Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
gpt-4o-2024-08-06· OpenAIAi2 WildChat-4.8M (AI2)

18. What is translation ranking? Give definitions and examples Translation ranking-…

  1. User
    1. What is translation ranking? Give definitions and examples Translation ranking- translation; translated work; moving; shift; recalculation of some measures or other units; forward movement; broadcast; conversion from one unit to another; recalculation of some other measures; Arrangement; transfer; translation; incarnation

    2. What translation ranks do you know? Give definitions and examples Catford's approach to translation equivalence clearly differs from that adopted by Nida since Catford had a preference for a more linguistic-based approach to translation and this approach is based on the linguistic work of Firth and Halliday. His main contribution in the field of translation theory is the introduction of the concepts of types and shifts of translation. Catford proposed very broad types of translation in terms of three criteria:

    The extent of translation (full translation vs partial translation);

    The grammatical rank at which the translation equivalence is established (rank-bound translation vs. unbounded translation);

    The levels of language involved in translation (total translation vs. restricted translation).

    1. What relationship is there between the approaches to translation and types of translation? Basic problem: translations are assumed to be somehow “the same” as the original, but they are obviously different. What does “equivalence” mean?

    • Six steps in the debate:

    Early Bible translation: equivalence must be understood as sameness. Translation must be possible.

    Modern semiotics: translation is always possible (depending on what you mean by translation....)

    The problem of untranslatability. Can meaning be separated from form? Absolutely the “same” meaning is (usually / often / sometimes ) impossible. The claim that there are no stable meanings (cf. deconstruction, postmodernism).

    Equivalence is better understood as similarity, relevant similarity, not sameness or identity. Two texts can be “similar” in very many ways.

    There are several basic types of equivalence: concerning form, meaning, style, desired effect...

    Each translation task requires its own hierarchy of equivalence: what are the priorities for this particular translation? Depends on aim and context.

    Conclusion: equivalence is produced by the translator, it is claimed. This claim may or may not be accepted by the client, by readers.

    Various ranks of translation; means to ensure adequate translation which have been suggested by dif­ferent scholars and translation ranks;

    fields of application and hierarchy of transformational, denotative and communicational approaches depending on type of translation;

    priorities in training translators;

    meaning, equivalence and extralinguistic information as three basic com­ponents of translation;

    the use of different approaches depending on translation variety.

    Even in routine translation practice one can see that there are differ­ent ranks of translation, that one rank of translation consists of rather simple substitutions whereas another involves relatively sophisticated and not just purely linguistic analysis.

    Several attempts have been made to develop a translation theory based on different translation ranks or levels as they are sometimes called. Among those one of the most popular in the former Soviet Union was the «theory of translation equivalence level (TEL)» developed by V. Komissarov14.

    According to this theory the translation process fluctuates passing from formal inter-language transformations to the domain of conceptual interrelations.

    V. Komissarov's approach seems to be a realistic interpretation of the translation process, however, this approach fails to demonstrate when and why one translation equivalence level becomes no longer ap­propriate and why, to get a correct translation, you have to pass to a higher TEL.

    48

    14 See: Комиссаров В.Н. Слово о переводе. - M., 1973; Комиссаров В.Н. Лингвистика перевода. - М., 1981.

    49

    Ideas similar to TEL are expressed by Y. Retsker'3 who maintains that any two languages are related by «regular» correspondences (words, word-building patterns, syntactical structures) and «irregular» ones. The irregular correspondences cannot be formally represented and only the translators knowledge and intuition can help to find the matching formal expression in the target language for a concept expressed in the source

    language.

    According to J. Firth16, in order to bridge languages in the process of translation, one must use the whole complex of linguistic and extralin-guistic information rather than limit oneself to purely linguistic objects and structures.

    J. Catford17, similar to V. Komissarov and J. Firth, interprets transla­tion as a multi-level process. He distinguishes between «total» and «re­stricted» translation - in «total» translation all levels of the source text are replaced by those of the target text, whereas in «restricted» transla­tion the substitution occurs at only one level.

    According to T. Catford a certain set of translation tools characteris­tic of a certain level constitutes a rank of translation and a translation per­formed using that or another set of tools is called rank bound. We have borrowed this terminology and call the theories that divide the transla­tion process into different levels theories with translation ranking.

    Generally speaking, all theories of human translation discussed above try to explain the process of translation to a degree of precision required for practical application, but no explanation is complete so far.

    Ш* The transformational approach quite convincingly suggests that in any language there are certain regular syntactic, morphological, and word-building structures which may be successfully matched with their analogies in another language during translation.

