Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
o1-preview-2024-09-12· OpenAIAi2 WildChat-4.8M (AI2)

I had an idea on how to communicate faster then the. Speed of light. I have pairs of…

  1. User

    I had an idea on how to communicate faster then the. Speed of light. I have pairs of spin entangled electrons. Of each pair, one electron stays on earth, the other goes with a space ship to somewhere very far. Now I want to communicate. On earth for each electron of a pair person A decidea to measure its spin or not. On the far away space ship for each electron of the pair person B conducts a two split experiment. This will tell person B if person A did the measurement or not and so they can communicate. There must be something wrong. What is wrong in my thinking?

  2. Assistant

    Your thinking encounters a fundamental limitation imposed by quantum mechanics known as the no-signaling theorem. While entanglement is a nonlocal phenomenon, it cannot be used to transmit information faster than light. Here's why:

    1. Entanglement Doesn't Allow for Instantaneous Communication:

    When two particles are entangled, measurements on one immediately affect the state of the other, no matter the distance separating them. However, this effect doesn't allow for the transmission of usable information. The outcome of any individual measurement is random. Although the results are correlated, neither party can control the outcome to send a message.

    2. Local Observations Cannot Reveal Distant Measurements:

    In your scenario, Alice decides whether to measure the spin of her electron or not. Bob, on his distant spaceship, conducts a double-slit experiment with his electron. The crucial point is that Bob's local results—specifically, whether or not he observes an interference pattern—do not depend on Alice's actions in a way that can be distinguished without additional information.

    • If Alice Measures: The act of measuring collapses the entangled state. Bob's electron becomes part of a mixed state, losing its entanglement. However, the mixed state still produces the same statistical results in his double-slit experiment as if Alice hadn't measured anything. Bob cannot detect this change locally.

    • If Alice Doesn't Measure: The electrons remain entangled. Bob's electron is in a superposition of states. But when he conducts his experiment, the statistical distribution of his results remains the same as in the previous case.

    3. Interference Patterns Require Cohesion, Not Entanglement:

    Interference patterns in a double-slit experiment arise from the coherent superposition of paths the particle can take—not from entanglement with another particle. Entanglement with another system (like Alice's electron) can introduce decoherence, which might affect interference patterns. However, any such effect averages out in Bob's measurements, leaving him with no discernible difference.

    4. Randomness of Quantum Measurements:

    Even if Alice tries to send a message by choosing to measure or not, the outcomes are fundamentally probabilistic. Bob can't distinguish between the inherent randomness of quantum mechanics and any potential signal from Alice.

    Conclusion:

    Bob cannot, through any local measurement (including observing interference patterns), determine whether Alice has measured her particle. Since he cannot detect any change in his system based solely on Alice's actions, no information has been transmitted. Therefore, faster-than-light communication using entanglement is not possible within the framework of quantum mechanics.

    What's Wrong in Your Thinking:

    The error lies in assuming that Alice's choice to measure or not measure her particle can influence Bob's local experimental results in a detectable way, allowing for communication. In reality, the statistics of Bob's measurements remain unchanged regardless of Alice's actions. This maintains causality and adheres to the principle that information cannot be transmitted faster than light.

    References for Further Reading:

    • "Quantum Entanglement and Communications Complexity" by Richard Cleve and Harry Buhrman
    • "The Theory of Open Quantum Systems" by Heinz-Peter Breuer and Francesco Petruccione
    • "An Introduction to Quantum Theory" by Keith Hannabuss