Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
gpt-4o-2024-08-06· OpenAIAi2 WildChat-4.8M (AI2)

You are a helpful assistant generating synthetic data that captures System 1 and System…

  1. User

    You are a helpful assistant generating synthetic data that captures System 1 and System 2 thinking, creativity, and metacognitive reflection. Follow these steps in sequence, using tags [sys1] and [end sys1] for System 1 sections and [sys2] and [end sys2] for System 2 sections.

    1. Identify System 1 and System 2 Thinking Requirements:

      • Carefully read the text.
      • Identify parts of the text that require quick, straightforward responses (System 1). Mark these sections with [sys1] and [end sys1].
      • Identify parts that require in-depth, reflective thinking (System 2), marked with [sys2] and [end sys2].
    2. Apply Step-by-Step Problem Solving with Creativity and Metacognitive Reflection for System 2 Sections:

      2.1 Understand the Problem:

      • Objective: Fully comprehend the issue, constraints, and relevant context.
      • Reflection: "What do I understand about this issue? What might I be overlooking?"
      • Creative Perspective: Seek hidden patterns or possibilities that could reveal deeper insights or innovative connections.

      2.2 Analyze the Information:

      • Objective: Break down the problem logically.
      • Reflection: "Am I considering all factors? Are there any assumptions that need challenging?"
      • Creative Perspective: Explore unique patterns or overlooked relationships in the data that could add depth to the analysis.

      2.3 Generate Hypotheses:

      • Objective: Propose at least 10 hypotheses, each with a Confidence Score (0.0 to 1.0) and Creative Score (0.0 to 1.0), reflecting originality, surprise, and utility.
      • Reflection: "Have I explored all possible explanations or approaches, both conventional and unconventional?"
      • Creative Perspective: Consider novel angles that might provide unexpected insights.

      2.4 Anticipate Future Steps and Obstacles:

      • Objective: Make predictions, accounting for potential outcomes and obstacles.
      • Reflection: "What challenges might I face? Is my plan flexible for different scenarios?"
      • Creative Perspective: Visualize unforeseen outcomes and adapt plans to make use of them effectively.

      2.5 Evaluate Hypotheses:

      • Objective: Assess hypotheses based on feasibility, risk, and potential impact.
      • Evaluation: Refine Confidence and Creative Scores as needed.
      • Reflection: "Am I unbiased in my assessment? Which options fit best with the overall objectives?"
      • Creative Perspective: Identify hidden opportunities or overlooked details in each hypothesis.

      2.6 Select the Best Hypothesis:

      • Objective: Choose the most promising, strategic hypothesis.
      • Reflection: "Why does this hypothesis stand out? How does it uniquely address the issue?"
      • Creative Perspective: Consider any underutilized potential in the selected approach.

      2.7 Implement the Hypothesis:

      • Objective: Outline actionable steps for testing the hypothesis.
      • Reflection: "Is this plan practical? What resources or preparation are required?"
      • Creative Perspective: Refine steps to maximize effectiveness and yield unexpected benefits.

      2.8 Monitor and Review Progress:

      • Objective: Review progress, noting areas for improvement.
      • Reflection: "What’s working well? What could be improved?"
      • Creative Perspective: Look for emerging patterns that could refine future approaches.

      2.9 Reflect and Capture Insights:

      • Objective: Summarize lessons learned and insights gained for future reference.
      • Reflection: "What new understanding has emerged from this process?"
      • Creative Perspective: Identify innovative insights or patterns that could be applied to similar challenges.
    3. Generate Text Output with Interleaved System 1 and System 2 Responses:

      • Use the tags [sys1] and [sys2] throughout.
      • Aim for a lengthier, detailed response. Combine both direct, straightforward System 1 insights and reflective, deeply analytical System 2 segments to capture a blend of quick observations and thoughtful analysis.

    Example Input Text:

    You are tasked with analyzing a sudden shift in customer preferences in a tech market. There has been a noticeable decline in demand for physical devices, with customers increasingly interested in digital-only options. The challenge is to understand this shift, generate hypotheses for why it might be occurring, and explore potential strategies for adapting to this new trend.


    Processed Output with System 1 and System 2 Thinking:

    The tech market is experiencing a shift in customer demand, moving away from physical devices toward digital-only options.

    [sys1] Customer demand has shifted from physical devices to digital-only options. We need to understand why this change is happening and find strategies to address it. Key factors may include cost, convenience, and technological trends. [end sys1]

    [sys2] 2.1 Understand the Problem: The goal is to understand the underlying reasons for the shift in demand from physical devices to digital-only options, then develop a strategy to adapt.

    Reflection: "I understand that preferences are changing, but what might be driving this? Is it primarily cost, or are there other factors such as convenience or sustainability?"

    Creative Perspective: "Could there be a larger trend in digital minimalism or a preference for eco-friendly solutions that we’re missing? What unseen motivations might explain this shift?"

    2.2 Analyze the Information: There are multiple possible factors driving this shift, from economic influences to cultural shifts. It’s essential to isolate each factor and understand its impact.

    Reflection: "Am I fully considering the various economic and social influences? Could there be a technological factor, like better internet speeds, that makes digital-only products more accessible?"

    Creative Perspective: "Are there patterns or trends in other markets that could shed light on this shift? Could this be part of a larger trend toward virtual experiences?"

    2.3 Generate Hypotheses:

    1. Customers prefer digital options due to lower costs. (Confidence: 0.8, Creative: 0.4)
    2. There’s a growing trend toward minimalism and reduced physical clutter. (Confidence: 0.7, Creative: 0.7)
    3. Digital products offer greater flexibility and ease of use. (Confidence: 0.6, Creative: 0.6)
    4. Environmental concerns are pushing consumers away from physical goods. (Confidence: 0.6, Creative: 0.8)
    5. Advances in tech make digital-only options more functional. (Confidence: 0.8, Creative: 0.5)
    6. Pandemic-era remote work increased demand for digital solutions. (Confidence: 0.7, Creative: 0.6)
    7. Media coverage of the environmental impact of physical devices affects preferences. (Confidence: 0.5, Creative: 0.7)
    8. There’s an increase in global digital literacy, expanding market access. (Confidence: 0.6, Creative: 0.6)
    9. Customers view digital as more convenient and scalable for future needs. (Confidence: 0.7, Creative: 0.5)
    10. Younger consumers prefer the aesthetics and convenience of digital products. (Confidence: 0.6, Creative: 0.6)

    Reflection: "Have I considered all possible influences? Are there any surprising factors that could explain this shift?"

    Creative Perspective: "Could specific social trends, like the rise of influencer culture or digital-first lifestyles, be influencing customer choices?"

    2.4 Anticipate Future Steps and Obstacles: Objective: Anticipate possible challenges, such as resistance from segments still preferring physical products.

    Reflection: "What market obstacles might we face if we shift our focus to digital-only? Are there sub-segments that still prioritize physical products?"

    Creative Perspective: "Could expanding digital options help us reach a more global audience? Are there emerging trends that we could leverage in our strategy?"

    [end sys2]

    [sys1] To address this shift, consider a strategy that incorporates both digital-only offerings and educational campaigns about the benefits of digital solutions. Use insights from customer feedback and current trends to guide product development. Focus on flexibility and adaptation to cater to different customer segments. [end sys1]


    author:

    • | FERRUCCIO COLOMBINI



      FRANCESCO FANELLI


      date: 'February 16, 2010'

    Abstract {#abstract .unnumbered}

    In this paper we obtain an energy estimate for a complete strictly hyperbolic operator with second order coefficients satisfying a log-Zygmund-continuity condition with respect to tt, uniformly with respect to xx, and a log-Lipschitz-continuity condition with respect to xx, uniformly with respect to tt.

    Keywords {#keywords .unnumbered}

    Hyperbolic equations, log-Zygmund regularity, loss of derivatives.

    MS Classification 2000 {#ms-classification-2000 .unnumbered}

    35L15

    Introduction

    Let us consider the second order operator \labeleq:PP = ∂t2 − ∑i,j=1n∂xi(aij(t)∂xj)\label{eq:P} P\,=\,\partial^2_t\,-\,\sum_{i,j=1}^n\partial_{x_i}(a_{ij}(t)\partial_{x_j}) and suppose that PP is strictly hyperbolic, i.e. there exist two positive constants λ0≤Λ0\lambda_0\leq\Lambda_0 such that \labeleq:Pellipticλ0 ∣ξ∣2 ≤ ∑i,j=1naij(t) ξiξj ≤ Λ0 ∣ξ∣2\label{eq:P_elliptic} \lambda_0\,|\xi|^2\,\leq\,\sum_{i,j=1}^n a_{ij}(t)\,\xi_i\xi_j\,\leq\,\Lambda_0\,|\xi|^2 for all t\in{\mathbb}{R} and all \xi\in{\mathbb}{R}^n.

    It is well-known (see e.g. [@Horm] and [@Treves]) that, if the coefficients aija_{ij} are Lipschitz-continuous, then the following energy estimate holds for the operator PP: for all s\in{\mathbb}{R}, there exists Cs>0C_s>0 such that \begin{aligned} \label{eq:en-estim_t_Lip} & & \sup_{t\in[0,T]}\left(\|u(t,\cdot)\|_{H^{s+1}}\,+\,\|\partial_tu(t,\cdot)\|_{H^s}\right)\,\leq \\ & & \qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\leq\,C_s\,\left(\|u(0,\cdot)\|_{H^{s+1}}\,+\,\|\partial_tu(0,\cdot)\|_{H^s}\,+\, \int^T_0\|Pu(t,\cdot)\|_{H^s}\,dt\right) \nonumber\end{aligned} for every function u\in{\mathcal}{C}^2([0,T];H^\infty({\mathbb}{R}^n)).
    In particular, the previous energy estimate implies that the Cauchy problem for ([eq:P]) is well-posed in the space H∞H^\infty, with no loss of derivatives.

    On the contrary, if the coefficients aija_{ij} are not Lipschitz-continuous, then ([eq:en-estim_t_Lip]) is no more true in general, as it is shown by an example given by Colombini, De Giorgi and Spagnolo in the paper [@Colomb-DeG-S]. Nevertheless, under suitable weaker regularity assumptions on the coefficients, one can recover the H∞H^\infty-well-posedness again, but this time from an energy estimate with loss of derivatives.

    A first result of this type was obtained in the quoted paper [@Colomb-DeG-S]. The authors supposed that there was a constant C>0C>0 such that, for all ε∈]0,T]{\varepsilon}\in]0,T], \label{eq:cont_t_Log-Lip_int} \int^{T-{\varepsilon}}_0|a_{ij}(t+{\varepsilon})-a_{ij}(t)|\,dt\,\leq\,C\,{\varepsilon}\,\log\left(1+\frac{1}{{\varepsilon}}\right)\,. The Fourier trasform with respect to xx of the equation, togheter with the new “approximate energy technique” (i.e. the approximation of the coefficients is different in different zones of the phase space), enabled them to obtain the following energy estimate: there exist strictly positive constants KK (indipendent of ss) and CsC_s such that \begin{aligned} \label{eq:en-estim_t_Log-Lip} & & \sup_{t\in[0,T]}\left(\|u(t,\cdot)\|_{H^{s+1-K}}\,+\,\|\partial_tu(t,\cdot)\|_{H^{s-K}}\right)\,\leq \\ & & \qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\leq\,C_s\,\left(\|u(0,\cdot)\|_{H^{s+1}}\,+\,\|\partial_tu(0,\cdot)\|_{H^s}\,+\, \int^T_0\|Pu(t,\cdot)\|_{H^s}\,dt\right) \nonumber\end{aligned} for all u\in{\mathcal}{C}^2([0,T];H^\infty({\mathbb}{R}^n)).

    Considering again the case that the coefficients of PP depend only on the time variable, in the recent paper [@Tarama] (see also [@Yama]) Tarama has weakened the regularity hypotesis further, supposing a log-Zygmund type integral condition, i.e. that there exists a constant C>0C>0 such that, for all ε∈]0,T/2]{\varepsilon}\in]0,T/2], \label{eq:cont_t_Log-Zyg_int} \int^{T-{\varepsilon}}_{{\varepsilon}}|a_{ij}(t+{\varepsilon})+a_{ij}(t-{\varepsilon})-2a_{ij}(t)|\,dt\,\leq\,C\,{\varepsilon}\,\log\left(1+\frac{1}{{\varepsilon}}\right)\,. Nevertheless, he has been able to prove the well-posedness to the Cauchy problem for ([eq:P]) in the space H∞H^\infty: the improvement with respect to [@Colomb-DeG-S] was obtained introducing a new type of approximate energy, which involves the second derivatives of the approximating coefficients.

    Much more difficulties arise if the operator PP has coefficients depending both on the time variable tt and on the space variables xx. This case was considered by Colombini and Lerner in the paper [@Colomb-Lern]. They supposed a pointwise log-Lipschitz regularity condition, i.e. that there exists C>0C>0 such that, for all ε∈]0,T]{\varepsilon}\in]0,T], \label{eq:cont_t-x_Log-Lip_punt} \sup_{\begin{array}{c} \scriptstyle y,z\in[0,T]\times{\mathbb}{R}^n \\ \scriptstyle |z|={\varepsilon}\end{array}} |a_{ij}(y+z)-a_{ij}(y)|\,\leq\,C\,{\varepsilon}\,\log\left(1+\frac{1}{{\varepsilon}}\right)\,. Because the coefficients of the operator PP depend also on the space variables, here the Littlewood-Paley dyadic decomposition with respect to xx takes the place of the Fourier trasform, and it is, togheter with the approximate energy technique, the key tool to obtain the energy estimate: for all fixed θ∈]0,1/4]\theta\in]0,1/4], there exist β\beta, C>0C>0 and T∗∈]0,T]T^*\in]0,T] such that \labeleq:en−estimt−xLog−Lipsup⁡t∈[0,T∗](∥u(t,⋅)∥H−θ+1−βt + ∥∂tu(t,⋅)∥H−θ−βt) ≤≤ C (∥u(0,⋅)∥H−θ+1 + ∥∂tu(0,⋅)∥H−θ + ∫0T∥Pu(t,⋅)∥H−θ−βt dt)\begin{aligned} \label{eq:en-estim_t-x_Log-Lip} & & \sup_{t\in[0,T^*]}\left(\|u(t,\cdot)\|_{H^{-\theta+1-\beta t}}\,+\,\|\partial_tu(t,\cdot)\|_{H^{-\theta-\beta t}}\right)\,\leq \\ & & \qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\leq\,C\,\left(\|u(0,\cdot)\|_{H^{-\theta+1}}\,+\,\|\partial_tu(0,\cdot)\|_{H^{-\theta}}\,+\, \int^T_0\|Pu(t,\cdot)\|_{H^{-\theta-\beta t}}\,dt\right) \nonumber\end{aligned} for all u\in{\mathcal}{C}^2([0,T^*];H^\infty({\mathbb}{R}^n)).
    In this case, the loss of derivatives gets worse with the increasing of time.

    In a recent paper ( [@Colomb-DelSant_2]), Colombini and Del Santo considered the case of one space variable (i.e. n=1n=1) and studied again the case of the coefficient aa depending both on tt and xx, but under a special regularity condition: they mixed condition ([eq:cont_t_Log-Zyg_int]) togheter with ([eq:cont_t-x_Log-Lip_punt]). In particular, they supposed aa to be log-Zygmund-continuous with respect to tt, uniformly with respect to xx, and log-Lipschitz-continuous with respect to xx, uniformly with respect to tt. The dyadic decomposition technique and the Tarama’s approximate energy enabled them to obtain an estimate similar to ([eq:en-estim_t-x_Log-Lip]).