    Besides, you may observe evident similarity between the transforma­tional approach and primary translation ranks within theories suggesting the ranking of translation (Komissarov, Retsker, Catford and others).

    As you will note later, the transformational approach forms the basis of machine translation design - almost any machine translation system uses the principle of matching forms of the languages involved in trans­lation. The difference is only in the forms that are matched and the rules of matching18.

    •* The denotative approach treats different languages as closed sys­tems with specific relationships between formal and conceptual as­pects, hence in the process of translation links between the forms of different languages are established via conceptual equivalence.

    This is also true, especially in such cases where language expressions correspond to unique indivisible concepts. Here one can also observe similarity with higher ranks within the theories suggesting the ranking of translation.

    ^ The communicational approach highlights a very important as­pect of translation - the matching of thesauruses. Translation may achieve its ultimate target of rendering a piece of information only if the translator knows the users' language and the subject matter of the translation well enough (i.e. if the translator's language and subject thesauruses are sufficiently complete). This may seem self-evident, but should always be kept in mind, because all translation mistakes result from the insufficiencies of the thesauruses.

    15 Рецкер Я.И. Теория перевода и переводческая практика. - М., 1974.

    16 Firth J.R. Linguistic Analysis and Translation // For Roman lakobson. The Hague. - 1956.

    17 Catford J. A Linguistic Theory of Translation. - London, 1967.

    50

    See, e. g. Staples Ch. The LOGOS Intelligent Translation System // Proceedings of Joint Conference on AI. - Karlsruhe, 1983; SYSTRAN Linguistische Beschreibung. - Berlin, 1990; Hiroaki Kitano. Speech-to-speech Translation: A massively parallel memory-based approach. - Boston, 1994.

    51

    Moreover, wholly complete thesauruses are the ideal case. No trans­lator knows the source and target languages equally well (even a native speaker of both) and even if he or she does, it is still virtually impossible to know everything about any possible subject matter related to the translation.

    Scientists and translators have been arguing and still do about the priorities in a translators education. Some of them give priority to the linguistic knowledge of translators, others keep saying that a knowledge­able specialist in the given area with even a relatively poor command of the language will be able to provide a more adequate translation than a good scholar of the language with no special technical or natural science background.

    In our opinion this argument is counter-productive - even if one or another viewpoint is proved, say, statistically, this will not add anything of value to the understanding of translation. However, the very existence of this argument underscores the significance of extralinguistic informa­tion for translation19.

    Summing up this short overview of theoretical treatments of transla­tion we would again like to draw your attention to the general conclusion that any theory recognizes these three basic components of translation, and different approaches differ only in the accents placed on this or that component. So, the basic components are:

    Meaning of a word or word combination in the source language (concept or concepts corresponding to this word or word combination in the minds of the source language speakers).

    Equivalence of this meaning expressed in a word or word combina­tion of the target language (concept or concepts corresponding to this word or word combination in the minds of the target language speakers).

    Extralinguistic information pertaining to the original meaning and/or its conceptual equivalent after the translation.

    19 This viewpoint is also shared by, e. g.: Batori I. Paradigmen der maschineller Sprachuebersetzung // Neue Ansaetze in maschineller Sprachbearbeitung. - Tuebungen, 1986; Новиков А.И., Слюсарева Н.А. Линг-вистические и зкстралингвистические аспектьі семантики текста. - М., L982.

    52

    So, to put it differently, what you can do in translation is either match individual words and combinations of the two languages directly (transformational approach), or understand the content of the source message and render it using the formal means of the target language (denotative approach) with due regard of the translation recipient and background information (communicational approach).

    The hierarchy of these methods may be different depending on the type of translation20. Approach priorities depending on the type of trans­lation are given in Table below.

    Translation Type

    Translation Method Priorities

    Oral Consecutive

    Denotative, Communicational

    Oral Simultaneous

    Transformational, Communica­tional

    Written (general & technical)

    Transformational

    Written (fiction & poetry)

    Denotative

    Thus, in oral consecutive translation priority is given to denotative method, because a translator is first listening to the speaker and only after some time formulates the translation, which is very seldom a structural copy of the source speech.

    In simultaneous translation as opposed to consecutive priority is given to direct transformations since a simultaneous interpreter simply has no time for conceptual analysis.

    In written translation, when you seem to have time for everything, pri­ority is also given to simple transformations (perhaps, with exception of po­etic translation). This is no contradiction, just the path of least resistance in action - it is not worthwhile to resort to complex methods unless simple ones fail.

