Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
o1-mini-2024-09-12· OpenAIAi2 WildChat-4.8M (AI2)

Grade my essay based on these criteria: 1. Core Values (aka Information) a. Can you name…

  1. User

    Grade my essay based on these criteria:

    1. Core Values (aka Information) a. Can you name at least 4-5 of the author’s core values? b. Do you detect a variety of values, or do the values repeat? Examples of NOT varied values: hard work, determination, perseverance Examples of more varied values: autonomy, resourcefulness, healthy boundaries, diversity 2. Vulnerability a. Does the essay sound like it’s mostly analytical or like it’s coming from a deeper, more vulnerable place? Another way of asking this: Does it sound like the author wrote it using mostly his or her head (intellect) or his or her heart and gut? b. After reading the essay, do you know more about the author AND feel closer to him or her? 3. “So what” moments (aka Important & interesting connections) a. Can you identify at least 3-5 “so what” moments of insight in the essay? b. Are these moments kind of predictable, or are they truly illuminating? 4. Craft a. Do the ideas in the essay connect in a way that is logical, but not too obvious (aka boring)? b. Can you tell that the essay represents a series of carefully considered choices and that the author spent a lot of time revising the essay over the course of several drafts? c. Is it interesting and succinct throughout? If not, where do you lose interest? Where could words be cut or which part isn’t revealing as much as it could be? UC Prompt# 6. Think about an academic subject that inspires you. Describe how you have furthered this interest inside and/or outside of the classroom.

    From the moment I first folded a paper airplane at the age of five, my fascination with flight was ignited. This curiosity persisted, and in my sophomore year of high school, I discovered a similar interest in chemistry, sparked by the interesting and inspiring chemistry teacher Mr. Foster. His engaging demonstrations—like dissolving chicken with sulfuric acid and piranha solution and using gas laws to get an egg inside a beaker—transformed seemingly abstract concepts in chemistry into memorable experiences which helped me get a handle on chemistry and solidified my passion for understanding and navigating the intricacies and the complex world of chemical reactions, marking the next step in my journey as AP Chemistry.

    Although the AP Chemistry class at my school did not meet my expectations, leading me to self-study, I scored a 4 on the AP exam, demonstrating my dedication to the subject matter. Outside the classroom, I expanded my understanding of chemistry through online demonstrations, such as those by professional chemists like NileRed.

    My love for airplanes evolved from origami to exploring flight physics, started by Scott H. Young’s “MIT Challenge.” His concepts of self-learning and books like “Ultralearning” empowered me to independently pursue knowledge in the field of engineering and drove me to acquire engineering skills, such as CAD design, culminating in a collaborative project with 2 of my friends to build a modified tricycle go-kart. Through building this somewhat whimsical project I overcame obstacles in sourcing parts and adapting a pre-built frame which honed my problem-solving abilities and teamwork skills.

    This intersection of chemistry and engineering(which I stumbled upon by chance) is vital to my aspirations in aerospace engineering as chemistry enhances my understanding of materials science and reactions essential for aircraft design, enabling me to address challenges like sustainable and safe aviation technologies.

    At the University of California, I aim to leverage my interdisciplinary interests by joining innovative clubs, engaging in research, and pursuing internships that will allow me to deepen my knowledge, collaborate with peers, and make a meaningful impact in the aerospace field. Through my contributions, I hope to drive both personal growth and advancements within the university community and the aerospace engineering field.

  2. Assistant

    Certainly! Here's a detailed evaluation of your essay based on the provided criteria:


    1. Core Values (Information)

    a. Identification of Core Values: You effectively showcase several of your core values throughout the essay. Here are at least five identified:

    1. Curiosity: Demonstrated by your early interest in flight and continued fascination with chemistry and engineering.
    2. Dedication: Evident from self-studying AP Chemistry and scoring a 4 on the exam despite classroom challenges.
    3. Self-Learning/Autonomy: Highlighted through your independent study methods inspired by "MIT Challenge" and "Ultralearning."
    4. Problem-Solving: Shown in overcoming obstacles during the tricycle go-kart project.
    5. Collaboration/Teamwork: Illustrated by working with friends on the engineering project.

    b. Variety of Values: Your essay presents a diverse range of values. While there is some overlap between dedication, self-learning, and problem-solving, each is explored in different contexts (academics, projects, and personal growth), preventing repetition and showcasing a multifaceted character.

