Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
o1-mini-2024-09-12· OpenAIAi2 WildChat-4.8M (AI2)

If I have N people, each with a single pool of entropy, and I pool each of their…

  1. User

    If I have N people, each with a single pool of entropy, and I pool each of their contributions together with XOR, is that as good as it gets?

    My assumptions are:

    • I trust no single person and their source of entropy.

    • I trust at least one person + pool.

    • Entropy by its definition is independent and is private (but it is worth stating these, as any leaks will kill us!)

    • Efficiency is not a concern, we just expand the pool size (each pool is size X, and the result is size X).

    • The people have ordinary skill.

    now to respond to the questions:

    1. I am assuming that at least one pool is good entropy. This is partly an assumption of desperation or simplicity.

    In practice, no individual (source or person) is trusted at an isolated level. But this leads to a sort of circular argument that says, nobody is trusted. We can solve this two ways:

    I join the circle.  I trust myself, *but* I don't trust
    my source of entropy.  So this is still hopeful.
    
    We ensure that there are at least two cartels in the
    circle that don't trust each other!  Then, add a dash
    of game theory, and the two cartel pools should at
    least be independent of each other, and therefore the
    result should be good entropy.
    

    I suspect others could more logically arrive at a better assumption, but for now, the assumption of one trusted person/pool seems to cover it.

    1. Having thought about Stephan's comment a bit more (because it arrived first), and a bit more about John D's entropy comments (because they were precise), it is clear that I need to stress the privacy / independence criteria, even if strictly covered by the definition of entropy. Too much of the practical aspects will depend on ensuring independence of the pools to just lean blithely on the definitions. I had missed that dependency.

    2. The proposals on concatenation and cleanup are tempting. In Jon's words, it can solve obvious problems. However, they introduce a complexity of understanding the cleanup function, and potential for failures. Jack's tradeoffs. This has made me realise the last assumption, now added:

    The people have ordinary skill.

    Which means they are unable to determine whether a cryptographically complex cleanup function is indeed cleaning, or not.

    Here, then, we reach an obvious limit, in that the people have to be able to determine that the XOR is doing its job, and they need to be able to do a bit of research to decide what is their best guess at their private entropy source.

  2. Assistant

    Pooling entropy from multiple independent sources is a fundamental aspect of creating robust and secure random number generators, especially in distributed or multi-party environments. Your approach of using XOR to combine entropy contributions from N individuals has merit, especially given your outlined assumptions. Here's a detailed analysis addressing your points and considerations for ensuring the robustness of your entropy pool.

    1. Trust Model and Assumptions

    Assumptions Recap:

    • No Trusted Individual Entropy Sources: No single person's entropy source is fully trusted.
    • At Least One Trusted Pool: You trust that at least one person's entropy source is good.
    • Entropy Independence and Privacy: Each entropy source is independent and remains private.
    • Efficiency is Secondary: Focus is on entropy quality, not computational efficiency.
    • Ordinary Skill Level: Participants have standard technical skills without expertise in cryptography.

    Analysis:

    • XOR as an Entropy Combiner: XOR is a simple and effective method for combining multiple entropy sources under the condition that at least one source is truly random and unknown to adversaries. If any single input to the XOR operation is genuinely random and secret, the output remains unpredictable regardless of the other inputs.

    • Trust Assurance: By assuming that at least one pool is trustworthy and contains high-quality entropy, using XOR ensures that the final pooled entropy maintains its randomness even if other sources are compromised or have poor entropy.

    2. Ensuring Entropy Quality and Independence

    Privacy and Independence:

    • Entropy Leakage Risks: Ensuring that each participant's entropy source remains private is crucial. Any leakage or correlation between sources can compromise the overall entropy pool.

    • Independent Sources: It’s vital that each entropy source is independent. Correlated sources can reduce the overall entropy, making the pooled result weaker than expected.

    Mitigation Strategies:

    • Source Validation: Encourage or enforce best practices for entropy generation among participants, such as using hardware-based random number generators or high-entropy software-based sources.

    • Regular Audits: Periodically validate the entropy sources to ensure continued independence and quality.

    3. XOR vs. Other Entropy Pooling Methods

    Advantages of XOR:

    • Simplicity: XOR is easy to implement and understand, reducing the complexity required for participants with ordinary skills.

    • Provable Security: As long as at least one source is truly random, XOR maintains the unpredictability of the output.

    Potential Alternatives:

    • Cryptographic Hash Functions: Using a hash function (like SHA-256) to combine entropy sources can provide additional security, especially against scenarios where multiple sources might be partially compromised. However, this introduces complexity that might not align with your assumption of ordinary skill levels among participants.

    • Verifiable Random Functions (VRFs): For higher security needs, VRFs can provide both randomness and proof of its generation process, but this again adds significant complexity.

    Conclusion on XOR: Given your constraints and assumptions, XORing the entropy sources is a suitable and effective method. It balances security with simplicity, ensuring that the pooled entropy maintains its strength without introducing unnecessary complexity.

    4. Addressing Practical Considerations

    Human Factors:

    • Understanding XOR's Role: Ensure that all participants understand the importance of their entropy contributions and the role of XOR in maintaining the pool's security. Educate them on not compromising their entropy sources.

    • Entropy Source Selection: Assist participants in choosing reliable entropy sources. Provide guidelines or recommended tools that are user-friendly and secure.

    Operational Security:

    • Secure Communication: When pooling the entropy, ensure that the methods of transmission are secure to prevent interception or tampering.

    • Monitoring and Maintenance: Implement monitoring to detect any anomalies in the entropy pool, such as sudden drops in entropy quality or unexpected patterns.

    5. Potential Enhancements

    While XORing provides a solid foundation, consider the following enhancements to bolster your entropy pooling strategy:

    • Layered Pooling: After XORing, you might pass the result through a simple cryptographic transformation (like a hash) to further diffuse any potential biases or patterns, provided that the added complexity is manageable for your participants.

    • Threshold Requirements: Instead of just trusting that at least one source is good, you can define a threshold (e.g., at least k out of N sources are good). This increases the resilience of the pool against multiple compromised sources.

    • Diverse Sources: Encourage diversity in entropy sources (e.g., combining hardware randomness with user input randomness) to minimize correlated entropy weaknesses.

    Final Recommendation

    Under your specified assumptions, XORing each individual's entropy contribution is a robust and straightforward method for pooling entropy. It leverages simplicity while maintaining strong security guarantees, provided that:

    • At least one entropy source is genuinely random and secure.
    • All sources remain independent and private.
    • Participants adhere to best practices in entropy generation and handling.

    By focusing on these areas and considering the potential enhancements for future scalability or increased security needs, your entropy pooling mechanism should serve your requirements effectively.