    It should be born in mind, however, that in any translation we ob­serve a combination of different methods.

    See, e. g.: Ревзин И.И., Розенцвейг В.Ю. Основи общего и машинно­го перевода. - М., 1964.

    53

    From the approaches discussed one should also learn that the matching language forms and concepts are regular and irregular, that seemingly the same concepts are interpreted differently by the speakers of different languages and different translation users.

    Now, having discussed briefly the main theoretical treatments of human translation, we pass over to basic translation parameters being the subject of the following lectures.

    Make this text like a recording of a lecture by a student from a class

  2. Assistant

    [Background noise fades as the student begins speaking.]

    Hello everyone, today I'm going to discuss some key concepts in translation theory that we’ve been exploring in class.

    Let's start with the idea of translation ranking. So, translation ranking can be thought of as how different forms of translation are organized or stratified, usually to ensure the adequacy of the translation process. It involves a sort of hierarchy or level system for different translation tasks. We consider aspects such as moving content from one language to another, recalculating measures, broadcasting ideas, and converting linguistic units. It’s about finding the most effective way to shift meaning from a source language into a target language.

    Moving on, let's delve into what we mean by translation ranks. This is more of a theoretical framework. We've all heard of J.C. Catford, right? Well, Catford's approach brought in some influential ideas about translation equivalence and ranking. He talked about three primary criteria for translation: First, the extent of the translation, like full vs. partial translation. Second, there's the grammatical rank at which translation equivalence is found—this is where rank-bound and unbounded translations come into play. And third, are the levels of language involved, like total versus restricted translation.

    Now, a major issue in translation is trying to define "equivalence." Historically, early Bible translations emphasized equivalence as sameness—essentially trying to replicate the original verbatim. Modern views, like those from semiotics, suggest that while translation is always possible, it’s more about similarity rather than exact sameness. For meaningful translation, the focus is often on relevant similarities, such as form, style, and desired effect.

    Now in terms of translation ranks related to practicality, we've seen several scholars propose theories. One notable example is V. Komissarov's "Theory of Translation Equivalence Level" (TEL). Komissarov pointed out that translation isn't just a simple matter of word-for-word substitution; it involves complex shifts between formal and conceptual aspects of language.

    These ideas align with Y. Retsker’s view that languages are related through regular and irregular correspondences. Regular ones are straightforward, while irregular ones require more intuitive leaps by the translator. The takeaway is that translators have to balance these different levels of equivalence based on the specific task and context.

    Finally, let’s discuss the approaches to translation and how they relate to these rankings: you have transformational, denotative, and communicational approaches. Each approach becomes more relevant depending on whether you’re dealing with oral consecutive translation, oral simultaneous translation, or written translations. For example, oral consecutive translation heavily relies on the denotative method as the translator interprets the message before relaying it.

    So, in sum, we see a blend of different methods in any translation task, and it's this blend that captures the complexity of finding equivalence and meaning between languages.

    Alright, any questions on these concepts? [The background noise returns as the student concludes.]

  3. User

    NOT SO. JUST WRITE THE TEXT LIKE A SYNOPSIS

  4. Assistant

    Certainly! Here's a synopsis of the provided text:

    The text explores different theories and concepts related to translation, focusing on translation ranking and translation ranks. Translation ranking refers to organizing translation tasks to ensure adequacy, involving different forms and levels of translation, such as moving content between languages, recalculating measures, and converting linguistic units.

    Catford's theory distinguishes between full and partial translations, rank-bound and unbounded translations, and total vs. restricted translations. He emphasizes equivalence, which doesn't imply sameness but rather relevant similarity, covering form, style, and intended effect.

    The discussion touches on V. Komissarov's "Theory of Translation Equivalence Level" (TEL), which describes translation as fluctuating between formal transformations and conceptual relationships. J. Catford, similar to other theorists, views translation as a multi-level process, differentiating between total and restricted translations.

    The text also contrasts transformational, denotative, and communicational approaches, showing how their priorities change with different types of translation, such as oral consecutive, oral simultaneous, and written translation. Each theory highlights aspects of equivalence, meaning, and extralinguistic information as core components in the translation process. Despite varying perspectives, all approaches aim to bridge language differences to achieve conceptual and formal equivalence.

