Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
o1-preview-2024-09-12· OpenAIAi2 WildChat-4.8M (AI2)

Legend and Symbols Before diving into the formulas, it's essential to understand the…

  1. User

    Legend and Symbols Before diving into the formulas, it's essential to understand the symbols and terms used: Symbol Description NKeys(Col) The number of distinct values in column Col. High(Col) The highest value in column Col. Low(Col) The lowest value in column Col. NTuples(R) The number of tuples (rows) in relation (table) R. NPages(R) The number of pages required to store relation R. NPages(I) The number of pages used by index I. Height(I) The height of index I (number of levels in a B-tree index). Π RFi The product of all reduction factors RFi applied in a query. Π NTuples(Ri) The product of the number of tuples in all relations Ri participating in a join operation. num_passes(R) The number of passes required to sort relation R. PF Projection Factor: The portion (fraction) of all columns retained after a projection operation.

    1. Reduction Factor (Selectivity) Reduction Factor (RF) quantifies the fraction of data remaining after applying a selection predicate. It estimates how much a query reduces the data size based on certain conditions. a. Selection: Column Equals a Value (Col = value) [ \text{RF} = \frac{1}{\text{NKeys(Col)}} ] • Explanation: Assumes uniform distribution of values. If a column has NKeys(Col) distinct values, selecting a specific value reduces the data to 1/NKeys(Col) of the original. b. Selection: Column Greater Than a Value (Col > value) [ \text{RF} = \frac{\text{High(Col)} - \text{value}}{\text{High(Col)} - \text{Low(Col)}} ] • Explanation: Proportion of data where the column's value is greater than the specified value, based on the column's range. c. Selection: Column Less Than a Value (Col < value) [ \text{RF} = \frac{\text{value} - \text{Low(Col)}}{\text{High(Col)} - \text{Low(Col)}} ] • Explanation: Proportion of data where the column's value is less than the specified value. d. Join: Column Equality (Col_A = Col_B) [ \text{RF} = \frac{1}{\max(\text{NKeys(Col_A)}, \text{NKeys(Col_B)})} ] • Explanation: For joining two tables on columns Col_A and Col_B, the reduction factor depends on the higher number of distinct keys in either column. e. No Information Available [ \text{RF} = \frac{1}{10} ] • Explanation: When there's no statistical information about the data distribution, a default "magic number" of 0.1 (1/10) is used as an estimate.

    2. Result Size Calculations Estimates the number of tuples resulting from query operations. a. Single Table Query [ \text{Result_size} = \text{NTuples(R)} \times \prod \text{RFi} ] • Explanation: The number of tuples after applying one or more selection predicates with reduction factors RFi. b. Join Operations [ \text{Result_size} = \prod \text{NTuples(Ri)} \times \prod \text{RFi} ] • Explanation: For joining multiple relations, multiply the number of tuples in each participating relation and apply the combined reduction factors.

    3. Indexing Cost Evaluates the cost of using different types of indexes to execute queries. a. B+-Tree Index i. Single Tuple Selection (Primary Key Lookup) [ \text{Cost} = \text{Height(I)} + 1 ] • Explanation: The cost includes traversing the index tree (height) and accessing the data page containing the tuple. ii. Clustered Index (Multiple Tuples) [ \text{Cost} = (\text{NPages(I)} + \text{NPages(R)}) \times \prod \text{RFi} ] • Explanation: Accessing the index pages and the clustered data pages. Reduction factors apply if multiple tuples are retrieved. iii. Unclustered Index (Multiple Tuples) [ \text{Cost} = (\text{NPages(I)} + \text{NTuples(R)}) \times \prod \text{RFi} ] • Explanation: Accessing index pages and individual data pages for each tuple (higher cost due to non-contiguous data storage). b. Hash Index i. Single Tuple Selection (Primary Key Lookup) [ \text{Cost} = 1.2 + 1 = 2.2 ] • Explanation: Fixed cost for hashing and accessing the tuple. ii. Clustered Hash Index (Multiple Tuples) [ \text{Cost} = \text{NPages(R)} \times \prod \text{RFi} \times 2.2 ] • Explanation: Accessing data pages multiplied by the fixed cost for each tuple. iii. Unclustered Hash Index (Multiple Tuples) [ \text{Cost} = \text{NTuples(R)} \times \prod \text{RFi} \times 2.2 ] • Explanation: Each tuple requires separate access, hence the multiplication by NTuples(R).

