my loss goes to be negative, check and let me know about my mistakes, the loss is cosine…
- User
my loss goes to be negative, check and let me know about my mistakes, the loss is cosine sim.import pandas as pd import numpy as np import tensorflow as tf from sklearn.model_selection import train_test_split from sklearn.metrics import accuracy_score, roc_auc_score from sklearn.metrics import mean_absolute_error, explained_variance_score import matplotlib.pyplot as plt from sklearn.cross_decomposition import CCA
Load data
d1 = pd.read_csv("/zi/home/sajad.rezaei/clip/clip/02_Full_Pipeline/data/psytools/IMAGEN-IMGN_ADRS_CHILD_FU2-IMAGEN_DIGEST.csv") d2 = pd.read_csv("/zi/home/sajad.rezaei/clip/clip/02_Full_Pipeline/data/psytools/IMAGEN-IMGN_ANXDX_CHILD_FU2-IMAGEN_DIGEST.csv") d3 = pd.read_csv("/zi/home/sajad.rezaei/clip/clip/02_Full_Pipeline/data/psytools/IMAGEN-IMGN_AUDIT_CHILD_FU2-IMAGEN_DIGEST.csv") d4 = pd.read_csv("/zi/home/sajad.rezaei/clip/clip/02_Full_Pipeline/data/psytools/IMAGEN-IMGN_BIS_CHILD_FU2-IMAGEN_DIGEST.csv") d5 = pd.read_csv("//zi/home/sajad.rezaei/clip/clip/02_Full_Pipeline/data/psytools/IMAGEN-IMGN_CAPE_CHILD_FU2-IMAGEN_DIGEST.csv") d6 = pd.read_csv("/zi/home/sajad.rezaei/clip/clip/02_Full_Pipeline/data/psytools/IMAGEN-IMGN_CSI_CHILD_FU2-IMAGEN_DIGEST.csv") d7 = pd.read_csv("/zi/home/sajad.rezaei/clip/clip/02_Full_Pipeline/data/psytools/IMAGEN-IMGN_CTQ_CHILD_FU2-IMAGEN_DIGEST.csv") d8 = pd.read_csv("/zi/home/sajad.rezaei/clip/clip/02_Full_Pipeline/data/psytools/IMAGEN-IMGN_EDEQ_CHILD_FU2-IMAGEN_DIGEST.csv") d9= pd.read_csv("/zi/home/sajad.rezaei/clip/clip/02_Full_Pipeline/data/psytools/IMAGEN-IMGN_JVQ_CHILD_FU2-IMAGEN_DIGEST.csv") d10= pd.read_csv("/zi/home/sajad.rezaei/clip/clip/02_Full_Pipeline/data/psytools/IMAGEN-IMGN_TFEQ_CHILD_FU2-IMAGEN_DIGEST.csv") data_df= pd.read_csv('/zi/home/sajad.rezaei/clip/clip/01_scripts/00_Text_processing/00_data/01_IMAGEN/00_data/IMAGEN_FU2.csv')
Preprocess data
d7["User code"] = d7["User code"].str.replace("-I", "-C") df_list = [d1, d2, d3, d4, d5, d6, d7, d8, d9, d10]
In[13]:
patterns = [ "adrs", "ANXDX", "audit", "BIS", "CAPE42", "item", "CTQ", "EDEQ", "SCID", "IRI", "JVQ", "PAAQ", "RRS", "tci", "TFEQ", "User code" ]
def process_dataframe(df, patterns, drop_zero_rows=False): df = df[df.columns[df.columns.str.contains('|'.join(patterns))]] df.loc[:,"User code"]= df.loc[:,"User code"].str.replace("-C", "") df.loc[:,"User code"]= df.loc[:,"User code"].str.lstrip("0")
# Convert all elements to numeric, forcing non-numeric to NaN df_numeric = df.apply(pd.to_numeric, errors='coerce') # Replace NaN values with 0 df_numeric.fillna(0, inplace=True) # Replace empty strings with 0 df_numeric.replace("", 0, inplace=True) # remove the row with all zeros besiders the first column if drop_zero_rows: df_numeric = df_numeric.loc[(df_numeric.iloc[:, 1:] != 0).any(axis=1)] return df_numericdf_list_processed = [process_dataframe(df, patterns, drop_zero_rows=True) for df in df_list]
drop rows with NaN
df_list_processed = [df.dropna() for df in df_list_processed]
merge all df on User code
#merge all df on User code merged_df = df_list_processed[0] for i, df in enumerate(df_list_processed, start=2): merged_df = pd.merge(merged_df, df, on='User code', suffixes=('', f'_df{i}'))
drop all row of data_df besides the first and the last
data_df = data_df.drop(data_df.columns[1:-1], axis=1) data_df.rename(columns={'Unnamed: 0': 'User code'}, inplace=True)