  5. User

    What is translation ranking? Give definitions and examples Translation ranking- translation; translated work; moving; shift; recalculation of some measures or other units; forward movement; broadcast; conversion from one unit to another; recalculation of some other measures; Arrangement; transfer; translation; incarnation What translation ranks do you know? Give definitions and examples Catford's approach to translation equivalence clearly differs from that adopted by Nida since Catford had a preference for a more linguistic-based approach to translation and this approach is based on the linguistic work of Firth and Halliday. His main contribution in the field of translation theory is the introduction of the concepts of types and shifts of translation. Catford proposed very broad types of translation in terms of three criteria: The extent of translation (full translation vs partial translation);

    The grammatical rank at which the translation equivalence is established (rank-bound translation vs. unbounded translation);

    The levels of language involved in translation (total translation vs. restricted translation).

    What relationship is there between the approaches to translation and types of translation? Basic problem: translations are assumed to be somehow “the same” as the original, but they are obviously different. What does “equivalence” mean? • Six steps in the debate:

    Early Bible translation: equivalence must be understood as sameness. Translation must be possible.

    Modern semiotics: translation is always possible (depending on what you mean by translation....)

    The problem of untranslatability. Can meaning be separated from form? Absolutely the “same” meaning is (usually / often / sometimes ) impossible. The claim that there are no stable meanings (cf. deconstruction, postmodernism).

    Equivalence is better understood as similarity, relevant similarity, not sameness or identity. Two texts can be “similar” in very many ways.

    There are several basic types of equivalence: concerning form, meaning, style, desired effect...

    Each translation task requires its own hierarchy of equivalence: what are the priorities for this particular translation? Depends on aim and context.

    Conclusion: equivalence is produced by the translator, it is claimed. This claim may or may not be accepted by the client, by readers.

    Various ranks of translation; means to ensure adequate translation which have been suggested by dif­ferent scholars and translation ranks;

    fields of application and hierarchy of transformational, denotative and communicational approaches depending on type of translation;

    priorities in training translators;

    meaning, equivalence and extralinguistic information as three basic com­ponents of translation;

    the use of different approaches depending on translation variety.

    Even in routine translation practice one can see that there are differ­ent ranks of translation, that one rank of translation consists of rather simple substitutions whereas another involves relatively sophisticated and not just purely linguistic analysis.

    Several attempts have been made to develop a translation theory based on different translation ranks or levels as they are sometimes called. Among those one of the most popular in the former Soviet Union was the «theory of translation equivalence level (TEL)» developed by V. Komissarov14.

    According to this theory the translation process fluctuates passing from formal inter-language transformations to the domain of conceptual interrelations.

    V. Komissarov's approach seems to be a realistic interpretation of the translation process, however, this approach fails to demonstrate when and why one translation equivalence level becomes no longer ap­propriate and why, to get a correct translation, you have to pass to a higher TEL.

    48

    14 See: Комиссаров В.Н. Слово о переводе. - M., 1973; Комиссаров В.Н. Лингвистика перевода. - М., 1981.

    49

    Ideas similar to TEL are expressed by Y. Retsker'3 who maintains that any two languages are related by «regular» correspondences (words, word-building patterns, syntactical structures) and «irregular» ones. The irregular correspondences cannot be formally represented and only the translators knowledge and intuition can help to find the matching formal expression in the target language for a concept expressed in the source

    language.

    According to J. Firth16, in order to bridge languages in the process of translation, one must use the whole complex of linguistic and extralin-guistic information rather than limit oneself to purely linguistic objects and structures.

    J. Catford17, similar to V. Komissarov and J. Firth, interprets transla­tion as a multi-level process. He distinguishes between «total» and «re­stricted» translation - in «total» translation all levels of the source text are replaced by those of the target text, whereas in «restricted» transla­tion the substitution occurs at only one level.

    According to T. Catford a certain set of translation tools characteris­tic of a certain level constitutes a rank of translation and a translation per­formed using that or another set of tools is called rank bound. We have borrowed this terminology and call the theories that divide the transla­tion process into different levels theories with translation ranking.

    Generally speaking, all theories of human translation discussed above try to explain the process of translation to a degree of precision required for practical application, but no explanation is complete so far.

    Ш* The transformational approach quite convincingly suggests that in any language there are certain regular syntactic, morphological, and word-building structures which may be successfully matched with their analogies in another language during translation.

    Besides, you may observe evident similarity between the transforma­tional approach and primary translation ranks within theories suggesting the ranking of translation (Komissarov, Retsker, Catford and others).

    As you will note later, the transformational approach forms the basis of machine translation design - almost any machine translation system uses the principle of matching forms of the languages involved in trans­lation. The difference is only in the forms that are matched and the rules of matching18.

    •* The denotative approach treats different languages as closed sys­tems with specific relationships between formal and conceptual as­pects, hence in the process of translation links between the forms of different languages are established via conceptual equivalence.

