I want to optimize the mean of an objective function with the following expression: U =…
- User
I want to optimize the mean of an objective function with the following expression: U = (\sum_{n=1}^N I_n)^3 / (\sum_{n=1}^N C_n)^2. I_n ~ Bernoulli(\beta_n), \beta_n ~ N(H_n \mu_n, \sigma_n^2) (let's ignore that the Gaussian should be clipped between 0 and 1 to be the parameter of a Bernoulli), H_n ~ Bernoulli(h_n), C_n = k_n H_n. If we assume that N is large, can I use the approximation E[U] = \frac{(\sum_{n=1}^N \mu_n h_n)^3}{(\sum_{n=1}^N k_n h_n)^2}? Or can I do something better?
- Assistant
Your proposed approximation for the expectation of the objective function ( U ) is a reasonable first-order estimate, especially when ( N ) is large. Here's a detailed breakdown:
Objective Function
[ U = \frac{\left(\sum_{n=1}^N I_n\right)^3}{\left(\sum_{n=1}^N C_n\right)^2} ]
Given Distributions
- ( I_n \sim \text{Bernoulli}(\beta_n) )
- ( \beta_n \sim \mathcal{N}(H_n \mu_n, \sigma_n^2) ) (clipping between 0 and 1 is ignored)
- ( H_n \sim \text{Bernoulli}(h_n) )
- ( C_n = k_n H_n )
Expectation Approximation
For large ( N ), by the Law of Large Numbers, the sums ( \sum_{n=1}^N I_n ) and ( \sum_{n=1}^N C_n ) can be approximated by their expected values:
-
Expected Value of ( I_n ): [ \mathbb{E}[I_n] = \mathbb{E}[\mathbb{E}[I_n | H_n]] = \mathbb{E}[H_n \mu_n] = h_n \mu_n ]
-
Expected Value of ( C_n ): [ \mathbb{E}[C_n] = \mathbb{E}[k_n H_n] = k_n h_n ]
Thus, the expectation ( \mathbb{E}[U] ) can be approximated as: [ \mathbb{E}[U] \approx \frac{\left(\sum_{n=1}^N h_n \mu_n\right)^3}{\left(\sum_{n=1}^N k_n h_n\right)^2} ]
Improving the Approximation
While the first-order approximation you've proposed is valid under the assumption of large ( N ) and minimal variance relative to the mean, you can enhance this estimate by considering higher-order terms. Here's how:
-
Variance Consideration:
- When ( N ) is large, the variances ( \text{Var}\left(\sum I_n\right) ) and ( \text{Var}\left(\sum C_n\right) ) become relatively small compared to the squared means. However, including these variances can provide a more accurate approximation.
-
Taylor Series Expansion or Delta Method:
- You can use a Taylor series expansion around the expected values ( \mathbb{E}\left[\sum I_n\right] ) and ( \mathbb{E}\left[\sum C_n\right] ).
- The Delta Method can be particularly useful here. It allows you to approximate ( \mathbb{E}\left[\frac{A^3}{B^2}\right] ) where ( A = \sum I_n ) and ( B = \sum C_n ) by considering the first and second moments of ( A ) and ( B ).
-
Higher-Order Corrections:
- Implementing higher-order corrections would involve calculating terms like ( \mathbb{E}[A^3] ) and ( \mathbb{E}[B^2] ), as well as their covariances, which can provide a more precise estimate of ( \mathbb{E}[U] ).
Conclusion
Your approximation: [ \mathbb{E}[U] \approx \frac{\left(\sum_{n=1}^N h_n \mu_n\right)^3}{\left(\sum_{n=1}^N k_n h_n\right)^2} ] is a valid and effective first-order approximation when ( N ) is large. If higher precision is required, especially in scenarios where the variance of the sums cannot be neglected, you can enhance the approximation using higher-order methods like the Taylor series expansion or the Delta Method.
Final Recommendation: Use your proposed approximation for simplicity and computational efficiency when ( N ) is large. If more accuracy is needed, especially for smaller ( N ) or higher variability, consider incorporating higher-order correction terms.
Yes; for large N, the expected value of U is well approximated by (Σμₙhₙ)³ divided by (Σkₙhₙ)². While higher-order corrections are possible, using E[U] ≈ (∑μₙhₙ)^3 ⁄ (∑kₙhₙ)^2 is a valid and effective approximation in this setting.