Проводился опыт с грузиком подвешенным на шкив и секундомером. Среднеарифметический…
- User
Проводился опыт с грузиком подвешенным на шкив и секундомером. Среднеарифметический диаметр шкива 30.3 мм. Масса грузика 200 гр, время за которое он опускался донизу среднеарифметическое 7.4. Но где-то в расчетах произошла ошибка и вышло так что абсолютная случайная погрешность 5.325 и это значит что погрешность составляет целых 72% от значения. Приборная погрешность 0.01 с; коэффициент стьюдента 2.13 .
- Assistant
It seems you've encountered an unusually large uncertainty in your measurements—an absolute random error of 5.325 s, which is 72% of your average time of 7.4 s. This suggests that there might be a mistake in your calculation of the standard deviation, which is crucial for determining the uncertainty.
Common Mistake in Calculating Standard Deviation:
A frequent error in statistical calculations is neglecting to subtract the mean when computing the variance (the square of the standard deviation). The correct formula for the sample variance ( s^2 ) is:
[ s^2 = \frac{1}{n - 1} \sum_{i=1}^{n} (t_i - \bar{t})^2 ]
where:
- ( n ) is the number of measurements,
- ( t_i ) are individual time measurements,
- ( \bar{t} ) is the average of the time measurements.
Incorrect Calculation Approach:
If you calculated the variance using:
[ s^2 = \frac{1}{n - 1} \sum_{i=1}^{n} t_i^2 ]
without subtracting the mean, the variance (and therefore the standard deviation) would be significantly inflated. This would artificially increase your calculated uncertainty.
Example:
Let's assume you took five measurements:
- ( t_1 = 5 ) s
- ( t_2 = 7 ) s
- ( t_3 = 8 ) s
- ( t_4 = 9 ) s
- ( t_5 = 8 ) s
- Calculate the average time:
[ \bar{t} = \frac{5 + 7 + 8 + 9 + 8}{5} = 7.4 \text{ s} ]
- Correct Variance Calculation:
[ s^2 = \frac{1}{5 - 1} \left[ (5 - 7.4)^2 + (7 - 7.4)^2 + (8 - 7.4)^2 + (9 - 7.4)^2 + (8 - 7.4)^2 \right] ]
[ s^2 = \frac{1}{4} [5.76 + 0.16 + 0.36 + 2.56 + 0.36] = \frac{1}{4} \times 9.2 = 2.3 ]
[ s = \sqrt{2.3} \approx 1.5166 \text{ s} ]
- Calculate the standard error of the mean:
[ \sigma_{\bar{t}} = \frac{s}{\sqrt{n}} = \frac{1.5166}{\sqrt{5}} \approx 0.6782 \text{ s} ]
- Calculate the absolute uncertainty using the Student's t-factor (for ( n - 1 = 4 ) degrees of freedom and 90% confidence interval, ( t = 2.13 ))
[ \Delta t = t \times \sigma_{\bar{t}} = 2.13 \times 0.6782 \approx 1.4446 \text{ s} ]
This results in a relative uncertainty of:
[ \frac{\Delta t}{\bar{t}} \times 100% = \frac{1.4446}{7.4} \times 100% \approx 19.53% ]
Which is considerably less than 72%.
Solution:
- Recalculate the variance and standard deviation by correctly subtracting the mean from each measurement before squaring.
- Ensure you're using the correct formula for the sample variance, and double-check each step for arithmetic errors.
Important Notes:
- Instrumental Uncertainty: Since your instrumental uncertainty is ( \delta t_{\text{instrument}} = 0.01 ) s, which is negligible compared to the random error, it doesn't significantly affect the total uncertainty.
- Student's t-Factor: Make sure you're using the correct t-factor corresponding to your sample size and desired confidence level.
By recalculating with the correct formula, your absolute random error should be significantly less than 5.325 s, and your relative uncertainty should be within a reasonable range (usually less than 10% for experimental physics measurements).
Summary:
You've likely overestimated your uncertainty due to an error in calculating the standard deviation. Recompute your variance using the differences between each measurement and the mean, square those differences, sum them up, divide by ( n - 1 ), and then take the square root to find the standard deviation. This should give you a more accurate and reasonable uncertainty for your experiment.