I ran explain analyse on mysql query: -> Limit: 2000 row(s) (cost=2530 rows=1) (actual…
- User
I ran explain analyse on mysql query: -> Limit: 2000 row(s) (cost=2530 rows=1) (actual time=1355..1355 rows=1 loops=1) -> Aggregate: avg(r.nps_score) (cost=2530 rows=1) (actual time=1355..1355 rows=1 loops=1) -> Nested loop left join (cost=2434 rows=952) (actual time=11.4..1351 rows=23355 loops=1) -> Nested loop left join (cost=2315 rows=239) (actual time=9.32..1235 rows=23355 loops=1) -> Nested loop left join (cost=2285 rows=239) (actual time=9.31..1192 rows=23355 loops=1) -> Nested loop left join (cost=2256 rows=239) (actual time=9.3..1161 rows=23355 loops=1) -> Filter: (s.discarded_at is null) (cost=2226 rows=239) (actual time=9.28..1107 rows=23355 loops=1) -> Nested loop left join (cost=2226 rows=239) (actual time=9.28..1104 rows=23377 loops=1) -> Nested loop left join (cost=1802 rows=239) (actual time=7.74..1048 rows=23377 loops=1) -> Nested loop inner join (cost=1545 rows=239) (actual time=7.23..985 rows=23377 loops=1) -> Nested loop inner join (cost=1106 rows=477) (actual time=6.65..807 rows=23377 loops=1) -> Nested loop inner join (cost=64.2 rows=18) (actual time=0.247..2.14 rows=245 loops=1) -> Covering index lookup on d using index_drivers_on_key (key='manager_support') (cost=1.1 rows=1) (actual time=0.0216..0.0269 rows=1 loops=1) -> Filter: (q.question_type = 'nps') (cost=46.9 rows=18) (actual time=0.225..2.09 rows=245 loops=1) -> Index lookup on q using index_questions_on_driver_id (driver_id=d.id) (cost=46.9 rows=180) (actual time=0.222..1.87 rows=362 loops=1) -> Filter: ((r.nps_score is not null) and (r.discarded_at is null) and (r.employee_chat_id is not null)) (cost=52.1 rows=26.5) (actual time=0.782..3.28 rows=95.4 loops=245) -> Index lookup on r using index_responses_on_question_id (question_id=q.id) (cost=52.1 rows=58.8) (actual time=0.782..3.26 rows=95.6 loops=245) -> Filter: (ec.discarded_at is null) (cost=0.822 rows=0.5) (actual time=0.00732..0.00742 rows=1 loops=23377) -> Single-row index lookup on ec using PRIMARY (id=r.employee_chat_id) (cost=0.822 rows=1) (actual time=0.00715..0.00719 rows=1 loops=23377) -> Filter: (r.option_id = op.id) (cost=0.977 rows=1) (actual time=0.0024..0.00251 rows=0.999 loops=23377) -> Single-row covering index lookup on op using PRIMARY (id=r.option_id) (cost=0.977 rows=1) (actual time=0.00221..0.00225 rows=0.999 loops=23377) -> Single-row index lookup on s using PRIMARY (id=ec.schedule_id) (cost=0.775 rows=1) (actual time=0.00217..0.0022 rows=1 loops=23377) -> Single-row index lookup on e using PRIMARY (id=ec.employee_id) (cost=0.254 rows=1) (actual time=0.00211..0.00214 rows=1 loops=23355) -> Single-row covering index lookup on dp using PRIMARY (id=e.department_id) (cost=0.254 rows=1) (actual time=0.0011..0.00113 rows=0.977 loops=23355) -> Single-row covering index lookup on m using PRIMARY (id=e.manager_id) (cost=0.254 rows=1) (actual time=0.00161..0.00164 rows=0.968 loops=23355) -> Filter: <in_optimizer>(p1.id,(select #4)) (cost=1.02 rows=3.99) (actual time=0.00472..0.00477 rows=0.0603 loops=23355) -> Covering index lookup on p1 using index_performance_ratings_on_employee_id (employee_id=e.id) (cost=1.02 rows=3.99) (actual time=0.00167..0.00179 rows=0.384 loops=23355) -> Select #4 (subquery in condition; dependent) -> Limit: 1 row(s) (cost=1.8 rows=1) (actual time=0.00674..0.00675 rows=0.157 loops=8975) -> Filter: ((p1.id) = <ref_null_helper>(max(p2.id))) (cost=1.8 rows=2) (actual time=0.00661..0.00661 rows=0.157 loops=8975) -> Group aggregate: max(p2.id) (cost=1.8 rows=2) (actual time=0.00635..0.00638 rows=1 loops=8975) -> Covering index lookup on p2 using index_performance_ratings_on_employee_id (employee_id=p1.employee_id) (cost=1.41 rows=3.99) (actual time=0.00291..0.00518 rows=7.87 loops=8975)
My query: SELECT avg(nps_score) as benchmark FROM engagement_analysis WHERE engagement_analysis.driverKey = 'manager_support' AND engagement_analysis.question_type = 'nps' AND engagement_analysis.nps_score IS NOT NULL can you help me understand the results here?