merge the merged_df with data_df
merged_df = pd.merge(data_df, merged_df, on='User code')
Pre-process dataframe for TensorFlow
df = merged_df.drop(columns=['User code', "FilePath"]) non_binary_columns = [col for col in df.columns if len(df[col].unique()) > 2] df = pd.get_dummies(df, columns=non_binary_columns, drop_first=True) df = df.astype(float)
Split data into train and validation sets
X_train, X_val = train_test_split(df.values, test_size=0.20, random_state=42)
Define the Autoencoder model
class Autoencoder(tf.keras.Model):
def init(self, input_size):
super().init()
self.encoder = tf.keras.Sequential([
tf.keras.layers.Dense(128, activation="relu", input_shape=(input_size,)),
tf.keras.layers.BatchNormalization(),
tf.keras.layers.Dense(64, activation="relu"),
tf.keras.layers.BatchNormalization(),
tf.keras.layers.Dense(32, activation="relu"),
tf.keras.layers.Dense(16, activation="relu")
])
self.decoder = tf.keras.Sequential([
tf.keras.layers.Dense(32, activation="relu"),
tf.keras.layers.BatchNormalization(),
tf.keras.layers.Dense(64, activation="relu"),
tf.keras.layers.BatchNormalization(),
tf.keras.layers.Dense(128, activation="relu"),
tf.keras.layers.Dense(input_size, activation="sigmoid")
])
def call(self, x):
encoded = self.encoder(x)
decoded = self.decoder(encoded)
# return decodedDefine the CNN Autoencoder model
Define the CNN Autoencoder model
class Autoencoder(tf.keras.Model): def init(self, input_size): super(Autoencoder, self).init() self.encoder = tf.keras.Sequential([ tf.keras.layers.Input(shape=(input_size, 1 )), tf.keras.layers.Conv1D(128, kernel_size=3, activation="relu", padding="same"), tf.keras.layers.BatchNormalization(), tf.keras.layers.MaxPooling1D(pool_size=3, padding="same"), tf.keras.layers.Conv1D(64, kernel_size=3, activation="relu", padding="same"), tf.keras.layers.BatchNormalization(), tf.keras.layers.MaxPooling1D(pool_size=3), ]) self.decoder = tf.keras.Sequential([ tf.keras.layers.UpSampling1D(size=3), tf.keras.layers.Conv1DTranspose(64, kernel_size=3, activation="relu", padding="same"), tf.keras.layers.BatchNormalization(), tf.keras.layers.UpSampling1D(size=3), tf.keras.layers.Conv1DTranspose(128, kernel_size=3, activation="relu"), tf.keras.layers.BatchNormalization(), tf.keras.layers.ZeroPadding1D(padding=2), # tf.keras.layers.Dense(input_size, activation="sigmoid")
tf.keras.layers.Conv1D(1, kernel_size=3, activation="sigmoid") ]) def call(self, x): x = tf.expand_dims(x, axis=-1) # Add channel dimension encoded = self.encoder(x) decoded = self.decoder(encoded) decoded = tf.squeeze(decoded, axis=-1) # Remove channel dimension return decodedcos = tf.keras.losses.CosineSimilarity( axis=-1, reduction="none", name="cosine_similarity" )
Compile and train the model
cos = tf.keras.losses.MeanSquaredLogarithmicError(
reduction="sum_over_batch_size", name="mean_squared_logarithmic_error"
)
input_size = df.shape[1] autoencoder = Autoencoder(input_size) autoencoder.compile(optimizer=tf.keras.optimizers.Adam(learning_rate=0.000001), loss=cos)
early_stopping = tf.keras.callbacks.EarlyStopping(monitor="val_loss", patience=10, restore_best_weights=True)
history = autoencoder.fit(X_train, X_train, epochs=100, batch_size=512, validation_data=(X_val, X_val), callbacks=[early_stopping])
Evaluate the model
train_predictions = autoencoder.predict(X_train) val_predictions = autoencoder.predict(X_val)
