The Second Revolution could have never reconstituted the whole of the United States in…
- User
The Second Revolution could have never reconstituted the whole of the United States in one go, especially not in those regions that were still held by [ECUMENICAL AGGRESSOR] at the time of the Orpheum Theatre Declaration, nor was it intended to. The National Radicals (NRs) for their part did not even expect that the bulk of the country would fall in line behind them as quickly as it did, though with hindsight and an understanding of just how thoroughly Operation Killswitch had damaged the other pretender governments it seems inevitable to us now that they would. By 2058, the current federative diarchy of the states of Sunbelt and Heartland had established itself, and with very few exceptions those local governments that did not immediately fold themselves directly into the new NR government had at least on paper acknowledged it as the legitimate successor of the original United States of America.
The “on paper” part is important though. While the NRs were busy adapting to the impracticality of hard one-party rule, giving way to the current “Majority Party” government now known as the “Grand Coalition of the Republic” with all its various cliques, hangers-on, and questionably integrable elements all debating the finer points of the Easternization Program and the scope of the then soon to come American Cultural Revolution, the working groups of the Northeast, Upcountry, and Far West congealed into what were effectively warlord states who, as is often the case in these instances, became far less eager to be fully subservient to the government in Memphis now that they could stand on their own two feet.
The ideology of the NRs in the briefest is that of a Consultative and Democratic Dictatorship, the norm in much of the civilized world. Democratic functions in theory operate along a twin tracked model of an internally democratic Majoritarian Party employing a form of Mass Line. In practice this takes the form of cliques within the Party that represent various interests, both public and intra-party. Within the NR party proper there are eight cliques, and within the “Majority Party” system more broadly there are 13-16 The variation here is whether one counts the interests of the municipal groups as a singular mass or distinct from one another. As there are four total this necessarily changes the number if you count all of them. These cliques are based primarily upon the degree of incorporation with the Party Core, and then from there distinctions in policy.
The Core or Central Clique of the Party are those affiliated with the NR vision of governance without qualifiers and without addons. This vision is one of directing the National Radical “governance revolution” into establishing a party of natural governance, a vanguard of the American people where all democracy occurs within the single party and ultimately fuses with the state and civil society.
The further away from the core the more qualifiers are attached. “Inner Party” cliques such as the Movement for National Reconstruction and the Political Synergy Clique broadly align with the vision of the Total Party-State but with particular carveouts for their own pet institutions such as the military and republic gendarmerie or of maintaining a multiplicity of internal forms of governance between the states. Such forms of unitary patron states or poly-federalism come just short of the Core’s vision.
“Middle Party” Cliques such as the Political Harmony Clique and the New Era Scientific Development Movement advocate for an effective multi-party system within the NRs themselves, with the non-elected functions of the state existing as a kind of commissarial office to ensure that all parties reflect the “diversity of revolutionary orthodoxy” not that any kind of political vision outside the NRs should be allowed to exist. They also, as an aside, are the strata of the Party that most vigorously advocates for annexing the shattered remnants of Canada into the United States.
“Outer Party” Cliques such as the Dynamist Conference of America, Political Engineering Clique, and Movement for American Socialism advocate for the division of the legislative and consultative offices, handing the second over to non-NR parties, effectively establishing the Grand Coalition as a permanent fixture of American politics rather than as a stop-gap measure towards the establishment of the Party-State itself. Inspired by China’s consultative conference in particular, the Outer Party believes that while orthodoxy should be strict within the Party (making them closer to the Core than the Middle Party on this point) that the idea of absorbing all civil society into the Party itself is premature at best. To this end they often adopt a form of constitutionalism, advocating not the return of the old US Constitution (which is still in writing and spirit the supreme document of the land) but of a revised constitution. On this point there is overlap here with the Inner Party who desire constitutionalism to codify their own special interests into law permanently.
Beyond this are what are called the “Unintegrated Interests”, which is to say those groups whose existence and platforms in some way conflict with the Core’s program of a Total Party-State. These would be the twin caucuses of the Communist Party, We Are Sorry for the Inconvenience, and the Prohibition Party.
Closest to the Party Proper would be the Apricot Caucus of the Communist Party. The larger of the two groups, the Apricots desire the reestablishment of the old American two-party system with them playing the second part of course. The Apricots argue that the national revolution represented the final culmination of the more general “bourgeois revolution” that the first United States failed to fully bring into being on the continent and thus is broadly speaking at the very least a “legitimate government” to operate under. Communist Party Orthodoxy states that the culmination of the progressive bourgeois revolution almost came in the United States during the early republic, the end of the civil war, and the end of World War II respectively. However, the potentially historically progressive character of the American national bourgeoise was undermined first in the defense of slaveocracy, then in the name of compromise and an institutional coup within the republic after the Civil War, and then in the complete takeover and attempted dissolution of the US entirely by rentier interests during the solidification of the late Anglo-American Banking Empire. Under a new two-party system the Apricots wager, perhaps correctly, that they could contest in the public sphere the claims of the NRs that they are the natural vanguard of the American people. In the present moment such an electoral coup would be impossible, but in 20-30 years who knows? To this end they are, despite not being NRs themselves, very supportive of the current state and constitute a part of the “Majority Party” at least on paper. They also agree with the Middle Party on annexing Canada.
The Plum Caucus does not agree. They broke off from the rest of the party (though kept their seats) when the current line of the Apricots was established. The Plums could not agree to what they saw as an “unqualified legitimization” of the second republic. They conceive of their situation as merely representing the interests of American Communists such that no “white terror” might be brought against them until such a time that the “real” party of the masses can fully constitute itself. In practice though this just means that they vote present most of the time and hang around the congressional snack bar a lot.
