"Hey bob you can have a submachine gun But not too many And they cant shoot too fast or…
- User
"Hey bob you can have a submachine gun But not too many And they cant shoot too fast or be too big John you can have a submachine gun But not too many as well.. Paul. im sorry but your only allowed to have pistols and a limited size and number of them as well. and as for the others. Your only allowed knives And a limited amount of those and sharpness.." Why would this agreement make no one happy. (this is meant to be an anaology for the washington naval treaty btw)
- Assistant
The agreement makes no one happy because it imposes restrictions on everyone, limiting their access to weapons (or, in the analogy, naval power) in a way that leaves all parties dissatisfied.
In the analogy:
- Bob and John are allowed submachine guns but with limitations on the number, size, and firing rate.
- Paul is restricted to pistols with limitations on size and quantity.
- The others are only permitted knives, with restrictions on the number and sharpness.
No one gets exactly what they want:
- Bob and John can't fully utilize their advantage because their submachine guns are limited.
- Paul feels disadvantaged compared to Bob and John because he's only allowed pistols.
- The others are at an even greater disadvantage, only allowed knives.
Relating this to the Washington Naval Treaty:
- The major naval powers (like the United States and the United Kingdom) had to accept limitations on their battleships and aircraft carriers, reducing their naval superiority.
- Emerging naval powers (like Japan) were allotted a smaller ratio, feeling unfairly constrained compared to the dominant powers.
- Smaller naval powers (like France and Italy) received even less favorable terms, limiting their ability to expand their navies.
Why this makes no one happy:
- Dominant Powers: They have to reduce or limit their capabilities, losing some of their strategic advantage.
- Rising Powers: They feel the limitations prevent them from achieving parity or asserting themselves on the world stage.
- Smaller Powers: They perceive the agreement as cementing their inferior status without the opportunity to grow.
Overall, the agreement aims to prevent an arms race by imposing limitations, but in doing so, it leaves all parties feeling constrained and dissatisfied. Each party is restricted in ways that prevent them from achieving their strategic goals, mirroring the discontent caused by the Washington Naval Treaty.
Answer: Because like the Washington Naval Treaty, the agreement imposes limiting restrictions on everyone—nobody gets all the weapons they want, and all feel disadvantaged by constraints on quantity and capability—so no one is happy since each party is prevented from fully achieving their goals or maintaining their desired power.