The Writing Process WEEK 1 - DAY 2: ENGL1014 COLLEGE ENGLISH I Faculty of…
- User
Assistant:
The Writing Process WEEK 1 - DAY 2: ENGL1014 COLLEGE ENGLISH I Faculty of Education and Arts University of Belize
OBJECTIVES •Attendance Check •Group Meeting •The Writer's Voice •The Rhetorical Situation •The Writing Process •In-Class Activity
REMINDERS •Narrative Essay Presentations begin on Monday, August 19th, 2024 •There will be no class on Wednesday, August 21st, 2024.
GROUP MEETINGS
Considerations before putting pen to paper...
The Writer’s Voice
Does the word “hence” look naked to you? Are you compelled to add a redundant “the reason why” afterward? When you say the word synchronous aloud, do you add a fourth syllable? Congratulations, your English reflects your Belizean heart and soul. But how about your college essays? Is your submitted work so genetic and devoid of local relevance? Does it begin with the dreaded “this essay will delve...”? In that case, you may be letting the robots steal your voice.
It used to be easier, in retrospect, to teach College English 1. Students had their own thoughts, which were sometimes widely scattered or even self-contradictory. The facilitators helped students research topics, organize and synchronize their ideas, and support their opinions. But now, some students have decided to let online applications do all the thinking and writing for them. The resulting submissions, admittedly, are written in more standard English, but they are soulless, boring, and ultimately meaningless. I am heartened to see mistakes like “hence the reason why” because these indicate that I am reading the words of a living being.
Since AI writing applications mimic the patterns and phrases most used by human writers, an AI essay is instantly recognizable to instructors because it is ridden with cliches and generalizations. It utilizes the words and phrases used most often online, never making an original point. AI writing lacks a unique Belizean perspective, fresh ideas, logic, and insight. If it does cite sources, these may not, on examination, actually support the point. AI -generated research papers, even those with credible citations, fall apart when the sources are examined.
Please share your own thoughts and opinions in your own voice, even if these are expressed in nonstandard English. Blend your ideas with the source material, creating a paper that expresses your unique stance. It is more important for you to develop your own voice than for you to perfect your English, although you should work towards both of these goals. If you do not write in your own voice, reflecting your unique life experience and intelligence, this course is a waste of our time, and yours. After all, there are apps that will mark the papers for us so we don’t have to spend hours laboriously reading and evaluating your work. But we won’t use them. We promise to give you our human response to your words. In return, please give us human words.
Read the following essay introduction. Was it written by a human being enrolled in College English 1 or is it AI generated?
In a world increasingly dominated by pharmaceuticals, the value of herbal remedies is often overlooked. Belize, with its rich biodiversity and long-standing tradition of herbal medicine, presents a unique opportunity to embrace these natural healing methods. This essay argues that Belizeans should prioritize herbal remedies over synthetic pharmaceuticals due to their cultural significance, cost-effectiveness, environmental sustainability, and holistic health benefits.
Read this introduction: Human or robot? What are the clues?
“As a Maya woman, the world around me has always revolved around nature and its energies, which are the pillars to sustain Mother Earth” (Saqui, 2022). Aurora Saqui, of southern Belize, writes of a way of life deeply connected to traditions. From the misty forests to the lively coastal towns, the remedies these healers offer are a part of Belize's heart and soul. In a world that is all about new things, it may be that the old ways keep people healthiest. Bush doctors, curanderas, and other traditional herbalists play a vital role in providing remedies that have been passed down through generations, blending herbal medicine, spiritual rituals, and community wisdom to address a wide range of health concerns. Garifuna and Maya communities hold profound Indigenous knowledge of medicinal plants and healing methods. The Creole and Mestizo populations embrace traditional healing practices rooted in African and Central American influences. These and other cultural groups collectively contribute to healing in Belize, embodying the interconnectedness between culture, nature, and health. Although there are potential challenges and controversies, embracing traditional healers and their remedies within the Belizean healthcare system is not only culturally significant as well as effective in holistic healthcare, but also crucial for preserving invaluable indigenous knowledge.
