Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
o1-preview-2024-09-12· OpenAIAi2 WildChat-4.8M (AI2)

Very rigorously but in a clear manner, define the number 0^# (zero sharp)

  1. User

    Very rigorously but in a clear manner, define the number 0^# (zero sharp)

  2. Assistant

    Definition of 0# (Zero Sharp):

    Let’s begin by setting up the necessary background.

    1. The Constructible Universe ( L ):

    • Definition of ( L ): The constructible universe ( L ) is built in stages ( L_\alpha ) indexed by ordinals ( \alpha ). It is defined recursively as follows:

      • ( L_0 = \emptyset )
      • For each successor ordinal ( \alpha + 1 ), ( L_{\alpha + 1} = \operatorname{Def}(L_\alpha) ), the set of all subsets of ( L_\alpha ) that are definable over ( L_\alpha ) using formulas in the language of set theory with parameters from ( L_\alpha ).
      • For limit ordinals ( \lambda ), ( L_\lambda = \bigcup_{\alpha < \lambda} L_\alpha ).
    • Properties of ( L ): The universe ( L = \bigcup_{\alpha \in \operatorname{On}} L_\alpha ) (where ( \operatorname{On} ) denotes the class of all ordinals) contains sets that are "constructible" in a precise sense from earlier stages.

    2. Indiscernibles for ( L ):

    • Definition of Indiscernibles: A sequence of ordinals ( \langle \kappa_n : n \in \omega \rangle ) is said to be a sequence of indiscernibles for ( L ) if, for any natural number ( k ), any formula ( \varphi(x_1, \ldots, x_k) ) in the language of set theory, and any increasing sequences of indices ( i_1 < i_2 < \cdots < i_k ) and ( j_1 < j_2 < \cdots < j_k ) from ( \omega ), the following holds:

      [ (L, \in) \vDash \varphi(\kappa_{i_1}, \ldots, \kappa_{i_k}) \iff \varphi(\kappa_{j_1}, \ldots, \kappa_{j_k}) ]

      This means that the truth of ( \varphi ) in ( L ) does not depend on which indiscernibles are substituted as parameters, only on the form of ( \varphi ).

    3. The Language ( \mathcal{L}_{\text{Set}}({\kappa_n}) ):

    • Expansion of Language: To formalize statements involving the indiscernibles, we use an expanded language ( \mathcal{L}_{\text{Set}}({\kappa_n}) ) which is the language of set theory augmented with constant symbols ( {\kappa_n : n \in \omega} ) corresponding to the indiscernibles.

    4. Gödel Numbers:

    • Gödel Numbering: There exists a method (Gödel numbering) to assign a unique natural number ( \ulcorner \varphi \urcorner ) to each formula ( \varphi ) in ( \mathcal{L}_{\text{Set}}({\kappa_n}) ). This allows us to code formulas and sentences as elements of ( \omega ).

    5. Definition of Zero Sharp ( 0^# ):

    • Zero Sharp ( 0^# ): The set ( 0^# ), called zero sharp, is defined as the set of Gödel numbers of all sentences in ( \mathcal{L}_{\text{Set}}({\kappa_n}) ) that are true in ( L ) when the constants ( {\kappa_n} ) are interpreted as a sequence of indiscernibles for ( L ).

    Formally, let ( \operatorname{Th}(L, \in, \kappa_n) ) denote the set of all sentences ( \varphi ) in ( \mathcal{L}_{\text{Set}}({\kappa_n}) ) such that

    [ (L, \in, \kappa_n) \vDash \varphi, ]

    where ( \langle \kappa_n : n \in \omega \rangle ) is any sequence of indiscernibles for ( L ).

    Then,

    [ 0^# = { \ulcorner \varphi \urcorner \in \omega : \varphi \in \operatorname{Th}(L, \in, \kappa_n) }. ]

    6. Notes on This Definition:

    • Uniqueness and Independence: The set ( 0^# ) is well-defined because the truth values of sentences in ( L ) with indiscernibles do not depend on the specific choice of the indiscernible sequence (due to their indistinguishability within ( L )). Thus, ( 0^# ) is uniquely determined if such indiscernibles exist.

    • Existence of Indiscernibles: The existence of such a sequence of indiscernibles for ( L ) is not provable within ( \text{ZFC} ) (Zermelo-Fraenkel set theory with the Axiom of Choice) but can be consistent with it. If ( 0^# ) exists, it implies that ( L ) is not the same as the universe ( V ), leading to significant consequences in set theory.

    • Set of Natural Numbers (a Real Number): Since ( 0^# ) is a subset of ( \omega ), it can be thought of as a real number in the context of set theory and descriptive set theory.

    Summary:

    Zero sharp ( 0^# ) is the set of Gödel numbers of all sentences in the language of set theory (expanded with constants for indiscernibles) that are true in the constructible universe ( L ) when the constants are interpreted as a sequence of indiscernible ordinals for ( L ). Formally,

    [ 0^# = { \ulcorner \varphi \urcorner \in \omega : (L, \in, \kappa_n) \vDash \varphi } ]

    for any sequence ( \langle \kappa_n : n \in \omega \rangle ) of indiscernibles for ( L ).

    Answer:

    Answer:

    Zero sharp, denoted 0#, is the set of Gödel numbers of all sentences in the language of set theory expanded by adding constant symbols for an infinite sequence of indiscernible ordinals, such that these sentences are true in the constructible universe L when the constants are interpreted as a sequence of indiscernibles for L. Formally:

     0# is the set of all natural numbers n such that there exists a sequence of ordinals (κₙ) that are indiscernibles for L, and n is the Gödel number of a sentence φ(with constants κₖ₁,...,κₖₘ) true in L with these indiscernibles—that is,

      0# = { n ∈ ℕ | (L, ∈, (κₙ)) ⊧ φ, and n is the Gödel number of φ },

    where (κₙ) is any sequence of ordinals indiscernible over L, and φ ranges over sentences in the expanded language with constants for these indiscernibles.