Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
o1-preview-2024-09-12· OpenAIAi2 WildChat-4.8M (AI2)

三、 是非題:(40 分) (1) 一個好的(good)論証,其前提必定皆為真。 (2) 一組邏輯上不一致的語句,一定會蘊涵(entail)所有語句。 (3) “All S…

  1. User

    三、 是非題:(40 分) (1) 一個好的(good)論証,其前提必定皆為真。 (2) 一組邏輯上不一致的語句,一定會蘊涵(entail)所有語句。 (3) “All S are P” 與 “No S are P” 是兩個彼此矛盾的句式。 (4) 一個結論為假的有效論証,其前提不可能皆為真。 (5) 兩個不同的單純語句之間,必定具有邏輯上互相獨立的(logically independent)關係。 (6) 充足的水分是維持一個人生命的充分條件。 (7) 一個好的歸納論證一定也是一個好的演繹論證。 (8) 一個有效論證的前提如果是一組邏輯上不一致的(logically inconsistent)陳述句,其結論必定為假。 (9) 一個不好的(bad)論證,其結論必定也是假的。 (10) 一個具說服力的(uncogent)論証,也會是個強的論証。

    A、B、C、和D四人晚上過橋,現得電筒一枝,過橋時一定要有電筒才能過到橋的對面,而同一時間只可以有兩個人在橋上,而A、B、C、D過橋時間分別為1,2,5,10分鐘,問他們最少要用多少時間才可以過完橋?

  2. Assistant

    To answer the questions, let's consider each one carefully.

    (1) A good argument must have all true premises.

    Answer: True

    A key aspect of a good (sound) deductive argument is that not only is it valid (the conclusion logically follows from the premises), but all its premises are indeed true. This ensures the conclusion must also be true, satisfying the definition of a sound argument.


    (2) A set of logically inconsistent statements entails any statement.

    Answer: True

    This is known as the principle of explosion in logic. From a contradiction (an inconsistent set of premises), any conclusion can logically follow because the inconsistent premises cannot all be true simultaneously.


    (3) "All S are P" and "No S are P" are contradictory forms of sentences.

    Answer: False

    In traditional logic, "All S are P" and "No S are P" are contraries, not contradictories. Contraries cannot both be true but can both be false. Contradictories (like "All S are P" and "Some S are not P") cannot both be true and cannot both be false; they always have opposite truth values.


    (4) In a valid argument with a false conclusion, its premises cannot all be true.

    Answer: True

    In a valid deductive argument, if all premises are true, the conclusion must be true. Therefore, if the conclusion is false, at least one of the premises must be false.


    (5) Any two distinct simple sentences must be logically independent of each other.

    Answer: False

    Two simple sentences can be logically related. For example, "It is raining" and "The ground is wet" are distinct but not independent, as one may logically influence the other. Logical independence requires that the truth of one does not affect the truth of the other, which isn't guaranteed merely because sentences are distinct and simple.


    (6) Adequate hydration is a sufficient condition for maintaining human life.

    Answer: False

    While adequate hydration is necessary for life, it is not sufficient on its own; humans also need nutrients, oxygen, etc. Therefore, it's a necessary but not sufficient condition.


    (7) A good inductive argument must also be a good deductive argument.

    Answer: False

    Inductive and deductive arguments function differently. A good inductive argument (strong and with true premises) provides probable support for its conclusion, but not the certainty required in a deductively valid argument. Therefore, a good inductive argument isn't necessarily a good deductive one.


    (8) In a valid argument, if the premises are logically inconsistent statements, the conclusion must be false.

    Answer: False

    From inconsistent premises, any conclusion can be logically derived (again, the principle of explosion). Thus, the conclusion derived from inconsistent premises can be either true or false; validity concerns the structure, not the truth values.


    (9) A bad argument must have a false conclusion.

    Answer: False

    An argument can be bad (invalid or with false premises) and still have a true conclusion. The quality of an argument is about the logical connection between premises and conclusion, not necessarily the truth value of the conclusion itself.


    (10) An uncogent argument can also be a strong argument.

    Answer: True

    An uncogent inductive argument is either weak or has at least one false premise. Therefore, if an argument is strong but has a false premise, it is uncogent. Thus, an uncogent argument can still be strong.


    For the bridge-crossing puzzle:

    Minimum total time required for all to cross: 17 minutes

    Strategy:

    1. A and B cross the bridge first with the flashlight. Time taken: 2 minutes (the slower person's time).
    2. A returns with the flashlight. Time taken: 1 minute.
    3. C and D cross the bridge together with the flashlight. Time taken: 10 minutes.
    4. B returns with the flashlight. Time taken: 2 minutes.
    5. A and B cross again with the flashlight. Time taken: 2 minutes.

    Total time: (2 + 1 + 10 + 2 + 2 = 17) minutes.

    This method minimizes the total time by ensuring that the two slowest individuals, C and D, cross together, and the fastest individuals are used to transport the flashlight whenever possible.


    Answer: Problem 1 answers:

    1. True 2. True 3. False 4. True 5. False 6. False 7. False 8. False 9. False 10. True

    Problem 2 answer: They can all cross the bridge in 17 minutes, which is the minimum total time.