The Writing Process
The Writing Process
The Writing Process is Recursive and not Linear
13 2. Writing is Genre Specific KNOW What a Genre Is Genres are ways of writing and speaking that help people communicate and work together in specific situations. Genres offer relatively stable patterns for writing, but more importantly they reflect how humans act, react, and interact in everyday situations. Genres are meeting places—and meaning places. LEARN “Genre Know-How” Genre know-how is the ability to use genres to analyze and interpret what is happening around you. When you have genre know-how, you can use genres to focus your creativity, generate new ideas, and present those ideas to others KEEP in Mind That Genres Are Flexible Genres are as flexible and changeable as the human activities they represent. They need to be adjusted to suit evolving situations. They can be stretched, blended, and messed around with to fit unique situations.
14 Writing is Genre Specific DEVELOP Your Writing Process A writing process leads you from your basic idea to a finished document, from inventing ideas to final editing. Developing and refining your writing process will save you time and effort in the long run. USE Genres in College and in Your Career A genre-based approach to writing helps you master a “genre set” that will transfer to your advanced college courses and to the workplace.
15 3. Writing is Thinking: From Start to Finish ●Writing is not some mystic art. It’s a practical skill—particularly since most of our communication is text-based to begin with.
●No one’s born with this skill, though. We hear routinely from people who say they’d love to write, but don’t know where to start.
●They feel unfocused and overwhelmed by the task.
●If this is beginning to sound like you, don’t worry because I’m going to walk you through how writing works, and how you can get better at it.
16 I know...Writing Sucks or that is often the Consensus! But it does not have to... ●I am not asking you to produce polished, perfect prose in one sitting.
●Hardly anybody does that anyway. I am asking you to start with thinking.
●That first leap into taking your idea and making it a Thing People Read—isn’t really about wording. It’s about thinking.
17 If you make thinking the first step, you will be doing it on purpose ●You become someone who thinks about why they do what they do, and understands how each decision affects the results.
●And developing this knack for critical thinking will make you better at what you do (in writing and all other situations).
●Metacognition is the fancy word for this. It is consciously thinking about what you are thinking.
18 If you make thinking the first step, it will get messy. •At this early, thinking stage, you’re just putting your ideas down on paper. •Try not to worry about re-reading or editing as yet. You’ll have time to do that later (preferably on a different day altogether). •Just think about what you’re trying to say, and jot the main ideas down. If you’re not sure how to finish a sentence, abandon it halfway through. •If you want to write extensively about one particular idea but your mind’s moving too quickly to flesh it all out, paraphrase for now and move on to the next point.
19 If you make thinking the first step, it will get messy. •Worst-case scenario here is that you’ll end up with a lot of open questions you’d like to answer. “More research needed” is an open door, not a reason to stop writing.
•If you’re anything like me, the end result of this first step is going to look a little like an outline interspersed with rants and probably a few side notes.
•In other words, it’s a rough draft.
20 But guess what, you have started Writing!
21 You cannot possibly share this with your Readers! •Think of the writing process as a journey you want to take your readers on.
•First, you need to provide them with a map for guidance. That is, your thesis.
•The thesis is your main idea. State it as clearly as you can in the early part of your draft. This is what you hope your reader will remember, and it’s what will help you organize and guide the rest of the piece.
•After you’ve written your thesis and gotten your ideas down, it is time to consider structure-organizing your ideas in paragraphs.
22 You need to Support your Readers! •After finishing the rough draft, you revise.
•At this state, you are no longer writing for yourself; you’re now truly writing for an audience-readers.
•You need to now think about your readers.
23 You need to Support your Readers! •Most of your readers may need more explanation that you’ve provided in your early draft, or more convincing. So you provide supporting details to flesh out your early ideas.
•Supporting your main point isn’t something you do just for the hell of it. You do it for your readers—the ones who live outside your own brain and aren’t able to read your mind. THESI S SUPPORTING DETAIL ORGANIZATION / COHERENCE SUPPORTING DETAIL SUPPORTING DETAIL GRAMMAR/ MECHANICS CLARITY
24 So how do you get to the GOOD WRITING: That takes a little more TIME and EFFORT. •At this stage, you’ll have the structure of a solid essay. Most of what remains to be done is line editing to improve word choice and sentence structure.
