Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
gpt-4o-2024-05-13· OpenAIAi2 WildChat-4.8M (AI2)

write a rebuttal to this "Recently, I watched the MK1 cutscenes and thought the…

  1. User

    write a rebuttal to this "Recently, I watched the MK1 cutscenes and thought the characters look cool, so I wanted to draw them. As I was looking for references I noticed that their inner robe collar is on the wrong… side? Characters like Scorpion or Sub-Zero are wearing outfits that are clearly inspired by East Asian robes, but their collars are put in the way that the right side is on top of the left side (only corpses wear their robes that way). Which brought me to this question, whether if I should keep it by justifying that this is a design choice (indicating that they’re figuratively dead) or whether I should fix it in my fanart.

    TLDR, I’m not familiar with Scorpion or Sub-Zero’s full lore, but I want to draw them in their MK1 versions. Found that their robe collar is not culturally accurate. Should I fix it in my fa or not?"

  2. Assistant

    While it is important to be culturally respectful and accurate whenever possible, the concerns raised about the collar orientation of Scorpion and Sub-Zero's outfits in Mortal Kombat 1 (MK1) can be viewed from a different perspective. Here are several points to consider in a rebuttal:

    1. Creative License and Design Choices:

      • Mortal Kombat is a fantasy series that amalgamates elements from various cultures and myths, often taking creative liberties. The design of the characters' costumes is likely a stylistic choice intended to establish a unique aesthetic rather than a strict adherence to any specific tradition.
    2. Context of the Mortal Kombat Universe:

      • The Mortal Kombat universe is one where the boundaries between life, death, and realms are blurred. Using a robe design that may traditionally signify death could be an intentional move, reflecting the characters' complex roles and experiences. Scorpion, for example, is a specter, and playing with death motifs could be symbolic.
    3. Respecting the Original Design:

      • Fan art often aims to celebrate and stay true to the source material. Adhering to the original design shows respect to the creators' vision. Adjusting it might stray too far from the distinctive look that fans identify with and appreciate.
    4. Cultural Evolution in Media:

      • Media representations evolve, and characters designed with a blend of cultural inspirations reflect this progress. This mishmash can create new interpretations and meanings, contributing to cultural dialogue and exchange in contemporary media.
    5. Personal Artistic Expression:

      • As an artist, you have the freedom to interpret characters in your own way. If you feel strongly about making the collars culturally accurate, that's a valid choice. Conversely, maintaining the design as it is can also be seen as a form of authenticity to the original depiction.
    6. Audience Expectations:

      • The fan community often expects certain visual cues and designs that they recognize. Altering the attire might lead to confusion or dissatisfaction among some fans who appreciate and expect fidelity to the game's visuals.

    TLDR: While the cultural accuracy of the collar orientation is a valid concern, the artistic and contextual justifications for keeping the design as it is can also be strong. Whether you choose to adhere to the traditional character design or adjust it for cultural accuracy should align with your personal artistic vision and the message you wish to convey through your fan art.