train_mse = np.mean(np.square(train_predictions - X_train)) val_mse = np.mean(np.square(val_predictions - X_val)) train_mae = mean_absolute_error(X_train, train_predictions) val_mae = mean_absolute_error(X_val, val_predictions)
train_explained_var = explained_variance_score(X_train, train_predictions) val_explained_var = explained_variance_score(X_val, val_predictions)
print(f"Training MSE: {train_mse:.4f}, Validation MSE: {val_mse:.4f}")
print(f"Training MSE: {train_mse:.4f}, Validation MSE: {val_mse:.4f}") print(f"Training MAE: {train_mae:.4f}, Validation MAE: {val_mae:.4f}") print(f"Training Explained Variance: {train_explained_var:.4f}, Validation Explained Variance: {val_explained_var:.4f}")
Compute Canonical Correlations
cca = CCA(n_components=min(X_train.shape[1], train_predictions.shape[1]))
num_components = min(X_train.shape[0], train_predictions.shape[0]) cca = CCA(n_components=num_components) cca.fit(X_train, train_predictions) X_train_c, train_predictions_c = cca.transform(X_train, train_predictions)
Compute the correlation for each pair of canonical variables
cca_correlations = np.corrcoef(X_train_c.T, train_predictions_c.T)[:X_train_c.shape[1], X_train_c.shape[1]:]
print("Canonical Correlations:") for i, corr in enumerate(cca_correlations.diagonal()): print(f"Canonical correlation {i+1}: {corr:.4f}")
Plot loss curves for training and validation
plt.plot(history.history["loss"], label="Training Loss") plt.plot(history.history["val_loss"], label="Validation Loss") plt.legend() plt.xlabel("Epochs") plt.ylabel("Loss") plt.title("Training and Validation Loss") plt.show()
Calculate accuracy and AUC if needed
Note: Since this is an autoencoder, calculating binary accuracy or AUC might not be meaningful in a reconstruction context
- Assistant
When you encounter a negative loss with the
CosineSimilarityloss function in TensorFlow, it typically means that the cosine similarity between your predicted values and your true values is high (sinceCosineSimilarityreturns the negative of the cosine similarity, a higher similarity results in a more negative value). However, a negative loss can be non-intuitive because we usually expect losses to be positive. Let’s review your code to identify potential issues:Data Preprocessing
Your preprocessing appears thorough, but let's ensure there are no mistakes:
- Make sure that your data contains meaningful information after preprocessing.
- Check that there is no issue with merged DataFrames.
- Ensure the data is correctly split into training and validation sets.
Model Definition
The autoencoder structure appears appropriate, but make sure the input data dimensions match the expected dimensions:
- Ensure that
X_trainandX_valhave the correct shapes. - Double-check padding and upsampling operations to make sure the decoder can reconstruct the input.
Loss Calculation and Optimization
You use
CosineSimilaritywhich will return values in[-1, 1]. A few things to consider:- In your compile method, ensure the ordering of arguments.
CosineSimilarityreturns high similarity values as negative (closer the vectors, more negative the loss).
Learning Rate
The learning rate of
0.000001may be too low. This might prevent the model from learning effectively.Check for Mistakes
- Shape of Data: Confirm the shape of
X_trainandX_valbefore feeding them into the model. - Scale of the Inputs and Outputs: Ensure that input values are appropriately scaled.
- Loss Function: Since you’re using cosine similarity, the training targets should ideally be normalized vectors.
