Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
o1-preview-2024-09-12· OpenAIAi2 WildChat-4.8M (AI2)

Joins Estimating the cost of different join algorithms between two relations, R (outer)…

  1. User

    Joins Estimating the cost of different join algorithms between two relations, R (outer) and S (inner). a. Nested Loop Join (NLJ) i. Tuple-Oriented Nested Loop Join [ \text{Cost} = \text{NPages(R)} + \text{NTuples(R)} \times \text{NPages(S)} ] • Explanation: Read all pages of R, then for each tuple in R, scan all pages of S.

    ii. Page-Oriented Nested Loop Join [ \text{Cost} = \text{NPages(R)} + \text{NPages(R)} \times \text{NPages(S)} ] • Explanation: Read all pages of R, then for each page in R, scan all pages of S. iii. Block-Oriented Nested Loop Join (Block Size B) [ \text{Cost} = \text{NPages(R)} + \left\lceil \frac{\text{NPages(R)}}{\text{B} - 2} \right\rceil \times \text{NPages(S)} ] • Explanation: Utilizes block I/O. B represents the number of blocks that can be loaded into memory. Reduces the number of scans on S by processing multiple pages of R simultaneously. b. Hash Join [ \text{Cost} = 3 \times (\text{NPages(R)} + \text{NPages(S)}) ] • Explanation: Involves building and probing hash tables, typically requiring three passes over both relations. c. Sort-Merge Join [ \text{Cost}_{\text{SMJ}} = \text{NPages(R)} + \text{NPages(S)} + 2 \times \text{NPages(R)} \times \text{num_passes(R)} + 2 \times \text{NPages(S)} \times \text{num_passes(S)} ] • Explanation: Costs include reading both relations, sorting them (each requires num_passes passes), and then merging.

    Q1 Introduction (Total marks for Q1: 5 marks)

    Consider two relations A and B. A has 80,000 tuples, and B has 100,000 tuples. Both relations store 100 tuples per page. Consider the following SQL statement:

    SELECT *

    FROM A INNER JOIN B

    ON A.a = B.a;

    We wish to evaluate an equijoin between A and B, with an equality condition A.a = B.a. There are 102 buffer pages available for this operation. Both relations are stored as (unsorted) heap files. Neither relation has any indexes built on it.

    Consider the alternative join strategies described below and calculate the cost of each alternative. Evaluate the algorithms using the number of disk I/O's (i.e., pages) as the cost.

    YOU MUST EVALUATE EACH OF THE ABOVE FORMULAS IN YOUR WORKING OUT AND USE THE FORMULAS ABOVE WITHOUT FAIL

    Page-oriented Nested Loops Join. Consider A as the outer relation. (1 mark)
    Block-oriented Nested Loops Join. Consider A as the outer relation. (1 mark)
    Sort-Merge Join. Assume that Sort-Merge Join can be done in 2 passes. (1 mark)
    Hash Join (1 mark)
    Assuming that no indexes are built on any of the two relations, and assuming that sufficient buffer space is available:
        What would be the lowest possible cost to perform this query ? (0.5 mark)
        What would be the minimum buffer size required to achieve this cost from 5A? (0.5 mark)
    
  2. Assistant

    To solve this problem, we need to calculate the cost (in disk I/Os) of performing different join strategies using the provided formulas. Here are the solutions for each part:

    Given:

    • Relation A: 80,000 tuples, 100 tuples per page ⇒ NPages(A) = 800
    • Relation B: 100,000 tuples, 100 tuples per page ⇒ NPages(B) = 1000
    • Buffer pages available: 102

    1) Page-oriented Nested Loops Join (PNLJ) with A as the outer relation:

    Formula: [ \text{Cost} = \text{NPages(A)} + \text{NPages(A)} \times \text{NPages(B)} ]

    Calculation: [ \text{Cost} = 800 + 800 \times 1000 = 800 + 800,000 = 800,800 \text{ disk I/Os} ]


    2) Block-oriented Nested Loops Join with A as the outer relation:

    • Block size ( B ) = Buffer size ( = 102 )
    • Available buffers for outer relation: ( B - 2 = 100 )

    Formula: [ \text{Cost} = \text{NPages(A)} + \left\lceil \frac{\text{NPages(A)}}{B - 2} \right\rceil \times \text{NPages(B)} ]

    Calculation: [ \left\lceil \frac{800}{100} \right\rceil = 8 ] [ \text{Cost} = 800 + 8 \times 1000 = 800 + 8000 = 8,800 \text{ disk I/Os} ]


    3) Sort-Merge Join (assuming it can be done in 2 passes):

    • Number of passes: ( \text{num_passes(A)} = \text{num_passes(B)} = 2 )

    Formula: [ \text{Cost} = \text{NPages(A)} + \text{NPages(B)} + 2 \times \text{NPages(A)} \times \text{num_passes(A)} + 2 \times \text{NPages(B)} \times \text{num_passes(B)} ]

    Calculation: [ \text{Cost} = 800 + 1000 + 2 \times 800 \times 2 + 2 \times 1000 \times 2 ] [ \text{Cost} = 800 + 1000 + 3200 + 4000 = 9,000 \text{ disk I/Os} ]


    4) Hash Join:

    Formula: [ \text{Cost} = 3 \times (\text{NPages(A)} + \text{NPages(B)}) ]

    Calculation: [ \text{Cost} = 3 \times (800 + 1000) = 3 \times 1800 = 5,400 \text{ disk I/Os} ]


    5A) Lowest possible cost assuming sufficient buffer space:

    If we have enough buffer space to hold one entire relation in memory, we can perform the join with minimal I/O cost.

    • Minimum cost: [ \text{Cost} = \text{NPages(A)} + \text{NPages(B)} = 800 + 1000 = 1,800 \text{ disk I/Os} ]

    Answer: The lowest possible cost is 1,800 disk I/Os.


    5B) Minimum buffer size required to achieve this cost:

    • To load relation A entirely into memory: [ \text{Minimum buffer size} = \text{NPages(A)} = 800 \text{ pages} ]

    Answer: The minimum buffer size required is 800 pages.


    Therefore, the answers are:

    1. 800,800 disk I/Os
    2. 8,800 disk I/Os
    3. 9,000 disk I/Os
    4. 5,400 disk I/Os 5A. The lowest possible cost is 1,800 disk I/Os 5B. Minimum buffer size required is 800 pages

    Answer Summary:

    1. 800,800 disk I/Os 
    2. 8,800 disk I/Os 
    3. 9,000 disk I/Os 
    4. 5,400 disk I/Os  5A. The lowest possible cost is 1,800 disk I/Os  5B. Minimum buffer size required is 800 pages