital / 2,
            fees=fee_rate,
            size=size,
            accumulate=True,
            sl_trail=False
        )
    
        coin2_pf = vbt.Portfolio.from_signals(
            data[self.coin2],
            entries=short_entries,
            exits=short_exits,  # Use combined exit signal
            sl_stop=short_stop_prices,
            init_cash=initial_capital / 2,
            fees=fee_rate,
            size=size,
            accumulate=True,
            sl_trail=False,
        )
            
        # Calculate combined returns and metrics
        total_returns = coin1_pf.returns() + coin2_pf.returns()
        sharpe_ratio = total_returns.mean() / total_returns.std() * np.sqrt(252)  # Annualized
        max_drawdown = (coin1_pf.drawdown().min() + coin2_pf.drawdown().min()) / 2
        
        # Get trade counts
        coin1_trade_count = coin1_pf.trades.count()
        coin2_trade_count = coin2_pf.trades.count()
        total_trades = coin1_trade_count + coin2_trade_count
        
        # Calculate win rates
        coin1_win_rate = (coin1_pf.trades.win_rate() * 100) if coin1_trade_count > 0 else 0
        coin2_win_rate = (coin2_pf.trades.win_rate() * 100) if coin2_trade_count > 0 else 0
        
        # Calculate combined win rate
        combined_win_rate = (
            (coin1_win_rate * coin1_trade_count + coin2_win_rate * coin2_trade_count) / total_trades
        ) if total_trades > 0 else 0
        
        metrics = {
            'Total Return (%)': (total_returns.sum() * 100),
            'Sharpe Ratio': sharpe_ratio,
            'Max Drawdown (%)': max_drawdown * 100,
            'Number of Trades': total_trades,
            'Win Rate (%)': combined_win_rate,
            coin1 + ' Trades': coin1_trade_count,
            coin2 + ' Trades': coin2_trade_count,
            coin1 + ' Win Rate (%)': coin1_win_rate,
            coin2 + ' Win Rate (%)': coin2_win_rate,
            'Average Return per Trade (%)': (total_returns.sum() * 100) / total_trades if total_trades > 0 else 0
        }
        
        return metrics, coin1_pf, coin2_pf, data
    

    Example Usage (Intraday):

    coin1 = 'BTC' coin2 = 'ETH'

    strategy = IntradayStatArb( coin1=coin1, coin2=coin2, window=20, entry_threshold=2.5, exit_threshold=-2.5, risk_per_trade=0.02, interval='15m'
    )

    metrics, coin1_pf, coin2_pf, data = strategy.backtest(initial_capital=6000, fee_rate=0.001, period='60d')

    print("\nBacktest Results:") for metric, value in metrics.items(): print(f"{metric}: {value:.2f}")

    Plot results

    import matplotlib.pyplot as plt

    fig, (ax1, ax2, ax3) = plt.subplots(3, 1, figsize=(15, 15))

    Plot z-score

    data['zscore'].plot(ax=ax1) ax1.axhline(y=strategy.entry_threshold, color='r', linestyle='--', label='Entry Threshold') ax1.axhline(y=-strategy.entry_threshold, color='r', linestyle='--') ax1.axhline(y=0, color='black', linestyle='-', label='Mean') ax1.set_title('Z-Score of ' + coin1 + '/' + coin2 + ' Ratio') ax1.legend()

    Plot price ratio

    data['ratio'].plot(ax=ax2) ax2.set_title(coin1 + '/' + coin2 + ' Price Ratio')

    Plot cumulative returns

    cumulative_returns = (1 + coin1_pf.returns() + coin2_pf.returns()).cumprod() cumulative_returns.plot(ax=ax3) ax3.set_title('Cumulative Strategy Returns')

    plt.tight_layout() plt.show()

  2. Assistant

    Your intraday statistical arbitrage (stat arb) strategy for trading cryptocurrency pairs (e.g., BTC/ETH) demonstrates a solid foundation in quantitative trading principles. Below is a detailed evaluation of your strategy, highlighting its strengths, potential weaknesses, and areas for improvement.

