Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
o1-preview-2024-09-12· OpenAIAi2 WildChat-4.8M (AI2)

Please give me the unbiased authentic answer. If a son wants to go to sharia but the mom…

  1. User

    Please give me the unbiased authentic answer. If a son wants to go to sharia but the mom doesn't want him to go there and she's against the idea fully and without a doubt, but if the son goes anyway and breaks her mom's heart as in not doing what she says, will that son be sinful according to authentic hadiths fatawas and everything else? Start with a clear-cut answer then go into details and state everything with an evidence.

  2. Assistant

    In Islam, obedience and kindness to one's parents are of paramount importance, and disobeying them without a valid Islamic reason can be considered sinful. Therefore, if a son pursues studying Sharia (Islamic law) against his mother's clear and unwavering objection, causing her genuine distress, he may be considered sinful unless his pursuit fulfills an obligatory duty that cannot be met otherwise.


    Detailed Explanation with Evidence:

    1. Obligation to Obey and Honor Parents:

      • Qur'anic Injunctions:

        • Allah Almighty commands: "Your Lord has decreed that you worship none but Him, and that you be kind to your parents..." (Surah Al-Isra, 17:23).
        • "And We have enjoined upon man goodness to parents..." (Surah Al-Ankabut, 29:8).
      • Hadiths Emphasizing Parental Obedience:

        • Abdullah ibn Mas'ud reported: "I asked the Prophet (peace and blessings be upon him), 'Which deed is most beloved to Allah?' He said, 'Prayer at its proper time.' I asked, 'Then what?' He said, 'Kindness to parents.' I asked, 'Then what?' He said, 'Jihad in the way of Allah.'" (Sahih Bukhari, Sahih Muslim).

        • Abu Huraira narrated that the Prophet (peace be upon him) said: "No child can repay his father unless he finds him enslaved and then buys him and sets him free." (Sahih Muslim).

        • The Prophet (peace be upon him) also emphasized: "The pleasure of the Lord is in the pleasure of the parent, and the anger of the Lord is in the anger of the parent." (Sunan al-Tirmidhi, Hasan li ghayrihi).

    2. Limits of Parental Obedience:

      • No Obedience in Disobedience to Allah:
        • The Prophet (peace be upon him) said: "There is no obedience to any created being if it involves disobedience to the Creator." (Musnad Ahmad, Sahih).
        • If parents command one to abandon obligatory acts or commit prohibited acts, obedience is not required.
    3. Seeking Knowledge in Islam:

      • Obligatory Knowledge (Fard 'Ayn):

        • The Prophet (peace be upon him) stated: "Seeking knowledge is an obligation upon every Muslim." (Sunan Ibn Majah, Sahih).
        • This refers to essential knowledge required for practicing one's faith correctly (e.g., how to pray, fast, basic beliefs).
      • Communal Obligation (Fard Kifayah):

        • Advanced Islamic studies, such as becoming a scholar, are considered a communal obligation. If some members of the community fulfill it, the obligation is lifted from others.
        • Not everyone is individually obliged to pursue in-depth Sharia studies.
    4. Balancing Parental Rights and Pursuit of Knowledge:

      • Non-Obligatory Acts vs. Parental Obedience:
        • Engaging in virtuous but non-obligatory acts should not come at the expense of disobeying or hurting one's parents.
        • Example from Hadith:
          • Abdullah ibn Amr ibn Al-As narrated: A man came to the Prophet (peace be upon him) and said, "I pledge allegiance to you for emigration and Jihad, seeking reward from Allah." The Prophet asked, "Are your parents alive?" He said, "Yes." The Prophet said, "Then strive in their service." (Sahih Bukhari, Sahih Muslim).
        • This indicates that serving one's parents can take precedence over Jihad, a highly esteemed act in Islam.
    5. Consideration of the Mother's Objection:

      • Understanding Her Reasons:

        • The son should consider why his mother is against him studying Sharia. Is it due to concern for his well-being, fear of separation, or misunderstanding of his intentions?
        • Islam encourages open communication and understanding within families.
      • Possible Solutions:

        • Compromise: If distance is a concern, perhaps he can study locally or through online courses.
        • Assurance: He can reassure his mother of his intentions and the benefits his knowledge will bring to the family and community.
        • Involving Wise Counsel: Seek mediation from knowledgeable and respected family members or community leaders.
    6. Scholarly Opinions (Fatwas):

      • Priority of Parental Rights:

        • Many scholars state that if pursuing additional religious knowledge is not obligatory for the individual, and parents object, one should obey the parents.
        • Ibn Taymiyyah said: "If one's parents forbid him from participating in voluntary jihad, he should obey them, because honoring parents is an individual obligation, whereas jihad is a communal obligation." (Majmu' al-Fatawa).
      • Exception for Obligatory Knowledge:

        • If the knowledge is essential for one's personal religious obligations, then one must pursue it, even if parents object.
    7. Potential Sinfulness:

      • Causing Unnecessary Distress:
        • Deliberately causing sorrow to one's parents without a legitimate Islamic reason is deemed sinful.
        • Obligation to Maintain Family Ties: Islam strongly emphasizes maintaining family harmony and kindness.
    8. Conclusion and Recommendation:

      • If Studying Sharia is Non-Obligatory:

        • The son should prioritize his mother's feelings and seek her approval.
        • He can engage in personal studies without formal enrollment that distresses his mother.
      • If There's a Greater Need:

        • If the community lacks scholars, and he has the aptitude and opportunity to fulfill this communal need, he should gently explain this to his mother, seeking her blessings.
      • Supplication and Trust in Allah:

        • He should make Istikhara (prayer for guidance) and du'a (supplication), asking Allah to facilitate the best outcome.

    Final Thoughts:

    It is essential to balance between one's personal aspirations and parental rights in Islam. Unless the son's pursuit addresses an obligatory need that cannot be achieved otherwise, he should honor his mother's wishes to avoid sin and seek alternative ways to fulfill his desire for knowledge without causing her distress.

Please give me the unbiased authentic answer. If a son… · The Chat Archive