Here's the modified code including some checks and potential fixes:
import pandas as pd import numpy as np import tensorflow as tf from sklearn.model_selection import train_test_split from sklearn.metrics import mean_absolute_error, explained_variance_score import matplotlib.pyplot as plt from sklearn.cross_decomposition import CCA # Load and preprocess data # ... (Assume you have done this part correctly) # Define the CNN Autoencoder model class Autoencoder(tf.keras.Model): def __init__(self, input_size): super(Autoencoder, self).__init__() self.encoder = tf.keras.Sequential([ tf.keras.layers.Input(shape=(input_size, 1)), tf.keras.layers.Conv1D(128, kernel_size=3, activation="relu", padding="same"), tf.keras.layers.BatchNormalization(), tf.keras.layers.MaxPooling1D(pool_size=3, padding="same"), tf.keras.layers.Conv1D(64, kernel_size=3, activation="relu", padding="same"), tf.keras.layers.BatchNormalization(), tf.keras.layers.MaxPooling1D(pool_size=3, padding="same"), ]) self.decoder = tf.keras.Sequential([ tf.keras.layers.UpSampling1D(size=3), tf.keras.layers.Conv1DTranspose(64, kernel_size=3, activation="relu", padding="same"), tf.keras.layers.BatchNormalization(), tf.keras.layers.UpSampling1D(size=3), tf.keras.layers.Conv1DTranspose(128, kernel_size=3, activation="relu", padding="same"), tf.keras.layers.BatchNormalization(), tf.keras.layers.Conv1D(1, kernel_size=3, activation="sigmoid", padding="same") ]) def call(self, x): x = tf.expand_dims(x, axis=-1) # Add the channel dimension encoded = self.encoder(x) decoded = self.decoder(encoded) decoded = tf.squeeze(decoded, axis=-1) # Remove the channel dimension return decoded # Function to normalize input data to unit vectors (required for cosine similarity) def normalize(data): norm = np.linalg.norm(data, axis=1, keepdims=True) return data / norm # Normalize your data X_train = normalize(X_train) X_val = normalize(X_val) input_size = df.shape[1] autoencoder = Autoencoder(input_size) autoencoder.compile(optimizer=tf.keras.optimizers.Adam(learning_rate=0.0001), loss=cos) # A higher learning rate early_stopping = tf.keras.callbacks.EarlyStopping(monitor="val_loss", patience=10, restore_best_weights=True) history = autoencoder.fit(X_train, X_train, epochs=100, batch_size=512, validation_data=(X_val, X_val), callbacks=[early_stopping]) # Evaluate the model train_predictions = autoencoder.predict(X_train) val_predictions = autoencoder.predict(X_val) train_mse = np.mean(np.square(train_predictions - X_train)) val_mse = np.mean(np.square(val_predictions - X_val)) train_mae = mean_absolute_error(X_train, train_predictions) val_mae = mean_absolute_error(X_val, val_predictions) train_explained_var = explained_variance_score(X_train, train_predictions) val_explained_var = explained_variance_score(X_val, val_predictions) print(f"Training MSE: {train_mse:.4f}, Validation MSE: {val_mse:.4f}") print(f"Training MAE: {train_mae:.4f}, Validation MAE: {val_mae:.4f}") print(f"Training Explained Variance: {train_explained_var:.4f}, Validation Explained Variance: {val_explained_var:.4f}") # Compute Canonical Correlations num_components = min(X_train.shape[1], train_predictions.shape[1]) cca = CCA(n_components=num_components) cca.fit(X_train, train_predictions) X_train_c, train_predictions_c = cca.transform(X_train, train_predictions) # Compute the correlation for each pair of canonical variables cca_correlations = np.corrcoef(X_train_c.T, train_predictions_c.T)[:X_train_c.shape[1], X_train_c.shape[1]:] print("Canonical Correlations:") for i, corr in enumerate(cca_correlations.diagonal()): print(f"Canonical correlation {i+1}: {corr:.4f}") # Plot loss curves for training and validation plt.plot(history.history["loss"], label="Training Loss") plt.plot(history.history["val_loss"], label="Validation Loss") plt.legend() plt.xlabel("Epochs") plt.ylabel("Loss") plt.title("Training and Validation Loss") plt.show()This version normalizes the input data to unit vectors before training, which is essential when using
CosineSimilarity. Also, the learning rate has been increased. You should monitor and adjust these parameters according to your specific dataset and requirements. If you still encounter issues, consider visualizing sample inputs, outputs, and reconstructions to debug further. - User
i a, still getting the negative loss, is it normal?
