Please give a rating score of the similarity of the text on a scale of 1-5 comparing…
- User
Please give a rating score of the similarity of the text on a scale of 1-5 comparing [original] which is the original texts compared with [rewrite] which is a combined text:
[original]: Based on "Editorial Note: From Conventional AI to Modern AI in Education: Re-examining AI and Analytic Techniques for Teaching and Learning", the research paper states that most of the implementation of AI focuses on combining traditional AI techniques with learning which are rule/statistic-based models to facilitate teaching and learning in education, another paper that was cited within, there was only 2 studies out of the 45 papers based on AI in education that they have selected that went into deep learning in education in the recent decade which further suggests that this topic is relatively new and educational researchers do not have the domain knowledge of modern AI techniques to suggest implementation nor operate such technology, combined with the fact that AI experts do not have knowledge of the pedagogical methodologies or in-depth experiences in the classroom. Based on “Graph neural network based intelligent tutoring system: A survey”, the paper mentioned at most of the research at the moment is based on offline data and that actual implementation and integration in real life scenarios still needed to be considered before a real conclusion can be reached. Based on "Online Practical Deep Learning Education: Using Collective Intelligence from a Resource Sharing Perspective", the author of the paper expressed concern about the lack of practical implementation due to some serious limitations.
[rewrite]: There has been much research on machine learning used in ITS. However, research and implementation of deep learning on ITS is few. The paper "Editorial Note: From Conventional AI to Modern AI in Education: Re-examining AI and Analytic Techniques for Teaching and Learning" pointed out hat most of the implementation of AI focuses on combining traditional AI techniques (rule/statistic based) with education and out of the 45 papers on AI in education within the decade that they have selected, only 2 of them are topics on deep learning. Furthermore, another paper "Graph neural network based intelligent tutoring system: A survey" mentioned that most research at the moment uses offline data and practical integration still needed to be considered before a conclusion can be reached. Finally, the last paper "Online Practical Deep Learning Education: Using Collective Intelligence from a Resource Sharing Perspective", the author of the paper expressed concerns about the lack of practical implementation due to some serious limitations. All these papers suggests that this topic is relatively new and educational researchers do not have the domain knowledge of modern AI techniques to suggest implementation nor operate such technology, combined with the fact that AI experts do not have knowledge of the pedagogical methodologies or in-depth experiences in the classroom.
- Assistant
Similarity Rating: 4 out of 5
Explanation:
The rewrite closely mirrors the content and key ideas presented in the original text, demonstrating a high level of similarity. Both texts discuss:
-
The Prevalence of Traditional AI Techniques in Education:
- Original: Emphasizes that most AI implementations in education focus on traditional, rule/statistic-based models.
- Rewrite: Notes that AI in education primarily combines traditional AI techniques with education.
-
The Scarcity of Deep Learning Applications in Educational Research:
- Original: Highlights that only 2 out of 45 papers examined delved into deep learning in education, suggesting the novelty of the topic.
- Rewrite: Points out that research and implementation of deep learning in Intelligent Tutoring Systems (ITS) are limited, referencing the same statistic.
-
Challenges in Practical Implementation and Integration:
- Original: Mentions concerns about the reliance on offline data and the need for real-world integration before drawing conclusions.
- Rewrite: Reflects the same concerns, stating that practical integration needs consideration before conclusions can be reached.
-
Lack of Domain Knowledge Between AI Experts and Educational Researchers:
- Original: Notes that educational researchers may lack modern AI expertise, while AI experts may lack pedagogical knowledge.
- Rewrite: Conveys the same idea, mentioning that educational researchers and AI experts lack each other's domain knowledge.
Differences Noted:
-
Structure and Flow: The rewrite consolidates the information more succinctly, reorganizing the points for clarity. It introduces the topic by mentioning research on machine learning in ITS and immediately contrasts it with the scarcity of deep learning applications.
-
Minor Rephrasing: Some sentences are reworded for conciseness or clarity, and transitional phrases are used to improve the flow of ideas.
-
Additional Context: The rewrite introduces acronyms like ITS (Intelligent Tutoring Systems) to provide context.
Conclusion:
While there are slight variations in wording and structure, the rewrite effectively retains the essence and key messages of the original text. The high level of content overlap justifies a similarity rating of 4 out of 5.
-