Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
o1-preview-2024-09-12· OpenAIAi2 WildChat-4.8M (AI2)

Does every simple closed curve in the plane contain four points that form the vertices…

  1. User

    Does every simple closed curve in the plane contain four points that form the vertices of a square? do the math

  2. Assistant

    The question you're asking is famously known as the Inscribed Square Problem or the Square Peg Problem. It asks whether every simple closed curve in the plane (a loop that doesn't cross itself) contains four points that are the vertices of a square.

    As of my knowledge cutoff in October 2023, this problem remains unsolved in full generality. It was first posed by mathematician Otto Toeplitz in 1911 and has intrigued mathematicians for over a century.

    However, there have been significant partial results:

    1. Smooth Curves: For curves that are sufficiently smooth (having continuous derivatives), the answer is known to be yes—they do contain an inscribed square.

    2. Convex Curves: If the curve is convex, it always contains an inscribed square. This was proven using methods from convex geometry.

    3. Polygons: For polygons, the problem reduces to finding a square whose vertices lie among the polygon's vertices, which is not always possible. However, if we allow the square to touch the sides (not just vertices), certain results apply.

    4. Locally Monotone Curves: Curves that are locally monotone (they don't wiggle back and forth too wildly) have been shown to contain an inscribed square.

    Despite these advances, there exist simple closed curves (even ones that are nowhere differentiable) for which it's still unknown whether a square can be inscribed. The general case for all simple closed curves remains an open problem in mathematics.

    So, to directly answer your question:

    No, it is not yet proven that every simple closed curve in the plane contains four points that form the vertices of a square. The problem remains open and is an active area of research in mathematics.

    Answer: As of now, it’s not known—the question remains unsolved for all curves, so the answer is still open.