    This is also true, especially in such cases where language expressions correspond to unique indivisible concepts. Here one can also observe similarity with higher ranks within the theories suggesting the ranking of translation.

    ^ The communicational approach highlights a very important as­pect of translation - the matching of thesauruses. Translation may achieve its ultimate target of rendering a piece of information only if the translator knows the users' language and the subject matter of the translation well enough (i.e. if the translator's language and subject thesauruses are sufficiently complete). This may seem self-evident, but should always be kept in mind, because all translation mistakes result from the insufficiencies of the thesauruses.

    15 Рецкер Я.И. Теория перевода и переводческая практика. - М., 1974.

    16 Firth J.R. Linguistic Analysis and Translation // For Roman lakobson. The Hague. - 1956.

    17 Catford J. A Linguistic Theory of Translation. - London, 1967.

    50

    See, e. g. Staples Ch. The LOGOS Intelligent Translation System // Proceedings of Joint Conference on AI. - Karlsruhe, 1983; SYSTRAN Linguistische Beschreibung. - Berlin, 1990; Hiroaki Kitano. Speech-to-speech Translation: A massively parallel memory-based approach. - Boston, 1994.

    51

    Moreover, wholly complete thesauruses are the ideal case. No trans­lator knows the source and target languages equally well (even a native speaker of both) and even if he or she does, it is still virtually impossible to know everything about any possible subject matter related to the translation.

    Scientists and translators have been arguing and still do about the priorities in a translators education. Some of them give priority to the linguistic knowledge of translators, others keep saying that a knowledge­able specialist in the given area with even a relatively poor command of the language will be able to provide a more adequate translation than a good scholar of the language with no special technical or natural science background.

    In our opinion this argument is counter-productive - even if one or another viewpoint is proved, say, statistically, this will not add anything of value to the understanding of translation. However, the very existence of this argument underscores the significance of extralinguistic informa­tion for translation19.

    Summing up this short overview of theoretical treatments of transla­tion we would again like to draw your attention to the general conclusion that any theory recognizes these three basic components of translation, and different approaches differ only in the accents placed on this or that component. So, the basic components are:

    Meaning of a word or word combination in the source language (concept or concepts corresponding to this word or word combination in the minds of the source language speakers).

    Equivalence of this meaning expressed in a word or word combina­tion of the target language (concept or concepts corresponding to this word or word combination in the minds of the target language speakers).

    Extralinguistic information pertaining to the original meaning and/or its conceptual equivalent after the translation.

    19 This viewpoint is also shared by, e. g.: Batori I. Paradigmen der maschineller Sprachuebersetzung // Neue Ansaetze in maschineller Sprachbearbeitung. - Tuebungen, 1986; Новиков А.И., Слюсарева Н.А. Линг-вистические и зкстралингвистические аспектьі семантики текста. - М., L982.

    52

    So, to put it differently, what you can do in translation is either match individual words and combinations of the two languages directly (transformational approach), or understand the content of the source message and render it using the formal means of the target language (denotative approach) with due regard of the translation recipient and background information (communicational approach).

    The hierarchy of these methods may be different depending on the type of translation20. Approach priorities depending on the type of trans­lation are given in Table below.

    Translation Type

    Translation Method Priorities

    Oral Consecutive

    Denotative, Communicational

    Oral Simultaneous

    Transformational, Communica­tional

    Written (general & technical)

    Transformational

    Written (fiction & poetry)

    Denotative

    Thus, in oral consecutive translation priority is given to denotative method, because a translator is first listening to the speaker and only after some time formulates the translation, which is very seldom a structural copy of the source speech.

    In simultaneous translation as opposed to consecutive priority is given to direct transformations since a simultaneous interpreter simply has no time for conceptual analysis.

    In written translation, when you seem to have time for everything, pri­ority is also given to simple transformations (perhaps, with exception of po­etic translation). This is no contradiction, just the path of least resistance in action - it is not worthwhile to resort to complex methods unless simple ones fail.

    It should be born in mind, however, that in any translation we ob­serve a combination of different methods.

    See, e. g.: Ревзин И.И., Розенцвейг В.Ю. Основи общего и машинно­го перевода. - М., 1964.

    53

    From the approaches discussed one should also learn that the matching language forms and concepts are regular and irregular, that seemingly the same concepts are interpreted differently by the speakers of different languages and different translation users.

    Now, having discussed briefly the main theoretical treatments of human translation, we pass over to basic translation parameters being the subject of the following lectures.

