Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
gpt-4o-mini-2024-07-18· OpenAIAi2 WildChat-4.8M (AI2)

so i'm writing notes from this lesson on our art theory class and i want you to continue…

  1. User

    so i'm writing notes from this lesson on our art theory class and i want you to continue the rest. I'm gonna send the transcript of the lesson first then then send you my notes

  2. Assistant

    Sure, go ahead and send the transcript of your lesson, followed by your notes, and I'll help you continue from there!

  3. User

    Chapter 3: The Renaissance (1300-1600) [from Art History’s History] by Vernon Hyde Minor

    The philosophy of art in the Renaissance arises from certain fundamental texts, such as Leon Battista Alberti's trilogy On Painting, On Sculpture, and On Architecture, Marsilio Ficino's Commentary on Plato's Symposium, Leonardo's Treatise, Michelangelo's literary legacy, and Giogio Vasari's Lives. In addition to these texts—written by artists as well as philosophers and humanists—there are certain key practices and expectations. Perspective, what we might call a technological development, is one of the important practices of the Renaissance; istoria, the idea that the picture must have an instructive narrative, is something inherited from the ancient tradition. Further, the philosophies of both Plato and Aristotle were revived. Let us begin with what the Renaissance derived from antiquity.

    Marsilio Ficino He met with the great intellectuals of his time, benefited from the patronage of the wealthy Medici, studied Greek and Latin, rediscovered texts by Plato, and founded the NewAcademy in Florence in 1462. His name is Marsilio Ficino (1433-1499), and he has a great deal to do with why the Renaissance is about rebirth. Like an archeologist, he attempted to reconstruct the ancient Mediterranean tradition of beauty and meaning. In his commentaries on Plato's Symposium and in his treatise the Theologica Platonica, Ficino summarized much of classical aesthetics and, in addition, emphasized the role of contemplation as first set forth in Plato's Phaedrus. The contemplative act is one of withdrawal from the world of experience so as better to ponder the world of forms. As a result of this process of inward consideration, one does not respond only to the proportional or quantitative aspect of beauty, but, like Saint Thomas Aquinas and Plotinus had suggested, one finds something unitary and indivisible: "Some regard beauty as an arrangement of component parts, or to use their own words, commensurability and proportion… We do not accept this view because this kind of arrangement occurs only in composites and, therefore, no simple thing can be beautiful. However, pure colors, lights, separate sounds, the glitter of gold and silver, knowledge, the soul, are all called beautiful and are all pure and simple" (Kristeller). The shaft of divine light that enters the human soul is this irreducible stuff of beauty—the pure and the simple. Ficino's contemplative mode of apprehension, however, is not one of utter, abject passivity; rather, it is a dynamic action of human spirit and human love. The mind, the ear, and the eye are all engaged. This is more than self-knowledge: it is an awareness of how each of us shares in the universal, how we come to know our essential humanness as part of the divine order. Whether we know it or not, we participate in God. Coming to terms with this makes us fully human and spiritually aware.

    Pico Della Mirandola Giovanni Pico della Mirandola, a member of Ficino's academy, wrote an oration entitled "On the Dignity ofMan," in which he had God speak to Adam. Here there is crystallized the Renaissance understanding of human nature: how it is that we can become great

    God therefore accorded to Man the function of a form not set apart, and a place in the middle of the world, and addressed him thus: "I have given thee neither a fixed abode nor a form that is thine alone nor any function peculiar to thyself, Adam, to the end that, according to thy longing and according to thy judgment, thou mayest have and possess that abode, that form, and those functions which thou thyself shalt desire. The nature of all other things is limited and constrained within the bounds of laws prescribed by me: thou, coerced by no necessity, shalt ordain for thyself the limits of thy nature in accordance with thine own free will, in whose hand I have placed thee. I have set thee at the world's center, that thou mayest from thence more easily observe whatever is in the world. I have made thee neither of heaven nor of earth, neither mortal nor immortal, so that thou mayest with greater freedom of choice and with more honor, as though the maker and molder of thyself, fashion thyself in whatever shape thou shalt prefer. Thou shalt have the power to degenerate into the lower forms of life, which are animal; thou shalt have the power, out of thy soul's judgment, to be reborn into the higher forms of life, which are divine.

    If we look at one of the most famous examples of the confrontation between God and Adam, Michelangelo's Creation ofAdam, from the Sistine Chapel ceiling (fig. 1 1), we should be able to see howPico's oration moves into visible form and how Ficino's inward deliberation can be depicted. What most commentators point out is that God the Father has yet to "create" Adam in the fullest sense: their fingers instead are about to touch. Adam moves, his eyes are open, yet he seems incapable of shaking offa dreamy lethargy. In Ficino's and Pico's terms, what Adam will receive is the gift of choice, of freedom, of self- discovery and self-realization. Being sentient is not being fully human. We have the potential to see what there is within us that can participate in the divine order, but we must learn how to bring that knowledge and that capacity into our lives.
    

    Leon Battista Alberti It is something of a relief to leave behind the Neoplatonic speculation of Marsilio Ficino and other Florentine humanists of the fifteenth century and en- counter a real, live artist writing about what he knows best. Although Leon Battista Alberti's treatises, especially the one on painting, are informed by theoretical concerns, he himself was no philosopher; he had no system. Perhaps that's what makes him so accessible, even today. Born in 1404, when his father was in exile from Florence, the young Battista received a humanist education first in Padua and later in Bologna. He be- came familiar with the antique tradition in literature and the arts through his university education. He studied philosophy and the natural sciences, and after the completion of his formal education, spent some time in Rome working for the Vatican Curia. When he entered Florence in 1434, the first flush of the Renaissance was nearly finished. So, in effect, he saw the Florentine Renaissance at midstream: Masaccio was dead; Filippo Brunelleschi was building the dome to the Cathedral; much of the sculpture at Or San Michele was now in place; Lorenzo Ghiberti's sculptural style had changed to one of greater classicism and order. Alberti soon was at work on Delia Pittura (On Painting, published in Italian in 1436; first published in Latin— as De re praestantissima—in 1435), to be followed by other treatises on the visual arts. So much of Neoplatonic aesthetics deals with the invisible, the mystical, the ideational. Alberti believes in things seen. He is not so concerned with experiences on another plane of reality; in fact, this world pleases him: "No one would deny that the painter has nothing to do with things that are not visible. The painter is concerned solely with presenting what can be seen."Just the same, Alberti realizes that the world of sense perception can be deceiving and highly relative. He insists, therefore, upon a mathematical check for objects represented in paintings. Measurement is important because things must be fixed in space. On account of his desire for a secure location of objects, he emphasizes outline and the texture of surfaces—tactile phenomena.And, although not the first to use it, he is the first to write about linear perspective. Alberti believes that a picture shows things that appear to be behind the surface of the picture itself. A picture, he writes, is like a “transparent window through which we look out into a section of the visible world." Alberti's visual system—based strongly on clear measurements, precise location, linear perspective, and the metaphor of the window—creates a system of absolutely determined visibility. In a sense, you can find the placement of every object in a painting created in terms of linear perspective; further, you can locate the position of the observer in relation to the space of the scene represented. That simply didn't occur before the Renaissance. Because the viewer now senses that the work of art is some kind of extension of his or her own space, the sense of identification with the scene is heightened. The painting is a microcosm—a self-contained "reality"—in which the observer participates. But the system—that arrangement of lines, colors, and patterns on a flat surface—isn't in and of itself enough. Pure visibility and the sensuous attraction of forms provide only the beginning for a humanistic end. Alberti calls this end or purpose istoria: "The greatest work of the painter is the istoria." Loosely speaking, we could say that istoria is subject matter, the story, narrative, or devotional image presented to the viewer. Literally istoria means "history," so that pictures employing traditional subject matter, especially multi-figured compositions, are called "history paintings." Gregory the Great believed that religious subject matter appealed directly to the unlettered, informed them, and re- minded them of the necessary lessons and personages of Holy Writ. Alberti would agree up to a point, but, had he read it, would have found Gregory's formulation impoverished. Istoria refers to those themes and figures sanctioned by time and tradition. The artist does not so much invent subjects, but reinterprets those that are well known, and he does it in such a way as to elevate and touch the viewer. The mode of presentation must achieve the effect of monumentality. ButAlberti does not mean absolute scale here: the monumental is that which impresses. It need not be physically big to do this. Grandeur of impact leads to pleasure and a certain spiritual current. Alberti writes that "the istoria which merits both praise and admiration will be so agreeably and pleasantly attractive that it will capture the eye of whatever learned or unlearned person is looking at it and will move his soul." Gregory the Great would scarcely have understood the double appeal of art. Why would the learned need or desire pictures when they had the text? Alberti believes that art has a certain efficacious and spiritual impact. How is our innermost being stirred? No more than Aristotle is Alberti clear on this matter. As Kant later was to say, although we may not have an objective definition of beauty, we can agree on its presence. Similarly, although we can give no functional description of how a soul moves and what physiological or spiritual change results, we can agree that great art stirs us deeply. This is vague language, but, even if not subject to epistemological criticism, it has been more or less accepted over the centuries. One of the ways in which the spectator is engaged is through the "passions of the soul"—human emotion. Alberti has a sensitivity to the psychological: 'The istoria will move the soul of the beholder when each man painted there clearly shows the movement of his own soul… We weep with the weeping, laugh with the laughing, and grieve with the grieving.” We are often aided in our emotional as well as intellectual response by a speaking and gesturing figure within the work of art:

    In an istoria I like to see someone who admonishes and points out to us what is happening there; or beckons with his hand to see, or menaces with an angry face and with flashing eyes, so that no one should come near; or shows some danger or marvellous thing there; or invites us to weep or to laugh together with them. Thus whatever the painted persons do among themselves or with the beholder, all is pointed towards ornamenting or teaching the istoria.

