Give me original and cohesive commentary on this using a critical straitforward informal…
- User
Give me original and cohesive commentary on this using a critical straitforward informal tone: Pre-release tracks aren’t necessarily meant to become the biggest hit of an artist’s career, but aespa’s Supernova surprised everyone by lodging itself at the top of the charts for the better part of the year. Karina’s recent solo track Up seems to be doing the same, adding to aespa’s red hot ascent. Now, the full group has returned to wrap up their incredible 2024 with new single "Whiplash". Which is a pretty good way to end a successful year and also serves as "Supernova"’s nice little successor.
Æspa find their sweet spot in propulsive electro pop, first utilized in 2021’s excellent Next Level. Whiplash goes full bore in this direction, offering a strutting dance beat that’s more engaging than the song itself. I love how consistently upbeat this instrumental is. Its pulse never relents, growing bigger and bolder as the track goes on. It’s not the most unusual or idiosyncratic production I’ve ever heard, but in a climate of subdued, easy-listening girl group pop I’m pleased to hear some energy. Some people are saying its reminds them of brat (off topic but some of you clearly don't know what "brat sound" actually is but thats a convo for another time) but I personally think it's more reminiscent of the early 2010s futuristic sounds/music (think Black Eye Peas "Boom Boom Pow" but in a good way) & it feels sorta different from what they've done before. It's giving me "90s fashion show runway music" if that makes sense.
When it comes to Whiplash‘s hooks, I’m of two minds. On one hand, this style of song suits a repetitive spoken-word centerpiece, but we also know how incredible aespa are when they’re belting out melody. If we were to completely remove Whipash‘s production, I’m not sure there’d me much of a song left — just four girls awkwardly muttering “whiplash” over and over. Because of this, I appreciate the moments where the track makes room for dynamic melody. The build toward its second chorus is especially effective and should have provided a guide for the entire song. Overall, this is a solid continuation of Supernova‘s musical success but not the knockout it could have been.
- Assistant
Alright, so aespa is on a roll this year, riding high on the unexpected success of "Supernova" and Karina's hit solo track. Now, they're back with "Whiplash," which is aiming to capitalize on their success. The song is an energetic dive back into the electro-pop realm they nailed with 2021's "Next Level."
"Whiplash" really rides on its vigorous dance beat. The production is lively and pumps energy from start to finish, even if it's not groundbreaking. It’s refreshing, especially when so many girl group tracks are leaning towards a more relaxed sound. Some folks say it has a "brat" vibe, but to me, it’s more like we're revisiting the futuristic feels of early 2010s hits, channeling something like Black Eyed Peas' "Boom Boom Pow," but in a good way. It also has that "90s fashion show runway music" vibe, which is both nostalgic and fresh.
Now, about the song’s hooks: I'm a bit conflicted. The repetitive, spoken-word style suits the song's vibe, but it also feels like a missed opportunity to really showcase aespa’s vocal talent. Without the punchy production, "Whiplash" doesn’t have much meat on its bones—just a repetitive chant of “whiplash.” Fortunately, the track has some dynamic moments, especially building up to the second chorus, but that needed to be the blueprint for the whole song.
In the end, "Whiplash" is a strong follow-up to "Supernova," maintaining aespa’s momentum. However, it misses being a total knockout due to its reliance on production over melody. It's like having a powerful car engine revving without going full throttle. Still, it’s a solid addition to aespa’s discography as they continue their rapid ascent.
- User
Give me original and cohesive commentary on this using a critical straitforward informal tone and try keep a similar length but make sure it's original: I really loved the MV. It's very stylish, a good use of a big budget with a plot and visual styling that we haven’t seen before. And it fits perfectly with the song. I’ve seen a recent discourse of people complaining abt how “boring” and much of a downgrade whiplash’s MV was compared to their recent TTs. You can say it’s “underwhelming”but in no way does it need a grandeur MV like Armageddon. Are we hearing the same songs? In what world does Whiplash need a techno-primordial alien battlefield themed MV. The “nothingness” and “blank” high fashion aesthetic "whiplash" had was absolutely fire and fit well with the hyperpop and ballroom influence Whiplash was going for. I appreciate how much they creatively used just a white background for pretty much the entire MV and I personally think it suits the song very well.
- Assistant
Okay, let's talk about aespa's "Whiplash" music video. Honestly, I think it’s pretty darn stylish. They clearly poured a decent budget into it, but instead of going all out with some over-the-top storyline or flashy fireworks, they went for something fresh and visually unique. And for me, it hits the nail on the head.
I've noticed some folks online grumbling that the "Whiplash" MV feels like a step down compared to aespa’s previous tracks. Sure, you might call it "underwhelming," but it doesn’t need to be some epic spectacle like "Armageddon." Let's be real, the song itself doesn’t scream for a massive production filled with alien landscapes. Are we even listening to the same track? It's got more of a hyperpop and ballroom vibe, and the minimalist, high-fashion aesthetic they chose was slick and on-point.
I actually dig how they used something as straightforward as a white background for most of the video. It shows off the members and their styling, complementing the song's vibe really well. Sometimes simplicity can be a statement in itself, and in this case, it totally works. For me, the stripped-back visuals of "Whiplash" fit seamlessly with the track's energy and style. It's a creative choice that might not be everyone's cup of tea, but it sure stands out in its own right.