Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
gpt-4o-2024-05-13· OpenAIAi2 WildChat-4.8M (AI2)

give a gap analysis table based on these literature review : Attia et al. (2019)…

  1. User

    give a gap analysis table based on these literature review : Attia et al. (2019) presented a multi objective optimization model for intermediate term planning of the supply chain in upstream hydrocarbon resources. The proposed model considered the environmental aspects and sustainability in planning chain operations. The model considers sustainability as an objective by minimizing the depletion rate of the reservoir. Beiranvand et al. (2018) developed a mathematical programming model for Iran's crude oil supply chain. The model consists of crude oil, refinery, petro chemistry, and downstream uses. By increasing the revenue from the sale of oil and its derivatives, as well as decreasing the related costs, the model attempts to maximize the amount of profit from the crude oil market and its derivatives. In order to consider real-world conditions with regard to the uncertainties, a robust optimization model was developed to increase the profitability of the whole chain by considering different scenarios. The model considers the possibility of violating the demand limit. In another study, Nicoletti and You (2020) modeled the crude oil supply chain from the oil well to the refinery as a mixed integer bi level linear program, including the conflicting objectives and interactions among different stakeholders. The composition, pricing, transportation distances, and environmental impacts of crude oil were considered in the model. In the bi level problem, crude oil producers aim to maximize their profits from selling crude oil, while crude oil refiner has dual objectives of both maximizing the profit from selling products to the market and minimizing the environmental effect of refinery products during their life cycle, which is determined by the type of crude oil purchased by the refinery. Then, the resulting model was applied in the two case studies. Zarrinpoor and Omidvari (2021) presented a mathematical model for designing the crude oil supply chain through considering related to facility location, demand allocation, transportation, and distribution planning. The proposed model considered the environmental requirements for greenhouse gas emissions, where the amount of greenhouse gas emissions from oil transportation cannot exceed a certain amount. The uncertainty of budget parameters, capacity of transportation units, capacity of exploitation units, quantity of exports, and amount of crude oil extraction and production, as well as the demand for refinery products and their production rate were included in the proposed model. In addition, a robust optimization approach was employed to deal with uncertainty in the model parameters. Numerical results verified the efficiency of the proposed model and indicated that the efficiency of the model decreases by increasing the uncertainty level of profitability. However, the profitability of oil supply chain can be guaranteed by handling the uncertainties of the parameters and appropriate production and distribution management. Some papers also included gas-natwork in their models. For example, Mikolajková et al. (2017) designed an optimization model for gas distribution pipeline network by considering supply of gas. Behrooz and Bozarjmehri (2017) studied the daily planning of natural gas transmission systems under demand uncertainty. Bittante et al. (2018) developed a mathematical model to help decide on the tactical aspects of gas supply chain design by focusing maritime transport between a set of supply ports and sparsely distributed receiving ports with given demands. Zarei and Naseri (2019) designed a natural gas supply chain (NGSC composed of oil and gas fields, refineries, distribution centers (DCs), or major consumption centers, import and export terminals, and underground storage reservoirs (USRs) by developing a mixed integer linear programming (MILP) model which optimizes the location of new facilities and pipeline routes together with the capacity and number of pipelines. Additionally, they formulated the expansion of the existing facilities and pipeline routes, extraction and production rates, gas storage, transmission flow rates, and import and export volumes on a limited time horizon. Azarakhsh et al., (2021) presents a multi-objective, scenario-based mixed-integer linear programming model for the entire oil supply chain, addressing uncertainties and incorporating social, environmental, and risk management aspects, validated using real data. Redutskiy and Balycheva (2024) address a research gap by proposing a mixed-integer nonlinear programming model for planning capacities and coordinating activities in the integrated petroleum supply chain, focusing on minimizing energy consumption and enhancing operational efficiency.

    C. STRATEGIC AND TACTICAL PLANNING According to Chopra and Meindl (2007), the strategic problem in supply chain management involves designing the infrastructure of the supply chain to align it with the strategic objectives of companies in the network. Optimization models aid decision-making processes across the network, improving overall profitability by balancing sourcing, production, inventory, and transportation costs while maintaining required service levels, as highlighted by Barbosa-Póvoa (2014). Facility location, capacity sizing, technology selection, transportation modes, outsourcing, and investment decisions are key strategic decisions (Sahebi et al., 2014) that have a long-term impact on the supply chain due to high setup costs. In tactical planning, the goal is to optimize the established configuration by making decisions related to production, distribution, resource planning, inventory management, and control policies within a timeframe of a few months to a year. Combining strategic and tactical decisions in network design leads to better outcomes, as noted by Barbosa-Póvoa (2014) and Papageorgiou (2009). Rafie and Sahebi (2021) introduces an optimization model for integrating gas-oil and biodiesel supply chains, optimizing their connection points with economic and environmental objectives. Applied to a real case study in Iran, the model addresses location, allocation, production planning, inventory management, and capacity expansion, showing promise for future fuel source management and supply chain integration research. Alnaqbi et al., (2023) proposes a stochastic model for tactical planning of the Crude Oil Supply Chain (COSC) to address cost and demand uncertainties. The model integrates multi-echelon supply chains, multiple products, and a multi-period planning horizon, considering inventory and backorder penalties. Using Sample Average Approximation (SAA) with Multiple Replications Procedure (MRP), the model illustrates the impact of cost uncertainty on planning decisions and synergy gains, highlighting the value of modeling uncertainty in supply chain planning. Finally, in this paper, we consider strategic and tactical planning in an integrated model.