- Assistant
Sure, I'd be happy to help you understand the
EXPLAIN ANALYZEresults for your MySQL query.Your Query:
SELECT avg(nps_score) as benchmark FROM engagement_analysis WHERE engagement_analysis.driverKey = 'manager_support' AND engagement_analysis.question_type = 'nps' AND engagement_analysis.nps_score IS NOT NULL;This query calculates the average
nps_scorefromengagement_analysiswhere thedriverKeyis'manager_support', thequestion_typeis'nps', and thenps_scoreis not null.Understanding the Execution Plan:
The execution plan you've provided is detailed and shows how MySQL executes your query step by step. Let's break it down to understand what's happening at each stage.
-
Aggregate Function (
avg(nps_score)):-> Aggregate: avg(r.nps_score) (cost=2530 rows=1) (actual time=1355..1355 rows=1 loops=1)- Explanation: MySQL computes the average
nps_scoreby aggregating the results obtained from the nested loop joins below. - Actual Time: The aggregation step takes approximately 1355 milliseconds.
- Rows: Only one row is returned, which is the computed average.
- Explanation: MySQL computes the average
-
Nested Loop Joins:
The bulk of the execution plan involves nested loop joins. This means that for each row in one table, MySQL loops through matching rows in the joined table.
-
Joins Involved:
- Drivers (d)
- Questions (q)
- Responses (r)
- Employee Chats (ec)
- Employees (e)
- Departments (dp)
- Managers (m)
- Performance Ratings (p1 and p2)
-
-
Breaking Down the Steps:
a. Starting with Drivers (
d):-> Covering index lookup on d using index_drivers_on_key (key='manager_support') (cost=1.1 rows=1) (actual time=0.0216..0.0269 rows=1 loops=1)- Explanation: MySQL uses the index on the
driverstable to find the driver withkey = 'manager_support'. - Actual Time: This step is very fast, taking only about 0.02 milliseconds.
- Rows: Only one driver is matched.
b. Joining with Questions (
q):-> Index lookup on q using index_questions_on_driver_id (driver_id=d.id) (cost=46.9 rows=180) (actual time=0.222..1.87 rows=362 loops=1)- Explanation: For the matched driver, MySQL retrieves all associated questions using the
driver_id. - Actual Time: This step takes between 0.222 to 1.87 milliseconds.
- Rows: 362 questions are retrieved.
c. Filtering Questions by
question_type = 'nps':-> Filter: (q.question_type = 'nps') (cost=46.9 rows=18) (actual time=0.225..2.09 rows=245 loops=1)- Explanation: Out of the questions retrieved, MySQL filters them to keep only those where
question_type = 'nps'. - Actual Time: This filtering takes up to 2.09 milliseconds.
- Rows: 245 questions remain after filtering.
d. Joining with Responses (
r):-> Index lookup on r using index_responses_on_question_id (question_id=q.id) (cost=52.1 rows=58.8) (actual time=0.782..3.26 rows=95.6 loops=245)- Explanation: For each of the 245 questions, MySQL retrieves responses using the
question_id. - Actual Time: Each loop takes between 0.782 to 3.26 milliseconds.
- Rows: On average, 95.6 responses are retrieved per loop, totaling approximately 23,422 responses.
e. Filtering Responses:
-> Filter: ((r.nps_score is not null) and (r.discarded_at is null) and (r.employee_chat_id is not null)) (cost=52.1 rows=26.5) (actual time=0.782..3.28 rows=95.4 loops=245)- Explanation: Responses are filtered to include only those where
nps_scoreis not null,discarded_atis null, andemployee_chat_idis not null. - Rows: After filtering, approximately 95.4 responses remain per loop.
f. Joining with Employee Chats (
ec):-> Single-row index lookup on ec using PRIMARY (id=r.employee_chat_id) (cost=0.822 rows=1) (actual time=0.00715..0.00719 rows=1 loops=23377) -> Filter: (ec.discarded_at is null) (cost=0.822 rows=0.5) (actual time=0.00732..0.00742 rows=1 loops=23377)- Explanation: For each response, MySQL retrieves the associated employee chat where
discarded_atis null. - Loops: This step loops 23,377 times (once for each response).
g. Joining with Employees (
e):-> Single-row index lookup on e using PRIMARY (id=ec.employee_id) (cost=0.254 rows=1) (actual time=0.00211..0.00214 rows=1 loops=23355)- Explanation: Retrieves the employee associated with each employee chat.