- Assistant
Yes, it's perfectly normal to get a negative loss when using the
CosineSimilarityloss function in TensorFlow. Here's why:The
CosineSimilarityloss function measures the cosine of the angle between two vectors. The formula for cosine similarity is:[ \text{cosine_similarity} = \frac{\mathbf{A} \cdot \mathbf{B}}{|\mathbf{A}| |\mathbf{B}|} ]
Which ranges from -1 to 1. TensorFlow's
CosineSimilarityloss function actually returns the negative of this value (because lower loss values are considered better):[ \text{cosine_similarity_loss} = - \frac{\mathbf{A} \cdot \mathbf{B}}{|\mathbf{A}| |\mathbf{B}|} ]
Interpretation:
- If the vectors are perfectly aligned (i.e., they are the same or very similar), the cosine similarity will be close to 1, making the loss close to -1.
- If the vectors are orthogonal, the cosine similarity will be 0, making the loss close to 0.
- If the vectors are diametrically opposed, the cosine similarity will be -1, making the loss close to 1.
Therefore, a more negative loss indicates higher cosine similarity between your predictions and the actual values, which means better performance.
Summary of Code Review:
Considering loss values in negative ranges is completely expected behavior for
CosineSimilarity.Further Steps:
- Inspect the Loss History: You may want to inspect the loss history to see if the loss is becoming more negative (indicating training progress).
- Evaluation Metrics: Rely on other evaluation metrics such as Mean Squared Error (MSE), Mean Absolute Error (MAE), and Explained Variance Score to judge the model performance:
# Evaluate the model in terms of reconstruction quality train_mae = mean_absolute_error(X_train, train_predictions) val_mae = mean_absolute_error(X_val, val_predictions) train_mse = np.mean(np.square(train_predictions - X_train)) val_mse = np.mean(np.square(val_predictions - X_val)) train_explained_var = explained_variance_score(X_train, train_predictions) val_explained_var = explained_variance_score(X_val, val_predictions) print(f"Training MSE: {train_mse:.4f}, Validation MSE: {val_mse:.4f}") print(f"Training MAE: {train_mae:.4f}, Validation MAE: {val_mae:.4f}") print(f"Training Explained Variance: {train_explained_var:.4f}, Validation Explained Variance: {val_explained_var:.4f}")Detecting if Learning is Occurring:
Check if the loss (though negative) is improving (i.e., becoming more negative) over epochs. If loss stabilizes or starts to increase, consider:
- Adjusting the learning rate.
- Fine-tuning model hyperparameters.
Visual Loss Progress:
# Plot loss curves for training and validation plt.plot(history.history["loss"], label="Training Loss") plt.plot(history.history["val_loss"], label="Validation Loss") plt.legend() plt.xlabel("Epochs") plt.ylabel("Loss") plt.title("Training and Validation Loss") plt.show()Even though the loss is negative, if the curve shows a downward trend, this indicates improving cosine similarity between your predictions and the actual values.
# Calculate and inspect explained variance and other metrics print(f"Training MSE: {train_mse:.4f}, Validation MSE: {val_mse:.4f}") print(f"Training MAE: {train_mae:.4f}, Validation MAE: {val_mae:.4f}") print(f"Training Explained Variance: {train_explained_var:.4f}, Validation Explained Variance: {val_explained_var:.4f}")If your metrics such as MSE, MAE, and explained variance are showing improvement, it further confirms that the model is learning well.
Conclusion:
The negative loss is an expected output for the cosine similarity loss function. Focus on the trend of the loss and complementary evaluation metrics to assess model performance effectively.
- User
is there any other measurements for autoencoders which can be used in this project
- Assistant
Certainly! Besides
CosineSimilarity, there are various metrics for evaluating autoencoder performance that focus on the differences between the reconstructed output and the original input data. Here are a few commonly used metrics and loss functions you can consider:Loss Functions
-
Mean Squared Error (MSE): Measures the average of the squares of the errors between predicted and actual values.
mse = tf.keras.losses.MeanSquaredError() -
Mean Absolute Error (MAE): Measures the average of the absolute differences between predicted and actual values.
mae = tf.keras.losses.MeanAbsoluteError() -
Mean Squared Logarithmic Error (MSLE): Measures the ratio or relative differences between predicted and actual values.