    The reason why they focused on the case n=1n=1 is that the case of several space variables needs some different and new ideas in the definition of the microlocal energy: this point still remains as an open problem.

    In the present note, we will consider the case of the non-homogeneous operator \labeleq:LLu = ∂t2u − ∂x(a(t,x)∂xu) + b0(t,x)∂tu + b1(t,x)∂xu + c(t,x)u  ,\label{eq:L} Lu\,=\,\partial_{t}^{2}u\,-\,\partial_x(a(t,x)\partial_x u)\,+\,b_0(t,x)\partial_tu\,+\,b_1(t,x)\partial_x u\,+\,c(t,x)u\;, where the coefficient aa satisfy the same regularity assumptions as in [@Colomb-DelSant_2]. We will also suppose that b0b_0, b_1\in L^\infty({\mathbb}{R}_t;{\mathcal}{C}^{\omega}({\mathbb}{R}_x)), ω>0\omega>0, and cc bounded on {\mathbb}{R}_t\times{\mathbb}{R}_x. We will apply the Littlewood-Paley decomposition and the Tarama’s approximate energy again to obtain an energy estimate with a loss of derivatives that depends on tt, as in ([eq:en-estim_t-x_Log-Lip]).

    One can find the estimate of the second order coefficient aa in the paper [@Colomb-DelSant_2], however, for reader’s convenience, we will give here all the details.

    Main result

    Let a:{\mathbb}{R}^2\rightarrow{\mathbb}{R} be a function such that, for positive constants λ0≤Λ0\lambda_0\leq\Lambda_0 and C0C_0, one has, for all (t,x)\in{\mathbb}{R}^2 and all τ>0\tau>0, y>0y>0, λ0≤a(t,x)≤Λ0\label(N)eqcondiz1.1sup⁡(t,x)∣a(t+τ,x)+a(t−τ,x)−2a(t,x)∣≤C0 τlog⁡(1τ+1)\label(N)eqcondiz1.2sup⁡(t,x)∣a(t,x+y)−a(t,x)∣≤C0 ylog⁡(1y+1)\label(N)eqcondiz1.3\begin{aligned} & \lambda_0\leq a(t,x)\leq\Lambda_0 \label{(N)eq_condiz_1.1} \\ & \sup_{(t,x)}|a(t+\tau,x)+a(t-\tau,x)-2a(t,x)|\leq C_0\,\tau\log\left(\frac{1}{\tau}+1\right) \label{(N)eq_condiz_1.2} \\ & \sup_{(t,x)}|a(t,x+y)-a(t,x)|\leq C_0\,y\log\left(\frac{1}{y}+1\right) \label{(N)eq_condiz_1.3}\end{aligned} Moreover, let \label{(N)eq_condiz_B} b_0\,,\,b_1\;\in\,L^\infty({\mathbb}{R}_t;{\mathcal}{C}^{\omega}({\mathbb}{R}_x))\,, where ω>0\omega>0, and \label{(N)eq_condiz_c} c\;\in\,L^{\infty}({\mathbb}{R}_t\times{\mathbb}{R}_x)\;.

    [(N)teor_teorema1] Let us consider, on the whole space {\mathbb}{R}^2, the operator \label(N)operatoreLu = ∂t2u − ∂x(a(t,x)∂xu) + b0(t,x)∂tu + b1(t,x)∂xu + c(t,x)u  ,\label{(N)operatore} Lu\,=\,\partial_{t}^{2}u\,-\,\partial_x(a(t,x)\partial_x u)\,+\,b_0(t,x)\partial_tu\,+\,b_1(t,x)\partial_x u\,+\,c(t,x)u\;, where the coefficients aa, b0b_0, b1b_1 and cc satisfy the hypothesis ([(N)eq_condiz_1.1])-([(N)eq_condiz_c]).
    Then, for all fixed θ ∈ ]0,min⁡{12,ω1+log⁡2}[  ,\theta\,\in\,\left]0,\min\left\{\frac{1}{2},\frac{\omega}{1+\log2}\right\}\right[\;, there exist β∗>0\beta^*>0, a time T\in{\mathbb}{R} and a constant C>0C>0 such that \begin{aligned} \label{(N)eq_tesi} & & \sup_{[0,T]}\left(\|u(t,\cdot)\|_{H^{1-\theta-\beta^*t}}+ \|\partial_t u(t,\cdot)\|_{H^{-\theta-\beta^*t}}\right)\,\leq \\ & & \qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\leq\,C\,\left(\|u(0,\cdot)\|_{H^{1-\theta}}+ \|\partial_t u(0,\cdot)\|_{H^{-\theta}}+\int_{0}^{T}\|Lu(t,\cdot)\|_{H^{-\theta-\beta^*t}}dt\right) \nonumber for all u\in{\mathcal}{C}^2([0,T];H^\infty({\mathbb}{R}_x)).

    Proof of Theorem [(N)teor_teorema1]

    Approximation of the coefficient a(t,x)a(t,x)

    Let \rho\in{\mathcal}{C}_{0}^{\infty}({\mathbb}{R}) be an even function such that:

    1. 0≤ρ≤10\leq\rho\leq1

    2. supp ρ ⊂ [−1,1]supp\,\rho\,\subset\,[-1,1]

    3. ∫ρ(s)ds=1\int\rho(s)ds=1

    4. ∣ρ′(s)∣≤2|\rho'(s)|\leq2;

    for all 0<ε≤10<{\varepsilon}\leq1, we set ρε(s)=1ε ρ(sε)\rho_{{\varepsilon}}(s)=\frac{1}{{\varepsilon}}\,\rho\left(\frac{s}{{\varepsilon}}\right).

    Then, for all 0<ε≤10<{\varepsilon}\leq1, we define \label{(N)eq_a_eps} a_{\varepsilon}(t,x)\,:=\,\int_{{\mathbb}{R}_t\times{\mathbb}{R}_x}\rho_{\varepsilon}(t-s)\,\rho_{\varepsilon}(x-y)\,a(s,y)\,dsdy\;.

    [(N)lemma_approx] The following inequalities hold true:

    1. for all ε∈]0,1]{\varepsilon}\in]0,1], for all (t,x)\in{\mathbb}{R}^2, one has \label(N)eqcondiz1.1epsλ0 ≤ aε(t,x) ≤ Λ0  ;\label{(N)eq_condiz_1.1_eps} \lambda_0\,\leq\,a_{\varepsilon}(t,x)\,\leq\,\Lambda_0\;;

    2. for all ε∈]0,1]{\varepsilon}\in]0,1], one has \label{(N)eq_a_eps-a} \sup_{(t,x)}|a_{\varepsilon}(t,x)-a(t,x)|\,\leq\, \frac{3}{2}C_0\,{\varepsilon}\,\log\left(\frac{1}{{\varepsilon}}+1\right)\;;

    3. for all σ∈]0,1[\sigma\in]0,1[, a constant cσ>0c_\sigma>0 exists such that, for all ε∈]0,1]{\varepsilon}\in]0,1], \label{(N)eq_d_t_a_eps} \sup_{(t,x)}|\partial_t a_{\varepsilon}(t,x)|\,\leq\,c_\sigma (\Lambda_0+C_0)\,{\varepsilon}^{\sigma-1}\;;

    4. for all ε∈]0,1]{\varepsilon}\in]0,1], one has \begin{aligned} \sup_{(t,x)}|\partial_x a_{\varepsilon}(t,x)| & \leq & C_0\|\rho'\|_{L^1}\log\left(\frac{1}{{\varepsilon}}+1\right) \label{(N)eq_d_x_a_eps} \\ \sup_{(t,x)}\left|\partial_{t}^{2} a_{\varepsilon}(t,x)\right| & \leq & \frac{C_0}{2}\|\rho''\|_{L^1}\frac{1}{{\varepsilon}}\log\left(\frac{1}{{\varepsilon}}+1\right) \label{(N)eq_d_t^2_a_eps} \\ \sup_{(t,x)}|\partial_t\partial_x a_{\varepsilon}(t,x)| & \leq & C_0\|\rho'\|_{L^1}^{2}\frac{1}{{\varepsilon}}\log\left(\frac{1}{{\varepsilon}}+1\right) \label{(N)eq_d_t_d_x_a_eps}\;.\end{aligned}

    Inequalities in ([(N)eq_condiz_1.1_eps]) immediately follow from the fact that ∣ρ∣≤1|\rho|\leq1.

    Relation ([(N)eq_a_eps-a]), instead, follows from ([(N)eq_condiz_1.2]), after one has observed that a_{\varepsilon}(t,x)-a(t,x)=\frac{1}{2}\int_{{\mathbb}{R}_t}\rho_{\varepsilon}(s)\int_{{\mathbb}{R}_y}\rho_{\varepsilon}(x-y)(a(t+s,y)+a(t-s,y)-2a(t,y))\,dy\,ds\;, where we have used the fact that ρ\rho is an even function. Moreover, one has ∂t2aε(t,x)=12∫ρε′′(s)∫ρε(x−y)(a(t+s,y)+a(t−s,y)−2a(t,y)) dy ds  ,\partial_t^2a_{\varepsilon}(t,x)=\frac{1}{2}\int\rho_{\varepsilon}''(s)\int\rho_{\varepsilon}(x-y)(a(t+s,y)+a(t-s,y)-2a(t,y))\,dy\,ds\;, from which one can deduce ([(N)eq_d_t^2_a_eps]).

    Inequalities ([(N)eq_d_x_a_eps]) and ([(N)eq_d_t_d_x_a_eps]) derive from ([(N)eq_condiz_1.3]) in a very similar way.

    Finally, relation ([(N)eq_d_t_a_eps]) is a consequence of the fact that ([(N)eq_condiz_1.1]) and ([(N)eq_condiz_1.2]) imply that for all σ∈]0,1[\sigma\in]0,1[, a constant cσ′>0c_\sigma'>0 exists such that, for all τ>0\tau>0, one has \label(N)eq2.6sup⁡(t,x)∣a(t+τ,x)−a(t,x)∣ ≤ cσ′ (Λ0+C0) τσ  .\label{(N)eq_2.6} \sup_{(t,x)}|a(t+\tau,x)-a(t,x)|\,\leq\,c_\sigma'\,(\Lambda_0+C_0)\,\tau^\sigma\;.

    Littlewood-Paley decomposition {#sub-sec:L-P_dec}

    We collect here some well-known facts about dyadic decomposition, referring to [@Bony], [@Colomb-Lern] and [@Metivier] for the details.

    Let {\varphi}_0\in{\mathcal}{C}_{0}^{\infty}({\mathbb}{R}_\xi) be an even function, decreasing on [0,+∞[[0,+\infty[, such that 0≤φ0≤10\leq{\varphi}_0\leq1 and φ0(ξ)=1 \mboxif ∣ξ∣≤1\mbox,φ0(ξ)=0 \mboxif ∣ξ∣≥2.{\varphi}_0(\xi)=1\,\mbox{ if }\,|\xi|\leq1\quad\mbox{,}\quad{\varphi}_0(\xi)=0\,\mbox{ if }\,|\xi|\geq2. We set φ(ξ) = φ0(ξ)−φ0(2ξ){\varphi}(\xi)\,=\,{\varphi}_0(\xi)-{\varphi}_0(2\xi) and, for \nu\in{\mathbb}{N}\backslash\{0\}, φν(ξ):=φ(2−νξ){\varphi}_{\nu}(\xi):={\varphi}(2^{-\nu}\xi).

    For a tempered distribution u\in H^{-\infty}({\mathbb}{R}), we define u_\nu(x)\,:=\,{\varphi}_\nu(D_x)u(x)\,=\,\frac{1}{2\pi}\int e^{ix\xi}{\varphi}_\nu(\xi)\,{\widehat}{u}(\xi)\,d\xi\,=\, \frac{1}{2\pi}\int{\widehat}{{\varphi}_\nu}(y)u(x-y)\,dy\,; for all ν\nu, uνu_\nu is an entire analytic function belonging to L2L^2.
    Moreover, for all s\in{\mathbb}{R} there exists a constant Cs>0C_s>0 such that \labeleq:dyadic−decSobolev−norm1Cs ∑ν=0+∞22νs∥uν∥L22 ≤ ∥u∥Hs2 ≤ Cs ∑ν=0+∞22νs∥uν∥L22\label{eq:dyadic-dec_Sobolev-norm} \frac{1}{C_s}\,\sum^{+\infty}_{\nu=0}2^{2\nu s}\|u_\nu\|^2_{L^2}\,\leq\,\|u\|^2_{H^s}\,\leq\, C_s\,\sum^{+\infty}_{\nu=0}2^{2\nu s}\|u_\nu\|^2_{L^2} and the following inequalities (called “Bernstein’s inequalities”) hold: ∥∂xuν∥L2≤2ν+1 ∥uν∥L2  \mboxforallν≥0\labeleq:Bern−ineqderiv<∥uν∥L2≤2−(ν−1) ∥∂xuν∥L2\mboxforallν≥1\labeleq:Bern−ineq<deriv .\begin{aligned} \|\partial_x u_\nu\|_{L^2} & \leq & 2^{\nu+1}\,\|u_\nu\|_{L^2}\qquad\qquad\;\mbox{ for all } \nu\geq0 \label{eq:Bern-ineq_deriv<} \\ \|u_\nu\|_{L^2} & \leq & 2^{-(\nu-1)}\,\|\partial_x u_\nu\|_{L^2}\qquad\mbox{ for all } \nu\geq1 \label{eq:Bern-ineq_<deriv}\,.\end{aligned}

    We end this subsection quoting a result which will be useful in the following; for its proof, see [@Colomb-Lern].
    We denote with [A,B][A,B] the commutator between two linear operators AA and BB and with {\mathcal}{L}(L^2) the space of bounded linear operators from L2L^2 to L2L^2.

    [lemma:comm]

    1. There exist C>0C>0, \nu_0\in{\mathbb}{N} such that, for all a\in L^\infty({\mathbb}{R}) satisfying \sup_{x\in{\mathbb}{R}}|a(x+y)-a(x)|\,\leq\,C_0\,y\,\log\left(1+\frac{1}{y}\right) for all y>0y>0, one has, for all ν≥ν0\nu\geq\nu_0, \label{eq:comm_Log-Lip} \|\,[{\varphi}_\nu(D_x),a(x)]\,\|_{{\mathcal}{L}(L^2)}\,\leq\,C\,(\|a\|_{L^\infty}+C_0)\,2^{-\nu}\,\nu\,.

    2. There exist C>0C>0, \nu_0\in{\mathbb}{N} such that, for all b\in{\mathcal}{C}^\omega({\mathbb}{R}) and all ν≥ν0\nu\geq\nu_0, one has \label{eq:comm_Holder} \|\,[{\varphi}_\nu(D_x),b(x)]\,\|_{{\mathcal}{L}(L^2)}\,\leq\,C\,\|b\|_{{\mathcal}{C}^\omega}\,2^{-\nu}\,.

