Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
o1-preview-2024-09-12· OpenAIAi2 WildChat-4.8M (AI2)

Please give me the unbiased authentic answer. Could you please tell me 10 things in…

  1. User

    Please give me the unbiased authentic answer. Could you please tell me 10 things in Islam thay are bid'ah for certain?

  2. Assistant

    Certainly! In Islamic theology, bid'ah refers to innovation in religious matters that has no basis in the Qur'an, Sunnah (teachings and practices of Prophet Muhammad, peace be upon him), or the practices of the early generations of Muslims (the Salaf). Such innovations are generally discouraged or prohibited because they may lead people away from the original teachings of Islam. Here are ten practices that are commonly considered bid'ah by many scholars:

    1. Celebrating the Prophet's Birthday (Mawlid an-Nabi):

      • While expressing love for the Prophet Muhammad is encouraged, some scholars consider the formal celebration of his birthday as an innovation, as it was not practiced by the Prophet or his Companions.
    2. Building Elaborate Structures over Graves:

      • Constructing ornate tombs or shrines over graves and venerating them is seen as an innovation that can lead to practices bordering on shirk (associating partners with Allah).
    3. Specific Rituals on Certain Nights (e.g., Mid-Sha'ban):

      • Holding special prayers or rituals on nights like the 15th of Sha'ban without authentic evidence from the Sunnah is considered bid'ah by some scholars.
    4. Group Dhikr with Unconventional Practices:

      • Engaging in collective remembrance of Allah (dhikr) that involves specific movements, chants, or formulas not prescribed in the Sunnah.
    5. Using Prayer Beads (Misbaha) Excessively or Superstitiously:

      • While counting dhikr is permissible, some scholars discourage the use of prayer beads if they lead to showiness or if one believes there is inherent blessing in the beads themselves.
    6. Adding Phrases to the Call to Prayer (Adhan):

      • Inserting additional phrases into the Adhan that were not taught by the Prophet Muhammad is considered an innovation.
    7. Saying Intentions Out Loud Before Prayers:

      • Articulating the intention (niyyah) verbally before beginning the prayer, whereas the Sunnah is to make the intention in the heart.
    8. Designating Unspecified Fasts and Prayers:

      • Instituting specific days for fasting or prayers that the Prophet did not designate, believing there is special merit in them without evidence.
    9. Writing and Wearing Amulets (Taweez) for Protection:

      • Using written verses or symbols as talismans for protection or good fortune, which may lead to superstitious beliefs.
    10. Practices Involving Numerology or Sacred Numbers:

      • Assigning special religious significance to certain numbers or patterns not supported by Islamic texts.

    Note: It's important to recognize that interpretations of what constitutes bid'ah can vary among different Islamic scholars, schools of thought, and cultural contexts. Some practices listed above may be considered acceptable or even beneficial in certain traditions. Therefore, for personal guidance, it's advisable to consult knowledgeable scholars or trusted sources within one's own community.

    I hope this information is helpful to you. If you have further questions or need clarification on any point, please feel free to ask.