- Loops: This loops 23,355 times.
h. Joining with Departments (
dp) and Managers (m):-> Single-row covering index lookup on dp using PRIMARY (id=e.department_id) (cost=0.254 rows=1) (actual time=0.0011..0.00113 rows=0.977 loops=23355) -> Single-row covering index lookup on m using PRIMARY (id=e.manager_id) (cost=0.254 rows=1) (actual time=0.00161..0.00164 rows=0.968 loops=23355)- Explanation: For each employee, MySQL retrieves the associated department and manager.
i. Joining with Performance Ratings (
p1andp2):-> Covering index lookup on p1 using index_performance_ratings_on_employee_id (employee_id=e.id) (cost=1.02 rows=3.99) (actual time=0.00167..0.00179 rows=0.384 loops=23355) -> Filter: <in_optimizer>(p1.id,<exists>(select #4)) (cost=1.02 rows=3.99) (actual time=0.00472..0.00477 rows=0.0603 loops=23355)-
Explanation: MySQL looks up performance ratings for each employee and filters them to include only relevant entries.
-
Subquery: There's a dependent subquery that retrieves the maximum
p2.idfor each employee.-> Select #4 (subquery in condition; dependent) -> Limit: 1 row(s) (cost=1.8 rows=1) (actual time=0.00674..0.00675 rows=0.157 loops=8975) -> Filter: (<cache>(p1.id) = <ref_null_helper>(max(p2.id))) (cost=1.8 rows=2) (actual time=0.00661..0.00661 rows=0.157 loops=8975) -> Group aggregate: max(p2.id) (cost=1.8 rows=2) (actual time=0.00635..0.00638 rows=1 loops=8975) -> Covering index lookup on p2 using index_performance_ratings_on_employee_id (employee_id=p1.employee_id) (cost=1.41 rows=3.99) (actual time=0.00291..0.00518 rows=7.87 loops=8975) -
Explanation: The subquery finds the latest performance rating (
max(p2.id)) for each employee.
- Explanation: MySQL uses the index on the
-
Final Aggregation:
After all the joins and filtering, MySQL aggregates the
nps_scorevalues to compute the average.
Key Metrics to Notice:
-
Total Execution Time: The entire query takes approximately 1355 milliseconds (1.355 seconds) to execute.
-
Row Counts and Loops:
- The query processes a significant number of records due to the nested loops.
- For example, the join with responses (
r) loops 245 times (once for each question) and processes around 95 rows per loop, totaling over 23,000 rows.
Potential Areas for Optimization:
-
Review Indexes:
- Ensure that indexes are properly defined on all columns used in JOIN conditions and WHERE clauses.
- Indexes on
question_id,employee_chat_id,employee_id, etc., can significantly improve performance.
-
Optimize Joins:
- Nested loop joins can be inefficient with large datasets.
- Consider restructuring queries or indexing to allow for more efficient join methods (e.g., hash joins if supported).
-
Simplify Subqueries:
- The dependent subquery involving performance ratings (
p1andp2) may be causing performance issues. - Investigate whether this subquery can be rewritten or optimized.
- The dependent subquery involving performance ratings (
-
Consider Query Refactoring:
- Examine if the query can be rewritten to reduce complexity.
- Possibly denormalize some data or use temporary tables if appropriate.
-
Assess Data Volume:
- If the
engagement_analysisview is based on large underlying tables, consider whether all joins are necessary for this query. - Limiting the data early in the query (e.g., filtering before joins) can reduce the amount of data processed.
- If the
Conclusion:
The execution plan shows that your query involves multiple nested joins and processes a large number of rows, leading to a total execution time of about 1.355 seconds. By reviewing indexes and possibly restructuring the query to reduce the number of nested loops and optimize subqueries, you may improve performance.
Next Steps:
- Profile Each Step: Use
EXPLAINon parts of the query to identify bottlenecks. - Adjust Indexes: Ensure all necessary indexes are in place.
- Rewrite Complex Joins or Subqueries: Simplify where possible.
- Test Performance Improvements: After making changes, test to see if execution time improves.
Let me know if you need further clarification on any specific part of the execution plan or if you'd like assistance in optimizing the query further!
-