    Alberti asserts that a composition should not have too many nor too few figures (between three and ten is best), that it should be neither too lavish nor too stark, and that it should be virile and dignified.
    Painting is a noble pursuit, and the artist should be well educated. Art is not simply a craft, the artist not just a humble workman. Alberti defends the status of the artist: 'The incredible esteem in which painted panels have been held has been recorded. Aristides the Theban sold a single picture for one hundred talents. They say that Rhodes was not burned by King Demetrius for fear that a painting of Protogenes should perish." He also observes that:
    

    the Greeks… because they wished their sons to be well educated, taught them painting along with geometry and music. It is also an honor among women to know how to paint. Martia, daughter ofVarro, is praised by the writers because she knew how to paint. Painting had such reputation and honour among the Greeks that laws and edicts were passed forbidding slaves to learn painting. It was certainly well that they did this, for the art of painting has always been most worthy of liberal minds and noble souls.

    In his book on architecture, De Re Aedificatoria, Alberti makes clear his definition of beauty. Beauty is a "certain regular harmony of all the parts of a thing of such a kind that nothing could be added or taken away or altered without making it less pleasing" (Blunt). This definition, depending as it does upon ancient notions of symmetria, underscores Alberti's traditional beliefs and reveals the depth of his insistence upon system. The work of art must be methodical, so orderly in fact that disturbing any element will upset the entire balance.
    As mentioned, Alberti arrived in Florence in 1434. And, although his first treatise (Delia Pittura) was not published in Italian until 1436, its ideas reflect both his own thought and to a certain extent the painting done in Florence before his arrival. The prime example of the new style in Florentine painting is Masaccio's Tribute Money, part of his frescoes for the Brancacci Chapel in the church of Santa Maria del Carmine (fig. 12).
    In The Tribute Money, the central scene of the frescoes and the chapel, we see several groups of figures: two men to the right, a man and a fish to the left, and figures arranged like a circle in depth in the center. The composition itself spreads to the left and right, like a large movie screen. Our position as observers is elevated, as if we were floating several feet above the floor of the chapel. In order to keep the composition arranged in an ideal fashion, so that it is parallel to the surface of the wall, Masaccio cannot take into account our actual point of view from the floor of the chapel, and thus we must assume our "hovering" position. The organizing system here, as in Alberti's treatise, is linear perspective. But, because the events of the painting take place largely in the country, we are not so aware of the perspectival system. Nature normally does not arrange itself according to some grid, but the architecture to our right does afford the possibility for artificial constructing. If your eye follows those lines or edges of architectural form that in reality would be parallel, you can see that as the building "recedes" in space the parallel lines converge. If this recession were to continue beyond the end of the building, you would find that the lines converge at approximately the location ofChrist's head. The non-obtrusive linear perspective "shows" us the central or focal point of the composition, and this is not just an exercise in system or arrangement of parts. Christ is the center of the drama as well as of the pictorial space. Because, as Alberti admonishes us, the istoria or narrative is the purpose of the work of art.
    Here we have illustrated a relatively obscure story from the Book of Matthew. which concerns one ofChrist's teachings. As the group ofJesus and his followers comes to the gate of a city controlled by the Romans, they are approached by a tax collector: a toll will be exacted before they can enter. Some of the Twelve voice disapproval, disgruntlement. But Jesus reminds them to "render unto Caesar that which is Caesar's, and unto God that which is God's." In other words, pay your taxes; worship God. There will be no  conflict. Peter, to our left, is directed by Christ to find a coin in the mouth of a fish; here is an ingenious way to pay the tribute. To the right, Peter hands the coin to the collector.
    The composition (in Alberti's sense a quadri storiati, meaning “multi-figured" composition) is neither too spare nor too populated. There is an economy to the arrangement of elements: twelve disciples, Christ, and the tax collector (Peter is shown three times, the collector twice). This method of continuous narration allows Masaccio to show the two primary events of the story and one secondary incident. Although Masaccio breaks with the unity of time (as Alberti points out in his treatise, unities should be visual, spatial, and temporal), he doesn't do so in a disruptive fashion: the scene remains coherent and, if one knows the story, quite legible. There is enough architecture represented to establish setting and the gate to a city. The scene relies upon the typical and general. And there are other elements—of light, outline, relief, facial and bod- ily expression, and so on—that Alberti discusses in a detailed manner in On Painting. Masaccio's The Tribute Money is an almost perfect illustration of Alberti's theories.
    

    Leonardo Da Vinci If we consider Leon Battista Alberti to be the major theorist of the early Renaissance, then Leonardo fulfills that role for what we call the High Renaissance. He was born in 1452 and grew up in Florence, where the Neoplatonic influence was strong. But he resisted it, just as he dismissed the authority of the medieval theologians known as Scholastics. He wrote that "any one who in an argument appeals to authority uses not his intelligence, but his memory" (all quotations from Leonardo are found in Richter's edition of Leonardo). Memory has indeed played an important role in the uses and theories of art, from Plato through Gregory the Great to Saint Thomas Aquinas. But what good is received opinion or an authority that descends from the heavens, if one cannot go out and look at the world? Leonardo looked, and did so scientifically. Although Leonardo da Vinci apparently had intended to write a comprehensive treatise on art, what we have surviving is more notes and marginalia than something philosophical and systematic. Yet a clear and unified view emerges, and it is based upon empiricism. The Oxford English Dictionary defines empiricism as "the doctrine which regards experience as the only source of knowledge." Leonardo raised the idea of experience to new heights. He made important contributions and discoveries in botany, zoology, biology, engineering, hydraulics, geology, optics, and anatomy, to name the most obvious. He studied in meticulous detail the world in all its fascinating parts. His drawings show the position of the fetus inside the womb, the structure of blood vessels, tissues, muscles, and skeleton. He was perhaps the most accomplished anatomist of his time. Vaselius's Fabrica, an important medical text published in 1543, owes a great deal to Leonardo's study. In fact, Leonardo called himself a pittor anatomista, meaning a "painter of anatomy." With great attention to detail he made drawings of plants, animals, and the characteristic movements of water. His drawings of visual phenomena were not done just to help train himself as an artist; in and of themselves, these details of the world captivated him. He was looking for and felt he had found the order of the physical world. Although he was almost rapturous about the sense of sight ("O most excellent above all other things created by God," he addresses the human eye, "what praises are there to express your nobility? What peoples, what tongues can describe your scope?"), seeing by itself is not enough. He refers not just to the naked eye, the eye as mechanical lens opening upon the world; more than that, seeing is thinking, is intelligent, is informed. If you detach the eye from the brain, you'll end up with mere likeness. "The painter who paints only by practice and the use of his eyes but without understanding is like a mirror that imitates without understanding all that is placed in front of him." He makes his procedure clear when he writes that "this is the true rule how observers of natural effects must proceed: While nature begins with reasons and ends in experience, we must follow the opposite path, beginning with experience and with that investigating the reasons.” So his position on mimesis is really very different from the traditional one. Alberti and many others had suggested that the artist select the most beautiful details from nature and combine them to find something better than that which actually exists. Plato and the legion of Neoplatonists believed that inherent in mimesis is a distance or a falling away from reality. For Leonardo, mirroring nature is almost enough, but not quite. When he writes "that paint- ing is the most to be praised which agrees most exactly with the thing imitated," he implies that the artist has not just shown us the surface of something but has captured the laws of nature (mathematics, anatomy, structure, optics, and color) and made them obvious in his depiction. Like Alberti, Leonardo uses linear perspective as an important organizing device for visual experience, as an artistic equivalent to nature's "reasons." Although painting is an imitation of nature, it is a scientific imitation. Based upon mathematical perspective and the study of nature, painting renders the truth. Leonardo's truth is not beauty; in fact, beauty plays only a marginal role in Leonardo's thinking. When he does refer to beauty, he characterizes it as charm and grace: no transcendental Neoplatonist he! Leonardo inherited the Renaissance tradition of centered, clearly visible, symmetrical compositions with three-dimensional, anatomically accurate, and functional figures. And he subscribes to the doctrine of istoria. History painting is the highest form. Painting is noble and one must submit to a certain degree of decorum: “Observe decorum, that is to say the suitability of action, dress, setting and circumstances to the dignity or lowliness of the things which you wish to present.” Another way that Leonardo ties himself to tradition is in his psychological interests. He says that when one paints the figure, one must also be attentive to the soul: 'The good painter must paint principally two things, which are man and the ideas in man's mind. The first is easy, the second difficult, because they can only be expressed by means of the gestures and the movements of the limbs." This is a call for the artist to make the invisible visible; the human soul should be exposed by the motion of the human body. Just as those scientific ideas about nature should be manifest in a landscape painting, so too should the vital center of human beings show forth through gesture and expression. Leonardo instructs the painter to study the speechless, because they communicate exclusively through gesture. We reveal ourselves, make ourselves known as human beings, not just through words but by the movement of our physical bodies. Leonardo would have understood what we mean today by "body language.” With an attitude that would have baffled medieval theologians, Leonardo values things seen over things read. He gives images priority over words—and not just because some observers are illiterate. Images inherently have more power than language: "Write up in one place the name of God, and put a figure representing him opposite, and see which will be the more deeply reverenced." From the beginnings of the Christian Era, the text—the Bible—had been thought to carry the essential Christian meaning and message. Now, ac- cording to Leonardo at least, the image embodies significance more directly and more powerfully than the word. As he observes, the relation of painting to text is the relation of object to shadow. We know from the Neoplatonic tradition what this comparison means: the original object or idea has more substance, greater reality. Leonardo uses the traditional analogy, but turns it upside down. Now the idea is shadow; the painting or work of art is substance.

    Michelangelo Again, in Michelangelo, we have an artist who probably intended to write a treatise on art, but never did. Still, Michelangelo's thoughts on art arc important because they reflect his times and have some originality. What we know about his ideas comes from his sonnets—he was an accomplished port—and from his biographers. Michelangelo had a powerful feeling for beauty. Ascanio Condivi, one of his pupils who later was to write a biography of the artist, explains that Michelangelo "loved not only human beauty but universally every beautiful thing… choosing the beauty in nature, as the bees gather honey from the flowers using it afterwards in their works, as all those have done who have ever made a noise in painting. That old master who had to paint a Venus was not content to see one virgin only, but studied many, and taking from each her most beautiful and perfect feature gave them to his Venus." This of course is the old-fashioned doctrine of selectivity, something to which virtually every artist (with the no table exception of Leonardo) for about 1,500 years subscribed.