    Grade: 5/5


    2. Vulnerability

    a. Analytical vs. Emotional Tone: The essay maintains a balanced tone, incorporating both analytical descriptions of your academic pursuits and personal reflections. The discussion about struggling with AP Chemistry and choosing to self-study reveals vulnerability, showing your resilience and personal growth.

    b. Connection with the Reader: By sharing personal experiences, such as your first paper airplane and the challenges in your engineering project, you provide insights into your motivations and character. This transparency helps readers feel more connected and understand your journey on a deeper level.

    Grade: 4.5/5


    3. “So What” Moments (Important & Interesting Connections)

    Identified "So What" Moments:

    1. Linking Early Flight Interest to Aerospace Engineering Aspirations: Shows a long-term passion driving your academic choices.
    2. Impact of Mr. Foster’s Demonstrations: Highlights the importance of inspiring teachers in shaping student interests.
    3. Transition from Origami to Flight Physics and Engineering: Demonstrates growth and application of foundational interests to complex projects.
    4. Interdisciplinary Approach Combining Chemistry and Engineering: Illustrates how diverse interests converge to form a unique academic and career path.
    5. Future Goals at UC: Connects past experiences to future aspirations, emphasizing the desire to contribute to the aerospace field.

    b. Depth and Originality: Most of these moments offer genuine insights into your motivations and learning processes. While the narrative arc from early interest to current aspirations is somewhat common, the specific connections between chemistry, engineering, and aerospace, along with the unique projects you've undertaken, provide originality.

    Grade: 4.5/5


    4. Craft

    a. Logical and Engaging Structure: Your essay flows logically from early interests to present achievements and future goals. The transitions between paragraphs are smooth, maintaining reader engagement without being overly predictable.

    b. Evident Revision and Consideration: The essay exhibits a well-thought-out structure with clear connections between different sections. The inclusion of specific examples (e.g., Mr. Foster’s demonstrations, NileRed’s videos, the tricycle go-kart project) suggests careful consideration and multiple drafts to refine these points.

    c. Interest and Succinctness: Overall, the essay is interesting and maintains the reader's attention. However, there are areas where sentences are lengthy and could be more concise for clarity and impact. For example:

    • "His engaging demonstrations—like dissolving chicken with sulfuric acid and piranha solution and using gas laws to get an egg inside a beaker—transformed seemingly abstract concepts in chemistry into memorable experiences which helped me get a handle on chemistry..."
      This could be streamlined to enhance readability.

    Suggestions for Improvement:

    • Conciseness: Simplify complex sentences to improve clarity.
    • Depth in Certain Areas: While the engineering project is mentioned, providing a bit more detail on what specifically you learned from it could add depth.
    • Emotive Language: Incorporate more emotional reflections to enhance vulnerability further.

    Grade: 4/5


    Overall Evaluation

    Your essay effectively communicates your passion for chemistry and engineering, demonstrating a clear trajectory from early interests to future aspirations in aerospace engineering. You showcase a variety of core values, maintain a balanced tone that merges analytical and personal elements, and provide insightful connections that underline your commitment and unique perspective. With minor improvements in conciseness and deeper emotional reflections, your essay would be even more compelling.

    Final Grade: 4.5/5


    Additional Recommendations

    • Proofreading for Clarity: Ensure all sentences are clear and concise to maintain the reader's engagement.
    • Enhance Emotional Depth: Share more personal reflections or challenges faced to deepen the connection with the reader.
    • Specificity in Future Goals: While you mention joining clubs and engaging in research at UC, specifying particular programs or opportunities that align with your interests could strengthen your conclusion.

    Overall, you have a strong and well-crafted essay that effectively showcases your strengths and passions.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.