Skip to content
The Chat Archive
gpt-4o-2024-08-06· OpenAI WildChat-4.8M (AI2)

Give me original and cohesive commentary on this using a critical straitforward informal…

  1. User

    Give me original and cohesive commentary on this using a critical straitforward informal tone: Ive's Supernova love wasn't good. More and more, we find modern pop songs that sound like AI. It’s an uncanny valley type sheen — vocals smoothed to the point they feel drained of humanity, melodies that sound like echoes of other songs we’ve heard before.

    In this case, Supernova Love‘s opening strings may sound familiar because they’re an interpolation of piano instrumental of a song released 14 years ago refashioned as a glistening dance track. Even though this well-known melody becomes the driving force behind the song, Love somehow finds a way to accommodate nine (!) other writers/producers.

    The instrumental is lovely, and i like the softer dreamy approach to the vocals, but it also feels like the girls are singing from the next room over or something they sound so ?distant? I like the chorus too, but it feels a bit low energy, and i think having layered vocals instead of a more chanty sound would really make it pop for my personal taste.

    The music video shortens the song by about a minute, but even in its extended iteration Supernova Love doesn’t take advantage of the best aspects of dance music. Rather than ebb and flow and build to glorious peaks, it simply bops along with limited ideas. The celestial production is quite satisfying as an idea, but IVE’s individual quirks get lost in the mix. Rather than sounding elusive or mysterious, they simply come across as bored and copy/pasted onto the beat. A gutsier performance during the verses would have countered the layered chorus and resulted in a more engaging set of textures. This is a definite improvement over All Night, yet succumbs to many of the same issues. IVE have too much star power to sound this flat and AI’ed.

  2. Assistant

    "Supernova Love" by IVE unfortunately seems to fall into the growing category of pop songs that feel artificially engineered, lacking the human touch that makes music truly resonate. The production on this track is reminiscent of an AI-driven composition where vocals are polished to the point of being devoid of emotional depth. This sheen, while technically flawless, creates an emotional disconnect, leaving listeners with a sense of something eerily familiar yet unsatisfying.

    The track opens with strings that might tug at your memory because they're actually an interpolation of a well-known piano melody from 14 years ago. While this could provide a nostalgic hook, it's instead repurposed into a dance track that doesn't fully capitalize on its origins. Despite having a whopping nine writers and producers, "Supernova Love" ends up feeling like a diluted effort.

    There's an undeniable beauty to the instrumental, and the softer, dreamy vocals could have been a strong choice. However, the execution makes the girls sound like they’re singing from the other side of a wall—distant and detached. The chorus, although catchy, lacks energy and could have benefited from a bolder, more layered vocal arrangement rather than its current chant-like form.

    The music video trims the song by about a minute, yet even in its extended version, the track doesn't quite harness dance music's potential peaks and valleys. It plods along with limited imagination, missing the dynamic build and release that characterizes great dance tracks. The celestial production conceptually fits, but the group's unique personalities and quirks are muted, making them seem more like background pieces rather than the stars they are.

    Overall, "Supernova Love" does mark an improvement over "All Night" but suffers from similar issues: a polished but lifeless production that smothers IVE's inherent charisma. With their level of talent and star power, IVE deserves songs that don't make them sound like they're being synthesized by a computer. They need music that amplifies their presence, not diminishes it.