  2. Assistant

    Below is a gap analysis table derived from the literature review provided. It focuses on different elements covered in the studies, highlighting common themes and identifying gaps.

    ReferencesObjective/FocusModeling ApproachUncertainties TackledSustainability/Efficiency ConsiderationsNotable Gaps
    Attia et al. (2019)Intermediate-term planning of upstream hydrocarbon supply chainMulti-objective optimization modelN/AEnvironmental aspects, sustainability by minimizing reservoir depletion rateDoes not address downstream supply chain; lacks robust optimization for uncertainties
    Beiranvand et al. (2018)Maximize profit in Iran's crude oil supply chainMathematical programming modelRobust optimization, scenariosFocus on increasing revenue, decreasing costs; considers violation of demand limitsLimited to Iran's context; lack of broader generalizability
    Nicoletti and You (2020)Crude oil supply chain from oil well to refineryMixed-integer bi-level linear programScenariosComposition, pricing, transportation distances, environmental impacts; conflicting stakeholder objectivesComplex multi-stakeholder interaction; applicability to other regions not demonstrated
    Zarrinpoor and Omidvari (2021)Design of crude oil supply chainMathematical modelRobust optimizationEnvironmental requirements for greenhouse gas emissions; impact of uncertainty on profitabilityFocuses mainly on design; less on operational/tactical aspects
    Mikolajková et al. (2017)Optimization model for gas distribution pipeline networkOptimization modelN/AFocuses on daily supply of gasDoes not integrate with oil supply chain; limited to pipeline optimization
    Behrooz and Bozarjmehri (2017)Daily planning of natural gas transmissionOptimization modelDemand uncertaintyN/AShort-term planning focus; lacks broader supply chain considerations
    Bittante et al. (2018)Tactical aspects of gas supply chainMathematical modelN/AMaritime transport between supply and receiving portsDoes not cover upstream oil supply chain integration
    Zarei and Naseri (2019)Natural gas supply chain designMixed-integer linear programming (MILP) modelN/AOptimize location, capacity, and number of pipelines; considers import/export volumesNo detailed focus on environmental aspects
    Azarakhsh et al., (2021)Entire oil supply chain; multi-objective optimizationScenario-based mixed-integer linear programmingAddress multiple uncertaintiesSocial, environmental, and risk management aspectsComplex model; may be challenging to apply without real data
    Redutskiy and Balycheva (2024)Planning capacities in petroleum supply chainMixed-integer nonlinear programmingN/AMinimize energy consumption, enhance operational efficiencyDoes not address tactical planning thoroughly; focus on energy only
    Rafie and Sahebi (2021)Integrating gas-oil and biodiesel supply chainsOptimization modelN/AEconomic and environmental objectives; applied to a real case study in IranLimited to a specific use case; needs broader application
    Alnaqbi et al., (2023)Tactical planning of the COSCStochastic modelCost/demand uncertaintiesInventory and backorder penalties; integrates multi-echelon supply chainsFocuses primarily on tactical aspects; lacks integration of long-term strategic planning

    Key Observations from the Gap Analysis:

    1. Integration across Supply Chains: Most studies focus either on the crude oil or natural gas supply chains in isolation. Limited attention is given to the integrated optimization of both.
    2. Uncertainty Modeling: While several models consider uncertainties (e.g., Beiranvand et al. (2018), Zarrinpoor and Omidvari (2021), and Alnaqbi et al. (2023)), there is scope for more comprehensive approaches combining robust and stochastic optimization.
    3. Sustainability Focus: Environmental considerations are integrated well in some models (e.g., Attia et al. (2019), Nicoletti and You (2020)), but social and broader sustainability elements are less frequently addressed.
    4. Strategic vs. Tactical Planning: Few models effectively combine both strategic and tactical planning aspects (e.g., Raphael and Sahebi (2021)). Models largely focus on either long-term design or short-term operational planning.
    5. Comprehensive Multi-Objective Models: Studies like Azarakhsh et al. (2021) present comprehensive models addressing multiple objectives; however, their complexity and applicability might limit their usability.

    This analysis identifies areas where future research could focus, such as developing integrated strategic and tactical models, enhancing robustness in uncertainty considerations, and increasing the focus on complete sustainability—including social impacts.