    4. Sequential Scan (Heap Scan) Cost Calculates the cost of scanning an entire table without using any indexes. [ \text{Cost} = \text{NPages(R)} ] • Explanation: Simply the number of pages in the relation, as each page must be read sequentially.

    Q2 Introduction (Total marks for Q2: 5 marks)

    Consider a relation with the following schema:

    JobSeekers(id, firstname, lastname, city, soughtsalary)

    The JobSeekers relation consists of 10,000 pages. Each page stores 100 tuples. The online software works in the 8 largest Australian cities and soughtsalary can have values between 60,000 and 160,000 (i.e., [60,000 – 160,000].)

    Suppose that the following SQL query is executed frequently using the given relation:

    SELECT *

    FROM JobSeekers

    WHERE city = ‘Melbourne’ AND soughtsalary > 80,000;

    Your job is to:

    Compute the reduction factors and the estimated result size in number of tuples. (1 mark)
    Compute the estimated cost in number of disk I/O’s required to use a clustered B+ tree index on (city, soughtsalary) to answer this query. Suppose there are 2,000 index pages. (1 mark)
    Compute the estimated cost in number of disk I/O’s required to use an unclustered B+ tree index on (soughtsalary)to answer this query. Suppose there are 2,000 index pages. (1 mark)
    Compute the estimated cost in number of disk I/O’s required to use an unclustered Hash index on (city) to answer this query.  (1 mark)
    Compute the estimated cost in number of disk I/O’s required to use an unclustered Hash index on (soughtsalary) to answer this query.  (1 mark)
    

    NOTE WHEN SOLVING THE ABOVE YOU MUST USE THE FORMULAS PROVIDED ABOVE WHERE APPLICABLE WITHOUT FAIL AS THEY WILL NET THE CORRECT ANSWER. YOUR THINKING PROCESS SHOULD BE THIS. YOU MUST A) CALCULATE THE RELEVANT FORMULAS APPLICABLE TO THE QUESTION AT HAND, AND SEE IF THEY ARE APPLICABLE TO THE GIVEN QUESTION. B) STATE HOW THE TERMS WITHIN THE EQUATION RELATE TO THE QUESTION AT HAND) C) USE THE FORMULA IN ORDER TO SOLVE THE QUESTION. NOTE THAT WITH THE REDUCTION FACTORS THEY ARE THE TERMS IN BRACKETS, IF ITS (A) THEN ITS JUST THE REDUCTION FACTOR OF A, IF ITS (A,B) ITS THE PRODUCT OF THE REDUCTION FACTOR OF A AND B ETC. YOU MUST USE THIS THINKING PROCESS WHEN SOLVING QUESTIONS

  2. Assistant

    Answer to Question 2:

    (1) Compute the reduction factors and the estimated result size in number of tuples.

    a) Calculate the relevant formulas applicable:

    • Reduction Factor for city = 'Melbourne':

      [ \text{RF}_{\text{city}} = \frac{1}{\text{NKeys(city)}} ]

    • Reduction Factor for soughtsalary > 80,000:

      [ \text{RF}_{\text{soughtsalary}} = \frac{\text{High(soughtsalary)} - \text{value}}{\text{High(soughtsalary)} - \text{Low(soughtsalary)}} ]

    • Combined Reduction Factor:

      [ \text{RF}{\text{total}} = \text{RF}{\text{city}} \times \text{RF}_{\text{soughtsalary}} ]

    • Result Size Calculation:

      [ \text{Result_size} = \text{NTuples(JobSeekers)} \times \text{RF}_{\text{total}} ]

    b) State how the terms within the equation relate to the question at hand:

    • NKeys(city) = 8 (since there are 8 largest Australian cities)
    • High(soughtsalary) = 160,000
    • Low(soughtsalary) = 60,000
    • Value = 80,000
    • NTuples(JobSeekers) = 10,000 pages × 100 tuples/page = 1,000,000 tuples

    c) Use the formula in order to solve the question:

    • Compute (\text{RF}_{\text{city}}):

      [ \text{RF}_{\text{city}} = \frac{1}{8} = 0.125 ]

    • Compute (\text{RF}_{\text{soughtsalary}}):

      [ \text{RF}_{\text{soughtsalary}} = \frac{160,000 - 80,000}{160,000 - 60,000} = \frac{80,000}{100,000} = 0.8 ]

    • Compute Combined Reduction Factor:

      [ \text{RF}_{\text{total}} = 0.125 \times 0.8 = 0.1 ]