    WRITE THIS TEXT AS AN OUTLINE

  6. Assistant

    Here's an outline of the provided text:

    I. Introduction to Translation Ranking A. Definition and various interpretations 1. Translation as movement or shift 2. Recalculation and conversion between units 3. Arrangement and incarnation of meaning

    II. Translation Ranks A. Catford's approach to translation 1. Extent of translation a. Full translation vs. Partial translation 2. Grammatical rank a. Rank-bound translation vs. Unbounded translation 3. Levels of language a. Total translation vs. Restricted translation

    III. Relationship between Approaches and Types of Translation A. Equivalence and its debates 1. Early Bible translation emphasizing sameness 2. Modern semiotics and the idea of similarity B. Untranslatability and the separation of meaning from form C. Understanding equivalence as relevant similarity 1. Types of equivalence: form, meaning, style, effect

    IV. Various Ranks of Translation A. Ensuring adequate translation 1. Transformational, denotative, and communicational approaches B. Priority in translator training C. Translation as a multi-level process 1. TEL by V. Komissarov and similar ideas by others

    V. Theories and Approaches A. Transformational approach 1. Matching regular syntactic structures B. Denotative approach 1. Conceptual equivalence C. Communicational approach 1. Matching of thesauruses

    VI. Applications and Limitations A. Oral and written translation priorities 1. Oral consecutive and simultaneous translation 2. Written (general, technical, fiction, poetry) B. The combination of different methods in practice

    VII. Conclusion A. Core components recognized by theories 1. Meaning, equivalence, extralinguistic information B. Practical implications for translators 1. Matching forms and concepts, understanding source content

    VIII. Future Directions A. Discussion of translation parameters in upcoming lectures

  7. User

    What is translation ranking? Give definitions and examples Translation ranking- translation; translated work; moving; shift; recalculation of some measures or other units; forward movement; broadcast; conversion from one unit to another; recalculation of some other measures; Arrangement; transfer; translation; incarnation What translation ranks do you know? Give definitions and examples Catford's approach to translation equivalence clearly differs from that adopted by Nida since Catford had a preference for a more linguistic-based approach to translation and this approach is based on the linguistic work of Firth and Halliday. His main contribution in the field of translation theory is the introduction of the concepts of types and shifts of translation. Catford proposed very broad types of translation in terms of three criteria: The extent of translation (full translation vs partial translation);

    The grammatical rank at which the translation equivalence is established (rank-bound translation vs. unbounded translation);

    The levels of language involved in translation (total translation vs. restricted translation).

    What relationship is there between the approaches to translation and types of translation? Basic problem: translations are assumed to be somehow “the same” as the original, but they are obviously different. What does “equivalence” mean? • Six steps in the debate:

    Early Bible translation: equivalence must be understood as sameness. Translation must be possible.

    Modern semiotics: translation is always possible (depending on what you mean by translation....)

    The problem of untranslatability. Can meaning be separated from form? Absolutely the “same” meaning is (usually / often / sometimes ) impossible. The claim that there are no stable meanings (cf. deconstruction, postmodernism).

    Equivalence is better understood as similarity, relevant similarity, not sameness or identity. Two texts can be “similar” in very many ways.

    There are several basic types of equivalence: concerning form, meaning, style, desired effect...

    Each translation task requires its own hierarchy of equivalence: what are the priorities for this particular translation? Depends on aim and context.

    Conclusion: equivalence is produced by the translator, it is claimed. This claim may or may not be accepted by the client, by readers.

    Various ranks of translation; means to ensure adequate translation which have been suggested by dif­ferent scholars and translation ranks;

    fields of application and hierarchy of transformational, denotative and communicational approaches depending on type of translation;

    priorities in training translators;

    meaning, equivalence and extralinguistic information as three basic com­ponents of translation;

    the use of different approaches depending on translation variety.

    Even in routine translation practice one can see that there are differ­ent ranks of translation, that one rank of translation consists of rather simple substitutions whereas another involves relatively sophisticated and not just purely linguistic analysis.

    Several attempts have been made to develop a translation theory based on different translation ranks or levels as they are sometimes called. Among those one of the most popular in the former Soviet Union was the «theory of translation equivalence level (TEL)» developed by V. Komissarov14.

    According to this theory the translation process fluctuates passing from formal inter-language transformations to the domain of conceptual interrelations.

    V. Komissarov's approach seems to be a realistic interpretation of the translation process, however, this approach fails to demonstrate when and why one translation equivalence level becomes no longer ap­propriate and why, to get a correct translation, you have to pass to a higher TEL.

