for(constauto&box:meshobj.boxes){floatcorners[8][3]={{box.min.x,box.min.y,box.min.z},{box…
- User
for(constauto&box:meshobj.boxes){floatcorners[8][3]={{box.min.x,box.min.y,box.min.z},{box.max.x,box.min.y,box.min.z},{box.min.x,box.max.y,box.min.z},{box.max.x,box.max.y,box.min.z},{box.min.x,box.min.y,box.max.z},{box.max.x,box.min.y,box.max.z},{box.min.x,box.max.y,box.max.z},{box.max.x,box.max.y,box.max.z}};for(inti=0;i<8;++i){transformVertexToWorld(corners[i][0],corners[i][1],corners[i][2],placement);}floatminX=corners[0][0],minY=corners[0][1],minZ=corners[0][2];floatmaxX=corners[0][0],maxY=corners[0][1],maxZ=corners[0][2];for(inti=1;i<8;++i){minX=std::min(minX,corners[i][0]);minY=std::min(minY,corners[i][1]);minZ=std::min(minZ,corners[i][2]);maxX=std::max(maxX,corners[i][0]);maxY=std::max(maxY,corners[i][1]);maxZ=std::max(maxZ,corners[i][2]);}floatcenterX=(minX+maxX)/2.0f;floatcenterY=(minY+maxY)/2.0f;floatcenterZ=(minZ+maxZ)/2.0f;floatwidth=maxX-minX;floatheight=maxY-minY;floatdepth=maxZ-minZ;}Why my box rotated wrong (little bit to left)?
- Assistant
The issue with your box rotation likely stems from how the vertex transformation is being handled. Let's break down the potential problems and provide solutions to ensure your box rotates correctly.
1. Transformation Function Usage
Problem:
ThetransformVertexToWorldfunction is used to transform each corner of the box. If this function is intended to modify the coordinates in place, but it's not correctly updating thecornersarray, the transformation won't apply as expected.Solution:
Ensure thattransformVertexToWorldproperly updates thecornersarray. If the function returns the transformed coordinates, you need to capture and assign them back to thecornersarray. Here's an example of how you might modify the code:for (int i = 0; i < 8; ++i) { // Assuming transformVertexToWorld returns a transformed point auto transformed = transformVertexToWorld(corners[i][0], corners[i][1], corners[i][2], placement); corners[i][0] = transformed.x; corners[i][1] = transformed.y; corners[i][2] = transformed.z; }Ensure that
transformVertexToWorldhas the correct signature and correctly applies the transformation. For example:struct Point { float x, y, z; }; Point transformVertexToWorld(float x, float y, float z, const Placement& placement) { // Apply transformation based on placement // This is a placeholder; implement your actual transformation logic here Point transformed; // ... transformation logic ... return transformed; }2. Rotation Center
Problem:
If the rotation is not centered correctly (e.g., it's centered at the origin rather than the box's center), the box may appear to rotate incorrectly, causing it to lean or shift unexpectedly.Solution:
Ensure that the rotation is performed around the box's center. Here's how you can adjust the transformation:-
Calculate the Center Before Rotation:
float centerX = (box.min.x + box.max.x) / 2.0f; float centerY = (box.min.y + box.max.y) / 2.0f; float centerZ = (box.min.z + box.max.z) / 2.0f; -
Translate Corners to Origin, Apply Rotation, Then Translate Back:
for (int i = 0; i < 8; ++i) { // Translate to origin float translatedX = corners[i][0] - centerX; float translatedY = corners[i][1] - centerY; float translatedZ = corners[i][2] - centerZ; // Apply rotation auto rotated = rotateVertex(translatedX, translatedY, translatedZ, placement.rotation); // Translate back corners[i][0] = rotated.x + centerX; corners[i][1] = rotated.y + centerY; corners[i][2] = rotated.z + centerZ; }Ensure that
rotateVertexcorrectly applies the desired rotation.
3. Ensuring Correct Min and Max Calculation
After transforming the vertices, you calculate the new
minandmaxvalues. Ensure that this calculation is correct:float minX = corners[0][0], minY = corners[0][1], minZ = corners[0][2]; float maxX = corners[0][0], maxY = corners[0][1], maxZ = corners[0][2]; for (int i = 1; i < 8; ++i) { minX = std::min(minX, corners[i][0]); minY = std::min(minY, corners[i][1]); minZ = std::min(minZ, corners[i][2]); maxX = std::max(maxX, corners[i][0]); maxY = std::max(maxY, corners[i][1]); maxZ = std::max(maxZ, corners[i][2]); }4. Debugging Steps
To further diagnose the issue:
-
Visualize the Corners:
Print out the coordinates of the corners before and after transformation to ensure they are being transformed correctly. -
Check the Placement Data:
Ensure that theplacementvariable contains the correct rotation values and that they are being applied as intended. -
Verify Transformation Logic:
Double-check the logic withintransformVertexToWorldor any rotation functions to ensure they perform the expected transformations. -
Use a Debugger:
Step through the transformation process using a debugger to observe how each corner is being modified.
5. Sample Corrected Code
Here's a revised version of your code incorporating the above suggestions:
for (const auto& box : meshobj.boxes) { float corners[8][3] = { {box.min.x, box.min.y, box.min.z}, {box.max.x, box.min.y, box.min.z}, {box.min.x, box.max.y, box.min.z}, {box.max.x, box.max.y, box.min.z}, {box.min.x, box.min.y, box.max.z}, {box.max.x, box.min.y, box.max.z}, {box.min.x, box.max.y, box.max.z}, {box.max.x, box.max.y, box.max.z} }; // Transform each corner to world coordinates for (int i = 0; i < 8; ++i) { auto transformed = transformVertexToWorld(corners[i][0], corners[i][1], corners[i][2], placement); corners[i][0] = transformed.x; corners[i][1] = transformed.y; corners[i][2] = transformed.z; } // Calculate min and max after transformation float minX = corners[0][0], minY = corners[0][1], minZ = corners[0][2]; float maxX = corners[0][0], maxY = corners[0][1], maxZ = corners[0][2]; for (int i = 1; i < 8; ++i) { minX = std::min(minX, corners[i][0]); minY = std::min(minY, corners[i][1]); minZ = std::min(minZ, corners[i][2]); maxX = std::max(maxX, corners[i][0]); maxY = std::max(maxY, corners[i][1]); maxZ = std::max(maxZ, corners[i][2]); } // Calculate center and dimensions float centerX = (minX + maxX) / 2.0f; float centerY = (minY + maxY) / 2.0f; float centerZ = (minZ + maxZ) / 2.0f; float width = maxX - minX; float height = maxY - minY; float depth = maxZ - minZ; // You can now use centerX, centerY, centerZ, width, height, depth as needed }Summary
- Ensure
transformVertexToWorldcorrectly updates the corner coordinates. - Rotate around the box's center to prevent unintended shifts.
- Verify the min and max calculations post-transformation.
- Debug step-by-step to identify where the rotation deviates.
By carefully checking each step of the transformation and ensuring that coordinates are correctly updated and rotated around the intended center, you should achieve the correct rotation without the unintended left shift.
-