    Michelangelo grew up in the Renaissance tradition. He knew the writings ofAlberti, and in matters of perspective and anatomy followed both him and Leonardo. And, although he derives some of his ideas of beauty from his con- temporaries and immediate predecessors, there is something more spiritual about Michelangelo. He yearns for beauty. It represents the Divine. He writes:
    

    He who made everything made every part, And then from everything He chose the fairest, To let us here look at His very greatest, And now has done so with His sacred art. (this and other poems from Gilbert's translation of Michelangelo)

    We recognize the Platonism here, the sense that the Divine is reflected on this earth and that we love that reflection because of what it represents. But the one thing that Plato and many of his followers insisted upon symmetria—isn't so important to Michelangelo. He believes that beauty is un- measurable. Its power to attract us is what's significant:
    

    While toward the beauty that I saw at first I bring my soul, which sees it through my eyes, The inward image grows, and this withdraws, Almost abject and wholly in disgrace.

    This passage shows how beauty creates in the heart of the observer a longing, a desire, a sense of being unfulfilled. We suffer from our aspiration and our need. But art offers some hope and consolation. There is something in the painting or sculpture that is pure, that embodies the eternal beauty. More than Plato believed possible, more even than Plotinus believed possible, art can contain the eternal. Beauty gets into an art object because the artist has it first in his head and then injects, or rather "discovers," it in the paint or stone. These are two differing processes—either putting something there or finding it there—but they both require the creative capacity of the artist. When one looks for beauty, one finds it in two places simultaneously:
    

    The best artist never has a concept A single marble block does not contain Inside its husk.

    This concept (a concetto in art historical language) is something like an idea, but is different from it as well. Benedetto Varchi, a contemporary theorist, wrote, with Michelangelo's blessing, an explanation of his use of concetto: "In this place our Poet's Concetto denotes that which... is called in Greek idea, in Latin exemplar, with us 'model'; that is, that form or image, called by some people the intention, that we have within our imagination, of everything that we intend to will or to make or to say; which, although spiritual... is for that reason the efficient cause of everything that can be said or made.”
    The concetto is the artist's intention. It can make it into the sculpture or the painting. In his later years, Michelangelo wearied of life's vanities and believed that art in its worldliness is not very important in light of the need for salvation. However, he never gave up the belief that art can, in fact, convey the beautiful, so long as the artist has an image of the beautiful in his or her mind and has the ability to "discover" it in the work of art. This is what we'd call creativity and talent.
    

    Giorgio Vasari’s Lives The first "modern" art historian was the Italian artist and writer Giorgio Vasari (1511-1574). In his Lives, published first in 1550 and in a second edition in 1568, Vasari wrote biographies of noted artists from the fourteenth century until his time. But it is not biographies alone that establish him as an art historian; rather, it is his scheme of ordering and conceptualizing art as a historical phenomenon. In Vasari's scheme there was a re nascere, a "rebirth" (the origin of our word "Renaissance"), of art in Italy in the fourteenth century, beginning with Giotto and Cimabue (it is worth noting that most Renaissance art courses, following Vasari's model, begin with Florentine art at the end of the thirteenth and beginning of the fourteenth century). Vasari, like others before him, sees the "ancients" as having the first true vision in art. With a certain imperiousness he dismisses the whole of art in the Middle Ages, seeing the Gothic in particular as barbarous. FromVasari's point of view, art attains its value by its similarity to antiquity. And he notes that the "moderns" regained the ideal beauty and naturalism of antiquity, imperfectly at first (with Cimabue and Giotto, artists of the "First Period"), but with greater confidence in the fifteenth century and with perfect realization in the sixteenth-century art of Michelangelo and some of his contemporaries. At the beginning of the third part of his Lives, Vasari writes a brief introduction that gives, in general terms, the foundations of his art historical methods. The first part of the Lives begins with Giotto and Cimabue and extends into the fifteenth century. According to Vasari, these early artists, while far better than anything in the preceding centuries, nonetheless are explorers, pioneers, and primitives—those whose vision is not satisfactorily developed. As Vasari points out at the beginning of the second part, with his historical method he has taken the reader and the three arts "from the nurse, and having passed the age of childhood, there follows the second period m which a notable improvement maybe remarked in everything." His method is developmental, genetic in some ways, biological, and progressive. But the artists of the second part, roughly from the beginning of the fifteenth century up until the time of Leonardo da Vinci, are antecedents for the inevitable artists of perfection, those we still call the artists of the High Renaissance. Vasari explains the perfection of the High Renaissance in terms of rule, order, proportion, design, and style. He writes that

    rule in architecture is the measurement of antiques, following the plans of ancient buildings in making modern ones. Order is the differentiation of one kind from another so that every body shall have its characteristic parts, and that the Doric, Ionic, Corinthian andTuscan shall no longer be mingled indiscriminately. Proportion in sculpture, as in architecture, is the making of the bodies of figures upright, the members being properly arranged, and the same in painting. De- sign is the imitation of the most beautiful things of nature in all figures whether painted or chiselled, and this requires a hand and genius to transfer everything which the eye sees, exactly and correctly, whether it be in drawings, on paper panel, or other surface, both in relief and sculpture. Style is improved by frequently copying the most beautiful things, and by combining the finest members, whether hands, heads, bodies or legs, to produce a perfect figure, which, being introduced in every work and in every figure, from what is known as a fine style.

    We can look a little more closely at Vasari's assumptions and definitions. First of all, he associates rule with the measurement of antique buildings, and by doing this, he gives to antiquity an authority over the present. The rule of ancient buildings carries certain implications, which Vasari certainly under- stands. Rule in art reflects the composition, exactitude, and structure of the universe. Rule in art is therefore divinatory. The Divine or universal is reflected in the particular. The belief had long existed (beginning at least with Aristotle) that that which is most "real" in human nature and construction corresponds to an idea, the immutable principles of the superlunary realm, of the highest heavens beyond the moon. A human wishes to find the Mystic Way, the itinerarium mentis in deum—the "mind's road to God," as Saint Bonaventure phrased it. The desire to find this path, this transcendental connection, was important to Vasari and to the artists of the Renaissance.
    Order for Vasari has to do with differentiation and classification. Separation creates clear categories, so that things are delimited, locatable, grounded, identifiable.
    Proportion is treated rather simply by Vasari, being defined by the upright and the proper. But again there are traditional ideas behind proportion that Vasari accepted and invoked. Proportion has to do with commensurability and the relation of parts to one another, ideas important to the Greeks. As Plato said, "Everywhere commensurability and measure are associated with excellence and beauty.”
    Design for Vasari is the creative capacity to imitate that which is most beautiful in the world, usually following a system of selectivity. As Zeuxis was thought to have done in antiquity, the artist finds the most beautiful parts of the most beautiful women and recombines them into something that is more beautiful than any single woman and in which the whole is greater than the sum of the parts.
    The word disegno means somewhat more in Italian than "design" does in English, for it is also the word for drawing, and it refers to the compositional underpinning of a work of art. And as "creative capacity" (another definition of the term), disegno is the intellectual, rational part of a work.
    The artists of Vasari's Second Period of the Renaissance (explicated in the second part of Lives) advanced over their predecessors, but they were not able to "attain the final stages of perfection" because they could not achieve a freedom that, although beyond the rules, remained guided by their predecessors (a conservative rather than radical freedom); in the realm of order they lacked the capacity for good judgment, which does not so much require measurement as grace; and, similarly, in the way of design—disegno—they were not capable of grace and ease, but rather were stunted and crude. 'Their draperies lacked beauty, their fancies variety, their coloring charm, their buildings diversity and their landscapes distance and variety." Some other things thatVasari found missing in the artists of the Second Period were finish, perfection, light- ness, polish, assurance, vigor, and softness.
    Vasari's story, like so many, has a beginning, a middle, and an end. The end is his own period. Leonardo daVinci begins the Third Period and heralds the culmination and resolution of that which went before. He was "notable for the boldness of design, the subtlest imitation ofNature in trifling details, good rules, better order, correct proportion, perfect design and divine grace, prolific and diving to the depths of art, endowing his figures with motion and breadth.”
    Conjuring divine grace, Vasari brings the art of the High Renaissance to its proper summit. Grace is the love, beneficence, and care ofGod that makes the figures painted by Leonardo, Michelangelo, and Raphael more than graceful. The artists and their art participate in the Divine. The artists of the High Renaissance give to us a theophany, a vision of the miraculous and ineffable.
    Such is the power of art, in Vasari's version. His study of art becomes the paradigm of art history. In the Third Period artists are “world-makers." As Nelson Goodman explains, world-making is rhetorical, and seeks to persuade and instruct, to purge in the Aristotelian sense (see Chapter 1, "Architecture and Order"), to bring about a catharsis. Art that participates in the Divine, that leads to the Mystic Way, persuades with an unrivaled authority. The result edifies the public, raises its consciousness and awareness of the True, the Good, and the Beautiful.
    Let us make an attempt to characterize and analyze a work that we could call quintessentially classical and canonical in the Vasarian sense. The School of Athens by Raphael (see fig. 4) can stand for many works of art in the context of High Renaissance art and art history. Commissioned by the pope for his public Papal Apartments, it is a compendium of Renaissance imagery and thought, and reflects the "Divine" Raphael's experience of the caput mundi (capital of the world), Rome. The School ofAthens resonates backward and forward in time.
    We can look at The School ofAthens first of all through Vasari's eyes, and then we can assess, from our own point of view, how the work reflects the Renaissance ideal. Although this work is an example of the Vasarian canon, his own discussion of it is, surprisingly, confused: he mixes it up with The Disputation on the Holy Sacrament, another painting by Raphael in the same room.
    Vasari's descriptive vocabulary is primarily one of praise. For instance, he mentions that the figure of Diogenes (lounging on the steps) is "admirable for its beauty." Other figures are "indescribably fine"; a youth has "remarkable beauty"; certain heads have a "beauty and excellence" that is “inexpressible."
    So some ofVasari's key ideas are expressed in such words as the "excellent," the "indescribable," the "remarkable," the "inexpressible," and the "admirable." If a modern critic were to use this kind of language, he or she would be dismissed as uttering vague praise. But for Vasari these are words that describe the artistic qualities oft he painting, those things that make the painting different from nature. Vasari includes the "admirable" and "inexpressible" as part of the "marvelous," or meraviglia, as Vasari's friend Vincenzo Borghini described it. In his Michelangelo and the Language of Art, David Summers discusses meraviglia as one of Borghini's three categories of art: varieta (variety), imparare (learning), and meraviglia. These three ideas correspond to the three aims of rhetoric: to teach, to delight, and to move. These, in turn, correspond to the three kinds of rhetoric: the simple, the middle, and the grand. Meraviglia is therefore associated with the highest form of discourse or oratory: the grand manner. Borghini states that "all things that cause meraviglia please you" (Summers). And he goes on: "There is no doubt that extravagant things, never before seen or heard, or that have in themselves such a rare excellence, delight extraordinarily, and this extraordinary delight is called meraviglia." The marvelous is that part of a work of art that goes beyond expectations, beyond the first two aims of rhetoric.
    Art historians treat TheSchool of Athens as one of the central documents of the High Renaissance. "Central" and "High"—the terms themselves confer prominence and authority. Arranged in a circle, the students of the school con- verse with one another, gesture, reason, contemplate, and pose themselves for the enlightenment of the observer. This is not so much a narrative as a display of ideal types, historical and contemporary figures, and personifications of reason. But before considering the human element, the story, or message, let's be "art historical" and consider the work in abstract terms. AlthoughI will not be using Vasarian language to describe and analyze The School of Athens, I will be speaking as a modern art historian who is a direct descendent of Vasari.
    This fresco organizes our visual experience through certain contrived devices. The work centers around two figures; it is large and in a lunette (window-like) shape; classical architecture (along with the values it implies) dominates the space, which is perspectival; the figures are distributed evenly; light clarifies and reveals the position of every figure. The whole is ideal and universal, embracing time from the Athenian Golden Age until Raphael's present; embracing place from Athens to Rome (the architecture is similar to Donato Bramante's plans for the rebuilding ofSaint Peter's Basilica). Raphael creates a world that is sufficient, logical, and legible.
    For Raphael and his contemporaries, the aim of art is to please, to instruct, to use rhetorical elegance to educate the observer and to create, as mentioned, a sense of purification and renewal. His painting of all of philosophy, deriving either from Plato on our left or Aristotle on our right, should satisfy us with its completeness.
    The educated observer would then, because of his or her interest in istoria, and will now, recognize, to the left of Plato (a portrait of Leonardo?), Socrates demonstrating a syllogism on his fingers. The man in full armor and helmet who listens to Socrates is Alcibiades; Epicurus reads a book that is propped against the base of a column; the child to Epicurus's left is the young Federico Gonzaga.Just to the right of Gonzaga is Pythagoras, who writes in a book his theory of proportion; those around Pythagoras are Averroes, standing and wearing a turban, and Empedocles. The seated, meditative man in the act of writing on a marble slab is Michelangelo in the guise of Heraclitus. The group on the right side of the composition, in the foreground plane, consists ofEuclid inscribing a design on a tablet (he is a portrait ofBramante), Ptolemy holding a terrestial globe, and Zoroaster with a celestial globe. Staring out at us are Raphael (to the left) and Sodoma. Because of its universality, the human or narrative element fits the design. This entire "code," when deciphered as I have suggested, gives to us the idea of virtus: those qualities of dignity, worthiness, impressiveness, and nobility so favored by the Renaissance. Alberti also had emphasized those qualities of strength and steadfastness in the face of capricious fate that are also an important connotation of virtus.
    