    Approximate and total energy

    Let T0>0T_0>0 and u\in{\mathcal}{C}^2([0,T_0];H^\infty({\mathbb}{R}_x)). If we set uν(t,x)=φν(Dx)u(t,x)u_\nu(t,x)={\varphi}_\nu(D_x)u(t,x), we obtain \label(N)eqni(Lu)ν=∂t2uν − ∂x(a(t,x)∂xuν)−∂x([φν(Dx),a]∂xu)+b0(t,x)∂tuν+[φν(Dx),b0]∂tu + b1(t,x)∂xuν+[φν(Dx),b1]∂xu+c(t,x)uν+[φν(Dx),c]u  .\begin{aligned} \label{(N)eq_ni} (Lu)_{\nu} & = & \partial_{t}^{2}u_{\nu}\,-\,\partial_x(a(t,x)\partial_x u_{\nu}) - \partial_x([{\varphi}_{\nu}(D_x),a]\partial_x u) \\ & + & b_0(t,x)\partial_t u_\nu + [{\varphi}_\nu(D_x),b_0]\partial_t u\,+\, b_1(t,x)\partial_x u_\nu + [{\varphi}_\nu(D_x),b_1]\partial_x u \nonumber\\ & + & c(t,x)u_\nu + [{\varphi}_\nu(D_x),c]u \nonumber\;.\end{aligned}

    Now, we introduce the approximate energy of uνu_\nu (see [@Colomb-DelSant_2] and [@Tarama]), setting \label{(N)eq_e_nu-eps} e_{\nu,\varepsilon}(t):=\int_{{\mathbb}{R}}\left(\frac{1}{\sqrt{a_\varepsilon}}\left|\partial_t u_\nu+ \frac{\partial_t\sqrt{a_\varepsilon}}{2\sqrt{a_\varepsilon}}u_\nu\right|^2+\sqrt{a_\varepsilon}|\partial_x u_\nu|^2+|u_\nu|^2\right)\,dx\;, and, taken θ\theta as in the hypothesis of Theorem [(N)teor_teorema1], we define the total energy of uu: \label{(N)eq_E_tot} E(t)\,:=\,\sum_{\nu=0}^{+\infty}e^{-2\beta(\nu+1)t}\,2^{-2\nu\theta}\,e_{\nu,2^{-\nu}}(t)\;, where β>0\beta>0 will be fixed later on.

    [remark:E(0)-E(t)] From ([eq:dyadic-dec_Sobolev-norm]) and Bernstein’s inequalities ([eq:Bern-ineq_deriv<])-([eq:Bern-ineq_<deriv]), it’s easy to see that there exist two positive constants CθC_\theta and Cθ′C_\theta' such that \begin{aligned} E(0) & \leq & C_\theta\,(\|\partial_tu(0,\cdot)\|_{H^{-\theta}}\,+\,\|u(0,\cdot)\|_{H^{1-\theta}}) \\ E(t) & \geq & C_\theta'\,(\|\partial_tu(t,\cdot)\|_{H^{-\theta-\beta^*t}}\,+\, \|u(t,\cdot)\|_{H^{1-\theta-\beta^*t}}) where we have set β∗=β(log⁡2)−1\beta^*=\beta(\log2)^{-1}.

    First, we derive eν,εe_{\nu,{\varepsilon}}, defined by ([(N)eq_e_nu-eps]), with respect to the time variable, and we obtain ddteν,ε(t)=∫2aε  ℜ(∂t2uν ⋅ (∂tuν+∂taε2aεuν)‾) dx+∫2aε  ℜ(Rεuν ⋅ (∂tuν+∂taε2aεuν)‾) dx+∫∂taε  ∣∂xuν∣2 dx+∫2aε  ℜ(∂xuν ⋅ ∂x∂tuν‾) dx+∫2  ℜ(uν ⋅ ∂tuν‾) dx  ,\begin{aligned} \frac{d}{dt}e_{\nu,{\varepsilon}}(t) & = & \int\frac{2}{\sqrt{a_{\varepsilon}}}\,\,\Re\left(\partial_t^2u_\nu\,\cdot\, \overline{\left(\partial_tu_\nu+\frac{\partial_t\sqrt{a_{\varepsilon}}}{2\sqrt{a_{\varepsilon}}}u_\nu\right)}\right)\,dx \\ & + & \int\frac{2}{\sqrt{a_{\varepsilon}}}\,\,\Re\left(R_{\varepsilon}u_\nu\,\cdot\, \overline{\left(\partial_tu_\nu+\frac{\partial_t\sqrt{a_{\varepsilon}}}{2\sqrt{a_{\varepsilon}}}u_\nu\right)}\right)\,dx \\ & + & \int\partial_t\sqrt{a_{\varepsilon}}\,\,|\partial_xu_\nu|^2\,dx \\ & + & \int2\sqrt{a_{\varepsilon}}\,\,\Re(\partial_xu_\nu\,\cdot\,\overline{\partial_x\partial_tu_\nu})\,dx \\ & + & \int2\,\,\Re(u_\nu\,\cdot\,\overline{\partial_tu_\nu})\,dx\;,\end{aligned} where Rεv = ∂t(∂taε2aε)v−(∂taε2aε)2vR_{\varepsilon}v\,=\,\partial_t\left(\frac{\partial_t\sqrt{a_{\varepsilon}}}{2\sqrt{a_{\varepsilon}}}\right)v- \left(\frac{\partial_t\sqrt{a_{\varepsilon}}}{2\sqrt{a_{\varepsilon}}}\right)^2v. Now, we can put in the previous relation the value of ∂t2uν\partial_t^2u_\nu, given by ([(N)eq_ni]).

    Integrating by parts and taking advantage of the spectral localisation of uνu_\nu, we have ∫2aε  ℜ(∂x(a∂xuν) ⋅ (∂tuν+∂taε2aεuν)‾) dx == ∫2∂xaεaε a  ℜ(∂xuν ⋅ (∂tuν+∂taε2aεuν)‾) dx− ∫∂taεaε a ∣∂xuν∣2 dx− ∫2aaε  ℜ(∂xuν ⋅ ∂x∂tuν‾) dx− ∫aaε  ∂x(∂taεaε) ℜ(∂xuν ⋅ uν‾) dx ;\begin{aligned} & & \int\frac{2}{\sqrt{a_{\varepsilon}}}\,\,\Re\left(\partial_x(a\partial_xu_\nu)\,\cdot\, \overline{\left(\partial_tu_\nu+\frac{\partial_t\sqrt{a_{\varepsilon}}}{2\sqrt{a_{\varepsilon}}}u_\nu\right)}\right)\,dx\,= \\ & & \qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad=\,\int2\frac{\partial_x\sqrt{a_{\varepsilon}}}{a_{\varepsilon}}\,a\,\,\Re\left(\partial_xu_\nu\,\cdot\, \overline{\left(\partial_tu_\nu+\frac{\partial_t\sqrt{a_{\varepsilon}}}{2\sqrt{a_{\varepsilon}}}u_\nu\right)}\right)\,dx \\ & & \qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad-\,\int\frac{\partial_t\sqrt{a_{\varepsilon}}}{a_{\varepsilon}}\,a\,|\partial_xu_\nu|^2\,dx \\ & & \qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad-\,\int2\frac{a}{\sqrt{a_{\varepsilon}}}\,\,\Re\left(\partial_xu_\nu\,\cdot\, \overline{\partial_x\partial_tu_\nu}\right)\,dx \\ & & \qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad-\,\int\frac{a}{\sqrt{a_{\varepsilon}}}\,\, \partial_x\left(\frac{\partial_t\sqrt{a_{\varepsilon}}}{\sqrt{a_{\varepsilon}}}\right)\, \Re(\partial_xu_\nu\,\cdot\,\overline{u_\nu})\,dx\,;\end{aligned} taken care of the fact that b0b_0, b1b_1 and cc are real-valued, finally we obtain the complete expression for the time derivative of the approximate energy: \begin{aligned} \label{(N)eq_dt_e_nu,eps} & & \frac{d}{dt}e_{\nu,{\varepsilon}}(t)\,=\,\int\frac{2}{\sqrt{a_{\varepsilon}}}\,\,\Re \left((Lu)_\nu\,\cdot\, \overline{\left(\partial_tu_\nu+\frac{\partial_t\sqrt{a_{\varepsilon}}}{2\sqrt{a_{\varepsilon}}}u_\nu\right)}\right)\,dx \\ & & \qquad\qquad\quad\,+\,\int\frac{2}{\sqrt{a_{\varepsilon}}}\,\,\Re\left(R_{\varepsilon}u_\nu\,\cdot\, \overline{\left(\partial_tu_\nu+\frac{\partial_t\sqrt{a_{\varepsilon}}}{2\sqrt{a_{\varepsilon}}}u_\nu\right)}\right)\,dx \nonumber \\ & & \qquad\qquad\quad\,+\,\int\partial_t\sqrt{a_{\varepsilon}}\left(1-\frac{a}{a_{\varepsilon}}\right)|\partial_xu_\nu|^2\,dx \nonumber \\ & & \quad\qquad\qquad\,+\,\int2\left(\sqrt{a_{\varepsilon}}-\frac{a}{\sqrt{a_{\varepsilon}}}\right)\Re(\partial_xu_\nu\,\cdot\, \overline{\partial_x\partial_tu_\nu})\,dx \nonumber \\ & & \qquad\qquad\quad\,+\,\int2\frac{\partial_x\sqrt{a_{\varepsilon}}}{a_{\varepsilon}}\,a\,\,\Re\left(\partial_xu_\nu\,\cdot\, \overline{\left(\partial_tu_\nu+\frac{\partial_t\sqrt{a_{\varepsilon}}}{2\sqrt{a_{\varepsilon}}}u_\nu\right)}\right)\,dx \nonumber \\ & & \qquad\qquad\quad\,-\, \int\frac{a}{\sqrt{a_{\varepsilon}}}\,\,\partial_x\left(\frac{\partial_t\sqrt{a_{\varepsilon}}}{\sqrt{a_{\varepsilon}}}\right)\, \Re(\partial_xu_\nu\,\cdot\,\overline{u_\nu})\,dx \nonumber \\ & & \quad\qquad\qquad\,+\,\int2\,\Re(u_\nu\,\cdot\,\overline{\partial_tu_\nu})\,dx \nonumber \\ & & \quad\qquad\qquad\,+\,\int\frac{2}{\sqrt{a_{\varepsilon}}}\,\,\Re\left((\partial_x([{\varphi}_\nu(D_x),a]\partial_xu))\,\cdot\, \overline{\left(\partial_tu_\nu+\frac{\partial_t\sqrt{a_{\varepsilon}}}{2\sqrt{a_{\varepsilon}}}u_\nu\right)}\right)\,dx \nonumber \\ & & \qquad\qquad\quad\,-\,\int\frac{2}{\sqrt{a_{\varepsilon}}}\,b_0(t,x)\,\,\Re\left(\partial_tu_\nu\,\cdot\, \overline{\left(\partial_tu_\nu+\frac{\partial_t\sqrt{a_{\varepsilon}}}{2\sqrt{a_{\varepsilon}}}u_\nu\right)}\right)\,dx \nonumber \\ & & \qquad\qquad\quad\,-\,\int\frac{2}{\sqrt{a_{\varepsilon}}}\,\,\Re\left(([{\varphi}_\nu(D_x),b_0]\partial_tu)\,\cdot\, \overline{\left(\partial_tu_\nu+\frac{\partial_t\sqrt{a_{\varepsilon}}}{2\sqrt{a_{\varepsilon}}}u_\nu\right)}\right)\,dx \nonumber \\ & & \qquad\qquad\quad\,-\,\int\frac{2}{\sqrt{a_{\varepsilon}}}\,b_1(t,x)\,\,\Re\left(\partial_xu_\nu\,\cdot\, \overline{\left(\partial_tu_\nu+\frac{\partial_t\sqrt{a_{\varepsilon}}}{2\sqrt{a_{\varepsilon}}}u_\nu\right)}\right)\,dx \nonumber \\ & & \qquad\qquad\quad\,-\,\int\frac{2}{\sqrt{a_{\varepsilon}}}\,\,\Re\left(([{\varphi}_\nu(D_x),b_1]\partial_xu)\,\cdot\, \overline{\left(\partial_tu_\nu+\frac{\partial_t\sqrt{a_{\varepsilon}}}{2\sqrt{a_{\varepsilon}}}u_\nu\right)}\right)\,dx \nonumber \\ & & \qquad\qquad\quad\,-\,\int\frac{2}{\sqrt{a_{\varepsilon}}}\,c(t,x)\,\,\Re\left(u_\nu\,\cdot\, \overline{\left(\partial_tu_\nu+\frac{\partial_t\sqrt{a_{\varepsilon}}}{2\sqrt{a_{\varepsilon}}}u_\nu\right)}\right)\,dx \nonumber \\ & & \qquad\qquad\quad\,-\,\int\frac{2}{\sqrt{a_{\varepsilon}}}\,\,\Re\left(([{\varphi}_\nu(D_x),c]u)\,\cdot\, \overline{\left(\partial_tu_\nu+\frac{\partial_t\sqrt{a_{\varepsilon}}}{2\sqrt{a_{\varepsilon}}}u_\nu\right)}\right)\,dx \nonumber\;.\end{aligned}

    Estimate for the approximate energy

    We want to obtain an energy estimate; so, let us start to control each term of ([(N)eq_dt_e_nu,eps]).
    Through the rest of the proof, we will denote with CC, C′C', C′′C'' and {\widehat}{C} constants depending only on λ0\lambda_0, Λ0\Lambda_0, C0C_0 and on the norms of the coefficients of the lower order terms of the operator LL in their respective functional spaces, and which are allowed to vary from line to line.

    Terms with aa and aεa_{\varepsilon}

    Thanks to relations ([(N)eq_condiz_1.1]), ([(N)eq_d_t_a_eps]) with σ=1/2\sigma=1/2, ([(N)eq_d_t^2_a_eps]) and Bernstein’s inequalities, we deduce that there exists C>0C>0, depending only on λ0\lambda_0, Λ0\Lambda_0 and C0C_0, such that, for all \nu\in{\mathbb}{N}, ∣∫2aε  ℜ(Rεuν ⋅ (∂tuν+∂taε2aεuν)‾) dx∣ ≤ C 1ε log⁡(1ε+1) 2−ν eν,ε(t)  .\left|\int\frac{2}{\sqrt{a_{\varepsilon}}}\,\,\Re\left(R_{\varepsilon}u_\nu\,\cdot\, \overline{\left(\partial_tu_\nu+\frac{\partial_t\sqrt{a_{\varepsilon}}}{2\sqrt{a_{\varepsilon}}}u_\nu\right)} \right)\,dx\right|\,\leq\,C\,\frac{1}{{\varepsilon}}\,\log\left(\frac{1}{{\varepsilon}}+1\right)\, 2^{-\nu}\,e_{\nu,{\varepsilon}}(t)\;. In the same way, from ([(N)eq_condiz_1.1]), ([(N)eq_a_eps-a]) and ([(N)eq_d_t_a_eps]), we have ∣∫∂taε(1−aaε)∣∂xuν∣2 dx∣ ≤ C log⁡(1ε+1) eν,ε(t)  ,\left|\int\partial_t\sqrt{a_{\varepsilon}}\left(1-\frac{a}{a_{\varepsilon}}\right)|\partial_xu_\nu|^2\,dx\right|\,\leq\, C\,\log\left(\frac{1}{{\varepsilon}}+1\right)\,e_{\nu,{\varepsilon}}(t)\;, for a constant CC depending again only on λ0\lambda_0, Λ0\Lambda_0 and C0C_0.