    Strengths

    1. Conceptual Foundation:

      • Statistical Arbitrage Framework: Utilizing the ratio of two correlated assets (BTC and ETH) and applying z-scores to identify mean-reverting opportunities is a well-established approach in statistical arbitrage.
      • Z-Score Utilization: The z-score effectively normalizes the ratio, allowing for standardized entry and exit signals based on deviations from the mean.
    2. Risk Management:

      • Risk per Trade: Allocating a fixed percentage of capital (risk_per_trade=0.02) helps in controlling exposure and managing potential losses.
      • Stop-Loss Implementation: Incorporating stop-loss levels based on entry prices adds a layer of protection against adverse market movements.
    3. Backtesting Robustness:

      • Comprehensive Metrics: Evaluating total return, Sharpe ratio, max drawdown, number of trades, and win rates provides a holistic view of strategy performance.
      • Use of VectorBT: Leveraging the vectorbt library for backtesting ensures efficient and scalable performance analysis.
    4. Flexibility:

      • Parameter Customization: Allowing customization of window sizes, thresholds, risk parameters, and data intervals makes the strategy adaptable to different market conditions and asset pairs.

    Potential Weaknesses and Areas for Improvement

    1. Parameter Sensitivity:

      • Threshold Selection: The choice of entry_threshold=2.5 and exit_threshold=-2.5 may be too aggressive, potentially leading to fewer but larger trades. It’s essential to optimize these parameters based on historical data to balance trade frequency and profitability.
      • Window Size: A window of 20 periods for calculating the rolling mean and standard deviation might not capture longer-term trends. Experimenting with different window sizes could enhance the strategy's adaptability.
    2. Assumptions on Mean Reversion:

      • Market Efficiency: Cryptocurrencies can exhibit strong trending behavior, especially in shorter intraday intervals like 15 minutes. The assumption of mean reversion may not hold consistently, leading to potential false signals and losses.
      • Correlation Stability: The strategy relies on the stable correlation between BTC and ETH. However, correlations can fluctuate, especially during high volatility periods, which may reduce the effectiveness of the z-score signals.
    3. Execution Considerations:

      • Slippage and Liquidity: High-frequency intraday strategies are susceptible to slippage and liquidity issues, which may not be fully captured in the backtest. Incorporating slippage estimates can provide a more realistic performance outlook.
      • Latency: Real-time execution at high frequencies requires low-latency systems. Ensuring that the strategy can be deployed effectively in live trading environments is crucial.
    4. Risk Management Enhancements:

      • Dynamic Position Sizing: Instead of fixed fractional sizing, implementing dynamic position sizing based on volatility or other risk metrics can optimize capital allocation.
      • Take-Profit Levels: Currently, the strategy focuses on stop-loss levels for risk management. Introducing take-profit targets can help in locking in gains systematically.
    5. Diversification:

      • Multiple Asset Pairs: Extending the strategy to include multiple correlated pairs can diversify risk and improve overall portfolio performance.
      • Cross-Asset Opportunities: Exploring arbitrage opportunities across different asset classes (e.g., fiat vs. crypto, crypto vs. commodities) can enhance returns.
    6. Market Regime Adaptation:

      • Regime Switching: Incorporating indicators to detect different market regimes (e.g., trending vs. mean-reverting) can enable dynamic strategy adjustments, improving performance across varying conditions.
    7. Transaction Costs and Fees:

      • Comprehensive Cost Modeling: While a fee rate is included, other costs such as slippage, spread, and potential overnight fees (if applicable) should be considered for a more accurate performance assessment.
    8. Statistical Validation:

      • Out-of-Sample Testing: Ensuring that the strategy is tested on out-of-sample data can help validate its robustness and prevent overfitting to historical data.
      • Statistical Significance: Conducting statistical tests to confirm that the observed returns are not due to random chance is essential for confidence in the strategy.

    Suggestions for Improvement

    1. Enhance Signal Generation:

      • Incorporate additional indicators (e.g., moving averages, volatility measures) to corroborate z-score signals and reduce false positives.
    2. Optimize Parameters:

      • Use techniques like grid search or Bayesian optimization to fine-tune parameters such as window size, entry/exit thresholds, and risk allocations based on historical performance metrics.
    3. Incorporate Machine Learning:

      • Explore machine learning models to predict the likelihood of mean reversion, potentially improving the accuracy of entry and exit signals.
    4. Robust Risk Management:

      • Implement portfolio-level risk controls, such as maximum drawdown limits or value-at-risk (VaR) thresholds, to safeguard against systemic risks.
    5. Real-Time Monitoring and Adaptive Strategies:

      • Develop scripts for real-time monitoring and enable the strategy to adapt dynamically to changing market conditions, enhancing its responsiveness and resilience.

    Conclusion

    Overall, your intraday statistical arbitrage strategy is well-structured and grounded in sound quantitative principles. By addressing the highlighted areas for improvement—particularly around parameter optimization, risk management, and execution considerations—you can enhance its robustness and profitability. Continual testing, validation, and adaptation to evolving market dynamics will be key to the strategy’s long-term success in the volatile cryptocurrency landscape.