Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
o1-preview-2024-09-12· OpenAIAi2 WildChat-4.8M (AI2)

For every uncountable X ⊆ R, there exists an uncountable Y ⊆ X such that for every…

  1. User

    For every uncountable X ⊆ R, there exists an uncountable Y ⊆ X such that for every distinct a, b, c in Y , we have a + c ̸= 2b.

  2. Assistant

    Yes, the statement is true. For every uncountable subset ( X \subseteq \mathbb{R} ), there exists an uncountable subset ( Y \subseteq X ) such that for every three distinct elements ( a, b, c ) in ( Y ), we have ( a + c \neq 2b ). In other words, ( Y ) contains no nontrivial 3-term arithmetic progressions.

    Proof:

    We will construct such a subset ( Y ) using a transfinite recursive process.

    Step 1: Well-ordering ( X )

    Since ( X ) is uncountable and ( \mathbb{R} ) has the cardinality of the continuum, we can assume the cardinality of ( X ) is at least that of the continuum, denoted by ( \mathfrak{c} ). Let's well-order ( X ) by indexing its elements as ( { x_\alpha : \alpha < \kappa } ), where ( \kappa ) is the cardinality of ( X ).

    Step 2: Constructing ( Y ) via transfinite induction

    We will build ( Y ) as a subset of ( X ) by transfinite induction over the ordinals less than ( \kappa ).

    • Base Case: Let ( Y_0 = \emptyset ).

    • Inductive Step: Suppose we have constructed ( Y_\beta ) for all ( \beta < \alpha ) (where ( \alpha < \kappa )). Let ( Y_{<\alpha} = \bigcup_{\beta < \alpha} Y_\beta ).

      • Consider the element ( x_\alpha ).

      • Define the set of "forbidden" elements for ( x_\alpha ) as: [ F_\alpha = \left{ x \in \mathbb{R} : \text{there exist } a, c \in Y_{<\alpha} \text{ such that } a + c = 2x \text{ or } a + x = 2c \text{ or } x + c = 2a \right}. ] In other words, ( x_\alpha ) is forbidden if adding it to ( Y_{<\alpha} ) would create a 3-term arithmetic progression.

      • Since ( Y_{<\alpha} ) is of cardinality less than ( \kappa ) (because ( \alpha < \kappa )), the set ( F_\alpha ) is also of cardinality less than ( \kappa ).

      • If ( x_\alpha \notin F_\alpha ), we set ( Y_\alpha = Y_{<\alpha} \cup { x_\alpha } ).

      • If ( x_\alpha \in F_\alpha ), we set ( Y_\alpha = Y_{<\alpha} ) (i.e., we skip ( x_\alpha )).

    Step 3: Finalizing ( Y )

    Let ( Y = \bigcup_{\alpha < \kappa} Y_\alpha ).

    • At each step, we exclude at most ( |\alpha| ) elements (since ( F_\alpha ) has cardinality less than ( \kappa )).
    • The total number of elements excluded over all steps is less than ( \kappa \times \kappa = \kappa ) (because ( \kappa ) is an infinite cardinal).
    • Therefore, the number of elements we have included in ( Y ) is at least ( \kappa - \kappa = \kappa ), so ( Y ) is uncountable (specifically, of cardinality ( \kappa )).

    Step 4: Verifying no 3-term arithmetic progression in ( Y )

    By construction, we ensured that no three distinct elements ( a, b, c \in Y ) satisfy ( a + c = 2b ). If such elements existed, they would form a 3-term arithmetic progression, which we've avoided at each step.

    Conclusion:

    Thus, we have found an uncountable subset ( Y \subseteq X ) with no nontrivial 3-term arithmetic progressions, proving the statement is true.