In an interesting wrinkle to this, the Movement for American Socialism was also once part of the core Communist Party, though they broke off for the opposite reason. When the Apricot Line was established they switched to the NRs, believing instead that it could be turned towards an explicitly socialistic program. As one can guess this has led to lots of grumbling about “left and right deviationists” by Communist Party cadres.
What are the eight cliques of the Majority Party system? What are the goals of the Core party? What are the goals of the Inner party? What are the goals of the Middle party? What are the goals of the Outer Party? What are the differences between the Apricot and Plum caucuses of the Communist Party? What are the goals for the Apricot caucus? What are the goals of the Plum caucus? Can the current Majoritarian system of under the National Radicals be described as a consociational system?
- Assistant
The passage describes a complex political system led by the National Radicals (NRs) after the Second Revolution in the United States, focusing on various factions within the party and their differing approaches to governance.
Eight Cliques of the Majority Party System:
- Core or Central Clique: Advocates for a Total Party-State where democracy exists within a single party that fuses with the state and civil society.
- Movement for National Reconstruction (Inner Party): Aligns with the vision of the Total Party-State but with specific carveouts for the military and other institutions.
- Political Synergy Clique (Inner Party): Wants to maintain a multiplicity of governance forms while staying close to the Core's vision.
- Political Harmony Clique (Middle Party): Supports a multi-party system within the NRs and promotes annexing Canada.
- New Era Scientific Development Movement (Middle Party): Similar to the Political Harmony Clique, supports diversity within the revolutionary orthodoxy and annexing Canada.
- Dynamist Conference of America (Outer Party).
- Political Engineering Clique (Outer Party).
- Movement for American Socialism (Outer Party): Advocates for dividing legislative and consultative offices, effectively a multi-party system, and a revised constitution.
Goals of Each Faction:
- Core Party: Establish a vanguard party-state, where democracy is internal and fused with the state.
- Inner Party: Support the Core’s vision with exceptions for special interests like the military, advocating for either patron states or poly-federalism.
- Middle Party: Propose a multi-party structure within the NRs and support annexing Canada, with non-elected functions ensuring party orthodoxy.
- Outer Party: Similar to Middle Party but advocate a more constitutionalist approach, supporting a revised constitution to stabilize the coalition.
Communist Party Factions:
- Apricot Caucus: Supports a reestablished two-party system, viewing the current regime as a legitimate bourgeois revolutionary government; they align with the Middle Party on annexing Canada.
- Plum Caucus: Disagrees with legitimizing the NR government and see themselves as placeholders until a true communist movement can take hold; generally passive in current proceedings.
Goals of the Communist Caucuses:
- Apricot Caucus: Ultimately aims to be part of a revived two-party system where they can challenge the NRs as the legitimate vanguard.
- Plum Caucus: Seek to wait out the current system, avoiding repression and maintaining a presence until they believe a genuinely revolutionary leadership can emerge.
Consociational System:
The Majoritarian system under the National Radicals can loosely be compared to a consociational system, given its various internal factions and the integration of diverse political interests. However, it lacks some key features of classic consociationalism, such as power-sharing between distinct and autonomous groups, since all political activity is still meant to align with the NR's overarching framework for a Total Party-State. The presence of factions and cliques suggests internal diversity, but not the full autonomy and separate influence typically seen in consociational systems.
- User
Can you explain your previous answer in layman's terms? Can you elaborate and interpolate on the goals of each clique of the National Radicals and the Communist party?
- Assistant
Sure, let's break this down into simpler terms.
Eight Cliques of the Majoritarian Party
-
Core Clique: This group is like the core team or central hub of the party. They want everything to be tightly controlled by a single party, which they believe should eventually blend into the government and society so that only their party has real power.
-
Movement for National Reconstruction (Inner Party): They mostly agree with the Core Clique but believe some exceptions should be made for powerful groups like the military. They support having state governments to manage their affairs a bit more independently.
-
Political Synergy Clique (Inner Party): Similar to the above, but they focus more on making sure different states can govern themselves in ways that suit them best, still mostly agreeing with the Core Clique’s overall direction.
-
Political Harmony Clique (Middle Party): This group thinks there should be more parties within the big party to better represent different views but agrees that all should follow the main party's revolutionary goals. They also support the idea of expanding into Canada.
-
New Era Scientific Development Movement (Middle Party): They think similarly to the Political Harmony Clique, promoting diversity in political thought within the party while sticking to the main goals. They also favor annexing Canada.
-
Dynamist Conference of America (Outer Party): They believe in keeping legislative work separate from consulting work and think other parties outside the main one should take part in consulting parts of governance. They want to keep the current coalition system permanently.
-
Political Engineering Clique (Outer Party): This group focuses on designing and structuring political systems and processes. They agree with having a permanent coalition and think having different parties involved might be better for governance.
-
Movement for American Socialism (Outer Party): They think the government should continue to be mixed with multiple parties influencing only some government roles. They think the current system isn't ready to be a one-party system yet.
Communist Party Factions
-
Apricot Caucus: Imagine them as a team that believes partnering up with the main party is smart for now. They think if there were two dominant parties, they could eventually be the challenger to the National Radicals. They think of the current government as a necessary step in a long history of governmental evolution.
-
Plum Caucus: This is more like a "wait and see" group. They're not on board with the current government and prefer staying out of the fray, not making waves, until they see a chance to take the lead in a truer communist movement.
Overall Structure
The National Radicals have a kind of big tent approach where even though there is one dominant party, it has many different factions within it pulling in various directions. While it's not like a typical political system where very different parties share power, it does have a range of opinions and ideas trying to influence how things are run. The question is really about how much all these different parts can work together, given how varied their views and goals are.
-