    Mannerism Mannerism is not an easy term to pin down. In general, it describes a period in artistic production, especially in Italy, from about 1520 until 1600. As a style it signals something odd—odd, that is, by the standards of the earlier Renaissance. There is a theme in artistic and art historical criticism that considers the relation of style to the thing represented. One school of thought favors what is sometimes called the "natural sign." This means that a painting of a tree can be nearly as natural as the tree itself, so that we judge a painting of a tree on how close it comes to the real tree. The opposite tradition, one that is very important in modern critical theory, says that everything in art is arbitrary, uncertain, variable: the picture of a tree is really a series of marks or signs arranged on a surface, and the only legitimate way of dealing with a painting is to consider it in abstract or semiological terms. Forget the so-called real tree. In mannerism, this reference to how a painting occurs seems to gain some ground on what the supposed subject matter is. These kinds of critical issues can seem elusive and almost precious to us, but they are important. That is why I'm digressing some here. Jacques Derrida, one of the lions of late twentieth- century criticism, says that there is a tradition that states that the imitated should have priority over the imitation (or imitator): "This is not just one metaphysical gesture among others; it is the metaphysical exigency, the most constant, profound, and potent procedure." What he means by this is that in pre-modernist art theory, style serves meaning. Or should. Don't let your style get in the way of painting a tree. But in mannerism there seems to be a struggle between style and meaning. For instance, in Parmigianino's Madonna with the Long Neck most of us will agree that stylishness is more important than normality (fig. 13). The Madonna is too big. Her lap is enormous, her head tiny, her child overgrown and maybe not alive (a prefiguration ofHis sacrifice). The space is discontinuous. The little man in the background with the scroll may be a prophet, but he turns his head away from what is written. And his spatial relation to the Madonna is ambiguous: how far back is he? All but one of the columns next to him evaporate toward the top. They support nothing. The angels, with one wearing a "French-cut" robe, crowd into the corner, like a giggling group of schoolchildren, and look at the big baby. Mary seems pleased, but very affected. Even if we can explain some of the imagery and its symbolic meaning in terms of tradition, the overall appearance is new and disturbing. And that, it seems to many observers, is because the artificial and the stylish are emphasized. It is worth remembering that the word "mannerism" comes from the Italian maniera, which means, among other things, “style." In antiquity, theories of beauty and the nature of the arts originated with philosophers. Although artists wrote about art, their ideas have survived only obliquely, through secondary sources. And the artists themselves were not highly theoretical. In the early through late MiddleAges, speculation on beauty came mostly from theologians. Art was understood almost exclusively in terms of its relation to religion. With the early Renaissance we have artists once again writ- ing about art. They wrote manuals and about shop practices, the how-to of art. They mixed this with some theory and self-justification. Leonardo brought the practical and the scientific into a wonderfully harmonious balance. Michelangelo, like Ficino before him, returned us to Neoplatonic considerations of the origins of beauty and how it can manifest itself in the real world. For nearly a century and a half, artists had been given (or, more likely, had taken) the dais and had spoken to other artists about art. Now in the second half of the sixteenth century, philosophical speculation again asserted itself. Although some of the writers were artists, more were not. They were humanists, antiquarians, and literati—well-educated individuals with an interest in the arts and ancient history. And they spoke to people like themselves. They are the predecessors of today's art historians and critical theorists. In fact, one of these writers, Vincenzo Borghini, sounds a lot like a professor of art history speaking to a class. "You should know," he said to the artists of the Academy of Design in Florence, "that in every art there is a difference between operating in that art, and speak- ing or treating of it" (Summers). Borghini believed that it was best to leave interpretation to the "philosophers and rhetoricians." One wonders if the artists responded with a degree of skepticism, as they often do today. Because so many of the writers at this time were only incidentally interested in technical matters such as the construction of perspectival space or the mixing of colors, more attention was given to speculation and to the nature of the artist and artistic creation. As Moshe Barasch has observed, this is the time when art theory comes of age. Theories of beauty, creativity, and the role of art are the direct focus of philosophical reasoning. We no Longer have to infer from writings on something else what a particular opinion of art and beaut) happens to be. Much of mannerist art theory has to do with an overthrow of the rules and a consideration of artistic freedom and creativity. Leonardo had suggested a mathematically based, scientific view of painting. Federico Zuccaro, a late sixteenth-century writer and artist, says about measurements that "it is necessary to know them; but one must bear in mind that it is not always advisable to observe them." The artist has to make adjustments that are not, strictly speak- ing, mathematical. He also writes that "the art of painting does not derive its principles from the mathematical sciences, indeed it need not even refer to them in order to learn any rules or manners of procedures, or even to be able to discuss them by way of speculation; for painting is not their daughter, but the daughter ofNature and Design. The first shows it form, the other teaches it to work." As we saw in Part One, on the academy, design—disegno in Italian—becomes a central element in sixteenth-century art theory. Nature perhaps is the source of the forms that turn up in paintings, but disegno is the style, the means of presentation, the structure, and—in a certain sense—the idea of a work. The idea comes from the artist. Zuccaro says of the artist that his "intellect must be not only clear but also free, and his spirit unfettered, and not thus restrained in mechanical servitude to such rules, because this truly most noble profession wishes judgment and good practice to be the rule and norm of working well." So the liberation of the artist from exactitude, certitude, rules, and measurement gave him license to explore and experiment. This free-ranging approach engaged the artist's aesthetic capacity, the disegno interno, or "interior design." This interior design is the "imagination," as we might call it. But that doesn't really clarify things. What is the imagination? What is the disegno interno? By getting rid of rules, by seeing nature as something imperfect, by giving the artist far more power than an accomplished imitator has, the theorists of this time painted themselves into a corner. They didn’t want to say "anything goes," but they weren't sure what the limits were either. They speculated on the origin of ideas. Zuccaro claims that before there can be a disegno in the work of art, it had first to exist in the mind of the creator. He says that the disegno interno is "a concept formed in our mind, that enables us explicitly and clearly to recognize any thing, whatever it maybe, and to operate practically in conformance with the thing intended." Is this consciousness, intentionality, or a biologically based function of the relationship between the two hemispheres of the brain? To answer these questions, theorists turned to the old model: Neoplatonism. The inner idea, or disegno interno, came originally from God; it is a spark of the Divine in the human mind. According to Giovanni Paolo Lomazzo (1538-1600), after emanating from the mind of God it also had first passed through the angels, then to the artist. So the artist is still something of a conduit for a higher power, but he or she seems to be active, not passive. There is a shard, a piece of the divine grazia, of "graceful beauty," in the artist's mind, and he or she can make it appear in material form. Describing how this happens is like describing beauty itself; it is shrouded in mystery and almost al- chemical in nature. It is perhaps magical. Giordano Bruno (1548-1600) claimed that "beauty is of many kinds," and that "the essence of beauty, like the essence of pleasure and good, is undefinable and indescribable" (Tatarkiewicz).

