Give me original and cohesive detailed commentary on this using a critical straitforward…
- User
Give me original and cohesive detailed commentary on this using a critical straitforward informal tone: it's really a shame that people for once can't look away from the whole "big company, bad" thing and use nuance here. yes ofc, hybe are definitely involved in shady shit and aren't all a-ok, but neither is mhj. the issue is she's positioned herself, from the start, as a caring mother-figure who's all alone fighting this big bad wolf, and it's managed to garner the sympathy of the GP despite the horrors of her actions. i hope people can use their eyes to say despite everyone having transgressed against everyone, mhj's literally just evil and we currently have more factual and damning evidence of her being such than hybe's ceo or bpd.
I feel like NewJeans were convinced that they would have a lot more power if they came out with a statement behind everyone's back. But they didn't realise that a lot of their points weren't valid from both a legal and a professional standpoint. We really need to consider how isolated they must have felt to be pushed to such a point. Everyone saw the outcome of what happened with 50-50, they must have as well. Inspite of that, they decide to resort to such a drastic measure. They can be wrong, but also be suffering by the hands that were supposed to feed them as well. They're not mutually exclusive.
I still think it's in poor taste for them to have forgotten that they were able to use both hybes resources and contacts to further their careers, but it's also important to acknowledge that all the important adults in their lives are supporting mhj.
They should understand that mhj's scandal caused a world of hurt for illit and lsfm, but it's not the public's duty to punish them for their ceos misdeeds. They're standing up for someone who they think has always defended them. Unfortunately that someone has also done some extremely questionable things, which they seem to gloss over. This seems to be the result of years of trust, faith and manipulation.
- Assistant
It’s a complex situation that requires more than the usual “big company bad” reflex. We’ve got layers here, and nobody involved is wearing a white hat. Yes, HYBE has its fair share of shady dealings—undoubtedly, no corporation of its size is squeaky clean. But let’s not pretend that MHJ is a scrappy underdog when she’s clearly got skeletons rattling her closet doors.
MHJ's positioning as a lone maternal figure battling a corporate Goliath is more PR strategy than reality. It’s brilliant in a way—capitalizing on the big bad corporation narrative to deflect from her own questionable history. Let’s be honest, we’ve got more tangible evidence pointing fingers at MHJ’s past and her unsavory actions than we do against HYBE's top brass at the moment.
Then there's NewJeans, who appear to have made a bold but perhaps ill-advised move by coming out with a statement. It’s easy to see their desperation, perhaps feeling cornered or brushed aside, much like the 50-50 situation. They seem to be standing at a precarious intersection of gratitude for the opportunities given by HYBE’s resources and networks, and resentment for feeling sidelined or manipulated.
Their decision reflects poorly on their grasp of the legal and professional implications, but it’s essential to consider the human aspect: they’re possibly feeling isolated and betrayed. It’s a classic case of not knowing who to trust when the very hands that feed them are tinged with manipulation. It’s not wrong to bite a feeding hand if it’s also the hand that smacks you around.
The allegiance shown by NewJeans to MHJ might look like mindless loyalty, but it likely stems from years of built-up trust and emotional investment. It’s like when you know your best friend is a mess but standing by them feels like an obligation because of history, not logic. The scandal has undeniably impacted other groups like ILIT and LSFM, but the public can’t be expected to do damage control on behalf of NewJeans, especially when the foundation of their stance appears as shaky as it does.
Ultimately, this is an entanglement of professional missteps, personal loyalties, and emotional manipulation. Each party—be it the corporation, the “mother-figure,” or the idol group—navigates a complex web of relationships, power dynamics, and public perceptions. It’s all messed up, and it’s critical we see that while everyone’s got a role in this drama, some roles are more treacherous than others.