Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
o1-mini-2024-09-12· OpenAIAi2 WildChat-4.8M (AI2)

In the matrix multiplication \( Ax = s \), where \( A \) is a \( 128000 \times 1024 \)…

  1. User

    In the matrix multiplication ( Ax = s ), where ( A ) is a ( 128000 \times 1024 ) matrix, ( x ) is a one-dimensional vector, and ( s ) is a ( 128000 \times 1 ) vector, is there a way to modify ( A ) without affecting the distribution of ( s ), while still being able to detect this through ( s ) and ( A )?

  2. Assistant

    Yes, it is possible to modify the matrix ( A ) in such a way that the distribution of ( s = Ax ) remains unchanged, while still allowing you to detect the modification. The key lies in applying transformations to ( A ) that preserve the statistical properties of ( s ).

    Using Orthogonal Transformations

    One effective method is to multiply ( A ) by an orthogonal matrix ( U ) from the right. Specifically, you can define a modified matrix ( A' ) as:

    [ A' = A U ]

    where ( U ) is a ( 1024 \times 1024 ) orthogonal matrix (i.e., ( U U^\top = I ), where ( I ) is the identity matrix).

    Why This Works:

    1. Preservation of Distribution:

      • Assumption on ( x ): If ( x ) is a random vector with certain properties (e.g., zero mean and covariance ( \Sigma_x = I )), then the distribution of ( s = Ax ) is determined by ( A ).
      • Effect of ( U ): Multiplying ( A ) by an orthogonal matrix ( U ) preserves the covariance of ( s ) because: [ \text{Cov}(s) = A A^\top \quad \text{and} \quad \text{Cov}(A' x) = A' A'^\top = A U U^\top A^\top = A A^\top ] Thus, the statistical distribution of ( s ) remains unchanged.
    2. Detection of Modification:

      • Known ( A ) and ( A' ): Since ( U ) is orthogonal, you can detect the modification by comparing the original ( A ) with the modified ( A' ). Specifically, you can compute: [ U = A^\dagger A' ] where ( A^\dagger ) is the pseudo-inverse of ( A ). Given that ( A ) is ( 128000 \times 1024 ) and likely full rank, ( U ) can be accurately determined.
      • Unique Transformation: The orthogonal matrix ( U ) is unique (up to certain symmetries) given ( A ) and ( A' ), allowing you to identify the specific modification applied.

    Generalization

    While orthogonal transformations are a straightforward method, other transformations that preserve ( A A^\top ) could also be used, provided they allow for the detection of the modification. The essential idea is to ensure that the transformation does not alter the statistical properties of ( s ) while embedding a detectable signature within ( A ).

    Conclusion

    By applying an orthogonal transformation to ( A ), you maintain the distribution of ( s = Ax ) while embedding a modification that can be detected by analyzing the relationship between ( A ) and ( A' ). This approach is both mathematically sound and practical for scenarios where such modifications and detections are required.

    Summary: Yes; for example, post-multiplying A by an orthogonal matrix changes A without altering the distribution of s = Ax. Such modifications leave s’s distribution unchanged yet can be detected by comparing A and the modified A.