  4. Assistant

    Thank you for sharing the transcript of your art theory class lesson. Please send your notes, and I will help you continue from there!

  5. User

    Oh by the way, the notes are in a markdown format. Once i send you the notes, copy the note styling and start where i left off

  6. Assistant

    Got it! Please go ahead and send your notes in markdown format, and I'll continue from where you left off, maintaining the same styling.

  7. User

    The Renaissance: A New Era in Art and Thought (1300-1600)

    Introduction

    The Renaissance was a remarkable period in European history, spanning from about 1300 to 1600. The word "Renaissance" means "rebirth" in French, and that's exactly what this era was - a rebirth of interest in classical learning and culture.

    Why did the Renaissance happen?

    • The medieval period (before the Renaissance) was often focused on religious themes and had less emphasis on individual achievement.
    • As European societies became wealthier and more stable, people had more time and resources to devote to art, learning, and culture.
    • The fall of Constantinople in 1453 led many Greek scholars to flee to Italy, bringing with them ancient texts and knowledge.

    Why does the Renaissance matter?

    • It marked a shift from medieval thinking to more modern ideas.
    • It emphasized the value of the individual and human potential.
    • Many of the ideas and artworks from this period still influence us today.

    Key Philosophical Texts and Practices

    During the Renaissance, several important texts shaped how people thought about art and beauty. Let's look at some of these in more detail:

    Important Texts

    1. Leon Battista Alberti's trilogy:

      • "On Painting" (De Pictura)
      • "On Sculpture" (De Statua)
      • "On Architecture" (De Re Aedificatoria)

      Why they matter: These books were like instruction manuals for artists. They explained new techniques and theories about how to create realistic and beautiful art.

    2. Marsilio Ficino's "Commentary on Plato's Symposium"

      • This book explored ideas about love and beauty from ancient Greek philosophy.
      • Why it matters: It helped bring Plato's ideas back into European thought and influenced how people understood beauty and love.
    3. Leonardo da Vinci's "Treatise"

      • This was a collection of Leonardo's notes on various subjects, including art and science.
      • Why it matters: It shows how Renaissance thinkers were interested in both art and science, and how these subjects could be connected.
    4. Michelangelo's literary works

      • These included poems and letters that expressed Michelangelo's ideas about art and beauty.
      • Why they matter: They give us insight into how one of the greatest Renaissance artists thought about his work.
    5. Giorgio Vasari's "Lives"

      • This book contained biographies of famous Italian artists.
      • Why it matters: It was one of the first books to treat artists as important individuals and to tell the story of how art developed over time.

    Key Practices and Concepts

    1. Perspective

      • What is it? A technique for creating the illusion of three-dimensional space on a flat surface.
      • How it works: Artists used mathematical principles to make distant objects appear smaller and closer together.
      • Why it matters: It made paintings look much more realistic and allowed artists to create complex, believable spaces in their work.
    2. Istoria

      • What is it? The idea that a picture should tell a story or teach a lesson.
      • How it works: Artists would choose subjects from history, mythology, or the Bible and depict them in a way that conveyed a moral or message.
      • Why it matters: It gave art a purpose beyond just being decorative. Paintings became a way to educate and inspire people.

    Revival of Classical Philosophy

    During the Renaissance, people became very interested in the ideas of ancient Greek and Roman thinkers, especially Plato and Aristotle.

    • Plato's ideas: He believed in an ideal world of perfect forms that our physical world only imperfectly copies.
    • Aristotle's ideas: He was more interested in observing and categorizing the physical world around us.

    Why this matters: These different ways of thinking influenced how artists approached their work. Some tried to depict an ideal beauty, while others focused on accurately representing the natural world.

    Major Renaissance Thinkers and Their Ideas

    1. Marsilio Ficino (1433-1499)

    Background

    • Ficino was an Italian scholar and Catholic priest.
    • He lived in Florence, which was a major center of Renaissance culture.
    • He was supported by the powerful Medici family, who were important patrons of the arts.

    Key Ideas

    1. The Nature of Beauty

      • Ficino disagreed with the idea that beauty was just about having all the parts in the right proportion.
      • He thought beauty was something simpler and more unified.
      • For example, he said pure colors, lights, and even knowledge could be beautiful on their own, without needing to be part of a larger arrangement.

      Why this matters: This idea allowed people to appreciate beauty in a wider range of things, not just in perfectly balanced compositions.

    2. Contemplation

      • Ficino emphasized the importance of contemplation, which means thinking deeply about something.
      • He believed that by contemplating beauty, we could connect with something divine or spiritual.

      Why this matters: This idea gave art a spiritual importance. It wasn't just about creating pretty pictures, but about connecting with something deeper.

    3. Universal Participation in the Divine

      • Ficino believed that everything in the world, including humans, participates in the divine in some way.
      • He thought that by understanding this, we become more fully human and spiritually aware.

      Why this matters: This idea gave great importance to human beings and their potential. It suggested that each person had a spark of the divine within them.

    2. Giovanni Pico della Mirandola

    Key Work: "On the Dignity of Man"

    In this work, Pico imagined God speaking to Adam (the first man) and telling him about his unique place in the world.

    Central Idea: Human Freedom and Potential

    • Pico said that unlike other creatures, humans weren't given a fixed nature or place in the world.
    • Instead, humans have the freedom to shape themselves and choose their own place.
    • Humans can either rise to be like angels or sink to be like beasts, depending on their choices.

    Why this matters: This idea was revolutionary. It placed great value on human free will and suggested that people had the power to determine their own destiny. This fit well with the Renaissance emphasis on individual achievement and potential.

    3. Leon Battista Alberti (1404-1472)

    Background

    • Alberti was a true "Renaissance man" - he was skilled in many areas, including architecture, art theory, and mathematics.
    • He lived and worked in several Italian cities, including Florence and Rome.

    Key Ideas

    1. Focus on the Visible World

      • Alberti said that painters should only concern themselves with what can be seen.
      • This was different from medieval art, which often tried to represent invisible, spiritual ideas.

      Why it matters: This helped shift art towards more realistic representation of the world.

    2. Importance of Measurement and Perspective

      • Alberti explained mathematical techniques for creating realistic space in paintings.
      • He treated painting almost like a science, with rules that could be learned and applied.

      Why it matters: This gave artists tools to create more convincing illusions of three-dimensional space in their work.

    3. The Painting as a "Window"

      • Alberti described a painting as being like a window that we look through to see a piece of the world.

      Why it matters: This idea helped people think about paintings in a new way, as views into other spaces rather than just flat decorations.

    4. Istoria (Narrative in Painting)

      • Alberti thought the most important thing in a painting was its story or message (istoria).
      • He believed paintings should use traditional themes to elevate and touch the viewer.

      Why it matters: This gave paintings a purpose beyond just being decorative. They became a way to communicate ideas and emotions.

    5. Rules for Composition

      • Alberti gave specific advice about how to arrange paintings, like how many figures to include.

      Why it matters: These guidelines helped create a recognizable "Renaissance style" that many artists followed.

    6. The Nobility of Painting

      • Alberti argued that painting was a noble pursuit and that artists should be well-educated.

      Why it matters: This helped raise the social status of artists, who had previously been seen more as craftsmen.

    4. Leonardo da Vinci (1452-1519)

    Background

    • Leonardo is perhaps the most famous Renaissance figure, known for his paintings, inventions, and scientific studies.
    • He worked in Florence and Milan, and spent his final years in France.

    Key Ideas

    1. Emphasis on Observation and Understanding

      • Leonardo believed artists needed to understand the world, not just copy its appearance.
      • He said an artist who paints without understanding is like a mirror that reflects without knowing what it's reflecting.

      Why it matters: This idea encouraged artists to study science and nature, leading to more accurate and insightful artworks.

    2. Scientific Approach to Art

      • Leonardo thought artists should start with experience (observation) and use that to understand the reasons behind what they see.

      Why it matters: This approach combined art and science in a new way, leading to innovations in both fields.

    3. Accurate Representation with Understanding

      • Leonardo wanted to represent nature accurately, but also to show the underlying laws and structures that govern it.

      Why it matters: This led to artworks that were not only realistic but also revealed deeper truths about their subjects.

    4. Focus on Truth Rather Than Idealized Beauty

      • Unlike some other Renaissance artists, Leonardo was more interested in depicting things truthfully than in making them look conventionally beautiful.

      Why it matters: This approach led to more varied and realistic depictions in art, moving away from idealized forms.

    5. Importance of Expressing the Soul

      • Leonardo believed artists should try to show the inner life of their subjects through gestures and expressions.

      Why it matters: This idea led to more psychologically complex and expressive portraits and figure paintings.

    6. Power of Images Over Words

      • Leonardo thought visual images could convey meaning more powerfully than words.

      Why it matters: This idea elevated the status of visual art as a means of communication and expression.

    5. Michelangelo (1475-1564)

    Background

    • Michelangelo was a sculptor, painter, architect, and poet, famous for works like the ceiling of the Sistine Chapel and the statue of David.
    • He worked mainly in Florence and Rome.

    Key Ideas

    1. Emphasis on Beauty

      • Michelangelo saw beauty as a reflection of the divine.
      • He believed that by creating beautiful art, he was in some way revealing God's beauty.

      Why it matters: This gave art a spiritual significance and motivated artists to strive for perfection in their work.

    2. Selective Approach to Beauty

      • Like many Renaissance artists, Michelangelo believed in selecting the most beautiful elements from nature to create idealized forms.

