Read the definitions of the sentence cited below. Comment on the arguments posed by the…
- User
Read the definitions of the sentence cited below. Comment on the arguments posed by the scholar in intention to focus either logical, psychological or linguistic aspects in defining the sentence. A sentence is an expression of a thought or feeling by means of a word or words used in such form and manner as to convey the meaning intended. (G.Gurme) An oral or written communication is made up of one or more units, each of which contains a complete utterance formed according to a definite pattern. Such units are called sentences. (R. W. Zandvoort) The sentence is a communication in words conveying a sense of completeness and containing at least one independent verb with its subject. (M.Bryant)
- Assistant
The definitions of a sentence provided by G. Gurme, R. W. Zandvoort, and M. Bryant each emphasize different aspects of sentence construction, reflecting a focus on logical, psychological, or linguistic elements:
-
G. Gurme's Definition: Gurme emphasizes the psychological aspect of a sentence by identifying it as an expression of thought or feeling. This definition underlines the sentence's purpose to convey meaning and intention, focusing on the communicative and expressive functions of language. The reference to intention suggests that understanding a sentence involves considering the speaker's or writer's psychological state and intentions, placing importance on how sentences reflect internal cognitive processes.
-
R. W. Zandvoort's Definition: Zandvoort focuses on the linguistic and structural aspects by referring to a sentence as a communication unit formed according to a definite pattern. This definition highlights the syntactical element, considering a sentence as a unit of communication with a structured pattern. The linguistic angle is evident in his description of sentences having a complete utterance and pattern, reinforcing the role of grammar and syntax in sentence formation and understanding.
-
M. Bryant's Definition: Bryant incorporates both logical and grammatical perspectives by defining a sentence as a communication that conveys completeness and contains an independent verb with its subject. Here, the logical aspect is suggested through the requirement of completeness, implying a coherence and wholeness to the communicated idea. Additionally, the linguistic focus is apparent in specifying the presence of an independent verb and subject, anchoring the definition in grammatical terms.
Overall, while each scholar provides a unique angle, there is an overlap in focusing on how sentences serve as vehicles for communication, with varying emphasis on the psychological motivations, linguistic structures, and logical completeness inherent in sentence construction.
-