msle = tf.keras.losses.MeanSquaredLogarithmicError() -
Huber Loss: A combination of MAE and MSE that's less sensitive to outliers:
huber = tf.keras.losses.Huber()
Evaluation Metrics
Besides the loss function used during training, you can calculate additional metrics on the validation set for better evaluation:
-
Root Mean Squared Error (RMSE):
train_rmse = np.sqrt(mean_squared_error(X_train, train_predictions)) val_rmse = np.sqrt(mean_squared_error(X_val, val_predictions)) print(f"Training RMSE: {train_rmse:.4f}, Validation RMSE: {val_rmse:.4f}") -
R-squared (R2 Score): Measures how well the predicted values approximate the actual data.
from sklearn.metrics import r2_score train_r2 = r2_score(X_train, train_predictions) val_r2 = r2_score(X_val, val_predictions) print(f"Training R2: {train_r2:.4f}, Validation R2: {val_r2:.4f}")
Practical Implementation
You can implement another loss function or evaluation metric for your autoencoder. For example, using MSE as a loss function:
Model Definition and Compilation:
# Define the CNN Autoencoder model class Autoencoder(tf.keras.Model): def __init__(self, input_size): super(Autoencoder, self).__init__() self.encoder = tf.keras.Sequential([ tf.keras.layers.Input(shape=(input_size, 1)), tf.keras.layers.Conv1D(128, kernel_size=3, activation="relu", padding="same"), tf.keras.layers.BatchNormalization(), tf.keras.layers.MaxPooling1D(pool_size=3, padding="same"), tf.keras.layers.Conv1D(64, kernel_size=3, activation="relu", padding="same"), tf.keras.layers.BatchNormalization(), tf.keras.layers.MaxPooling1D(pool_size=3, padding="same"), ]) self.decoder = tf.keras.Sequential([ tf.keras.layers.UpSampling1D(size=3), tf.keras.layers.Conv1DTranspose(64, kernel_size=3, activation="relu", padding="same"), tf.keras.layers.BatchNormalization(), tf.keras.layers.UpSampling1D(size=3), tf.keras.layers.Conv1DTranspose(128, kernel_size=3, activation="relu", padding="same"), tf.keras.layers.BatchNormalization(), tf.keras.layers.Conv1D(1, kernel_size=3, activation="sigmoid", padding="same") ]) def call(self, x): x = tf.expand_dims(x, axis=-1) # Add the channel dimension encoded = self.encoder(x) decoded = self.decoder(encoded) decoded = tf.squeeze(decoded, axis=-1) # Remove the channel dimension return decoded input_size = df.shape[1] autoencoder = Autoencoder(input_size) autoencoder.compile(optimizer=tf.keras.optimizers.Adam(learning_rate=0.0001), loss='mse') # Using Mean Squared Error loss early_stopping = tf.keras.callbacks.EarlyStopping(monitor="val_loss", patience=10, restore_best_weights=True) history = autoencoder.fit(X_train, X_train, epochs=100, batch_size=512, validation_data=(X_val, X_val), callbacks=[early_stopping])Evaluate the Model
You can then evaluate the model using additional metrics:
from sklearn.metrics import mean_squared_error, mean_absolute_error, explained_variance_score, r2_score train_predictions = autoencoder.predict(X_train) val_predictions = autoencoder.predict(X_val) # Metrics train_mse = mean_squared_error(X_train, train_predictions) val_mse = mean_squared_error(X_val, val_predictions) train_mae = mean_absolute_error(X_train, train_predictions) val_mae = mean_absolute_error(X_val, val_predictions) train_r2 = r2_score(X_train, train_predictions) val_r2 = r2_score(X_val, val_predictions) print(f"Training MSE: {train_mse:.4f}, Validation MSE: {val_mse:.4f}") print(f"Training MAE: {train_mae:.4f}, Validation MAE: {val_mae:.4f}") print(f"Training R2: {train_r2:.4f}, Validation R2: {val_r2:.4f}") # Plot loss curves for training and validation plt.plot(history.history["loss"], label="Training Loss") plt.plot(history.history["val_loss"], label="Validation Loss") plt.legend() plt.xlabel("Epochs") plt.ylabel("Loss") plt.title("Training and Validation Loss") plt.show()Conclusion
Using additional metrics and evaluating multiple aspects of reconstruction quality can give you a better understanding of your autoencoder's performance. Depending on your specific use case and data characteristics, you might find certain metrics more insightful than others.
-