Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
gpt-4o-2024-08-06· OpenAIAi2 WildChat-4.8M (AI2)

Give me original and cohesive detailed commentary on this using a critical straitforward…

  1. User

    Give me original and cohesive detailed commentary on this using a critical straitforward informal tone: congrats to lisa, but how an English song by a Thai artist under her newly formed Thai label can win the category of Best K-Pop makes no sense to me. She should've been afforded the "privilege" of being put into the main pop category, but I can see the VMAs are childishly using the label of K-Pop to just mean any Asian artist. It's such a conundrum, because honestly speaking, her song isn't near as impactful to be in pop categories while it's indeed a pop song, but they want that 'K-pop' cloud and social engagements, they also invited her to perform, so they will give her something. Thus I think they took the 'easy' way out by pushing her song in K-pop category, specially as they seem to gather any Asian artists in this category nowadays.

    We see how they treated huge hits like fifty fifty's 'Cupid' or Jungkook's 'Seven', these awards shows having K-pop categories was never a blessing for the K-pop industry. I personally don't think JK's "Seven" should've been labeled as K-Pop either since it was a fully English, totally global smash hit with an American artist featured, but Jungkook is Korean and debuted it under a Korean label so it was easier for the VMAs to label him as k-pop.

    Tyla really spoke to me during the show when she made sure to point out that not all African artists are afro-beats artists. Currently, Lisa's solo career has no association with "K"-Pop at all, seeing how she's Thai and her company is a Thai company, so it feels slightly tone deaf to be labeling her k-pop to me. I think the West has no idea or even interest to make the distinction between releases, group or solo careers. Like, the industry they debuted in or their nationality/ethnicity shouldn't define what category they are in, the music should. When it's a pop song, it should be in pop categories, it's as easy as that but Western industry will just always prioritize American artists, specially white ones. That's why Beyoncé is shutdown from the country conversation, that Latin artists are stuck in 'Latin' GRAMMYs or black artists in specific categories.

  2. Assistant

    I get where you’re coming from, and your frustration is definitely valid. The idea of slotting Lisa’s English song under the "Best K-Pop" category at the VMAs feels a bit like they’re trying to fit a square peg into a round hole. It highlights a larger issue with how Western award shows often mislabeled or misinterpret non-Western music. It’s like they toss the term "K-Pop" around as a catch-all for any Asian artists, which does a disservice not only to the artists but to the genre itself.

    Putting Lisa in the K-Pop category seems more like a lazy attempt to capitalize on the popularity of K-Pop rather than giving her the recognition she deserves in a broader pop context. It’s a complicated situation because, while her music might not have the massive pop cultural impact needed for the main pop categories, it still doesn’t neatly fit into what's traditionally considered K-Pop, especially when it involves her solo work from a Thai label.

    The VMAs and other award shows could take a page from Tyla’s comment about African artists: not everyone fits neatly into one genre or category based on their ethnicity or origin. It’s reductive and fails to appreciate the diversity and nuance in music today. Just because Jungkook is Korean doesn't mean his song "Seven" should automatically default to K-Pop, especially when it’s a global hit featuring an American artist.

    And your point about the Western music industry putting American, particularly white, artists at the forefront is spot on. There’s a long-standing tendency to pigeonhole artists of color into specific categories, whether it’s Beyoncé being sidelined in the country genre or Latin artists being confined to the Latin Grammys. These categorizations often seem to prioritize marketability and ease of labeling over genuine musical classification.

    Ultimately, the music industry could benefit from developing a more nuanced understanding and appreciation of global music beyond these simplistic and often misguided categorizations. Recognizing artists for the scope and style of their music rather than their nationality or the genre they're typically associated with would be a step in the right direction.