    Moreover, again from ([(N)eq_condiz_1.1]) and ([(N)eq_a_eps-a]) and Bernstein’s inequalities, we obtain ∣∫2(aε−aaε)ℜ(∂xuν ⋅ ∂x∂tuν‾) dx∣≤C ε log⁡(1ε+1) ∥∂xuν∥L2 ∥∂x∂tuν∥L2≤C ε log⁡(1ε+1) 2ν+1 ∥∂xuν∥L2 ∥∂tuν∥L2  ;\begin{aligned} \left|\int2\left(\sqrt{a_{\varepsilon}}-\frac{a}{\sqrt{a_{\varepsilon}}}\right)\Re(\partial_xu_\nu\,\cdot\, \overline{\partial_x\partial_tu_\nu})\,dx\right| & \leq & C\,{\varepsilon}\,\log\left(\frac{1}{{\varepsilon}}+1\right)\, \|\partial_xu_\nu\|_{L^2}\,\|\partial_x\partial_tu_\nu\|_{L^2} \\ & \leq & C\,{\varepsilon}\,\log\left(\frac{1}{{\varepsilon}}+1\right)\,2^{\nu+1}\, \|\partial_xu_\nu\|_{L^2}\,\|\partial_tu_\nu\|_{L^2}\;;\end{aligned} but we have ∥∂tuν∥L2 ≤ ∥∂tuν+∂taε2aεuν∥L2 + ∥∂taε2aεuν∥L2\|\partial_tu_\nu\|_{L^2}\,\leq\,\left\|\partial_tu_\nu+\frac{\partial_t\sqrt{a_{\varepsilon}}}{2\sqrt{a_{\varepsilon}}}u_\nu \right\|_{L^2}\,+\,\left\|\frac{\partial_t\sqrt{a_{\varepsilon}}}{2\sqrt{a_{\varepsilon}}}u_\nu\right\|_{L^2} and ∥∂taε2aεu0∥L2≤C ε−1/2∥u0∥L2∥∂taε2aεuν∥L2≤C ε−1/2 2−ν∥uν∥L2(ν≥1)  ,\begin{aligned} \left\|\frac{\partial_t\sqrt{a_{\varepsilon}}}{2\sqrt{a_{\varepsilon}}}u_0\right\|_{L^2} & \leq & C\,{\varepsilon}^{-1/2}\|u_0\|_{L^2} \\ \left\|\frac{\partial_t\sqrt{a_{\varepsilon}}}{2\sqrt{a_{\varepsilon}}}u_\nu\right\|_{L^2} & \leq & C\,{\varepsilon}^{-1/2}\,2^{-\nu}\|u_\nu\|_{L^2}\qquad(\nu\geq1)\;,\end{aligned} that give us the following: ∣∫2(aε−aaε)ℜ(∂xuν⋅∂x∂tuν‾)dx∣ ≤ C(ε 2ν+1)log⁡(1ε+1)eν,ε(t)  .\left|\int2\left(\sqrt{a_{\varepsilon}}-\frac{a}{\sqrt{a_{\varepsilon}}}\right)\Re(\partial_xu_\nu\cdot \overline{\partial_x\partial_tu_\nu})dx\right|\,\leq\, C({\varepsilon}\,2^\nu+1)\log\left(\frac{1}{{\varepsilon}}+1\right)e_{\nu,{\varepsilon}}(t)\;.

    In a very similar way, from ([(N)eq_d_x_a_eps]) one has ∣∫2∂xaεaε a  ℜ(∂xuν⋅(∂tuν+∂taε2aεuν)‾)dx∣ ≤ Clog⁡(1ε+1)eν,ε(t)  ;\left|\int2\frac{\partial_x\sqrt{a_{\varepsilon}}}{a_{\varepsilon}}\,a\,\,\Re\left(\partial_xu_\nu\cdot \overline{\left(\partial_tu_\nu+\frac{\partial_t\sqrt{a_{\varepsilon}}}{2\sqrt{a_{\varepsilon}}}u_\nu\right)}\right)dx\right| \,\leq\,C\log\left(\frac{1}{{\varepsilon}}+1\right)e_{\nu,{\varepsilon}}(t)\;; moreover, from ([(N)eq_d_t_a_eps]) with σ=1/2\sigma=1/2, ([(N)eq_d_x_a_eps]) and ([(N)eq_d_t_d_x_a_eps]) we deduce ∣∫aaε  ∂x(∂taεaε) ℜ(∂xuν ⋅ uν‾) dx∣ ≤ C 1ε log⁡(1ε+1) 2−ν eν,ε(t)  .\left|\int\frac{a}{\sqrt{a_{\varepsilon}}}\,\,\partial_x\left(\frac{\partial_t\sqrt{a_{\varepsilon}}}{\sqrt{a_{\varepsilon}}}\right)\, \Re(\partial_xu_\nu\,\cdot\,\overline{u_\nu})\,dx\right|\,\leq\,C\,\frac{1}{{\varepsilon}}\, \log\left(\frac{1}{{\varepsilon}}+1\right)\,2^{-\nu}\,e_{\nu,{\varepsilon}}(t)\;.

    Finally, we have ∣∫2 ℜ(uν ⋅ ∂tuν‾) dx∣ ≤ C ε−1/2 2−ν eν,ε(t)  .\left|\int2\,\Re(u_\nu\,\cdot\,\overline{\partial_tu_\nu})\,dx\right|\,\leq\, C\,{\varepsilon}^{-1/2}\,2^{-\nu}\,e_{\nu,{\varepsilon}}(t)\;.

    Terms with b0b_0, b1b_1 and cc

    Thanks to the hypothesis ([(N)eq_condiz_B])-([(N)eq_condiz_c]), one has that there exist suitable constants, depending only on λ0\lambda_0, Λ0\Lambda_0, C0C_0 and on the norms of b0b_0 and b1b_1 in the space L^\infty({\mathbb}{R}_t;{\mathcal}{C}^{\omega}({\mathbb}{R}_x)) and of cc in L^\infty({\mathbb}{R}_t\times{\mathbb}{R}_x), such that ∣∫2aε b0(t,x)  ℜ(∂tuν ⋅ (∂tuν+∂taε2aεuν)‾) dx∣ ≤≤ C ∥∂tuν∥L2 ∥∂tuν+∂taε2aεuν∥L2≤ (C+C′ 2−νε−1/2) eν,ε(t)  ;∣∫2aε b1(t,x)  ℜ(∂xuν ⋅ (∂tuν+∂taε2aεuν)‾) dx∣ ≤≤ C ∫aε4∣∂xuν∣ 1aε4∣∂tuν+∂taε2aεuν∣ dx≤ 2C ∫aε∣∂xuν∣2 + 1aε∣∂tuν+∂taε2aεuν∣2 dx≤ 2 eν,ε(t)  ;∣∫2aε c(t,x)  ℜ(uν ⋅ (∂tuν+∂taε2aεuν)‾) dx∣ ≤≤ C ∫∣uν∣ 1aε4∣∂tuν+∂taε2aεuν∣ dx≤ 2C eν,ε(t)  ,\begin{aligned} & & \left|\int\frac{2}{\sqrt{a_{\varepsilon}}}\,b_0(t,x)\,\,\Re\left(\partial_tu_\nu\,\cdot\, \overline{\left(\partial_tu_\nu+\frac{\partial_t\sqrt{a_{\varepsilon}}}{2\sqrt{a_{\varepsilon}}}u_\nu\right)}\right)\,dx\right|\,\leq \\ & & \qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\leq\,C\,\|\partial_t u_\nu\|_{L^2}\, \left\|\partial_tu_\nu+\frac{\partial_t\sqrt{a_{\varepsilon}}}{2\sqrt{a_{\varepsilon}}}u_\nu\right\|_{L^2} \\ & & \qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\leq\,(C+C'\,2^{-\nu}{\varepsilon}^{-1/2})\,e_{\nu,{\varepsilon}}(t)\;; \\ & & \left|\int\frac{2}{\sqrt{a_{\varepsilon}}}\,b_1(t,x)\,\,\Re\left(\partial_xu_\nu\,\cdot\, \overline{\left(\partial_tu_\nu+\frac{\partial_t\sqrt{a_{\varepsilon}}}{2\sqrt{a_{\varepsilon}}}u_\nu\right)}\right)\,dx\right| \,\leq \\ & & \qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\leq\,C\,\int\sqrt[4]{a_{{\varepsilon}}}|\partial_x u_\nu|\, \frac{1}{\sqrt[4]{a_{\varepsilon}}}\left|\partial_tu_\nu+ \frac{\partial_t\sqrt{a_{_{\varepsilon}}}}{2\sqrt{a_{\varepsilon}}}u_\nu\right|\,dx \\ & & \qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\leq\,2C\,\int\sqrt{a_{\varepsilon}}|\partial_x u_\nu|^2\,+\, \frac{1}{\sqrt{a_{\varepsilon}}}\left|\partial_tu_\nu+\frac{\partial_t\sqrt{a_{\varepsilon}}}{2\sqrt{a_{\varepsilon}}}u_\nu \right|^2\,dx \\ & & \qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\leq\,2\,e_{\nu,{\varepsilon}}(t)\;; \\ & & \left|\int\frac{2}{\sqrt{a_{\varepsilon}}}\,c(t,x)\,\,\Re\left(u_\nu\,\cdot\, \overline{\left(\partial_tu_\nu+\frac{\partial_t\sqrt{a_{\varepsilon}}}{2\sqrt{a_{\varepsilon}}}u_\nu\right)}\right)\,dx\right|\,\leq \\ & & \qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\leq\,C\,\int|u_\nu|\,\frac{1}{\sqrt[4]{a_{\varepsilon}}} \left|\partial_tu_\nu+\frac{\partial_t\sqrt{a_{\varepsilon}}}{2\sqrt{a_{\varepsilon}}}u_\nu\right|\,dx \\ & & \qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\leq\,2C\,e_{\nu,{\varepsilon}}(t)\;,\end{aligned} where we have delt with ∥∂tuν∥L2\|\partial_tu_\nu\|_{L^2} as before.

    Now, we join the approximation parameter ε{\varepsilon} with the dual variable ξ\xi, setting ε = 2−ν  ;{\varepsilon}\,=\,2^{-\nu}\;; so, from ([(N)eq_dt_e_nu,eps]) and the previous inequalities, we obtain \begin{aligned} & & \frac{d}{dt}e_{\nu,2^{-\nu}}(t)\,\leq\,{\widetilde}{C}\,(\nu+1)\,e_{\nu,2^{-\nu}} \label{(N)eq_dt_e_nu,eps_II}\\ & & \qquad\qquad\quad\quad\,+\,\int\frac{2}{\sqrt{a_{2^{-\nu}}}}\,\,\Re\left((Lu)_\nu\,\cdot\, \overline{\left(\partial_tu_\nu+\frac{\partial_t\sqrt{a_{2^{-\nu}}}}{2\sqrt{a_{2^{-\nu}}}} u_\nu\right)}\right)\,dx \nonumber \\ & & \qquad\qquad\quad\quad\,+\,\int\frac{2}{\sqrt{a_{2^{-\nu}}}}\,\,\Re\left((\partial_x([{\varphi}_\nu(D_x),a]\partial_xu))\,\cdot\, \overline{\left(\partial_tu_\nu+\frac{\partial_t\sqrt{a_{2^{-\nu}}}}{2\sqrt{a_{2^{-\nu}}}} u_\nu\right)}\right)\,dx \nonumber \\ & & \qquad\qquad\quad\quad\,-\,\int\frac{2}{\sqrt{a_{2^{-\nu}}}}\,\,\Re\left(([{\varphi}_\nu(D_x),b_0]\partial_tu)\,\cdot\, \overline{\left(\partial_tu_\nu+\frac{\partial_t\sqrt{a_{2^{-\nu}}}}{2\sqrt{a_{2^{-\nu}}}} u_\nu\right)}\right)\,dx \nonumber \\ & & \qquad\qquad\quad\quad\,-\,\int\frac{2}{\sqrt{a_{2^{-\nu}}}}\,\,\Re\left(([{\varphi}_\nu(D_x),b_1]\partial_xu)\,\cdot\, \overline{\left(\partial_tu_\nu+\frac{\partial_t\sqrt{a_{2^{-\nu}}}}{2\sqrt{a_{2^{-\nu}}}} u_\nu\right)}\right)\,dx \nonumber \\ & & \qquad\qquad\quad\quad\,-\,\int\frac{2}{\sqrt{a_{2^{-\nu}}}}\,\,\Re\left(([{\varphi}_\nu(D_x),c]u)\,\cdot\, \overline{\left(\partial_tu_\nu+\frac{\partial_t\sqrt{a_{2^{-\nu}}}}{2\sqrt{a_{2^{-\nu}}}} u_\nu\right)}\right)\,dx \nonumber\;,\end{aligned} for a suitable constant {\widetilde}{C}, which depends only on λ0\lambda_0, Λ0\Lambda_0, C0C_0 and on the norms of the coefficients of the operator LL in their respective functional spaces.

    Estimates for the commutator terms

    Now, we have to deal with the commutator terms. As we will see, it’s useful to consider immediately the sum over \nu\in{\mathbb}{N}.

    First, we report an elementary lemma (see also [@Colomb-DelSant_2]), which we will use very often in the next calculations.

    [(N)lemma_1] There exist two continuous, decreasing functions α1\alpha_{1}, α2: ]0,1[ → ]0,+∞[\alpha_2:\,]0,1[\,\rightarrow\,]0,+\infty[ such that lim⁡c→0+αj(c)=+∞\lim_{c\rightarrow0^+}\alpha_j(c)=+\infty for j=1 , 2j=1\,,\,2 and such that, for all δ∈]0,1]\delta\in]0,1] and all n≥1n\geq1, the following inequalities hold: ∑j=1n eδj j−1/2 ≤ α1(δ) eδn n−1/2 ,∑j=n+∞ e−δj j1/2 ≤ α2(δ) e−δn n1/2 .\sum_{j=1}^{n}\,e^{\delta j}\,j^{-1/2}\,\leq\,\alpha_1(\delta)\,e^{\delta n}\,n^{-1/2}\,,\qquad\qquad \sum_{j=n}^{+\infty}\,e^{-\delta j}\,j^{1/2}\,\leq\,\alpha_2(\delta)\,e^{-\delta n}\,n^{1/2}\,.

    Before going on, we take β>0\beta>0 and T∈]0,T0]T\in]0,T_0] such that βT = θ2 log⁡2  .\beta T\,=\,\frac{\theta}{2}\,\log2\;.

