Climate change is the defining challenge of our time. Our civilization has built untold…
- User
Climate change is the defining challenge of our time. Our civilization has built untold wealth upon 200 years of frantic burning of coal, oil, and gas. Its heat has lifted our species from cold, hunger, ignorance, aremature death, and poverty, in a single century routine famine went from being near-universal to practically unknown.
And yet, burning fossilized carbon carries a hidden cumulative cost, and the bill is coming due. Burning coal and oil turns fossil carbon into CO2 gas that accumulates in the atmosphere far faster than natural processes, sudvas
weathering and plants, can take it back out. Atmospheric CO2, now 50% higher than pre-industrial levels, drives the greenhouse effect and gradually increases Earth's temperature, sea level, and climatic extremes. But these
gradual increases result in enormous effects. Every year, temperatures hit all-time highs and lows, the coast alternately bakes and floods and unseasonal weather harms crops and ecosystems.
Our options seem bleak. We can do nothing and keep on burning fossil fuels until they run out, trying to adapt as climatic forces wipe our civilization from the Earth. There will be all manner of apocalyptic signs, crops falling, extreme floods and fires, mass casualty heat waves, and runaway destabilization of ice sheets raising sea levels.
It is hard to say what will be left after the oceans rise 10 m or so, but for the survivors, it will be a hard life among the ruins of a broken world, with hunger and violence a certainty, it is difficult to imagine how omilization could be rebuilt if the lower rungs of industrial energy, mineral ores, coal, and oil, are depleted. We can't go directly from campfires to nuclear fission, bypassing fossil fuels. Our industrial capacity might be a one hit wonder if we pull the ladder up behind us. In this scenario, human beings probably aren't made extinct, but they are reduced to pre-civilizational subsistence forever.
The alternative is even worse. What if, we are sometimes asked, we simply stopped using oil? Prosecuted oil company CEOs? Grounded our global fleet of aircraft? I can forgive the pure-hearted idealism of these slogans only because our society is so wealthy that many have the luxury of forgetting from whence it springs. Look at your surroundings, everything is built on oill Your food, your water, clothing, medicine, furnishings, houses, cars, careers, are all made from, or powered by, oil.
Question: What is the author's view on the likelihood of civilization rebuilding after a complete depletion of fossil fuels?
Pick ONE option
Civilization will likely rebuild using alternative energy sources.
It will be nearly impossible to rebuild civilization if key industrial resources are depleted.
Rebuilding civilization is certain, but it will take much longer without fossil fuels.
The passage does not address the potential for civilization to rebuild
- Assistant
The author's view appears to be that rebuilding civilization after the complete depletion of fossil fuels and other key industrial resources would be nearly impossible. This perspective is evident in the passage, particularly in the fourth paragraph:
-
"It is difficult to imagine how civilization could be rebuilt if the lower rungs of industrial energy, mineral ores, coal, and oil, are depleted."
-
"We can't go directly from campfires to nuclear fission, bypassing fossil fuels."
-
"Our industrial capacity might be a one hit wonder if we pull the ladder up behind us."
-
"In this scenario, human beings probably aren't made extinct, but they are reduced to pre-civilizational subsistence forever."
These statements suggest that the author believes the depletion of essential resources like fossil fuels would make it exceptionally challenging to rebuild civilization. The metaphor of "pulling the ladder up behind us" implies that the foundational steps (fossil fuels and other resources) necessary for industrial and technological advancement would no longer be available, preventing future generations from retracing the path to rebuild an advanced civilization.
Therefore, the option that best reflects the author's view is:
It will be nearly impossible to rebuild civilization if key industrial resources are depleted.
Answer: It will be nearly impossible to rebuild civilization if key industrial resources are depleted.
-