Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
o1-mini-2024-09-12· OpenAIAi2 WildChat-4.8M (AI2)

can i generate a marking guide based on 4 crietria that cover all the presentations?…

  1. User

    can i generate a marking guide based on 4 crietria that cover all the presentations? (five parts) following the guide below

    The Assignment This assessment evaluates how students have met the learning outcomes of the module. The assessment consists of a narrated PowerPoint presentation (approximately 15 minutes) covering different aspects of data analytics and decision-making. Below is a step-by-step breakdown of the components and guidelines for the assessment. Task Step 1 Develop and record a narrated PowerPoint presentation to address the following five tasks. For technical guidance, see how to record a slide show with narration and slide timings.Links to an external site. Task 1 - Identify Structured and Unstructured Data Sources • Identify Examples: Share specific examples of both structured (e.g., databases, spreadsheets) and unstructured data (e.g., emails, social media posts) from your professional experience. • Evaluate Benefits and Limitations: Discuss how these data types benefit your decision-making process and any limitations they present in your industry or role. Task 2 - Evaluating Data Sources • Identify Secondary Data Sources: Find secondary data sources relevant to a specific industry or topic. • Evaluate Data: Assess each data source based on relevance, reliability, completeness, timeliness, accessibility, and ethical considerations. • Discuss Usefulness: Explain how these factors influence the data's usefulness for decision-making. Task 3 - Creating a Data Management Plan • Outline the Plan: Present a customised data management plan for your workplace. • Steps and Processes: Include steps for organising, documenting, storing, and sharing data. • Address Needs and Challenges: Explain how your plan addresses the unique needs and challenges of your organisation or industry. Task 4 - Making Data-driven Decisions • Apply Steps: Apply the steps of data-driven decision-making in your workplace context. • Reflect on Process: Reflect on your decision-making process, considering rational models, cognitive biases, and emotional influences. • Data-Based Evidence: Discuss how data-based evidence-informed your decisions and any challenges faced. Task 5 - Communicating Data-driven Decisions • Explain Decisions: Clearly explain the decisions made based on data-based evidence. • Highlight Communication Importance: Emphasise the importance of clear communication to stakeholders. • Provide Examples: Give examples of effective communication strategies you would use to convey decisions within your organization. Step 2 Please do not export your presentation as a video (.mp4 file). Instead, you should save your presentation as a PowerPoint (.pptx) file with your audio and video embedded within it. Step 3 Submit your narrated presentation (.pptx file) in the drop-box below.
    Canvas has a file upload limit of 500MB. If your presentation exceeds this, follow the steps in the following guide to reduce file size - Reduce the file size of your PowerPoint presentationsLinks to an external site..

    1. All criteria should be weighted to give the students an indication of the relative value of each aspect of the assessment.

    2. For Level 1 assignments, up to 8 criteria are acceptable and this plurality is strongly recommended as it affords us a chance to guide the candidate through the minutiae of assessment requirements. This number should reduce to 4 or 5 criteria for higher levels.

    3. At all levels (but especially higher levels) care must be taken NOT to create a criterion in which several disparate requirements are mentioned, yet where specific ‘reward’ for each of these separate ‘subcomponents’ is not made clear.

    4. For each level (1 to 4) the criteria MUST adhere to SCQF guidelines (Levels 7 to 10) .

    5. Expression of each marking criterion should be kept simple. Any extra information or supplementary guidance may be given in the form of an additional ‘indicative answer’ section

    6. Expression of each criterion must be descriptive and NOT directive – thus, imperative verb forms may not be used. In the same vein, it is inappropriate to pose questions to the candidates in the marking criteria. It should be borne in mind that the Marking Criteria are intended solely as an objective account of how marks are to be allocated)*

    7. NO qualitative elements may appear in a marking criterion (e.g. in the first item in the sample above, ‘Fully addresses the question’ would not be acceptable)

  2. Assistant

    Certainly! Below is a Marking Guide based on four criteria that comprehensively cover all five tasks of the narrated PowerPoint presentation assignment. Each criterion is designed to align with higher-level SCQF guidelines (Levels 7 to 10) and includes appropriate weightings to indicate their relative importance.


    Marking Guide for Narrated PowerPoint Presentation

    CriterionDescriptionWeighting
    1. Identification and Evaluation of Data Sources- Structured and Unstructured Data: Provides specific examples of both structured (e.g., databases, spreadsheets) and unstructured data (e.g., emails, social media posts) from professional experience.- Benefits and Limitations: Evaluates the advantages and constraints of these data types in the context of decision-making within the relevant industry or role.25%
    2. Evaluation of Secondary Data Sources- Identification of Sources: Identifies relevant secondary data sources pertinent to a specific industry or topic.- Assessment Criteria: Evaluates each data source based on relevance, reliability, completeness, timeliness, accessibility, and ethical considerations.- Usefulness for Decision-Making: Explains how the assessed factors influence the data's applicability and utility in making informed decisions.25%
    3. Development of a Data Management Plan- Plan Outline: Presents a customised data management plan tailored to the workplace.- Organisational Processes: Details the steps for organising, documenting, storing, and sharing data.- Addressing Needs and Challenges: Demonstrates how the plan meets the unique requirements and overcomes specific challenges of the organisation or industry.25%
    4. Application and Communication of Data-driven Decisions- Decision-Making Process: Applies the steps of data-driven decision-making within the workplace context and reflects on the process, including considerations of rational models, cognitive biases, and emotional influences.- Data-based Evidence: Discusses how data-informed evidence supports decisions and addresses any encountered challenges.- Effective Communication: Explains decisions clearly and highlights the importance of communicating these decisions to stakeholders, providing examples of communication strategies used within the organisation.25%

    Guidelines for Using the Marking Guide

    1. Weighting Allocation: Each criterion holds equal weight (25%) to reflect its significance in the overall assessment. This distribution ensures a balanced evaluation of all aspects of the presentation.

    2. Descriptive Criteria: The descriptions focus on what is required from the student without using directive language. This approach provides clear expectations for each aspect of the assignment.

    3. Comprehensive Coverage: All five tasks outlined in the assignment are addressed within the four criteria, ensuring that each component of the presentation is adequately assessed.

    4. Alignment with SCQF Levels: The criteria are structured to meet the requirements of SCQF Levels 7 to 10, emphasizing higher-order thinking and comprehensive analysis.

    5. Objective Assessment: The criteria avoid qualitative judgments and instead focus on the presence and quality of specific elements, facilitating an objective allocation of marks.


    Indicative Indicators for Each Criterion

    While the primary marking guide should remain free of qualitative terms, instructors may use internal indicators to guide their assessment. Below are examples of what might be considered for each criterion:

    • Criterion 1:

      • Includes at least two examples each of structured and unstructured data.
      • Provides a balanced evaluation of benefits and limitations with relevant industry context.
    • Criterion 2:

      • Identifies multiple relevant secondary data sources.
      • Applies all assessment criteria comprehensively to each data source.
      • Clearly links assessment factors to data usefulness.
    • Criterion 3:

      • Presents a clear and detailed data management plan.
      • Describes each organisational process thoroughly.
      • Demonstrates an understanding of organisational needs and challenges.
    • Criterion 4:

      • Clearly outlines the decision-making steps applied.
      • Reflects thoughtfully on the influences affecting decisions.
      • Provides concrete examples of communication strategies used.

    This marking guide ensures a structured and fair assessment of each student's narrated PowerPoint presentation, aligning with the specified assignment requirements and educational standards.