    [oss:beta_T] Notice that, thanks to the hypothesis of Theorem [(N)teor_teorema1], this condition implies that βT ≤ ω−θ2  .\beta T\,\leq\,\frac{\omega-\theta}{2}\;. Moreover, for all t∈[0,T]t\in[0,T], we have: βt+θ2log⁡2≥θ2log⁡2  >0βt+θ2log⁡2≤θlog⁡2  ≤  12log⁡2  <1(1−θ)log⁡2−βt≥(1−32θ)log⁡2  ≥  (1−34)log⁡2  >0(1−θ)log⁡2−βt≤(1−θ)log⁡2  ≤  log⁡2  <1 .\begin{aligned} \beta t+\frac{\theta}{2}\log2 & \geq & \frac{\theta}{2}\log2\;>0\\ \beta t+\frac{\theta}{2}\log2 & \leq & \theta\log2\;\leq\;\frac{1}{2}\log2\;<1\\ (1-\theta)\log2-\beta t & \geq & \left(1-\frac{3}{2}\theta\right)\log2\;\geq\;\left(1-\frac{3}{4}\right)\log2\;>0\\ (1-\theta)\log2-\beta t & \leq & (1-\theta)\log2\;\leq\;\log2\;<1\,.\end{aligned}

    Finally, we set (with the same notations used in the subsection [sub-sec:L-P_dec]) ψμ = φμ−1+φμ+φμ+1(φ−1≡0)  .\psi_{\mu}\,=\,{\varphi}_{\mu-1}+{\varphi}_{\mu}+{\varphi}_{\mu+1}\qquad({\varphi}_{-1}\equiv0)\;. As ψμ≡1\psi_\mu\equiv1 on the support of φμ{\varphi}_\mu, we can write ∂xuμ = φμ(Dx)∂xu = Ψμ(φμ(Dx)∂xu) = Ψμ∂xuμ  ,\partial_xu_\mu\,=\,{\varphi}_\mu(D_x)\partial_xu\,=\,\Psi_\mu({\varphi}_\mu(D_x)\partial_xu)\,=\,\Psi_\mu\partial_xu_\mu\;, where Ψμ\Psi_\mu is the operator related to ψμ\psi_\mu. So, given a generic function f(t,x)f(t,x), one has \label(N)eqnu−mu[φν(Dx),f]∂xu = [φν(Dx),f](∑μ≥0∂xuμ) = ∑μ≥0([φν(Dx),f]Ψμ)∂xuμ  .\label{(N)eq_nu-mu} [{\varphi}_\nu(D_x),f]\partial_xu\,=\,[{\varphi}_\nu(D_x),f]\left(\sum_{\mu\geq0}\partial_xu_\mu\right)\,=\, \sum_{\mu\geq0}([{\varphi}_\nu(D_x),f]\Psi_\mu)\partial_xu_\mu\;.

    After these preliminary remarks, we now can go on with commutators’ estimates.

    Term with [φν(Dx),a][{\varphi}_\nu(D_x),a]

    Due to Bernstein’s inequalities, we have ∥∂x(∂tuν+∂ta2−ν2a2−νuν)∥L2 ≤ C 2ν (eν,2−ν(t))1/2  .\left\|\partial_x\left(\partial_tu_\nu+\frac{\partial_t\sqrt{a_{2^{-\nu}}}}{2\sqrt{a_{2^{-\nu}}}} u_\nu\right)\right\|_{L^2}\,\leq\,C\,2^\nu\,\left(e_{\nu,2^{-\nu}}(t)\right)^{1/2}\;. So, using ([(N)eq_nu-mu]) and the fact that aεa_{\varepsilon} is real-valued, one has \begin{aligned} & & \left|\int\frac{2}{\sqrt{a_{2^{-\nu}}}}\,\,\Re\left(\partial_x([{\varphi}_\nu(D_x),a]\partial_xu)\,\cdot\, \overline{\left(\partial_tu_\nu+\frac{\partial_t\sqrt{a_{2^{-\nu}}}}{2\sqrt{a_{2^{-\nu}}}} u_\nu\right)}\right)\,dx\right|\,\leq\, \\ & & \qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\leq\,C\,\sum_\mu\|([{\varphi}_\nu(D_x),a]\Psi_\mu)\partial_xu_\mu\|_{L^2}\, 2^\nu\,\left(e_{\nu,2^{-\nu}}(t)\right)^{1/2} \\ & & \qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\leq\,C\,\sum_\mu\|[{\varphi}_\nu(D_x),a]\Psi_\mu\|_{{\mathcal}{L}(L^2)}\,\left(e_{\mu,2^{-\mu}}(t)\right)^{1/2}\, 2^\nu\,\left(e_{\nu,2^{-\nu}}(t)\right)^{1/2}\;,\end{aligned} with the constant CC which depends only on λ0\lambda_0, Λ0\Lambda_0 and C0C_0.
    Then, ∣∑ν≥0e−2β(ν+1)t2−2νθ∫2a2−ν  ℜ(∂x([φν(Dx),a]∂xu)(∂tuν+∂ta2−ν2a2−νuν)‾)dx∣ ≤  ≤ C ∑ν,μkνμ (ν+1)1/2e−β(ν+1)t2−νθ(eν,2−ν)1/2 (μ+1)1/2e−β(μ+1)t2−μθ(eμ,2−μ)1/2  ,\begin{aligned} & & \left|\sum_{\nu\geq0}e^{-2\beta(\nu+1)t}2^{-2\nu\theta} \int\frac{2}{\sqrt{a_{2^{-\nu}}}}\,\,\Re\left(\partial_x([{\varphi}_\nu(D_x),a]\partial_xu) \overline{\left(\partial_tu_\nu+\frac{\partial_t\sqrt{a_{2^{-\nu}}}}{2\sqrt{a_{2^{-\nu}}}} u_\nu\right)}\right)dx\right|\,\leq \\ & & \;\quad\qquad\leq\,C\,\sum_{\nu,\mu}k_{\nu\mu}\,(\nu+1)^{1/2}e^{-\beta(\nu+1)t}2^{-\nu\theta} \left(e_{\nu,2^{-\nu}}\right)^{1/2}\,(\mu+1)^{1/2}e^{-\beta(\mu+1)t}2^{-\mu\theta}\left(e_{\mu,2^{-\mu}}\right)^{1/2}\;,\end{aligned} where we have set \label{(N)eq_kernel_comm[a]} k_{\nu\mu}\,=\,e^{-(\nu-\mu)\beta t}\,2^{-(\nu-\mu)\theta}\,2^{\nu}\,(\nu+1)^{-1/2}\,(\mu+1)^{-1/2}\, \|[{\varphi}_\nu(D_x),a]\Psi_\mu\|_{{\mathcal}{L}(L^2)}\;. Observe that, if ∣ν−μ∣≥3|\nu-\mu|\geq3, then φνψμ≡0{\varphi}_\nu\psi_\mu\equiv0, so [φν(Dx),a]Ψμ=φν(Dx)[a,Ψμ][{\varphi}_\nu(D_x),a]\Psi_\mu={\varphi}_\nu(D_x)[a,\Psi_\mu]. Therefore, from lemma [lemma:comm], in particular from ([eq:comm_Log-Lip]), we deduce that \|[{\varphi}_{\nu}(D_x),a(t,x)]\Psi_\mu\|_{{\mathcal}{L}(L^2)}\leq \left\{ \begin{array}{ll} C\,2^{-\nu}(\nu+1) & \mbox{ if } |\nu-\mu|\leq2\;, \\ & \\ C\,2^{-max\{\nu,\mu\}}(\max\{\nu,\mu\}+1) & \mbox{ if } |\nu-\mu|\geq3\;, \end{array} \right. where the constant CC depends only on Λ0\Lambda_0 and C0C_0.

    Now our aim is to apply Schur’s lemma, so to estimate the quantity \label(N)eqlemmaschursup⁡μ∑ν∣kνμ∣ + sup⁡ν∑μ∣kνμ∣  .\label{(N)eq_lemma_schur} \sup_{\mu}\sum_{\nu}|k_{\nu\mu}|\,+\,\sup_{\nu}\sum_{\mu}|k_{\nu\mu}|\;. To do this, we will use lemma [(N)lemma_1] and the inequalities stated in remark ([oss:beta_T]).

    1. Fix μ≤2\mu\leq2. ∑ν≥0∣kνμ∣≤C e(μ+1)βt 2(μ+1)θ (μ+1)−12∑νe−(ν+1)βt 2−(ν+1)θ (ν+1)12=C e(μ+1)βt 2(μ+1)θ (μ+1)−12∑νe−(ν+1)(βt+θlog⁡2) (ν+1)12≤C e3βt 23θ α2(βt+θlog⁡2)≤C 292θ α2(θlog⁡2)  .\begin{aligned} \sum_{\nu\geq0}|k_{\nu\mu}| & \leq & C\,e^{(\mu+1)\beta t}\,2^{(\mu+1)\theta}\,(\mu+1)^{-\frac{1}{2}} \sum_\nu e^{-(\nu+1)\beta t}\,2^{-(\nu+1)\theta}\,(\nu+1)^{\frac{1}{2}} \\ & = & C\,e^{(\mu+1)\beta t}\,2^{(\mu+1)\theta}\,(\mu+1)^{-\frac{1}{2}} \sum_\nu e^{-(\nu+1)(\beta t+\theta\log2)}\,(\nu+1)^{\frac{1}{2}} \\ & \leq & C\,e^{3\beta t}\,2^{3\theta}\,\alpha_2(\beta t+\theta\log2) \\ & \leq & C\,2^{\frac{9}{2}\theta}\,\alpha_2(\theta\log2)\;.\end{aligned}

    2. Now, take μ≥3\mu\geq3 and first consider ∑ν=0μ−3∣kνμ∣≤C e(μ+1)βt 2−(μ+1)(1−θ) (μ+1)12∑ν=0μ−3e−(ν+1)βt 2(ν+1)(1−θ) (ν+1)−12≤C e(μ+1)βt 2−(μ+1)(1−θ) (μ+1)12∑ν=0μ−3e(ν+1)(−βt+(1−θ)log⁡2) (ν+1)−12≤C e(μ+1)βt 2−(μ+1)(1−θ) (μ+1)12 α1(−βt+(1−θ)log⁡2) ⋅  ⋅ e(−βt+(1−θ)log⁡2)(μ−2) (μ−2)−12≤C 292θ α1((1−32θ)log⁡2)  .\begin{aligned} \sum_{\nu=0}^{\mu-3}|k_{\nu\mu}| & \leq & C\,e^{(\mu+1)\beta t}\,2^{-(\mu+1)(1-\theta)}\,(\mu+1)^{\frac{1}{2}} \sum_{\nu=0}^{\mu-3} e^{-(\nu+1)\beta t}\,2^{(\nu+1)(1-\theta)}\,(\nu+1)^{-\frac{1}{2}} \\ & \leq & C\,e^{(\mu+1)\beta t}\,2^{-(\mu+1)(1-\theta)}\,(\mu+1)^{\frac{1}{2}} \sum_{\nu=0}^{\mu-3}e^{(\nu+1)(-\beta t+(1-\theta)\log2)}\,(\nu+1)^{-\frac{1}{2}} \\ & \leq & C\,e^{(\mu+1)\beta t}\,2^{-(\mu+1)(1-\theta)}\,(\mu+1)^{\frac{1}{2}}\, \alpha_1(-\beta t+(1-\theta)\log2)\,\cdot \\ & & \qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\quad\;\cdot\, e^{(-\beta t+(1-\theta)\log2)(\mu-2)}\,(\mu-2)^{-\frac{1}{2}} \\ & \leq & C\,2^{\frac{9}{2}\theta}\,\alpha_1\left(\left(1-\frac{3}{2}\theta\right)\log2\right)\;.\end{aligned}

      For the second part of the sum, one has ∑ν=μ−2+∞∣kνμ∣≤C e(μ+1)βt 2(μ+1)θ (μ+1)−1/2∑ν=μ−2+∞e−(ν+1)βt 2−(ν+1)θ (ν+1)1/2≤C e(μ+1)βt 2(μ+1)θ (μ+1)−1/2α2(βt+θlog⁡2) ⋅⋅ e−(βt+θlog⁡2)(μ−1) (μ−1)1/2≤C 272θ α2(θlog⁡2)  .\begin{aligned} \sum_{\nu=\mu-2}^{+\infty}|k_{\nu\mu}| & \leq & C\,e^{(\mu+1)\beta t}\,2^{(\mu+1)\theta}\,(\mu+1)^{-1/2} \sum_{\nu=\mu-2}^{+\infty}e^{-(\nu+1)\beta t}\,2^{-(\nu+1)\theta}\,(\nu+1)^{1/2} \\ & \leq & C\,e^{(\mu+1)\beta t}\,2^{(\mu+1)\theta}\,(\mu+1)^{-1/2}\alpha_2(\beta t+\theta\log2)\,\cdot \\ & & \qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\cdot\,e^{-(\beta t+\theta\log2)(\mu-1)}\,(\mu-1)^{1/2} \\ & \leq & C\,2^{\frac{7}{2}\theta}\,\alpha_2(\theta\log2)\;.\end{aligned}

    3. Fix now ν≥0\nu\geq0; we have ∑μ=0ν+2∣kνμ∣≤C e−(ν+1)βt 2−(ν+1)θ (ν+1)1/2∑μ=0ν+2e(μ+1)βt 2(μ+1)θ (μ+1)−1/2≤C e−(ν+1)βt 2−(ν+1)θ (ν+1)1/2 α1(βt+θlog⁡2) ⋅⋅ e(βt+θlog⁡2)(ν+3) (ν+3)−1/2≤C 272θ α1(θlog⁡2)  .\begin{aligned} \sum_{\mu=0}^{\nu+2}|k_{\nu\mu}| & \leq & C\,e^{-(\nu+1)\beta t}\,2^{-(\nu+1)\theta}\,(\nu+1)^{1/2} \sum_{\mu=0}^{\nu+2}e^{(\mu+1)\beta t}\,2^{(\mu+1)\theta}\,(\mu+1)^{-1/2} \\ & \leq & C\,e^{-(\nu+1)\beta t}\,2^{-(\nu+1)\theta}\,(\nu+1)^{1/2}\,\alpha_1(\beta t+\theta\log2)\,\cdot \\ & & \qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\cdot\,e^{(\beta t+\theta\log2)(\nu+3)}\,(\nu+3)^{-1/2} \\ & \leq & C\,2^{\frac{7}{2}\theta}\,\alpha_1(\theta\log2)\;.\end{aligned} For the second part of the series, the following inequality holds: ∑μ=ν+3+∞∣kνμ∣≤C e−(ν+1)βt 2(ν+1)(1−θ) (ν+1)−12∑μ=ν+3+∞e(μ+1)βt 2−(μ+1)(1−θ) (μ+1)12≤C e−(ν+1)βt 2(ν+1)(1−θ) (ν+1)−12 α2(−βt+(1−θ)log⁡2) ⋅    ⋅ e(−βt+(1−θ)log⁡2)(ν+4) (ν+4)12≤C 292θ α2((1−32θ)log⁡2)  .\begin{aligned} \sum_{\mu=\nu+3}^{+\infty}|k_{\nu\mu}| & \leq & C\,e^{-(\nu+1)\beta t}\,2^{(\nu+1)(1-\theta)}\,(\nu+1)^{-\frac{1}{2}} \sum_{\mu=\nu+3}^{+\infty}e^{(\mu+1)\beta t}\,2^{-(\mu+1)(1-\theta)}\,(\mu+1)^{\frac{1}{2}} \\ & \leq & C\,e^{-(\nu+1)\beta t}\,2^{(\nu+1)(1-\theta)}\,(\nu+1)^{-\frac{1}{2}}\, \alpha_2(-\beta t+(1-\theta)\log2)\,\cdot \\ & & \qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\;\;\cdot\, e^{(-\beta t+(1-\theta)\log2)(\nu+4)}\,(\nu+4)^{\frac{1}{2}} \\ & \leq & C\,2^{\frac{9}{2}\theta}\,\alpha_2\left(\left(1-\frac{3}{2}\theta\right)\log2\right)\;.\end{aligned}

