my client is a cooperative bank in kerala, india. my bank entered into a registered rent…
- User
my client is a cooperative bank in kerala, india. my bank entered into a registered rent agreement in the year in the year of 2015 for 10 years and took the building of a person named x for rent. it will end only in 2025. now the bank needed to change the location of their branch due to some unforeseen difficulties the bank want to terminate the agreement in the 9th year and send a notice informing that the bank to vacate the premise and to end the agreement and asked to return the security amount and cooperate to mutually terminate the agreement. but x issued a lawyer reply notice stating that the bank should pay rent until another person take that building for rent. they are saying they took a loan depending on this rent and as there was no early termination clause bank cannot terminate the agreement and if bank terminate the agreement bank should pay rent until a new tenant is come. they also claimed for arrears in rent. they also informed that it is bank's liability to pay all expenses to terminate the registered rent agreement in the sub register office. bank is ready the arrears of rent from the security amount but not willing to pay the rent for until another person take the building for rent. draft a legal reply notice in this matter like a lawyer who is expert in civil litigation in indian legal scenario.
- Assistant
[Your Name]
[Your Address]
[City, State, ZIP Code]
[Email Address]
[Phone Number][Date]
[Name of Opposing Party's Lawyer]
[Law Firm Name]
[Address]
[City, State, ZIP Code]Subject: Legal Response to Notice Regarding Tenancy Termination
Dear [Name of Opposing Party's Lawyer],
I am writing to you as the legal representative of [Cooperative Bank Name], located in Kerala, in response to the legal notice dated [Date of Notice] regarding the termination of the registered rent agreement dated [Date of Agreement] with your client, Mr. X.
Understanding of the Situation:
-
Tenancy Details: The cooperative bank entered into a registered rent agreement with your client for a term of ten (10) years commencing from [Start Date of Agreement]. Due to unforeseen circumstances, our client wishes to terminate this agreement prior to its expiry in 2025.
-
Communication of Intent: On [Date of Bank's Notice], our client communicated its intention to vacate the premises and mutually dissolve the agreement. Our client requested the return of the security deposit, adjusted for any rent arrears, and desired an amicable solution.
-
Response Received: Your response dated [Date of Your Notice] outlined several demands, including that our client should pay rent until a new tenant takes occupancy, asserting reliance on rental income for a loan, and the need for our client to bear expenses related to terminating the agreement at the sub-registrar's office.
Legal Position:
-
Absence of Early Termination Clause: It is acknowledged that the agreement does not contain an explicit early termination clause; however, unfortunate circumstances necessitate such an action, such as unforeseen exigencies affecting the bank’s operation.
-
Mitigation of Damages: Indian contract law principles, particularly under Section 73 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872, require parties to mitigate losses. It is incumbent upon your client to make reasonable efforts to re-let the premises in order to reduce potential losses.
-
Equitable Adjustment: While our client is prepared to adjust any rent arrears against the security deposit, we do not find an obligation under the agreement or prevailing law requiring continued rental payments until a new tenant is found.
-
Costs Incurred at Sub-Registrar’s Office: An equitable resolution to the termination should not impose unilateral financial burdens related to formal termination formalities on the bank, particularly in the absence of specific clauses in the agreement.
Proposal for Resolution:
-
Adjustment Against Security Deposit: Our client offers to settle any outstanding rent arrears against the security deposit. The balance, if any, should be returned to our client promptly.
-
Non-Continuation of Rent Payments: Our client will vacate the premises respectfully and undertake no further rent payment beyond the vacate date as appropriate mitigation steps are expected to be taken by your client.
-
Negotiation for Formal Exit: We propose engaging in discussions to consider fair distribution of the administrative costs associated with formal agreement termination to facilitate an uncontentious exit.
Our client remains committed to reaching an amicable solution that is fair and just for both parties. We invite your client's cooperation to discuss the most feasible path forward.
Should you require further discussion or clarification, please contact me directly at [Your Phone Number] or [Your Email Address].
Thank you for your consideration.
Sincerely,
[Your Name]
[Your Law Firm's Name]
[Your Position]
[Contact Information] -