•You also clarify meaning in meandering phrases, or perhaps reorder paragraphs to keep the ideas running smoothly. This stage is usually more satisfying than the rough draft you wrote at first.
25 So how do you get to the GOOD WRITING: That takes a little more TIME and EFFORT. •Many people have great ideas but hate the process of writing. I get it—even for people who write regularly, it can be a frustrating process. Good writing is hard work.
• If it were easy, everyone would be able to do it and we would not even need classes like this one!
•But the payoff is so, so worth it. Wherever you are on your life or professional path, whether you have years of experience or a fresh outlook to share, writing your ideas gives you a particular ownership of and authority over what you do.
26 So with every NEW assignment, in order to RISE TO the CHALLENGE you will: Think Critically Plan Consistently Draft Generously Craft Purposefully Revise diligently Edit keenly Format Specifically
Writing is not Simply Good Grammar
In-Class Activity
Let’s Write.. In 250-300 words, reflect on your personal writing process, considering the following guiding questions: 1.Starting of Your Writing Process: Where does your writing process typically begin? Is it with brainstorming, research, or perhaps outlining? 2.Environmental Factors: Do you require a specific setting or environment to engage effectively in writing? Consider aspects such as location, noise level, time of day, and other factors that contribute to or hinder your productivity. How do these environmental preferences influence the quality and flow of your writing? 3.Tools and Resources: What tools do you rely on during your writing process? This could include digital tools like word processors, grammar checkers, and research databases, or physical tools such as notebooks, pens, and printed resources. How do these tools support or shape your writing? Are there any particular methods or strategies you use to organize your thoughts and ideas? 4.Ending Your Writing Process: How do you know when your writing process is complete? Is there a particular step or feeling that signifies completion for you? 5.Challenges and Strategies: Reflect on any challenges you face during your writing process. What strategies do you use to overcome these challenges? Consider how you approach tasks like editing, revising, or staying focused. Your reflection should offer insight into how your personal approach to writing impacts your overall work. Be specific about your habits and preferences, and consider how understanding your process can help you improve as a writer.
For Next Session...... ●Narrative Essay Presentations!
El Fin! Questions? Concerns? User: Don't include instructor nor location. Please give me it in the provided format only, no additional text or words. Generate study notes and questions at the end in this format: Chapter: Chapter Title Notes: Some important notes. Questions: - What is this? Options: a.) Option 1, b.) Option 2, c.) Option 3, d.) Option 4
Answer: b.) Option 2 Assistant:
- Assistant
Chapter: The Writing Process
Notes:
- The session focuses on developing a distinct writer's voice and avoiding AI dependency for unique expression.
- Discusses generic AI writing patterns: clichéd and lacking originality.
- Encourages integrating personal experiences and unique cultural perspectives in writing.
- Emphasizes understanding the recursive nature of the writing process and the importance of genre know-how.
- Writing begins with thinking and messy drafting before moving to structured and audience-conscious writing.
- Critical components include developing a thesis, organizing ideas, and line editing.
- Outlines a multi-stage writing process: think critically, plan, draft, revise, and edit.
- Reflects on personal writing habits and environmental factors influencing writing efficiency.
Questions:
-
What is AI writing typically lacking? Options: a.) Standard English, b.) Unique perspectives, c.) Grammatical errors, d.) Length Answer: b.) Unique perspectives
-
What is necessary before starting the actual writing according to the lesson? Options: a.) Immediate essay structure, b.) Deep editing, c.) Critical thinking, d.) Extensive research Answer: c.) Critical thinking
-
How does the document suggest identifying a human-written essay? Options: a.) Lack of grammar, b.) Unique mistakes and perspectives, c.) Absence of citations, d.) Perfect structure Answer: b.) Unique mistakes and perspectives
-
What stage involves considering the audience's needs according to the document? Options: a.) Brainstorming, b.) Rough drafting, c.) Revising, d.) Initial idea generation Answer: c.) Revising
-
What signifies the end of the writing process? Options: a.) Exhaustive research, b.) A satisfying draft, c.) Emotional closure, d.) Reader feedback Answer: b.) A satisfying draft
Other models, same or similar prompt
Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.