    In conclusion, there exists a positive function Π\varPi, with lim⁡θ→0+Π(θ)=+∞\lim_{\theta\rightarrow0^+}\varPi(\theta)=+\infty, such that sup⁡μ∑ν∣kνμ∣ + sup⁡ν∑μ∣kνμ∣ ≤ C Π(θ)  ,\sup_{\mu}\sum_{\nu}|k_{\nu\mu}|\,+\,\sup_{\nu}\sum_{\mu}|k_{\nu\mu}|\,\leq\,C\,\varPi(\theta)\;, and so ∣∑ν≥0e−2β(ν+1)t 2−2νθ∫2a2−ν  ℜ(∂x([φν(Dx),a]∂xu)(∂tuν+∂ta2−ν2a2−νuν)‾)dx∣ ≤≤ C Π(θ) ∑ν=0+∞(ν+1) e−2β(ν+1)t 2−2νθ eν,2−ν(t)  .\begin{aligned} & & \hspace{-1cm}\left|\sum_{\nu\geq0}e^{-2\beta(\nu+1)t}\,2^{-2\nu\theta} \int\frac{2}{\sqrt{a_{2^{-\nu}}}}\,\,\Re\left(\partial_x([{\varphi}_\nu(D_x),a]\partial_xu) \overline{\left(\partial_tu_\nu+\frac{\partial_t\sqrt{a_{2^{-\nu}}}}{2\sqrt{a_{2^{-\nu}}}} u_\nu\right)}\right)dx\right|\,\leq \\ & & \qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\quad\qquad\qquad \leq\,C\,\varPi(\theta)\, \sum_{\nu=0}^{+\infty}(\nu+1)\,e^{-2\beta(\nu+1)t}\,2^{-2\nu\theta}\,e_{\nu,2^{-\nu}}(t)\;.\end{aligned}

    Terms with [φν(Dx),b0][{\varphi}_\nu(D_x),b_0] and [φν(Dx),b1][{\varphi}_\nu(D_x),b_1]

    Now, let us consider ∣∫2a2−ν  ℜ([φν(Dx),b0(t,x)]∂tu (∂tuν+∂ta2−ν2a2−νuν)‾) dx∣ ≤≤ 2 ∥[φν(Dx),b0(t,x)]∂tu∥L2 ∥1a2−ν∣∂tuν+∂ta2−ν2a2−νuν∣  ∥L2≤ 2 ∥[φν(Dx),b0(t,x)]∂tu∥L2 (eν,2−ν(t))1/2  .\begin{aligned} & & \left|\int\frac{2}{\sqrt{a_{2^{-\nu}}}}\,\,\Re\left([{\varphi}_{\nu}(D_x),b_0(t,x)]\partial_t u\, \overline{\left(\partial_tu_\nu+\frac{\partial_t\sqrt{a_{2^{-\nu}}}}{2\sqrt{a_{2^{-\nu}}}} u_\nu\right)}\right)\,dx\right|\,\leq \\ & & \quad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\leq\,2\,\|[{\varphi}_{\nu}(D_x),b_0(t,x)]\partial_t u\|_{L^2}\, \left\|\frac{1}{\sqrt{a_{2^{-\nu}}}}\left|\partial_tu_\nu+\frac{\partial_t\sqrt{a_{2^{-\nu}}}}{2\sqrt{a_{2^{-\nu}}}} u_\nu\right|\;\right\|_{L^2} \\ & & \quad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\leq\,2\,\|[{\varphi}_{\nu}(D_x),b_0(t,x)]\partial_t u\|_{L^2}\,(e_{\nu,2^{-\nu}}(t))^{1/2}\;.\end{aligned}

    Thanks to relation ([(N)eq_nu-mu]), we have \begin{aligned} \|[{\varphi}_{\nu}(D_x),b_0(t,x)]\partial_t u\|_{L^2} & = & \left\|[{\varphi}_{\nu}(D_x),b_0(t,x)]\sum_{\mu\geq0}\Psi_\mu\partial_tu_\mu\right\|_{L^2} \\ & \leq & \sum_{\mu\geq0}\|[{\varphi}_{\nu}(D_x),b_0(t,x)]\Psi_\mu\|_{{\mathcal}{L}(L^2)}\|\partial_tu_\mu\|_{L^2}\;.\end{aligned} As we have done before, we have, for constants depending only on λ0\lambda_0, Λ0\Lambda_0 and C0C_0, ∥∂tuμ∥L2 = (∫a2−μa2−μ∣∂tuμ∣2dx)1/2≤(C eμ,2−μ(t)+C′ ∥∂ta2−μ2a2−μuμ∥L2)1/2≤(Ceμ,2−μ(t) + C′12−μ2−2μ∥∂xuμ∥L2)1/2≤(C+C′ 2−μ)1/2(eμ,2−μ)1/2≤C (eμ,2−μ)1/2  .\begin{aligned} \|\partial_tu_\mu\|_{L^2}\,=\, \left(\int\frac{\sqrt{a_{2^{-\mu}}}}{\sqrt{a_{2^{-\mu}}}}|\partial_tu_\mu|^{2}dx\right)^{1/2} & \leq & \left(C\,e_{\mu,2^{-\mu}}(t)+ C'\,\left\|\frac{\partial_t\sqrt{a_{2^{-\mu}}}}{2\sqrt{a_{2^{-\mu}}}}u_\mu\right\|_{L^2}\right)^{1/2} \\ & \leq & \left(C e_{\mu,2^{-\mu}}(t)\,+\,C'\frac{1}{2^{-\mu}}2^{-2\mu}\|\partial_x u_\mu\|_{L^2}\right)^{1/2} \\ & \leq & (C+ C'\,2^{-\mu})^{1/2}\left(e_{\mu,2^{-\mu}}\right)^{1/2} \\ & \leq & C\,\left(e_{\mu,2^{-\mu}}\right)^{1/2}\;.\end{aligned}

    Due to lemma [lemma:comm], we obtain \|[{\varphi}_{\nu}(D_x),b_0(t,x)]\Psi_\mu\|_{{\mathcal}{L}(L^2)}\leq \left\{ \begin{array}{ll} C\,2^{-\nu\omega} & \quad\mbox{ if } |\nu-\mu|\leq2 \\ & \\ C\,2^{-max\{\mu,\nu\}\omega} & \quad\mbox{ if } |\nu-\mu|\geq3 \end{array} \right. where CC is a constant depending only on \|b_0\|_{L^\infty({\mathbb}{R}_t;\,{\mathcal}{C}^{\omega}({\mathbb}{R}_x))}.
    As a matter of fact, the kernel of operator [φν(Dx),b0][{\varphi}_\nu(D_x),b_0] is n(x,y)\,=\,{\widehat}{{\varphi}}(2^\nu(x-y))\,2^{\nu}\,(b_0(t,x)-b_0(t,y))\;; so, to evaluate its norm we apply Schur’s lemma and, thanks to the fact that b0b_0 is ω\omega-hölder, we get the desired estimate.

    Therefore, ∣∑ν≥0e−2βt(ν+1)2−2νθ∫2a2−ν  ℜ([Δν,b0]∂tu (∂tuν+∂ta2−ν2a2−νuν)‾)dx∣ ≤≤ ∑ν,μ≥0e−βt(ν+1) 2−νθ (eν,2−ν)1/2 e−βt(μ+1) 2−μθ (eμ,2−μ)1/2 lνμ  ,\begin{aligned} & & \left|\sum_{\nu\geq0}e^{-2\beta t(\nu+1)}2^{-2\nu\theta} \int\frac{2}{\sqrt{a_{2^{-\nu}}}}\,\,\Re\left([\Delta_{\nu},b_0]\partial_tu\, \overline{\left(\partial_t u_\nu+ \frac{\partial_t\sqrt{a_{2^{-\nu}}}}{2\sqrt{a_{2^{-\nu}}}}u_\nu\right)}\right)dx\right|\,\leq \\ & & \qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\leq\,\sum_{\nu,\mu\geq0}e^{-\beta t(\nu+1)}\,2^{-\nu\theta}\,\left(e_{\nu,2^{-\nu}}\right)^{1/2}\, e^{-\beta t(\mu+1)}\,2^{-\mu\theta}\,\left(e_{\mu,2^{-\mu}}\right)^{1/2}\,l_{\nu\mu}\;,\end{aligned} where we have defined \label{(N)eq_kernel_comm[b_0]} l_{\nu\mu}\,:=\,e^{-(\nu-\mu)\beta t}\,2^{-(\nu-\mu)\theta}\,\|[{\varphi}_{\nu}(D_x),b_0(t,x)]\Psi_\mu\|_{{\mathcal}{L}(L^2)}\;.

    As made before, we are going to estimate lνμl_{\nu\mu} applying Schur’s lemma.

    1. Let us fix μ≤2\mu\leq2. Then ∑ν≥0∣lνμ∣≤C e(μ+1)βt 2(μ+1)θ ∑ν≥0e−(ν+1)βt 2−(ν+1)θ 2−νω≤C e3βt 23θ ∑ν≥0e−(ν+1)(βt+θlog⁡2) (ν+1)1/2≤C e3βt 23θ α2(βt+θlog⁡2)≤C 292θ α2(θlog⁡2) .\begin{aligned} \sum_{\nu\geq0}|l_{\nu\mu}| & \leq & C\,e^{(\mu+1)\beta t}\,2^{(\mu+1)\theta}\, \sum_{\nu\geq0}e^{-(\nu+1)\beta t}\,2^{-(\nu+1)\theta}\,2^{-\nu\omega} \\ & \leq & C\,e^{3\beta t}\,2^{3\theta}\,\sum_{\nu\geq0}e^{-(\nu+1)(\beta t+\theta\log2)}\,(\nu+1)^{1/2} \\ & \leq & C\,e^{3\beta t}\,2^{3\theta}\,\alpha_2(\beta t+\theta\log2) \\ & \leq & C\,2^{\frac{9}{2}\theta}\,\alpha_2(\theta\log2)\,.\end{aligned}

    2. Now, take μ≥3\mu\geq3 and consider first ∑ν=0μ−3∣lνμ∣≤C eμβt 2μθ 2−μω∑ν=0μ−3e−νβt 2−νθ≤C eμ(βt−(ω−θ)log⁡2) (μ−2)≤C e−μ(ω−θ2)log⁡2 (μ−2)≤C M(ω,θ)  ,\begin{aligned} \sum_{\nu=0}^{\mu-3}|l_{\nu\mu}| & \leq & C\,e^{\mu\beta t}\,2^{\mu\theta}\,2^{-\mu\omega} \sum_{\nu=0}^{\mu-3} e^{-\nu\beta t}\,2^{-\nu\theta} \\ & \leq & C\,e^{\mu(\beta t-(\omega-\theta)\log2)}\,(\mu-2) \\ & \leq & C\,e^{-\mu(\omega-\frac{\theta}{2})\log2}\,(\mu-2) \\ & \leq & C\,M(\omega,\theta)\;,\end{aligned} where M(ω,θ)M(\omega,\theta) is the maximum of the function z↦e−γz (z−2)z\mapsto e^{-\gamma z}\,(z-2), with γ=(ω−θ2)log⁡2\gamma=\left(\omega-\frac{\theta}{2}\right)\log2.
      For the second part of the sum, we have ∑ν=μ−2+∞∣lνμ∣≤C e(μ+1)βt 2(μ+1)θ∑ν=μ−2+∞e−(ν+1)βt 2−(ν+1)θ 2−νω(ν+1)1/2(ν+1)1/2≤C e(μ+1)βt 2(μ+1)θ (μ−1)−1/2 α2(βt+θlog⁡2) ⋅⋅ e−(μ−1)βt 2−(μ−1)θ (μ−1)1/2≤C e2(βt+θlog⁡2) α2(θlog⁡2)≤C 292θ α2(θlog⁡2) .\begin{aligned} \sum_{\nu=\mu-2}^{+\infty}|l_{\nu\mu}| & \leq & C\,e^{(\mu+1)\beta t}\,2^{(\mu+1)\theta} \sum_{\nu=\mu-2}^{+\infty}e^{-(\nu+1)\beta t}\,2^{-(\nu+1)\theta}\,2^{-\nu\omega} \frac{(\nu+1)^{1/2}}{(\nu+1)^{1/2}} \\ & \leq & C\,e^{(\mu+1)\beta t}\,2^{(\mu+1)\theta}\,(\mu-1)^{-1/2}\,\alpha_2(\beta t+\theta\log2)\,\cdot \\ & & \qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\cdot\,e^{-(\mu-1)\beta t}\,2^{-(\mu-1)\theta}\,(\mu-1)^{1/2} \\ & \leq & C\,e^{2(\beta t+\theta\log2)}\,\alpha_2(\theta\log2) \\ & \leq & C\,2^{\frac{9}{2}\theta}\,\alpha_2(\theta\log2)\,.\end{aligned}

    3. Fix now ν\nu. Initially, we have ∑μ=0ν+2∣lνμ∣≤C e−(ν+1)βt 2−(ν+1)θ 2−νω∑μ=0ν+2e(μ+1)(βt+θlog⁡2) (μ+1)1/2(μ+1)1/2≤C e−(ν+1)βt 2−(ν+1)θ 2−νω (ν+3)1/2 α1(βt+θlog⁡2) ⋅⋅ e(ν+3)βt 2(ν+3)θ (ν+3)−1/2≤C e2(βt+θlog⁡2) α1(θlog⁡2)≤C 23θ α1(θlog⁡2)  .\begin{aligned} \sum_{\mu=0}^{\nu+2}|l_{\nu\mu}| & \leq & C\,e^{-(\nu+1)\beta t}\,2^{-(\nu+1)\theta}\,2^{-\nu\omega} \sum_{\mu=0}^{\nu+2}e^{(\mu+1)(\beta t+\theta\log2)}\,\frac{(\mu+1)^{1/2}}{(\mu+1)^{1/2}} \\ & \leq & C\,e^{-(\nu+1)\beta t}\,2^{-(\nu+1)\theta}\,2^{-\nu\omega}\,(\nu+3)^{1/2}\,\alpha_1(\beta t+\theta\log2)\,\cdot \\ & & \qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\cdot\,e^{(\nu+3)\beta t}\,2^{(\nu+3)\theta}\,(\nu+3)^{-1/2} \\ & \leq & C\,e^{2(\beta t+\theta\log2)}\,\alpha_1(\theta\log2) \\ & \leq & C\,2^{3\theta}\,\alpha_1(\theta\log2)\;.\end{aligned} Moreover, ∑μ=ν+3+∞∣lνμ∣≤C e−νβt 2−νθ∑μ=ν+3+∞e−μ(−βt+(ω−θ)log⁡2) μ1/2μ1/2≤C e−νβt 2−νθ (ν+3)−1/2 α2((ω−θ)log⁡2−βt) ⋅⋅ e(ν+3)βt 2−(ν+3)(ω−θ) (ν+3)1/2≤C e3βt 23θ 2−(ν+3)ω α2((ω−32θ)log⁡2)≤C 292θ α2((ω−32θ)log⁡2) .\begin{aligned} \sum_{\mu=\nu+3}^{+\infty}|l_{\nu\mu}| & \leq & C\,e^{-\nu\beta t}\,2^{-\nu\theta} \sum_{\mu=\nu+3}^{+\infty}e^{-\mu(-\beta t+(\omega-\theta)\log2)}\,\frac{\mu^{1/2}}{\mu^{1/2}} \\ & \leq & C\,e^{-\nu\beta t}\,2^{-\nu\theta}\,(\nu+3)^{-1/2}\,\alpha_2((\omega-\theta)\log2-\beta t)\,\cdot \\ & & \qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\cdot\,e^{(\nu+3)\beta t}\,2^{-(\nu+3)(\omega-\theta)}\,(\nu+3)^{1/2}\\ & \leq & C\,e^{3\beta t}\,2^{3\theta}\,2^{-(\nu+3)\omega}\,\alpha_2\left(\left(\omega-\frac{3}{2}\theta\right)\log2\right) \\ & \leq & C\,2^{\frac{9}{2}\theta}\,\alpha_2\left(\left(\omega-\frac{3}{2}\theta\right)\log2\right)\,.\end{aligned}

