The solution to Moore's paradox we reached in the last question is due to Jaakko…
- User
The solution to Moore's paradox we reached in the last question is due to Jaakko Hintikka (in his book "Knowledge and Belief"). Because Hintikka's solution requires the logic of belief to be D4 and not just D, he is committed to the thesis that: Group of answer choices If I believe I believe p, then I believe p If I believe p, I believe that I believe that p If I believe p, then p if p, then I believe p
- Assistant
The solution to Moore's paradox according to Jaakko Hintikka implicates that the logic of belief must include both the seriality axiom (D) and the positive introspection axiom (4), thus forming system D4.
System D involves the axiom which ensures that belief is consistent: if one believes something, it is possible. However, system D alone is insufficient to address Moore's paradox according to Hintikka.
By including axiom 4, which states that if a person believes something, they also believe that they believe it (formally ( \text{If } \mathbf{B}p \text{ then } \mathbf{B}\mathbf{B}p )), the system becomes D4. This positive introspection is crucial for Hintikka’s solution because it formalizes the notion that a person is aware of their own beliefs.
Therefore, Hintikka is committed to the thesis:
If I believe p, I believe that I believe that p.
Answer: If I believe p, I believe that I believe that p