    • Compute Estimated Result Size:

      [ \text{Result_size} = 1,000,000 \times 0.1 = 100,000 \text{ tuples} ]

    Answer:

    • Reduction Factors:

      • (\text{RF}_{\text{city}} = 0.125)
      • (\text{RF}_{\text{soughtsalary}} = 0.8)
      • Combined Reduction Factor: (\text{RF}_{\text{total}} = 0.1)
    • Estimated Result Size: 100,000 tuples


    (2) Compute the estimated cost using a clustered B+ tree index on (city, soughtsalary).

    a) Calculate the relevant formula:

    • Cost using Clustered Index (Multiple Tuples):

      [ \text{Cost} = (\text{NPages(I)} + \text{NPages(R)}) \times \prod \text{RFi} ]

    b) Relate terms to the question:

    • NPages(I) = 2,000 index pages
    • NPages(R) = 10,000 pages (given)
    • (\prod \text{RFi} = \text{RF}_{\text{total}} = 0.1) (from part 1)

    c) Solve using the formula:

    • Compute Cost:

      [ \text{Cost} = (2,000 + 10,000) \times 0.1 = 12,000 \times 0.1 = 1,200 \text{ disk I/Os} ]

    Answer:

    • Estimated Cost: 1,200 disk I/Os

    (3) Compute the estimated cost using an unclustered B+ tree index on (soughtsalary).

    a) Calculate the relevant formula:

    • Cost using Unclustered Index (Multiple Tuples):

      [ \text{Cost} = (\text{NPages(I)} + \text{NTuples(R)}) \times \prod \text{RFi} ]

    b) Relate terms to the question:

    • NPages(I) = 2,000 index pages
    • NTuples(R) = 1,000,000 tuples
    • (\prod \text{RFi} = \text{RF}_{\text{total}} = 0.1) (from part 1)

    c) Solve using the formula:

    • Compute Cost:

      [ \text{Cost} = (2,000 + 1,000,000) \times 0.1 = 1,002,000 \times 0.1 = 100,200 \text{ disk I/Os} ]

    Answer:

    • Estimated Cost: 100,200 disk I/Os

    (4) Compute the estimated cost using an unclustered Hash index on (city).

    a) Calculate the relevant formula:

    • Cost using Unclustered Hash Index (Multiple Tuples):

      [ \text{Cost} = \text{NTuples(R)} \times \prod \text{RFi} \times 2.2 ]

    b) Relate terms to the question:

    • NTuples(R) = 1,000,000 tuples
    • (\prod \text{RFi} = \text{RF}_{\text{city}} = 0.125) (since index is on 'city')

    c) Solve using the formula:

    • Compute Cost:

      [ \text{Cost} = 1,000,000 \times 0.125 \times 2.2 = 125,000 \times 2.2 = 275,000 \text{ disk I/Os} ]

    Answer:

    • Estimated Cost: 275,000 disk I/Os

    (5) Compute the estimated cost using an unclustered Hash index on (soughtsalary).

    a) Calculate the relevant formula:

    • Cost using Unclustered Hash Index (Multiple Tuples):

      [ \text{Cost} = \text{NTuples(R)} \times \prod \text{RFi} \times 2.2 ]

    b) Relate terms to the question:

    • NTuples(R) = 1,000,000 tuples
    • (\prod \text{RFi} = \text{RF}_{\text{soughtsalary}} = 0.8) (since index is on 'soughtsalary')

    c) Solve using the formula:

    • Compute Cost:

      [ \text{Cost} = 1,000,000 \times 0.8 \times 2.2 = 800,000 \times 2.2 = 1,760,000 \text{ disk I/Os} ]

    Answer:

    • Estimated Cost: 1,760,000 disk I/Os

    Summary of Answers:

    1. Reduction Factors:

      • (\text{RF}_{\text{city}} = 0.125)
      • (\text{RF}_{\text{soughtsalary}} = 0.8)
      • Combined Reduction Factor: (\text{RF}_{\text{total}} = 0.1)
      • Estimated Result Size: 100,000 tuples
    2. Cost with Clustered B+ Tree Index on (city, soughtsalary): 1,200 disk I/Os

    3. Cost with Unclustered B+ Tree Index on (soughtsalary): 100,200 disk I/Os

    4. Cost with Unclustered Hash Index on (city): 275,000 disk I/Os

    5. Cost with Unclustered Hash Index on (soughtsalary): 1,760,000 disk I/Os