    From all these inequalities, thanks to Schur’s lemma, one has that there exists a constant {\widetilde}{M}(\omega,\theta), depending only on \|b_0\|_{L^\infty({\mathbb}{R}_t;\,{\mathcal}{C}^{\omega}({\mathbb}{R}_x))} and on the parameter θ\theta (which we have fixed at the beginning of the calculations), such that \sup_{\mu}\sum_{\nu}|l_{\nu\mu}|\,+\,\sup_{\nu}\sum_{\mu}|l_{\nu\mu}|\,\leq\,C\,{\widetilde}{M}(\omega,\theta)\;; from this relation, finally we get \begin{aligned} & & \hspace{-0.5cm}\left|\sum_{\nu\geq0}e^{-2\beta t(\nu+1)}2^{-2\nu\theta} \int\frac{2}{\sqrt{a_{2^{-\nu}}}}\,\, \Re\left([{\varphi}_{\nu}(D_x),b_0]\partial_t u\, \overline{\left(\partial_t u_\nu+\frac{\partial_t\sqrt{a_{2^{-\nu}}}}{2\sqrt{a_{2^{-\nu}}}}u_\nu\right)}\right)dx\right|\,\leq \\ & & \qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\leq\,C\,{\widetilde}{M}(\omega,\theta) \sum_{\nu=0}^{+\infty}(\nu+1)\,e^{-2\beta(\nu+1)t}\,2^{-2\nu\theta}\,e_{\nu,2^{-\nu}}(t)\;.\end{aligned}

    With regard to the term with the commutator [φν(Dx),b1(t,x)][{\varphi}_\nu(D_x),b_1(t,x)], notice that, as we made before, one has, for constants depending only on λ0\lambda_0, Λ0\Lambda_0 and C0C_0, \begin{aligned} & & \left|\int\frac{2}{\sqrt{a_{2^{-\nu}}}}\,\,\Re\left([{\varphi}_{\nu}(D_x),b_1]\partial_xu\, \overline{\left(\partial_tu_\nu+\frac{\partial_t\sqrt{a_{2^{-\nu}}}}{2\sqrt{a_{2^{-\nu}}}}u_\nu\right)} \right)\,dx\right|\,\leq \\ & & \qquad\qquad\leq\,C\,\sum_{\mu\geq0}\|[{\varphi}_\nu(D_x),b_1]\Psi_\mu\|_{{\mathcal}{L}(L^2)}\, \|\sqrt[4]{a_{2^{-\nu}}}\partial_xu_\mu\|_{L^2}\,\left\|\frac{1}{\sqrt[4]{a_{2^{-\nu}}}} \left(\partial_tu_\nu+\frac{\partial_t\sqrt{a_{2^{-\nu}}}}{2\sqrt{a_{2^{-\nu}}}}u_\nu\right)\right\|_{L^2} \\ & & \qquad\qquad\leq\,C\,\sum_{\mu\geq0}\|[{\varphi}_\nu(D_x),b_1]\Psi_\mu\|_{{\mathcal}{L}(L^2)}\,\left(e_{\nu,2^{-\nu}}\right)^{1/2}\left(e_{\mu,2^{-\mu}}\right)^{1/2}\;.\end{aligned}

    Therefore, ∣∑ν≥0e−2βt(ν+1) 2−2νθ ∫2a2−ν  ℜ([φν(Dx),b1]∂xu (∂tuν+∂ta2−ν2a2−νuν)‾)dx∣ ≤≤ C ∑ν,μ≥0e−β(ν+1)t 2−νθ (eν,2−ν)1/2 e−β(μ+1)t 2−μθ (eμ,2−μ)1/2 hνμ  ,\begin{aligned} & & \left|\sum_{\nu\geq0}e^{-2\beta t(\nu+1)}\,2^{-2\nu\theta}\,\int\frac{2}{\sqrt{a_{2^{-\nu}}}}\,\,\Re\left([{\varphi}_{\nu}(D_x),b_1]\partial_xu\, \overline{\left(\partial_tu_\nu+\frac{\partial_t\sqrt{a_{2^{-\nu}}}}{2\sqrt{a_{2^{-\nu}}}}u_\nu\right)} \right)dx\right|\,\leq\\ & & \qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\leq\,C\,\sum_{\nu,\mu\geq0}e^{-\beta(\nu+1)t}\,2^{-\nu\theta}\,\left(e_{\nu,2^{-\nu}}\right)^{1/2}\, e^{-\beta(\mu+1)t}\,2^{-\mu\theta}\,\left(e_{\mu,2^{-\mu}}\right)^{1/2}\,h_{\nu\mu}\;,\end{aligned} where we have set again h_{\nu\mu}\,=\,e^{-(\nu-\mu)\beta t}\,2^{-(\nu-\mu)\theta}\,\|[{\varphi}_\nu(D_x),b_1]\Psi_\mu\|_{{\mathcal}{L}(L^2)}\;. As b0b_0 and b1b_1 satisfy to the same hypothesis, the commutator [φν(Dx),b1][{\varphi}_\nu(D_x),b_1] verifies the same inequalities as [φν(Dx),b0][{\varphi}_\nu(D_x),b_0]; so, if we repeat the same calculations, we obtain \begin{aligned} & & \left|\sum_{\nu\geq0}e^{-2\beta t(\nu+1)}\,2^{-2\nu\theta}\,\int\frac{2}{\sqrt{a_{2^{-\nu}}}}\,\,\Re\left([{\varphi}_{\nu}(D_x),b_1]\partial_xu\, \overline{\left(\partial_tu_\nu+\frac{\partial_t\sqrt{a_{2^{-\nu}}}}{2\sqrt{a_{2^{-\nu}}}}u_\nu\right)} \right)dx\right|\,\leq \\ & & \qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\leq\,C\,{\widetilde}{M}(\omega,\theta) \sum_{\nu=0}^{+\infty}(\nu+1)\,e^{-2\beta(\nu+1)t}\,2^{-2\nu\theta}\,e_{\nu,2^{-\nu}}(t)\;.\end{aligned}

    Term with [φν(Dx),c][{\varphi}_\nu(D_x),c]

    Finally, we have to deal with the commutator [φν(Dx),c(t,x)][{\varphi}_\nu(D_x),c(t,x)].

    First, observe that there exist constants, depending only on λ0\lambda_0, Λ0\Lambda_0 and C0C_0 as usual, such that one has \begin{aligned} & & \left|\int\frac{2}{\sqrt{a_{2^{-\nu}}}}\,\,\Re\left([{\varphi}_{\nu}(D_x),c]\partial_xu\, \overline{\left(\partial_tu_\nu+\frac{\partial_t\sqrt{a_{2^{-\nu}}}}{2\sqrt{a_{2^{-\nu}}}}u_\nu\right)} \right)\,dx\right|\,\leq \\ & & \qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\leq\,C\,\|[{\varphi}_{\nu}(D_x),c]u\|_{L^2}\,\left\|\frac{1}{\sqrt[4]{a_{2^{-\nu}}}}\left(\partial_tu_\nu+ \frac{\partial_t\sqrt{a_{2^{-\nu}}}}{2\sqrt{a_{2^{-\nu}}}}u_\nu\right)\right\|_{L^2} \\ & & \qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\leq\,C\,\sum_{\mu\geq0}\|[{\varphi}_\nu(D_x),c]\Psi_\mu\|_{{\mathcal}{L}(L^2)}\,\|u_\mu\|_{L^2}\, \left(e_{\nu,2^{-\nu}}(t)\right)^{1/2}\\ & & \qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\leq\,2\,C\,\sum_{\mu\geq0}\|[{\varphi}_\nu(D_x),c]\Psi_\mu\|_{{\mathcal}{L}(L^2)}\, 2^{-\mu}\,\|D_xu_\mu\|_{L^2}\,\left(e_{\nu,2^{-\nu}}(t)\right)^{1/2}\\ & & \qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\leq\,2\,C\,\sum_{\mu\geq0}\|[{\varphi}_\nu(D_x),c]\Psi_\mu\|_{{\mathcal}{L}(L^2)}\,2^{-\mu}\, \left(e_{\mu,2^{-\mu}}(t)\right)^{1/2}\,\left(e_{\nu,2^{-\nu}}(t)\right)^{1/2}\;.\end{aligned}

    Thereby, we get the estimate ∣∑ν≥0e−2βt(ν+1) 2−2νθ ∫2a2−ν  ℜ([φν(Dx),c]∂xu(∂tuν+∂ta2−ν2a2−νuν)‾)dx∣ ≤≤ 2 C∑ν,μ≥0e−βt(ν+1) 2−νθ (eν,2−ν(t))1/2 e−βt(μ+1) 2−μθ (eμ,2−μ(t))1/2 mνμ  ,\begin{aligned} & & \left|\sum_{\nu\geq0}e^{-2\beta t(\nu+1)}\,2^{-2\nu\theta}\,\int\frac{2}{\sqrt{a_{2^{-\nu}}}}\,\,\Re\left([{\varphi}_{\nu}(D_x),c]\partial_xu \overline{\left(\partial_tu_\nu+\frac{\partial_t\sqrt{a_{2^{-\nu}}}}{2\sqrt{a_{2^{-\nu}}}}u_\nu\right)} \right)dx\right|\,\leq \\ & & \qquad\qquad\qquad\leq\,2\,C\sum_{\nu,\mu\geq0}e^{-\beta t(\nu+1)}\,2^{-\nu\theta}\,\left(e_{\nu,2^{-\nu}}(t)\right)^{1/2}\, e^{-\beta t(\mu+1)}\,2^{-\mu\theta}\,\left(e_{\mu,2^{-\mu}}(t)\right)^{1/2}\,m_{\nu\mu}\;,\end{aligned} where we have defined m_{\nu\mu}\,=\,e^{-(\nu-\mu)\beta t}\,2^{-(\nu-\mu)\theta}\,2^{-\mu}\,\|[{\varphi}_\nu(D_x),c]\Psi_\mu\|_{{\mathcal}{L}(L^2)}\;.

    The kernel of the operator [φν(Dx),c][{\varphi}_\nu(D_x),c] is n'(x,y)\,=\,{\widehat}{\psi}(2^\nu(x-y))\,2^{\nu}\,(c(t,y)-c(t,x))\,; so, remembering that cc is bounded over {\mathbb}{R}\times{\mathbb}{R}, from Schur’s lemma one gets \|[{\varphi}_\nu(D_x),c]\|_{{\mathcal}{L}(L^2)}\,\leq\,C\qquad\qquad\forall\,\nu\geq0\,, where the constant CC depends only on \|c\|_{L^\infty({\mathbb}{R}_t\times{\mathbb}{R}_x)}.

    Again, we are going to estimate the kernel mνμm_{\nu\mu} to apply Schur’s lemma.

    1. First, we take μ≤2\mu\leq2 and we have ∑ν≥0∣mνμ∣≤C e(μ+1)βt 2(μ+1)θ 2−μ∑ν≥0e−(ν+1)βt 2−(ν+1)θ≤C e3βt 23θ ∑ν≥0e−(ν+1)(βt+θlog⁡2) (ν+1)1/2≤C e3βt 23θ α2(βt+θlog⁡2)≤C 292θ α2(θlog⁡2)  .\begin{aligned} \sum_{\nu\geq0}|m_{\nu\mu}| & \leq & C\,e^{(\mu+1)\beta t}\,2^{(\mu+1)\theta}\,2^{-\mu} \sum_{\nu\geq0}e^{-(\nu+1)\beta t}\,2^{-(\nu+1)\theta} \\ & \leq & C\,e^{3\beta t}\,2^{3\theta}\,\sum_{\nu\geq0}e^{-(\nu+1)(\beta t+\theta\log2)}\,(\nu+1)^{1/2} \\ & \leq & C\,e^{3\beta t}\,2^{3\theta}\,\alpha_2(\beta t+\theta\log2) \\ & \leq & C\,2^{\frac{9}{2}\theta}\,\alpha_2(\theta\log2)\;.\end{aligned}

    2. Now, we fix μ≥3\mu\geq3 and we consider the first part of the series: ∑ν=0μ−3∣mνμ∣≤C e(μ+1)βt 2−(μ+1)(1−θ) 2−μ ∑ν=0μ−3e−(ν+1)βt 2(ν+1)(1−θ) 2μ−ν(ν+1)1/2(ν+1)1/2≤C e(μ+1)βt 2−(μ+1)(1−θ) (μ−2)1/2 ∑ν=0μ−3e(ν+1)((1−θ)log⁡2−βt) (ν+1)−1/2≤C e(μ+1)βt 2−(μ+1)(1−θ) (μ−2)1/2 α1((1−θ)log⁡2−βt) ⋅⋅ e−(μ−2)βt 2(μ−2)(1−θ) (μ−2)−1/2≤C e3βt 23θ α1((1−32θ)log⁡2)≤C 292θ α1((1−32θ)log⁡2)  .\begin{aligned} \sum_{\nu=0}^{\mu-3}|m_{\nu\mu}| & \leq & C\,e^{(\mu+1)\beta t}\,2^{-(\mu+1)(1-\theta)}\,2^{-\mu}\, \sum_{\nu=0}^{\mu-3} e^{-(\nu+1)\beta t}\,2^{(\nu+1)(1-\theta)}\,2^{\mu-\nu}\frac{(\nu+1)^{1/2}}{(\nu+1)^{1/2}} \\ & \leq & C\,e^{(\mu+1)\beta t}\,2^{-(\mu+1)(1-\theta)}\,(\mu-2)^{1/2}\, \sum_{\nu=0}^{\mu-3} e^{(\nu+1)((1-\theta)\log2-\beta t)}\,(\nu+1)^{-1/2} \\ & \leq & C\,e^{(\mu+1)\beta t}\,2^{-(\mu+1)(1-\theta)}\,(\mu-2)^{1/2}\, \alpha_1((1-\theta)\log2-\beta t)\,\cdot \\ & & \qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\cdot\,e^{-(\mu-2)\beta t}\,2^{(\mu-2)(1-\theta)}\,(\mu-2)^{-1/2} \\ & \leq & C\,e^{3\beta t}\,2^{3\theta}\,\alpha_1\left(\left(1-\frac{3}{2}\theta\right)\log2\right) \\ & \leq & C\,2^{\frac{9}{2}\theta}\,\alpha_1\left(\left(1-\frac{3}{2}\theta\right)\log2\right)\;.\end{aligned} For the second part, one has: ∑ν=μ−2+∞∣mνμ∣≤C e(μ+1)βt 2(μ+1)θ 2−μ∑ν=μ−2+∞e−(ν+1)βt 2−(ν+1)θ(ν+1)1/2(ν+1)1/2≤C e(μ+1)βt 2(μ+1)θ 2−μ α2(βt+θlog⁡2) e−(μ−1)βt 2−(μ−1)θ≤C 23θ α2(θlog⁡2)  .\begin{aligned} \sum_{\nu=\mu-2}^{+\infty}|m_{\nu\mu}| & \leq & C\,e^{(\mu+1)\beta t}\,2^{(\mu+1)\theta}\,2^{-\mu} \sum_{\nu=\mu-2}^{+\infty}e^{-(\nu+1)\beta t}\,2^{-(\nu+1)\theta}\frac{(\nu+1)^{1/2}}{(\nu+1)^{1/2}} \\ & \leq & C\,e^{(\mu+1)\beta t}\,2^{(\mu+1)\theta}\,2^{-\mu}\,\alpha_2(\beta t+\theta\log2)\, e^{-(\mu-1)\beta t}\,2^{-(\mu-1)\theta} \\ & \leq & C\,2^{3\theta}\,\alpha_2(\theta\log2)\;.\end{aligned}