      Why it matters: This led to a style of art that was based on nature but more perfect than nature itself.

    3. Spiritual Yearning for Beauty

      • Michelangelo wrote about how beauty creates a longing in the observer.
      • He saw this longing as a spiritual experience, drawing people towards the divine.

      Why it matters: This idea connected art appreciation with spiritual experience, giving art a profound emotional and spiritual power.

    4. Concept of "Concetto"

      • This was the idea or intention in the artist's mind that guided the creation of the artwork.

      Why it matters: This concept emphasized the intellectual and creative role of the artist, seeing them as more than just a skilled craftsperson.

    5. Belief in Art's Power to Convey Eternal Beauty

      • Michelangelo thought that the artist could capture something of eternal, divine beauty in their work.

      Why it matters: This idea gave art a transcendent quality, suggesting it could connect viewers with something beyond the physical world.

    6. Giorgio Vasari (1511-1574)

    Background

    • Vasari was an artist himself, but is best known for his book "Lives of the Most Excellent Painters, Sculptors, and Architects."
    • He worked in various Italian cities and was a friend of Michelangelo.

    Key Contributions

    1. Historical Framework for Art

      • Vasari was one of the first to write a history of art, tracing its development over time.
      • He introduced the term "Renaissance" to describe the rebirth of art in his time.

      Why it matters: This helped people start thinking about art as something that changes and develops over time, laying the groundwork for art history as a discipline.

    2. Three Periods of Art

      • Vasari divided recent art history into three periods: a) First Period (14th century): Artists like Cimabue and Giotto, who began to move away from medieval styles. b) Second Period (15th century to early 16th century): Artists continued to develop new techniques and styles. c) Third Period (High Renaissance): Artists like Leonardo, Michelangelo, and Raphael, who Vasari saw as achieving perfection in art.

      Why it matters: This way of dividing art history into periods is still used (though modified) by art historians today.

    3. Emphasis on Rule, Order, Proportion, Design, and Style

      • Vasari believed these elements were crucial to creating great art.

      Why it matters: These ideas helped define what people considered "good art" for centuries to come.

    4. Concept of "Divine Grace" in Art

      • Vasari believed the best artists had a kind of divine inspiration that allowed them to create perfect beauty.

      Why it matters: This idea further elevated the status of artists, seeing them almost as divinely inspired geniuses rather than mere craftsmen.

    The High Renaissance: Raphael's "The School of Athens"

    Background

    • Painted by Raphael between 1509 and 1511.
    • It's a fresco (a type of wall painting) in the Apostolic Palace in the Vatican.
    • It was commissioned by Pope Julius II as part of a series of paintings for his private library.

    Key Features

    1. Composition

      • The painting is centered around two main figures: Plato and Aristotle.
      • Other philosophers and scientists from various periods are arranged around them.
      • The figures are set in a grand architectural space inspired by Roman buildings.

      Why it matters: This composition brings together the greatest thinkers of the ancient world, symbolizing the Renaissance's revival of classical learning.

    2. Perspective

      • Raphael uses linear perspective to create a convincing illusion of deep space.
      • The architecture's lines all converge at a point behind the central figures.

      Why it matters: This demonstrates the Renaissance mastery of perspective, which allowed for more realistic and complex compositions.

    3. Lighting

      • The light in the painting is clear and even, allowing each figure to be clearly seen.

      Why it matters: This lighting emphasizes the Renaissance focus on clarity and rational understanding.

    4. Symbolism

      • Plato points upward, representing his focus on abstract ideas.
      • Aristotle gestures to the earth, representing his interest in concrete observation.
      • Other figures represent different areas of knowledge: mathematics, music, astronomy, etc.

      Why it matters: This rich symbolism makes the painting a kind of visual encyclopedia of Renaissance knowledge and values.

    5. Portraits

      • Many of the ancient figures are actually portraits of Renaissance artists and thinkers.
      • For example, Plato is thought to be a portrait of Leonardo da Vinci.

      Why it matters: This connects the ancient world with the Renaissance present, suggesting that contemporary thinkers were equals to the ancients.

    Significance

    • "The School of Athens" embodies Renaissance ideals of harmony, balance, and the pursuit of knowledge.
    • It showcases Raphael's mastery of complex composition, perspective, and human anatomy.
    • The painting celebrates human knowledge and achievement, reflecting core Renaissance values.

    Mannerism: A Shift in Artistic Style (c. 1520-1600)

    What is Mannerism?

    • Mannerism was an artistic style that developed after the High Renaissance.
    • It moved away from the balanced, harmonious ideals of High Renaissance art.
    • The term comes from the Italian "maniera," meaning "style" or "manner."

    Characteristics

    1. Emphasis on Style Over Naturalism

      • Mannerist artists were less concerned with creating realistic representations.
      • They often distorted figures and spaces for dramatic effect.

      Why it matters: This shift showed that artists were becoming more interested in personal expression and stylistic experimentation.

    2. Exaggeration of Proportions and Poses

      • Figures might have unnaturally long limbs or be shown in complex, twisted poses.
      • Example: Parmigianino's "Madonna with the Long Neck"

      Why it matters: These exaggerations created a sense of tension and instability, moving away from Renaissance ideals of harmony and balance.

    3. Complex, Often Ambiguous Compositions

      • Mannerist paintings often have crowded, complex compositions.
      • Space might be unclear or contradictory.

      Why it matters: This complexity reflected a growing sense of uncertainty in European society, as religious and scientific ideas were being challenged.

    4. Heightened Emotionalism and Tension

      • Mannerist art often has a sense of drama or unease.
      • Figures might show extreme emotions or be in dynamic, unstable poses.

      Why it matters: This emotional intensity was a way for artists to explore and express complex psychological states.

    Key Ideas in Mannerist Theory

  8. Assistant

    Key Ideas in Mannerist Theory

    1. Rejection of Traditional Norms

      • Mannerist theorists challenged the established rules of proportion, perspective, and composition that had been emphasized during the High Renaissance.
      • They argued for greater artistic freedom and personal expression rather than strict adherence to classical ideals.

      Why it matters: This rejection of norms marked a significant shift in artistic philosophy, allowing artists to explore innovative approaches that reflected their individual styles and interpretations.

    2. The Role of Imagination (Disegno Interno)

      • Artists like Federico Zuccaro emphasized the importance of the artist's imagination, or disegno interno, which should guide the execution of their work.
      • This concept prioritized the internal vision of the artist over strict mimetic representation.

      Why it matters: The focus on imagination highlighted the creative process, positioning the artist as an innovator rather than merely an imitator of nature.

    3. Divine Inspiration and the Artist's Role

      • Mannerist thinkers often invoked Neoplatonic ideas, suggesting that the artist serves as a conduit for divine creativity.
      • Giovanni Paolo Lomazzo proposed that the inner idea or disegno in an artist's mind comes from a divine source and can manifest in their work.

      Why it matters: This belief elevated the status of artists, suggesting they engage in a spiritual dialogue through their creations, further enhancing the reverence for artistic expression.

    4. Exploration of Psychological Depth

      • Mannerist artists sought to capture the complexities of the human psyche, often utilizing exaggerated expressions and poses to convey deeper emotional truths.
      • This focus on emotion and individual experience diverged from the more idealized representations characteristic of the High Renaissance.

      Why it matters: This exploration of psychological depth allowed for a richer, more nuanced portrayal of human experience in art, paving the way for subsequent movements like the Baroque.

    5. Ambiguous Space and Narrative Complexity

      • Mannerist compositions often present ambiguous spatial relationships and complex narratives that invite viewers to engage more actively with the artwork.
      • The use of unexpected perspectives and crowded arrangements challenged traditional storytelling in visual art.

      Why it matters: This complexity encouraged viewers to interpret works in multiple ways, fostering a dynamic relationship between the observer and the artwork.

    Conclusion

    The Renaissance was a transformative period that not only revitalized interest in the classical world but also reshaped art and philosophy for centuries to come. Through the works and ideas of key figures such as Alberti, Leonardo, Michelangelo, and Vasari, artists explored new ways of understanding beauty, nature, and the human experience. In turn, the transition to Mannerism signified a shift toward personal expression and innovative artistic practices that would influence the path of Western art history.

    As we study this rich era, we come to appreciate how the Renaissance set the foundations for modern thought and creativity, reminding us of the enduring power of art to communicate deeper truths about our world and ourselves.

  9. User

    provide a markdown format pls

  10. Assistant

    Certainly! Here’s the continuation in markdown format, reflecting your original style:

    ### Key Ideas in Mannerist Theory
    
    1. **Rejection of Traditional Norms**
       - Mannerist theorists challenged the established rules of proportion, perspective, and composition that had been emphasized during the High Renaissance.
       - They argued for greater artistic freedom and personal expression rather than strict adherence to classical ideals.
    
       Why it matters: This rejection of norms marked a significant shift in artistic philosophy, allowing artists to explore innovative approaches that reflected their individual styles and interpretations.
    
    2. **The Role of Imagination (Disegno Interno)**
       - Artists like Federico Zuccaro emphasized the importance of the artist's imagination, or *disegno interno*, which should guide the execution of their work.
       - This concept prioritized the internal vision of the artist over strict mimetic representation.
    
       Why it matters: The focus on imagination highlighted the creative process, positioning the artist as an innovator rather than merely an imitator of nature.
    
    3. **Divine Inspiration and the Artist's Role**
       - Mannerist thinkers often invoked Neoplatonic ideas, suggesting that the artist serves as a conduit for divine creativity. 
       - Giovanni Paolo Lomazzo proposed that the inner idea or *disegno* in an artist's mind comes from a divine source and can manifest in their work.
    
       Why it matters: This belief elevated the status of artists, suggesting they engage in a spiritual dialogue through their creations, further enhancing the reverence for artistic expression.
    
    4. **Exploration of Psychological Depth**
       - Mannerist artists sought to capture the complexities of the human psyche, often utilizing exaggerated expressions and poses to convey deeper emotional truths.
       - This focus on emotion and individual experience diverged from the more idealized representations characteristic of the High Renaissance.
    