    48

    14 See: Комиссаров В.Н. Слово о переводе. - M., 1973; Комиссаров В.Н. Лингвистика перевода. - М., 1981.

    49

    Ideas similar to TEL are expressed by Y. Retsker'3 who maintains that any two languages are related by «regular» correspondences (words, word-building patterns, syntactical structures) and «irregular» ones. The irregular correspondences cannot be formally represented and only the translators knowledge and intuition can help to find the matching formal expression in the target language for a concept expressed in the source

    language.

    According to J. Firth16, in order to bridge languages in the process of translation, one must use the whole complex of linguistic and extralin-guistic information rather than limit oneself to purely linguistic objects and structures.

    J. Catford17, similar to V. Komissarov and J. Firth, interprets transla­tion as a multi-level process. He distinguishes between «total» and «re­stricted» translation - in «total» translation all levels of the source text are replaced by those of the target text, whereas in «restricted» transla­tion the substitution occurs at only one level.

    According to T. Catford a certain set of translation tools characteris­tic of a certain level constitutes a rank of translation and a translation per­formed using that or another set of tools is called rank bound. We have borrowed this terminology and call the theories that divide the transla­tion process into different levels theories with translation ranking.

    Generally speaking, all theories of human translation discussed above try to explain the process of translation to a degree of precision required for practical application, but no explanation is complete so far.

    Ш* The transformational approach quite convincingly suggests that in any language there are certain regular syntactic, morphological, and word-building structures which may be successfully matched with their analogies in another language during translation.

    Besides, you may observe evident similarity between the transforma­tional approach and primary translation ranks within theories suggesting the ranking of translation (Komissarov, Retsker, Catford and others).

    As you will note later, the transformational approach forms the basis of machine translation design - almost any machine translation system uses the principle of matching forms of the languages involved in trans­lation. The difference is only in the forms that are matched and the rules of matching18.

    •* The denotative approach treats different languages as closed sys­tems with specific relationships between formal and conceptual as­pects, hence in the process of translation links between the forms of different languages are established via conceptual equivalence.

    This is also true, especially in such cases where language expressions correspond to unique indivisible concepts. Here one can also observe similarity with higher ranks within the theories suggesting the ranking of translation.

    ^ The communicational approach highlights a very important as­pect of translation - the matching of thesauruses. Translation may achieve its ultimate target of rendering a piece of information only if the translator knows the users' language and the subject matter of the translation well enough (i.e. if the translator's language and subject thesauruses are sufficiently complete). This may seem self-evident, but should always be kept in mind, because all translation mistakes result from the insufficiencies of the thesauruses.

    15 Рецкер Я.И. Теория перевода и переводческая практика. - М., 1974.

    16 Firth J.R. Linguistic Analysis and Translation // For Roman lakobson. The Hague. - 1956.

    17 Catford J. A Linguistic Theory of Translation. - London, 1967.

    50

    See, e. g. Staples Ch. The LOGOS Intelligent Translation System // Proceedings of Joint Conference on AI. - Karlsruhe, 1983; SYSTRAN Linguistische Beschreibung. - Berlin, 1990; Hiroaki Kitano. Speech-to-speech Translation: A massively parallel memory-based approach. - Boston, 1994.

    51

    Moreover, wholly complete thesauruses are the ideal case. No trans­lator knows the source and target languages equally well (even a native speaker of both) and even if he or she does, it is still virtually impossible to know everything about any possible subject matter related to the translation.

    Scientists and translators have been arguing and still do about the priorities in a translators education. Some of them give priority to the linguistic knowledge of translators, others keep saying that a knowledge­able specialist in the given area with even a relatively poor command of the language will be able to provide a more adequate translation than a good scholar of the language with no special technical or natural science background.

    In our opinion this argument is counter-productive - even if one or another viewpoint is proved, say, statistically, this will not add anything of value to the understanding of translation. However, the very existence of this argument underscores the significance of extralinguistic informa­tion for translation19.

    Summing up this short overview of theoretical treatments of transla­tion we would again like to draw your attention to the general conclusion that any theory recognizes these three basic components of translation, and different approaches differ only in the accents placed on this or that component. So, the basic components are:

    Meaning of a word or word combination in the source language (concept or concepts corresponding to this word or word combination in the minds of the source language speakers).

    Equivalence of this meaning expressed in a word or word combina­tion of the target language (concept or concepts corresponding to this word or word combination in the minds of the target language speakers).

    Extralinguistic information pertaining to the original meaning and/or its conceptual equivalent after the translation.