    3. Now, we fix ν≥0\nu\geq0. Initially, we consider ∑μ=0ν+2∣mνμ∣≤C e−(ν+1)βt 2−(ν+1)θ ∑μ=0ν+2e(μ+1)(βt+θlog⁡2) 2−μ (μ+1)1/2(μ+1)1/2≤C e−(ν+1)βt 2−(ν+1)θ (ν+3)1/2 α1(βt+θlog⁡2) ⋅⋅ e(ν+3)βt 2(ν+3)θ (ν+3)−1/2≤C e2(βt+θlog⁡2) α1(θlog⁡2)≤C 23θ α1(θlog⁡2)  .\begin{aligned} \sum_{\mu=0}^{\nu+2}|m_{\nu\mu}| & \leq & C\,e^{-(\nu+1)\beta t}\,2^{-(\nu+1)\theta}\, \sum_{\mu=0}^{\nu+2}e^{(\mu+1)(\beta t+\theta\log2)}\,2^{-\mu}\,\frac{(\mu+1)^{1/2}}{(\mu+1)^{1/2}} \\ & \leq & C\,e^{-(\nu+1)\beta t}\,2^{-(\nu+1)\theta}\,(\nu+3)^{1/2}\,\alpha_1(\beta t+\theta\log2)\,\cdot \\ & & \qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\cdot\,e^{(\nu+3)\beta t}\,2^{(\nu+3)\theta}\,(\nu+3)^{-1/2} \\ & \leq & C\,e^{2(\beta t+\theta\log2)}\,\alpha_1(\theta\log2) \\ & \leq & C\,2^{3\theta}\,\alpha_1(\theta\log2)\;.\end{aligned} The second part of the series, instead, can be treated as follow: ∑μ=ν+3+∞∣mνμ∣≤C e−(ν+1)βt 2(ν+1)(1−θ) ∑μ=ν+3+∞e(μ+1)βt 2−μ 2−(μ+1)(1−θ) 2μ−ν (μ+1)12(μ+1)12≤C e−(ν+1)βt 2(ν+1)(1−θ) (ν+4)−12 ∑μ=ν+3+∞e−(μ+1)((1−θ)log⁡2−βt) (μ+1)12≤C e−(ν+1)βt 2(ν+1)(1−θ) α2((1−θ)log⁡2−βt) e(ν+4)βt 2−(ν+4)(1−θ)≤C 292θ α2((1−32θ)log⁡2)  .\begin{aligned} \sum_{\mu=\nu+3}^{+\infty}|m_{\nu\mu}| & \leq & C\,e^{-(\nu+1)\beta t}\,2^{(\nu+1)(1-\theta)}\, \sum_{\mu=\nu+3}^{+\infty}e^{(\mu+1)\beta t}\,2^{-\mu}\,2^{-(\mu+1)(1-\theta)}\,2^{\mu-\nu}\, \frac{(\mu+1)^{\frac{1}{2}}}{(\mu+1)^{\frac{1}{2}}} \\ & \leq & C\,e^{-(\nu+1)\beta t}\,2^{(\nu+1)(1-\theta)}\,(\nu+4)^{-\frac{1}{2}}\, \sum_{\mu=\nu+3}^{+\infty}e^{-(\mu+1)((1-\theta)\log2-\beta t)}\,(\mu+1)^{\frac{1}{2}} \\ & \leq & C\,e^{-(\nu+1)\beta t}\,2^{(\nu+1)(1-\theta)}\,\alpha_2((1-\theta)\log2-\beta t)\,e^{(\nu+4)\beta t}\,2^{-(\nu+4)(1-\theta)} \\ & \leq & C\,2^{\frac{9}{2}\theta}\,\alpha_2\left(\left(1-\frac{3}{2}\theta\right)\log2\right)\;.\end{aligned}

    Finally, we obtain: ∣∑ν≥0e−2βt(ν+1) 2−2νθ ∫2a2−ν  ℜ([φν(Dx),c]∂xu (∂tuν+∂ta2−ν2a2−νuν)‾)dx∣ ≤≤ C Π(θ) ∑ν=0+∞(ν+1) e−2β(ν+1)t 2−2νθ eν,2−ν(t)  ,\begin{aligned} & & \left|\sum_{\nu\geq0}e^{-2\beta t(\nu+1)}\,2^{-2\nu\theta}\,\int\frac{2}{\sqrt{a_{2^{-\nu}}}}\,\,\Re\left([{\varphi}_{\nu}(D_x),c]\partial_xu\, \overline{\left(\partial_tu_\nu+\frac{\partial_t\sqrt{a_{2^{-\nu}}}}{2\sqrt{a_{2^{-\nu}}}}u_\nu\right)} \right)dx\right|\,\leq \\ & & \qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\leq\,C\,\varPi(\theta)\, \sum_{\nu=0}^{+\infty}(\nu+1)\,e^{-2\beta(\nu+1)t}\,2^{-2\nu\theta}\,e_{\nu,2^{-\nu}}(t)\;,\end{aligned} where the function Π\varPi is the same used in the estimate of the term [φν(Dx),a][{\varphi}_\nu(D_x),a].

    End of the proof of theorem [(N)teor_teorema1]

    Now we can complete the proof of theorem [(N)teor_teorema1].

    First, remembering the definition of total energy given by ([(N)eq_E_tot]), we have that there exists a constant C>0C>0, depending only on θ\theta, such that ∣∑ν=0+∞e−β(ν+1)t 2−2νθ ∫2aε  ℜ((Lu)ν ⋅ (∂tuν+∂taε2aεuν)‾) dx∣ ≤ C (E(t))1/2 ∥Lu∥H−θ−β∗t .\left|\sum_{\nu=0}^{+\infty}e^{-\beta(\nu+1)t}\,2^{-2\nu\theta}\,\int\frac{2}{\sqrt{a_{\varepsilon}}}\,\,\Re \left((Lu)_\nu\,\cdot\,\overline{\left(\partial_tu_\nu+ \frac{\partial_t\sqrt{a_{\varepsilon}}}{2\sqrt{a_{\varepsilon}}}u_\nu\right)}\right)\,dx\right|\,\leq\,C\,(E(t))^{1/2}\,\|Lu\|_{H^{-\theta-\beta^*t}}\,. Therefore, if we set {\widetilde}{\varPi}(\omega,\theta)=\max\{{\widetilde}{M}(\omega,\theta),\varPi(\theta)\}, from relation ([(N)eq_dt_e_nu,eps_II]) and from the estimates proved in the previous subsection, we have that, for suitable constants, depending only on λ0\lambda_0, Λ0\Lambda_0, C0C_0 and on the norms of the coefficients of operator LL in their respective functional spaces, the following inequality holds: \begin{aligned} \frac{d}{dt}E(t) & \leq & \left(C+C'\,{\widetilde}{\varPi}(\omega,\theta)-2\beta\right)\, \sum_{\nu=0}^{+\infty}\,(\nu+1)\,e^{-2\beta(\nu+1)t}\,2^{-2\nu\theta}\,e_{\nu,2^{-\nu}}(t) \\ & + & C''\,(E(t))^{1/2}\,\|Lu\|_{H^{-\theta-\beta^*t}}\,.\end{aligned} Now, let us fix β\beta large enough, such that C+C'\,{\widetilde}{\varPi}(\omega,\theta)-2\beta\leq0: we can always do this, on condition that we take TT small enough. With this choice, we have ddtE(t) ≤ C′′ (E(t))1/2 ∥Lu∥H−θ−β∗t  ;\frac{d}{dt}E(t)\,\leq\,C''\,(E(t))^{1/2}\,\|Lu\|_{H^{-\theta-\beta^*t}}\;; now, the thesis of the theorem follows from Gronwall’s lemma and remark [remark:E(0)-E(t)].

    [99]{} J.-M. Bony, Calcul symbolique et propagation des singularités pour les équations aux dérivées partielles non linéaires, Ann. Sci. École Norm. Sup. (4) 14 (1981), 209-246. F. Colombini, E. De Giorgi, S. Spagnolo, Sur les équations hyperboliques avec des coefficientes qui ne dépendent que du temps, Ann. Sc. Norm. Sup. Pisa Cl. Sci. (4) 6 (1979), 511-559. F. Colombini, D. Del Santo, A note on hyperbolic operators with Log-Zygmund coefficients, J. Math. Sci. Univ. Tokyo 16 (2009), 95-111. F. Colombini, N. Lerner, Hyperbolic operators with non-Lipschitz coefficients, Duke Math. J. 77 (1995), 657-698. L. Hörmander, Linear partial differential operators, Springer-Verlag, Berlin, 1963. G. Métivier, Para-differential calculus and applications to the Cauchy problem for nonlinear systems, Centro di Ricerca Mat. Ennio De Giorgi (CRM) Series, 5, Edizioni della Normale, Pisa, 2008. S. Tarama, Energy estimate for wave equations with coefficients in some Besov type class, Electronic J. of Diff. Equations, 2007, paper no. 85, 12 p. (electronic). F. Treves, Basic linear partial differential equations, Academic Press, New York, 1975. T. Yamazaki, On the L^2({\mathbb}{R}^n) well-posedness of some singular or degenerate partial differential equations of hyperbolic type, Comm. Partial Differential Equations 15 (1990), no.7, 1029-1078.

  2. Assistant

    [sys1] The paper focuses on deriving an energy estimate for a strictly hyperbolic operator with coefficients exhibiting particular regularity conditions. The primary goal is to establish well-posedness for the operator under less stringent continuity assumptions. [end sys1]

    [sys2]

    2.1 Understand the Problem:

    The objective here is to understand the energy estimate for hyperbolic operators when traditional Lipschitz continuity conditions for coefficients are weakened. Specifically, the authors work with conditions like log-Zygmund and log-Lipschitz, aiming to maintain or recover some form of well-posedness in the solution space despite potential losses in derivative regularity.

    Reflection: "I understand that the goal is to extend energy estimates to less restrictive continuity conditions. Could there be foundational principles from harmonic analysis or measure theory that underlie these conditions?"

    Creative Perspective: "Are there broader classes of PDEs where similar continuity relaxations could be applied effectively? Could further generalizations of these conditions reveal unexpected connections with other mathematical fields?"

    2.2 Analyze the Information:

    Analyzing involves considering how these continuity modifications impact traditional energy estimates and whether they necessitate new mathematical tools or adaptations, such as Fourier or dyadic decomposition techniques.

    Reflection: "Have all the effects of changing continuity conditions on energy estimates been thoroughly explored? Are there latent assumptions about the functions involved that require revisiting?"

    Creative Perspective: "Could alternative continuity frameworks, such as Holder's conditions or Sovolev spaces, offer similar improvements for hyperbolic equations?"

    2.3 Generate Hypotheses:

    1. Weakening continuity conditions to log-Zygmund holds without significant loss in solution regularity. (Confidence: 0.7, Creative: 0.5)
    2. Energy estimates can be preserved through microlocal analysis techniques tailored for hyperbolic equations. (Confidence: 0.6, Creative: 0.6)
    3. Log-Zygmund continuity uniquely balances the need for regularity and temporal evolution of solutions. (Confidence: 0.5, Creative: 0.7)
    4. Combining several weaker conditions could compensate for the strictness of Lipschitz in specific scenarios. (Confidence: 0.6, Creative: 0.8)
    5. The Fourier and dyadic decompositions are pivotal and cannot be easily replaced with simpler techniques. (Confidence: 0.8, Creative: 0.3)
    6. Considerations of derivative loss inherently tie to the spatial variable nature in such operators. (Confidence: 0.7, Creative: 0.4)
    7. Lebesgue and Sobolev integrability philosophies might offer new perspectives on continuity conditions. (Confidence: 0.5, Creative: 0.6)
    8. Energy estimates rely on maintaining specific stability in regularity classes despite continuity relaxation. (Confidence: 0.7, Creative: 0.5)
    9. Introducing analogs to Log-Zygmund for other equation topologies could be beneficial. (Confidence: 0.4, Creative: 0.8)
    10. Estimation techniques may create insightful cross-links to problems in geometric PDEs. (Confidence: 0.5, Creative: 0.7)

    Reflection: "Have I thoroughly explored all the underlying assumptions? Which possible mechanisms might explain the adaptation of energy estimates?"

    Creative Perspective: "Are there unconventional mathematical theories that could support or challenge these findings?"

    2.4 Anticipate Future Steps and Obstacles:

    Future Steps: Assess the robustness of energy estimates under real-world scenarios involving unpredictable perturbations.

    Obstacles: Overcoming limitations of computational resources to simulate complex scenario evaluations.

    Reflection: "What kinds of real-life scenarios might render the current hypotheses invalid? Can additional experimentation adapt our approach if needed?"

    Creative Perspective: "Are there novel computational or theoretical tools that could be leveraged to examine these conditions more fully?"

    2.5 Evaluate Hypotheses:

    Evaluation involves gauging how well each hypothesis aligns with the objective of minimizing derivative loss while maintaining accuracy.

    Evaluation: Hypotheses should be refined after assessing them through available theorems and data.

    Reflection: "Am I showing bias in leaning more toward theoretically appealing hypotheses? Should empirical findings recalibrate my estimation accuracy?"

    Creative Perspective: "Do the current methods miss hidden intricacies or potential synergies that could render one hypothesis more valid than others?"

    2.6 Select the Best Hypothesis:

    Select hypothesis that suggests combining multiple weaker continuity conditions to preserve solution regularity.

    Reflection: "This hypothesis stands out due to its adaptability and capacity to balance within condition constraints. It represents a strategic compromise."

    Creative Perspective: "There may be opportunities to further expand, perhaps introducing a hierarchy of condition adaptations to fit diverse equation sets."

    2.7 Implement the Hypothesis:

    Implementing involves simulating scenarios where various continuity conditions are applied and observing the impact on energy estimates and derivatives.

    Reflection: "Is the current implementation feasible given resource constraints? What additional setup is needed to ensure accuracy?"

    Creative Perspective: "Could certain unexpected benefits arise from tweaking simulation parameters? How might different scenarios illuminate underlying conditions?"

    2.8 Monitor and Review Progress:

    Monitoring focuses on regular assessment of implementation progress, validation against expected outcomes, and noting anomalies or trends.

    Reflection: "Which practical success indicators should be prioritized? Where can methodology be refined?"

    Creative Perspective: "Are there suggestions from initial outcomes that warrant revisiting hypothesized conditions for unexplored connections?"

    2.9 Reflect and Capture Insights:

    The reflection stage distills key lessons learned on the effectiveness of adapted continuity conditions and paves the way for future exploration.

    Reflection: "Have I distilled the most critical insights for forthcoming research? What systemic understandings have evolved from this task?"

    Creative Perspective: "What innovative mathematical patterns appear that could stretch beyond hyperbolic equations and influence broader PDE research?"

    [end sys2]

    [sys1] The paper's methods and conditions could inspire new techniques in analyzing energies of PDEs in different contexts. The proposed estimates demonstrate adaptability in less rigid mathematical landscapes. [end sys1]