       Why it matters: This exploration of psychological depth allowed for a richer, more nuanced portrayal of human experience in art, paving the way for subsequent movements like the Baroque.
    
    5. **Ambiguous Space and Narrative Complexity**
       - Mannerist compositions often present ambiguous spatial relationships and complex narratives that invite viewers to engage more actively with the artwork.
       - The use of unexpected perspectives and crowded arrangements challenged traditional storytelling in visual art.
    
       Why it matters: This complexity encouraged viewers to interpret works in multiple ways, fostering a dynamic relationship between the observer and the artwork.
    
    ### Conclusion
    
    The Renaissance was a transformative period that not only revitalized interest in the classical world but also reshaped art and philosophy for centuries to come. Through the works and ideas of key figures such as Alberti, Leonardo, Michelangelo, and Vasari, artists explored new ways of understanding beauty, nature, and the human experience. In turn, the transition to Mannerism signified a shift toward personal expression and innovative artistic practices that would influence the path of Western art history.
    
    As we study this rich era, we come to appreciate how the Renaissance set the foundations for modern thought and creativity, reminding us of the enduring power of art to communicate deeper truths about our world and ourselves.
    

    Feel free to modify any part if needed!

  11. User

    Okay, next. still follow my note styling. I'm gonna send over a new lesson

  12. Assistant

    Sounds good! Please send over the new lesson, and I'll continue in the same note styling.

  13. User

    The Aesthetics of the Organism by Umberto Eco The expression 'aesthetics of the organism' fits Aquinas better than 'aesthetics of form' for the following reason. When Albertus Magnus referred to beauty as a resplendence of substantial form, he was clearly thinking of form as an entelechy, which actualizes the potentialities of matter, uniting with matter to compose a substance. Beauty was the irradiation of this organizing principle in the matter it unifies. In Aquinas, however, if we interpret the concepts of clarity, integrity, and proportion in the light of his whole philosophical system, we must conclude that 'form' in his theory of beauty has to do with a whole substance rather than with substantial form. What he had in mind was a concrete synthesis of matter and form, therefore a whole organism. The use of the term 'form' to mean 'substance' is fairly common in Aquinas. 'Form' is sometimes used in the superficial sense of morphe, or shape—that is, a quality of the fourth species, the quantitative boundary of a body, its tridimensional contour. Or it can mean the substantial form which achieves existence only when incorporated in matter, escaping thus from its essential abstractness. Or finally, it can signify an essentia—that is, a substance in so far as it is something comprehended and defined. It was characteristic of Aquinas's metaphysics that he should consider objects in their substantial concreteness. The orthodox Aristotelian position was to concentrate upon substantial form, and this orthodoxy had affinities also with Platonism. Platonism likes to isolate the idea in the sensible (or the idea as opposed to the sensible); it interprets the dialectic of idea and reality as a dialectic of things and their essences. The id quod est or ens is distinguished from the quo est, the conceptual essence. However, in an ontology of essences, there is always a tendency, however subterranean, to succumb to idealism, to the feeling that it is more important for a thing to be definable than to simply 'be there'. Now the novelty of Aquinas's ontology lies precisely here: he proposed an existential ontology, in which the primary value was ipsum esse, the concrete act of existence. He superimposed the constitutive and determining combination of essence and existence upon that of matter and form. For Aquinas, the quo est did not explain the ens; form without matter was nothing. But when, through divine participation, form and matter united in an act of existence, a relation was established between the organizing principle and what was organized. At this point, what counted was the whole subsistent organism, the substance whose proper act was ipsum esse. Being was no longer a mere accidental determination of essence, as it had been for Avicenna, but something which made the essence possible and actual, and also the substance of which it was the essence. The connection between form and substance was so profound, neither subsisting without the other, that for Aquinas the very term 'form' implied 'substance'—excepting, of course, the specific case where form and substance were being logically distinguished. Thus, the concept of essence or quidditas, of form conceived of as something formative, was redolent above all of the act of existing. In this ontology, the hyperuranic worlds were overtaken by life, and it is scarcely necessary to stress the radical import of this new Thomistic conception of things for the medieval mentality. Arnold Hauser has rightly drawn attention to its connection with the development of culture and of social relations: Page of 1 6 Organic life, which after the end of the ancient world had lost all meaning and value, once more comes to be honoured, and the individual things of experienced reality are henceforth made subjects of art without requiring some supernatural, other-worldly justification... The God who is present and working in all the orderings of nature corresponds to the attitude of a more liberal world in which the possibility of rising is not entirely excluded. The metaphysical hierarchy of things still reflects a society that is built up of estates, but the liberalism of the age already voices itself in the conception that even the lowest stage of being is in its own way indispensable. We must not, of course, desacralise the essentially theocentric universe of Aquinas; his ontology of concrete existence should always be interpreted in the light of the metaphysics of divine participation. But at the same time we must recognise the growth of naturalism and humanism in his philosophy. In the light of all this, we can turn now to the three criteria of beauty in Aquinas: integrity, proportion, and clarity. It seems reasonable to argue that they acquire their full meaning only when thought of as characteristics of a concrete substance, rather than of substantial form. And indeed, there are several illustrations of this view in the various meanings of the term ‘proportion'. One type of proportion is the appropriateness of matter to form, the adequacy of a potentiality to its organizing principle. In the Summa Contra Gentiles, Aquinas writes, "Thus, form and matter must always be mutually proportioned and, as it were, naturally adapted; for the proper act is produced in its proper matter." And in his Commentary on the De Anima, he emphasizes that proportion is not a mere attribute of substantial form but is the very relation itself between matter and form—to such a degree, in fact, that if matter is not disposed to receive the form, the form disappears. This sense of the term is of special interest in aesthetic experience, the object of which is a structural grace in things. Proportion can refer to another kind of relation, more metaphysical in character and beyond the reach of aesthetic experience. This is the relation of essence to existence, a proportion which, although it cannot be experienced aesthetically, makes aesthetic experience possible by giving concreteness to things. The other types of proportion are phenomenal consequences of this metaphysical proportion, and it is they which answer most directly to our aesthetic requirements. Aquinas mentions the ordinary sensuous and quantitative type of proportion, the proportion found in a sculpture or a melody. "Man," he says, "experiences pleasure in sensations... because they are pleasing in themselves... Thus he enjoys music..." He also talks of proportion in the sense of a purely intelligible decorum in moral behavior and in rational discourse, referring here to the intelligible beauty so admired by the Medievals: "spiritual beauty consists in conversation and actions that are well-proportioned in accordance with the spiritual light of reason.” This view is less perverse than it might sometimes seem to the modern mind. There is something Page of 2 6 of a return nowadays to the idea that there is an aesthetic quality in rational and practical activities, and in mathematical and logical reasoning. Aquinas refers also to a psychological type of proportion, the suitability of a thing for being experienced by a subject. This conception, which derived from Augustine and Boethius, has to do with the relation between the knower and the known. When we reflect upon the objective and rule-governed character of perceived phenomena, we discover our own connaturality with their proportions, that there are proportions also in ourselves. Thus, proportion is conceived of as something objective, something realized on an infinite number of levels, and something which finally coincides with the cosmic proportions of an ordered universe. In his discussion of visual proportion Aquinas reverts to the type of cosmological theory which we looked at earlier; but his descriptions of the cosmic order possess a certain personal vigour and originality of tone.” There is one further type of proportion which is of central importance in Aquinas's aesthetics, and is a constant in medieval aesthetics. This is proportion in the sense of the adequacy of a thing to itself and to its function. The Scholastics reterred to it as the ‘first perfection' (perfectio prima), the adequacy of a thing both to its species and to its own individual nature. "For it is evident", Aquinas writes, ‘that everything in nature has a certain end, and a fixed rule of size and growth…’ Thus, people may differ from one another in size and shape, but if the variations go beyond certain limits there is no longer a true and proper human nature, but abnormality instead. This kind of perfection is related to another criterion of beauty, integrity. Integritas means the presence in an organic whole of all the parts which concur in defining it as that which it is. The human body, for instance, is deformed if a limb is missing: 'wecall mutilated people ugly, for they lack the required proportion of parts to the whole', " Clearly these are principles of an aesthetics of the organism in every sense, and they are not without interest nowadays in a phenomenology of artistic form. However, Aquinas's concept of first perfection is rather limited when he refers it to art: a work of art, he says, is complete it it is adequate to the idea in the mind of its maker. When the first perfection is present in a thing, it is then adequate to its proper end. It also acquires the 'second perfection' (perfectio secunda), which means that it operates in accordance with its proper finality, Furthermore, the second perfection regulates the first perfection, because if a thing is to be truly complete its structure should accord with its function: the end is operative before anything else... for an effective action is complete only through its end’. The efficient cause constructs a thing in accordance with its end. For this reason, a work of art (of ars that is - human making in general) is beautiful if it is functional, it its form is adequate to its scope. ‘’Every craftsman aims to produce the best work that he can, not in a simple manner, but by reference to the end.’’ If an artist made a saw out of glass it would be ugly despite the beauty of its appearance, because it could not fulfill its cutting function. The human body is beautiful because it is constructed with an appropriate distribution of parts: 'I claim therefore that God disposes the human body in the best possible fashion as being appropriate to its form and operations'." The human Page of 3 6 organism sustains a complex arrangement of relations between the forces of mind and body, the higher and the lower powers, so that all its features are there for precise reasons. There are functional reasons why the human senses, with the exception of the sense of touch, are less developed than those of other animals: for example, his sense of smell is weak because smell thrives in conditions of dryness, and the large size of the human brain creates humidity - a humidity necessary to cope with the heat given off by the heart. Man has no feathers, horns or claws because these are things that show a preponderance of the terrestrial in animals, while in man the terrestrial is balanced by other elements. By way of compensation man has hands, the organum organorum, which make up for every other deficiency, Finally, man is beautiful because of his erect posture. He is made this way because if his head were in an inclined position it would interfere with the sensitive internal forces centred in the brain; also because his hands need not be used for locomotion and so are freed for their own business; fin- ally, because if men had to grasp food with their mouths their linguistic capacities would be impaired. For all these reasons man is erect, and is thus enabled to use his most noble sense, the sense of sight, 'to freely acquire knowledge of every kind of sensible object, both in the skies and on the earth'." He can cast his eye at will over the earth and its beauty. Only man can enjoy the beauty of sensible objects for its own sake (solus homo delectatur in pulchritudine sensibilium secundum seipsam)." In this account of the human body, it is clear that its aesthetic value and its functional value are one and the same. The scientific principles of the age were also its principles of beauty. Aquinas's functionalist theory of beauty gave systematic expression to a sentiment which was very characteristic of the Middle Ages as a whole. This was its tendency to identify the beautiful and the useful, an identification which itself originated in the equation of the beautiful and the good. The identity of beauty and use seemed to be required in many of their life experiences, even when they were trying to distinguish theoretically between them. Here again we must refer to their integrated sensibility. In fact the difficulty which they had in distinguishing beauty and function shows how there was an aesthetic element in every department of life. They could no more subordinate beauty to goodness or use than they could subordinate goodness and use to beauty. Whenever contemporary man finds that art and morality are in conflict, this occurs because he is trying to reconcile a modern conception of the aesthetic with a classical conception of the moral. The present-day problem of integration (without entering here into the merits of the question) takes the form of a revision of traditional ideas to see which of them still have a value in our historical situation, and which of them have lost their significance for us. For the Medievals, a thing was ugly if it did not relate to a hierarchy of ends centred on man and his supernatural destiny; and this in turn was because of a structural imperfection which rendered it inadequate for its function. It was a type of integrated sensibility which made it hard for the Medievals to experience aesthetic pleasure in anything which fell short of their ethical ideals; and conversely, whatever gave aesthetic pleasure was also morally justified, in cases where this was relevant. Page of 4 6 In practice, they did not express this sensibility in a perfect and balanced manner. On the one hand there was someone like St. Bernard, who liked gargoyles but rejected them because of his excessive strictness. On the other hand there were the goliardic songs; or there was Aucassin preferring to follow Nicolette to the underworld rather than live in a paradise for ancient dotards. However, neither was any more 'medieval' than the other. They were departures from the ideal, but the philosophy of first and second perfections represented a kind of optimum cultivated by the Medievals within varying schemes of values. The Thomistic theory was too pure to find its unequivocal counterpart in concrete acts of taste and judgment, but it did express, on a deontological level, the fundamental co-ordinates of a civilisation and its conventions. Confident in the soundness of his philosophy, Aquinas could even grant a certain autonomy to art: ‘for a craftsman, as such, is commendable not because of his intentions, but because of the work he produces’. The moral intention is discounted here. What matters is that the object should be well made, and it is well made if it is positive in all its aspects. An artist might construct a building with perverse intentions, but there is no reason why it should not be aesthetically perfect and good so long as it fulfills its function. A sculptor might, with the best intention in the world, create an immodest work liable to disturb someone's moral balance. In such a case, the Prince should banish the work from the City; for the City is founded on an organic integration of ends and cannot tolerate any disturbance of its integritas." The rhythm of morality is ruled by an aesthetic principle. All of this, as we have seen, is grounded on the principle that the bearer of aesthetic value is the concrete organism in all the complexity of its relations. As a consequence, the concept of clarity, or splendor, or light, has quite a different meaning in Aquinas from what it meant for the neo-Platonists, for instance. In neo-Platonism, light descended from above and diffused itself creatively in the world; it gathered and solidified in things. But Aquinas held that clarity rises from below, from the heart of things. It is the organizing form manifesting itself. Physical light is 'a consequence of the substantial form of the sun'; the clarity of glorified bodies is the luminosity of the soul in its blessedness, overflowing throughout the physical body; and the clarity of Christ's transfigured body 'overflows from His soul'. Thus, the color and luminosity of bodies are produced by bodies when they are correctly structured according to their natural needs. But on the ontological level, claritas refers to the expressive capacity of organisms. It is, as someone put it, the radioactivity of the form of things. Claritas is the one principle of expressiveness in medieval times which could fill the place occupied nowadays by such concepts as lyricism or symbolism or the iconicity of form. An organism which is fully perceived and grasped reveals its organic nature, and the intellect can enjoy the beauty of its discipline and order. This ontological expressiveness is not something that exists even when it is not an object of knowledge; rather, it becomes real and manifest when the visio focuses upon it, a form of disinterested observation which regards the object under the aspect of its formal cause. The object is ontologically predisposed to be judged as beautiful. But the judgment is not made until the observer, conscious of the proportion between himself and the object, and aware of all the Page of 5 6 properties of the completed organism, enjoys the resplendence of this completeness fully and freely for himself. Ontologically, claritas is clarity 'in itself', and it becomes aesthetic clarity or clarity 'for us' in a specific perception of it. It follows that the aesthetic visio is for Aquinas an act of judgment. It entails activities of collocating and distinguishing, the measurement of parts with respect to the whole, studies of how the matter lends itself to the form, an awareness of purposes and of how adequately they are fulfilled. Aesthetic perception is not an instantaneous intuition but a 'dialogue' with its object. The dynamism of the act of judgment corresponds to the dynamism of the act of organized existence which is the object of judgment. In this connection, Aquinas writes, "To say that the appetite desires the good, and peace, and the beautiful, is not to say that it desires different things." By peace, he means the tranquillity of order (tranquillitas ordinis). After the travail of the act of discursive understanding, the intellect rejoices at the vision of an order and integrity which are manifest in their own clear presence. More than just pleasure, there is peace, peace which 'causes the removal of disorder and of obstacles to the good'. The pleasure experienced in perception is a free pleasure, the pleasure of contemplation free from desire and content with the perfection which it admires. Beauty is what pleases when it is seen, not because it is intuited without effort but because it is through effort that it is won, and when the effort is successful it is enjoyed. We take pleasure in knowledge which has overcome the obstacles in its path and so brought about the quiescence of desire. This part of the Thomistic philosophy represents the highest point in medieval intellectualism. It is clear that nothing could be further from certain modern theories of aesthetic intuition. But it is still of value nowadays, for its basic conception of aesthetic experience is of something active, discriminating, and critical.

