\subsection*{6.5.7 Calculation of $E(\hat{a}, \hat{b})$} 1. Find the amplitudes $a{+-},…
- User
\subsection*{6.5.7 Calculation of }
-
Find the amplitudes and (cf. (6.46)).
-
Show that (cf. (6.47)) [ E(\hat{a}, \hat{b}) = \langle (\vec{\sigma} \cdot \hat{a}) \otimes (\vec{\sigma} \cdot \hat{b}) \rangle_{\Phi} = \langle \Phi | (\vec{\sigma} \cdot \hat{a}) \otimes (\vec{\sigma} \cdot \hat{b}) | \Phi \rangle = -\hat{a} \cdot \hat{b}, ] where is the entangled state (6.15) of two spins : [ |\Phi\rangle = \frac{1}{\sqrt{2}} \left( | + - \rangle - | - + \rangle \right). ]
\textit{Hint: using the rotational invariance of , show that and use (3.50).}
-
- Assistant
Certainly! Let's tackle the problem step by step.
1. Finding the Amplitudes ( a_{+-}, a_{-+}, ) and ( a_{--} )
Given the entangled state: [ |\Phi\rangle = \frac{1}{\sqrt{2}} \left( | + - \rangle - | - + \rangle \right) ] where ( | + - \rangle ) represents the first spin being up (( + )) and the second spin being down (( - )), and ( | - + \rangle ) represents the first spin being down (( - )) and the second spin being up (( + )).
The general form for a two-spin state can be written as: [ |\Psi\rangle = a_{++} |++\rangle + a_{+-} |+-\rangle + a_{-+} |-+\rangle + a_{--} |--\rangle ] Comparing this with our given state ( |\Phi\rangle ), we can identify the amplitudes:
-
Amplitude ( a_{++} ):
- In ( |\Phi\rangle ), there is no ( |++\rangle ) term.
- Therefore, ( a_{++} = 0 ).
-
Amplitude ( a_{+-} ):
- The coefficient of ( |+-\rangle ) in ( |\Phi\rangle ) is ( \frac{1}{\sqrt{2}} ).
- Therefore, ( a_{+-} = \frac{1}{\sqrt{2}} ).
-
Amplitude ( a_{-+} ):
- The coefficient of ( |-+\rangle ) in ( |\Phi\rangle ) is ( -\frac{1}{\sqrt{2}} ).
- Therefore, ( a_{-+} = -\frac{1}{\sqrt{2}} ).
-
Amplitude ( a_{--} ):
- In ( |\Phi\rangle ), there is no ( |--\rangle ) term.
- Therefore, ( a_{--} = 0 ).
Summary of Amplitudes: [ \begin{align*} a_{++} &= 0, \ a_{+-} &= \frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}, \ a_{-+} &= -\frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}, \ a_{--} &= 0. \end{align*} ]
2. Calculating the Expectation Value ( E(\hat{a}, \hat{b}) )
We are to compute: [ E(\hat{a}, \hat{b}) = \langle \Phi | (\vec{\sigma} \cdot \hat{a}) \otimes (\vec{\sigma} \cdot \hat{b}) | \Phi \rangle ] where:
- ( \vec{\sigma} ) represents the vector of Pauli matrices ( (\sigma_x, \sigma_y, \sigma_z) ).
- ( \hat{a} ) and ( \hat{b} ) are unit vectors representing measurement directions for the first and second spins, respectively.
- ( |\Phi\rangle ) is the entangled singlet state.
Using the Hint:
- Rotational Invariance: The singlet state ( |\Phi\rangle ) is rotationally invariant, meaning its form remains unchanged under simultaneous rotation of both spins.
- Relation Between Spin Operators: Using the property ( \vec{\sigma}^{(a)} |\Phi\rangle = -\vec{\sigma}^{(b)} |\Phi\rangle ). This expresses the fact that measuring the spin of one particle along any direction instantly determines the spin of the other particle along the same direction, but with opposite orientation.
Step-by-Step Calculation:
-
Express the Measurement Operators: [ \vec{\sigma} \cdot \hat{a} = \sigma_x a_x + \sigma_y a_y + \sigma_z a_z ] [ \vec{\sigma} \cdot \hat{b} = \sigma_x b_x + \sigma_y b_y + \sigma_z b_z ]
-
Apply the Spin Operator to the Entangled State: Using the hint: [ \vec{\sigma}^{(a)} |\Phi\rangle = -\vec{\sigma}^{(b)} |\Phi\rangle ] Therefore: [ (\vec{\sigma} \cdot \hat{a})^{(a)} |\Phi\rangle = - (\vec{\sigma} \cdot \hat{a})^{(b)} |\Phi\rangle ]
-
Compute the Expectation Value: [ E(\hat{a}, \hat{b}) = \langle \Phi | (\vec{\sigma} \cdot \hat{a}) \otimes (\vec{\sigma} \cdot \hat{b}) | \Phi \rangle ]
Substitute the relation from the hint: [ = \langle \Phi | (\vec{\sigma} \cdot \hat{a})^{(a)} \otimes (\vec{\sigma} \cdot \hat{b})^{(b)} | \Phi \rangle ] [ = \langle \Phi | (\vec{\sigma} \cdot \hat{a})^{(a)} \otimes (-\vec{\sigma} \cdot \hat{a})^{(b)} | \Phi \rangle ] [ = - \langle \Phi | (\vec{\sigma} \cdot \hat{a})^{(a)} \otimes (\vec{\sigma} \cdot \hat{a})^{(b)} | \Phi \rangle ]
-
Simplify Using Known Expectations for Singlet States: For the singlet state, [ \langle \Phi | (\vec{\sigma} \cdot \hat{a}) \otimes (\vec{\sigma} \cdot \hat{b}) | \Phi \rangle = -\hat{a} \cdot \hat{b} ]
This result arises from the properties of the Pauli matrices and the entangled nature of ( |\Phi\rangle ). Specifically, the expectation value captures the perfect anti-correlation between the spins along any pair of directions.
-
Final Result: [ E(\hat{a}, \hat{b}) = -\hat{a} \cdot \hat{b} ]
Conclusion: The expectation value ( E(\hat{a}, \hat{b}) ) for the singlet state ( |\Phi\rangle ) is given by the negative of the dot product of the measurement directions ( \hat{a} ) and ( \hat{b} ): [ E(\hat{a}, \hat{b}) = -\hat{a} \cdot \hat{b} ]
This result manifests the quantum mechanical prediction of perfect anti-correlation in the measurements of spin-(\frac{1}{2}) particles in the singlet state, irrespective of the directions ( \hat{a} ) and ( \hat{b} ) chosen for the measurements.
-
Other models, same or similar prompt
Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.