    19 This viewpoint is also shared by, e. g.: Batori I. Paradigmen der maschineller Sprachuebersetzung // Neue Ansaetze in maschineller Sprachbearbeitung. - Tuebungen, 1986; Новиков А.И., Слюсарева Н.А. Линг-вистические и зкстралингвистические аспектьі семантики текста. - М., L982.

    52

    So, to put it differently, what you can do in translation is either match individual words and combinations of the two languages directly (transformational approach), or understand the content of the source message and render it using the formal means of the target language (denotative approach) with due regard of the translation recipient and background information (communicational approach).

    The hierarchy of these methods may be different depending on the type of translation20. Approach priorities depending on the type of trans­lation are given in Table below.

    Translation Type

    Translation Method Priorities

    Oral Consecutive

    Denotative, Communicational

    Oral Simultaneous

    Transformational, Communica­tional

    Written (general & technical)

    Transformational

    Written (fiction & poetry)

    Denotative

    Thus, in oral consecutive translation priority is given to denotative method, because a translator is first listening to the speaker and only after some time formulates the translation, which is very seldom a structural copy of the source speech.

    In simultaneous translation as opposed to consecutive priority is given to direct transformations since a simultaneous interpreter simply has no time for conceptual analysis.

    In written translation, when you seem to have time for everything, pri­ority is also given to simple transformations (perhaps, with exception of po­etic translation). This is no contradiction, just the path of least resistance in action - it is not worthwhile to resort to complex methods unless simple ones fail.

    It should be born in mind, however, that in any translation we ob­serve a combination of different methods.

    See, e. g.: Ревзин И.И., Розенцвейг В.Ю. Основи общего и машинно­го перевода. - М., 1964.

    53

    From the approaches discussed one should also learn that the matching language forms and concepts are regular and irregular, that seemingly the same concepts are interpreted differently by the speakers of different languages and different translation users.

    Now, having discussed briefly the main theoretical treatments of human translation, we pass over to basic translation parameters being the subject of the following lectures.

    WRITE THIS TEXT AS AN EXTRACT

  8. Assistant

    Certainly! Here's an extract based on the provided text:


    Translation Ranking and Ranks

    Translation ranking involves organizing and prioritizing the translation process to ensure effective conversion from one language to another. This concept encompasses various aspects such as moving content, recalculating units, forward movement, and conversion, all tailored to achieve accurate transfer and arrangement of meaning in translation.

    Types of Translation Ranks

    J.C. Catford introduced a linguistic-based approach, differing from other methodologies, by focusing on types and shifts in translation. He proposed broad categories based on:

    1. Extent of Translation: Differentiating between full and partial translation, where the entire content or parts of a text are translated.

    2. Grammatical Rank: Establishing equivalence at different levels, distinguishing between rank-bound (limited to specific grammatical levels) and unbounded translations.

    3. Language Levels: Considering total translation, where all language levels are replaced in the target text, versus restricted translation, focusing on specific levels.

    Relationship Between Approaches

    The concept of equivalence is central to translation, aiming for relevant similarity rather than exact sameness. This involves form, meaning, style, and desired effects, with each task requiring a tailored hierarchy of equivalence depending on the context and goals.

    Translation Theories and Applications

    Various scholars have contributed to understanding translation via different ranks or levels. V. Komissarov's "Theory of Translation Equivalence Level" (TEL) suggests a process fluctuating between formal transformations and conceptual interrelations. Similarly, Y. Retsker and J. Firth emphasize using a complex mix of linguistic and extralinguistic information for effective translation.

    Approaches: Transformational, Denotative, and Communicational

    1. Transformational Approach: Utilizes regular syntactic and morphological structures matched across languages, forming the basis of many machine translation systems.

    2. Denotative Approach: Treats languages as closed systems with structured formal and conceptual links, establishing equivalence through universal concepts.

    3. Communicational Approach: Focuses on matching thesauruses to ultimate render information accurately, heavily relying on the translator's language and subject matter knowledge.

    Prioritizing Approaches Based on Translation Type

    • Oral Consecutive: Emphasizes the denotative and communicational approaches.
    • Oral Simultaneous: Prioritizes transformational and communicational approaches due to time constraints.
    • Written Translation: Favors transformational methods for efficiency except in fiction and poetry, where the denotative approach is preferred for depth of meaning.

    In any translation practice, a combination of methods is often utilized to adapt to the varying complexities and requirements of the task, acknowledging both regular and irregular correspondences between languages.


    This extract summarizes key points about translation ranking systems, the nature of equivalence in translation, and the theorized approaches that guide translation practices.