  14. Assistant

    Here’s your lesson formatted in markdown, following your established note styling:

    # The Aesthetics of the Organism by Umberto Eco
    
    ## Introduction
    
    The expression 'aesthetics of the organism' fits Aquinas better than 'aesthetics of form' for the following reason. When Albertus Magnus referred to beauty as a resplendence of substantial form, he was clearly thinking of form as an entelechy, which actualizes the potentialities of matter, uniting with matter to compose a substance. Beauty was the irradiation of this organizing principle in the matter it unifies. In Aquinas, however, if we interpret the concepts of clarity, integrity, and proportion in the light of his whole philosophical system, we must conclude that 'form' in his theory of beauty has to do with a whole substance rather than with substantial form. What he had in mind was a concrete synthesis of matter and form, therefore a whole organism.
    
    ### The Meaning of 'Form' in Aquinas
    - The term 'form' can mean various things:
      - **Shape (morphe):** A quality of the body, its tridimensional contour.
      - **Substantial form:** Achieves existence only when incorporated in matter, escaping essential abstractness.
      - **Essentia:** A substance defined in terms of comprehension and definition.
    
    - Aquinas's metaphysics focuses on substantial concreteness, contrasting with the orthodox Aristotelian focus on substantial form, which relates more to isolated ideas rather than concrete realities.
    
    ### Existential Ontology
    - Aquinas proposed an existential ontology where the primary value is **ipsum esse**, the concrete act of existence.
    - The combination of essence and existence becomes crucial, establishing a relation between the organizing principle (form) and what is organized (substance).
      
    Why this matters: This concept innovates traditional views by placing existence at the forefront of metaphysical inquiry.
    
    ## Criteria of Beauty in Aquinas
    ### Three key criteria:
    1. **Integrity**
       - Refers to the presence of all necessary parts defining an organic whole.
       - For example, a human body is considered deformed if a limb is missing.
      
    2. **Proportion**
       - Can denote various relations:
         - **Appropriateness of matter to form:** Ensures that potentialities are aligned with the organizing principle.
         - **Relation of essence to existence:** A more metaphysical proportion that undergirds aesthetic experience.
         - **Sensuous and quantitative proportion:** Found in artistic forms like sculpture or music.
    
    3. **Clarity**
       - Refers to the expressiveness and luminous quality of an organism.
       - Clarity is seen as the organizing form manifesting itself, reflecting beauty stemming from correct structure according to natural needs.
    
    ### Additional Insights
    - Aquinas's metaphysics recognizes the value of organic life, elevating individual experiences to subjects of art.
    - The aesthetic experience combines clarity with integrity, leading to a deeper appreciation of beauty in lived reality.
      
    ## Functionalist Theory of Beauty
    - Aquinas's approach aligns beauty with utility; the beautiful is also the useful, originating from the equation of beauty with the good.
      
    ### Implications
    - A work of art must be functional—the construction must align with its intended purpose. For example, a glass saw is deemed ugly despite its visual beauty if it fails to perform its intended function.
    
    - The beauty of the human body derives from its appropriate distribution of parts and inherent functional relationships.
    
    ### Integration of Aesthetic and Functional Values
    - Aquinas discerned an integration of aesthetic values: things are ugly if they lack hierarchical significance and function.
      
    ### Application to Art and Morality
    - Aquinas distinguished between moral intentions and aesthetic achievements, suggesting that an object can be beautiful regardless of the artist's intentions, provided it fulfills its function effectively.
    
    ### Clarity as Expressiveness
    - Clarity transitions from an ontological to an aesthetic attribute, realized in perception, which depends upon the intellectual engagement with the object.
    
    ## Conclusion
    - Aquinas's aesthetics represents a peak in medieval intellectualism, emphasizing an active, discerning nature in aesthetic experience.
    - This view remains valuable today as it challenges modern theories of aesthetic intuition, advocating for a critical and engaged approach to beauty.
    
    

    Feel free to let me know if you need any modifications or additional sections!